High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5150/2020allowed

Nem Kumar v. State Of Haryana And Others

2026-03-23Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

!"#$#$%

&''

( )*+$ , +, ++ * ****

!

" #$%& !

' #$%&

() !

*% #$

$+ !

$ #$%& , !

- #$%& ./(01 2345,52,6,3) , /(01 273762,6,6) ,-"

.!/ 012 $ (3)

#'

01 273762,6,601 2345,52 ,6,3& % % 8 & #01 273762,6,6

&

3-4 3 (,)

9

0 " %- $

,,:;,,5 0

' &<

= & 64 ,633 ($>

,)# < &

& 3?

6, ,63. ($> /)

- 2 - 6, ,63. ($> :) < " % &

% "

$

"

% &<

&=

"

< 6, ,63.

- 56 (.)

9

< $&& 0 -(0

1 & & ) <

0&

0

1 # *

&# 8 " % ;"

6, 3??4# < 0&

0 33 < & < %

< + & (/)

64 ,633# . ;& 5 0 %

% & ( $ ) # 3?45 ( # @ 3?45 A)

"BB ;

.5#:6#4?3;2# < &

"

<

,7 ,633 & $ '= & < # % < & & %% 3?

6, ,63. <

< &

& &

A % % & 9 # <

%

"

"

# / 6, ,63. %

% & <

& #

'= & && % (7)

9

&2 #

0 ! (" *

0

1 & )# < & 8' 34/ 35 6:

,633 &

/6?#/,6#./

- 3 - '

0 "

2

#<% #% 36 ,635#

& &=

&& & < " $

C # 8 " %

,63?

$ &=

#

& / %

; = ,.

,6353/ ,63?#"

& < " 63 ,6,6#%

0 #

#

< <

&2

01 3/464 ,63: (

) 01 ,/7// ,63. (0 ! )#<

D $ 3:4,,63:#

&

&=

"

(:)

&

<

55!"

3)6!"5 "5!"6 (5)

D &

&

&

&

# && # %

< & & &

#

&

& =

0&

; + & 0 33 * 0 2&2 #*001#8 "#< 6, ,63.

'

& < & &

#<

& 2

& <

%

&& < #

&

& 5 3?45 <

- 4 - (4)

'

"

= <&& %

&

&# & "

0

# & & < & # 2- <

%

% &" &

<

<& (?)

'

& & 8' 34/,633 &

"BB <

A &=

%

& 36 ,635 ($>

33)" "

0 % 63 ,63? ($> 3,)

< & & &

" & #

& <" & % &&

> (36)

D & %

& %- &

#

&2 #

0 ! #<< & 2 %

& #% "

"

0 01 3/464 ,63:# 01 ,/7// ,63. D $ 3:4, ,63:#

&

!"5 "5!"6!"7 8-19!9 6.!"

"56"!$5!: (33)

9 , /# <

#

"

<

% &&

&# & < 6, ,63.#"

%

%

- 5 -

0&

0

1 (E % &) #,635 &

0 % #<

& >

(3,)

D & , / "

#" $&& #<

"

& && .5#:6#4?3;2 < &

# "BB

<

% # & &

&

<< *

0

1 & (3.)

9 =

& &2 < && " + & # 0&

0

1 #<

A&# = <&& " "2* % & (0)#8 "#<

* 0 2&2 # *001# &

&

#

& &

<

'

<

= # &

& 2> <

#% "

&& = & &

# '= & A #

A <&#

% < & " - 6, ,63.

'

& &=

& &

"

%

& # & "

< & #

A

& % &2

- 6 - && % "& "

$&& < =

%

(3/)

&

& "-1466-" !"

1/6!" (37)

% & % " #

0

&

&

& " #

& & "

" & & * 0 2&2 # *001# & &

<

0&

; + & # "

&- &<

(3:)

& #

"

($>

2. 27) &<

6, ,63.($> 2:)#

% #

& & "&

& 2 #2=

&

#

>

# &

& # # && '= & && %#<

%

% &

A>

9&

($>

25)# < &

"

"BB # % % "% 6, ,63.# " &

% <>& &

<

>

(35)

9 &

&

= "

% % &

- 7 -

A >

# & # = && %# &

=

= A "

& % >& "

& & &

= # & <

<

&

#= &

& > " 0 "

0

& &"

"

< (34)

#

& 64 ,633 ($> ‐,)# = ;< & 3?

6, ,63. ($>

‐/) 6, ,63.($> ‐:)

"BB .5#:6#4?3;‐

A

8 "# < & "

‐

8' 34/ 6:

,633 9

# <

&‐ #

0 ! #"&=

% & " 9 0 #&&=

" " $

0 #

"

% % &

< & &

(3?)

'

"&- #

< "

& < < " 0 !

"#

$%&' (())# < 0 # %

& & (* !

+$,-

.

,! &

((/ # &

& # &=&

< < " & " & #% &<

9 0

- 8 - % < " @ # %A &&

<

9

&

&#& #< 8'# & 2 & & " < & & & &=

% #

% & &

9 % > & 2

(* !

+$,-

.

,! 0 -

! "

#

$" %

$

'

$ %

%

(

%

(

- 9 -

%

)

$ $

)

(

$

((((

(((( ((((

%

%

*

!

& '

+

, (,6)

'% < & #

0

&

&

& " 9 % & &

< & "

< ! % # = %

" 2&

A& &

&

# & " & &

& # % # &

& "

% " && & & #<

0 >

- 10 -

&

&&2 &

#

&

>&

& % !

"#&( ) (,3)

$&&

#

<

<

;& 2 64 ,633 ($> 2,)# = <2& 3?

6, ,63. ($> 2/) 6, ,63. ($> 2:) " = 9

" % &#

"

&&=

"

"

<# "< -

>

0 ! 9

"

F:G % &;

< &

" "

" < <

& &

&

(,,)

&

&&

#$#$% ,-"

.!/ 01

/ 0

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

:

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

:

Yes/No