High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/386/2002allowed

Mohinder Singh v. Darshan Singh

2023-07-10Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra16 pages

!"!#!

$!! ! !#!

# '#, -

-/0

!* 1"2* & & *!&!"! !

" #

" $$$ *!&!"! !

3 % & ' " ( ) %%%**++% ' " ,

- %.* " /%*%000

' ( ) %1%%%000 ' " ,

- *.2 " *3+3%011

' * 4 ! " ' "

" ) " . 5" " " " " " ""6 " ") ) " ) 7 - /80 /809% ) +60 ' +6/ ' : ) " ) " ) ! - 80 ! -0+ ! /809* ) %+ ' : ; " ' " < = ;

) " " ") " "" ) ) *3+3%01* > " ; ) " " ""

" : " ' ! '"" ) : '' ?@ A " B " ) " ') " ) "" "

' '' ) " ;" " " ) ( ' " ") " " ")

) ") ) / ; " "

) ) '( )' & " ' ) " 5 %02. ' ) > " ; " +0+3%01* ") 'C " ) " & '

" ) C '" ;

B )

) ) " ' " 2 - ( " D " " ' *.+0%011 <% B "" " E D * B "" ( "E D . B )' ")E D / "= 8 ; " ; "" )" '> B6% B6* & ) A>% " " ( ) .+%%%012

-*3 " %01/

A>6* " " ( ) .+%%%012

-/* " %01/

A>6. "

()' " %01*61. ""

" ) 7 -/809* ) %+ ' A>6/ " ()' " %01*61. ) ' " ) 7 -8*19/80 ) 0 ' & ""

A>F " +.+2%00% A>G " ()' " %01*61. 3 D " : )" '> B6% >) B6* (

B6. ) & ) *6! +*+1%03* > ' ) "

5 " "

) :' 7 C '

-%0 ' " : ; *6 "78 #7! +.+/%031 > '

) :' 7 " " ) " -%0 *69 +0+3%01* > ' ) " "

" C -%0 A>9. " ()' " %02*62.

A>9/ " ! ( A>92 " ()' " %0**6*. H A>98 " ()' H A>93 "

A>91 90 " ()' " %08%68*

A>9%+ " ! ( A>9%% " " *8+3%01. ' 7 A>9%* " .+%*%00% '

))

! G " %2%%%011 ' ;

1 D ' ' " ' "" ( ) %1%%%000 " ") " " "" ") ) ") ) 0 4

" " '" 4 ( ) %%%**++% ' ( ) '

' ) ""

' " %+ & ' " "

6"" ) ( ) ' 4 ' "

" ' ' ( ) ; 4 ( ) ) ; 6" )' " ' -%0 "

) '

) 7 -/809* ) ; ") " " ") ' )" ' ") A>9%% ' #

)) ' &

" ' " ) : ') " '

' 4 ' ' B ' ) ) ( ) ' 4 ' ' ( ) ' ' " ' %% B ' " 6""

" 6 " ) " '

4 " ; " ) " ) " : "

" : ' '

A ) ' " ) ' ' ; ' ) ' ! " ) ' ) ; ) " -%0 ) ) " 'C ' ' 6" ; ) " ' " ') " B ')

4.4

' " ) ' ' ) %* # " ' ' ) ' ' %. & ' " ) " 6"" " D /% *3 "

+2+2*+*. " '( ' '

" > 6% " +8+0%010 '

' D""

6)6

))

" %2%%%011 ' ;

> 6* " *.+3%00+ '

))6)6 "

))

> 6. " ( ) *8+.*++* -;61. " %002

%/ ; 6""

) )" '

" ) 7 -/809* ) %+ ' ) " " ( 6" 6" ) ' -%0 " ) ' ) ") 'C " ) " ) " ) "

" ) ' 6"" ;

' 6" " ' -%0 " ) 7 -/809* 4 ' ) 'C ' 6 " 6" ' " " ' ' " ) ( 4 " C ) -%0 ' " ) 7 -/809* E 4 ) ) ' ' " 6"" ' ) *3+3%01* ' " ) ) " ; 6"" " *3+3%01* " ) ' "

") ) '

' " " ) 7 -/809* ) %+ ' > " " 6"" *3+3%01* ' ) *6$ " %2%%%011 ' ;

' 6" " ;

) ! ) %+ " (' !

%038 ' ) 7 -/809* ) /++ C ) " " "

4%4

9"" *3+3%01* ' " 9 : " ' ) " "

)! ' )) 6""

') > " %+ ' " ) 7 -/809* / ' " " 7 -/80 7 -/809% ' ) /++ C ) " *3+3%01* ; ;

*3+3%01* ) -%.3 ' " ) ) 7 -/809* ' "

I) ) 4) *6$ *3+3%01* ' > " " 6"" C %2 4 6"" )" '"

" ) > 6% 6* > 6% " +8+0%010 ' ' D""

6)6 )) ' " ' %2%%%011 ' ;

! G D " ' ;

' ) ) '! ) ' )! ' ' 7 -/809* " 6"" ' ) ' )! ' ) " ' ' ") )

4) " > 6* " *.+3%00+ " ))6)6 "

)) ) " ' 6" > 6% '

)) D " ! G > 6% > 6* C ) 7 -/809* ' > '

) *3+3%01* " " 6"" ' ' ' ;

' ' ) ) ' ) ' ) ' " ) 5 > 6% > 6* ' ' '" " '( ' " 6" C " 6"" " ) '

'( " > 6% 6* ' ' " ' ) > 6% 6* ' ' ' " ;

> " " 6 "" C ) 7 -/809* ) ) ") *3+3%01* " ) /++ C ) " ) 7 -/809* ' " " 6 "" %+ ' " ) ' ) & " ") ! G ) -%.3 ' C %+

' " ) 7 -/809* " " 6 "" ' ; C " ) ' ' ' > 6% 6* " ) 6"" " ) 7 -/809* ) %+ ' " " " ) %+ ' %8 & ) '"

" ) 7 -/809* ) %+ ' ' " ) " 6"" ) %+ ' ) C

6"" ) ! *3+3%01* ' -2 " ) " 6" 5 "

" %+ ' " ) 7 -/809* ' ) : " " ( ' ) ' 6 "" ' "

C " " ' " %+ ' " ) 7 -/809* 5" ' ) -%0 ' " ' )

! )' E & > ) " ' 6" ) ) -%0 ' ) ") ) : ! -%0 ' )

) :' 7 +*+1%03* ! 5 " +.+/%031 > ' ) :' 7 " " ) " , ! F " +0+3%01* > ' ) " " 6" ; ' " " -%0

" " 6" 5 " 6" " '

"" " 4) ) ! ! F " ' )

; ! )' "

' ) ; 4 " " " " ' 4 "" ' ' 6" ' " ' ' 4 ! %2%%%011 ! G "

' ") ) > 6 % > 6* %2%%%011 ' ;

' ;"

6" " )' -%0 ' ' ) ! F ) ' ! -/809*

'! C 6""

" " ( ' ) ' "

*3+3%01* ' ' ' " ) ' > ) " ' ' ") ) ' " )

' ) ! G ' ;

/++ C ) " '( ) " *3+3%01* ' ' ; ) A>' 6% 6/ ) " ) %+ ' ) '

7 -/809* A>' 6% 6* " ( ) .+%%%012 -*3 /* " %01/ ; -*3 " %01/ ' " '

) -/* ' " ' D " " ( ) ' ' ) 6"" %+ ' " " ) 7 -/809* : '( ) " ' ' ) "

' " )

454

) ; ) A>6.

()' " %01*61. 6"" ' " ()' : ) ) ' ' ()' ()' " 'C ()' ' ' " " ) ' "

" ' 6 "" ' " %+ ' " ") " ! -/809* ' ) ) ) ) " ' B6* ( " ) ) " " 6"" & ") " 6" ) " ) " *++1%00+ :C 7 : #

)) ) : ) %2%%%00+ ') '" ; ' ") >' ' ' D " ' ! -/809* " ! )' %** ' ) ' # )) " " 6"" - '( ' " '

6" " ;" ' " " " 6"" ; 4 " ! " #

)) ' " ) ) ' B6* " ! ' 4 "

" " ( 6""

C ' > " 6" " ) ' " ' " ) B ' 6""

& )

") " " ' ") ) 9 ' " " " 4 " " ( ;" " ' 4 ' " ; ) C ( ) ' 4 ; ( ) ' ' ; " ' 6"" ) ;

%3 " " (*!&!"! !+ .

# )( B ! 9 G9- B ' G9-