High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3991/2023dismissed

Jagtar Singh Sidhu v. State Of Punjab And Another

2023-07-046 pages

!"#$% & '!$!$%'"

(## #!!' )%*+%,%!&'"

'-.%,'%!-

"'-'%!

/"0!'*#$% &#$,&)1#",23!'1 4$!&/"$55!#$% &#$,&)1,23!'1

"!&'.'!$!$%'" /"6#$% 01,,0)%*+

&'.'!$!$%'"1+8!&$-4"$!.'!$!$%1&-."8', "$--)%3' 4"$!$%!&'%!)"' '"!$""$!300 "%,-'!-$,'!&'."3'',$% -

'."!5'%!0"5!$%55$!!'',!',

4&'"'+8%$%'039 '2'0.5'%! %, %3&8!

$3'"- &2' +''% ."5!', - $-!"$3! '2'0.5'%! %, %3&8!

$3'"- :"). ;1 4& "' *)%$" ! !&' .'!$!$%'"%,3-' !&'.'!$!$%'"&-+''%9'.!$%<-'0',32'"=,)'! .'%,'%38

,!',

@1)%,'"#'3!$% 1 :

; !&'

"'2'%!$%%,"").!$%3!1 @@%,)%,'"#'3!$%

A1"' $-!'"', !0$3'#!!$%($ $0%3')"')!&$%,:%%'B)"'C;1+'$% 3%!""8! !&')%*+2!$"3)0"C%-!")3!$%-,!',

@:%%'B)"'A ;%, +'$% 3%!""8!!&'040$,,4%+8!&'%=+0'#)."'5')"! %,$$% %$% %,$26(%9$"5%

:#)."'5')"!;

)"!&'"."8'" "$--)%3' 4"$!$%!&'%!)"' /%,5)- ,$"'3!$% !&'"'-.%,'%!-!3%-$,'"%,."5!'!&'.'!$!$%'"!!&'.-!

$-!"$3!'2'0.5'%!%,%3&8!

$3'"4$!&'

'3! "5!&',!'1!&'

.'"-%-*)%$"!&$5&2'+''%."5!',%,! "%!003%-'D)'%!$0 +'%'

$!-!!&'.'!$!$%'"$%30),$% -'%$"$!81.8%,$%3"'5'%!-'!30% 4$!&$%!'"'-!E @F.'"%%)5

G'"%',-'%$"3)%-'0..'"$% "!&'.'!$!$%'"-)+5$!-!&!

!&'.'!$!$%'"4-""'-!',$%3-'"' $-!'"',)%,'"#'3!$% %, :

; !&'

"'2'%!$%%,"").!$%3!1 @@%+-$- 35.0$%!"' $-!'"',+8%'

/%,''.#$% &1#".%3&1 $%-!4&5!&'.'!$!$%'"&, $0',%%

)%,'"#'3!$%-

@%,

A G'"%',3)%-'0-)+5$!-!&!0!&) &!&'.'!$!$%'"4-""'-!', %

@1&'4-"'0'-',%

@%,4-4"9$% !&'"'

!'" &'35.'!'%!)!&"$!8"'

)-',! "%!-%3!$%%

;3&" '-&''!4- $0',).!!&',!'4&'%!&'-'0',32'"."3',)"' 4-,.!',G'"%',3)%-'0-)+5$!-!&!%

:%%'B)"'A>;!&'

3-' !&'.'!$!$%'"4-3%-$,'"', "."5!$%!!&'.-! $-!"$3!

'2'0.5'%!%,%3&8!

$3'"4'2'"1<-'0',32'"."3',)"'=4- ,.!',$%2$0!$% !&'"3',)"'%, )$,'0$%'-$--)',+8!&''."!5'%! '"-%%'0,!',

@:%%'B)"'A ;4&$3&"'D)$"',,.!$%

<-'0',32'"."3',)"'=%08$% )"3$"3)5-!%3'--0$,,4%!&'"'$%

G'"%',3)%-'0-)+5$!-!&!%%' !&' )"3$"3)5-!%3'- 3%-$-!',%!&',!'4&'%!&'3-' !&'.'!$!$%'"4-+'$% 3%-$,'"', "

."5!$%1 !&' ,.!$% <-'0', 32'" ."3',)"'= 4- 0' 0 %, !&' .'!$!$%'"4-'%!$!0',!+'3%-$,'"',%, "%!',."5!$%-.'"&$- '%!$!0'5'%! G'"%',3)%-'0&-0-"'0$',).%*), 5'%!.--',+8!&' .'B)"!$%

!"# $%%$ &'"(#( &") *+$+1-4'00--)+-'D)'%!*), 5'%!- ",- &#"

-"# ,

))(

&./

)-("

*+$0 &'"(#( &") $*1 %, ))(

)2 )!

$%%34 153 10'"%',3)%-'0..'"$% "!&'#!!'.$%!',)!

!&!!&'.'!$!$%'"4-," ',$%3-' +"$+'"8%,-)5 -

CA 4-"'32'"', "5&$-&)-'G'"%',3)%-'00--)+5$!-!&!!&'3&" '$-

!&'-'"$)-%!)"' 3"").!$%%,+"$+'"8%,1!&'"'

"'1 .'!$!$%'"3%%!+'4",',."5!$%%,!&'."3',)"' ,.!$% <-'0', 32'"=3%%!+' )0!',!$- )"!&'"-)+5$!!',!&!!&'-%3!$%4&$3&4- "'

)-','"0$'"%

;4-"'2$-',%,3&" '-&''!&- +''%%4-)+5$!!',+8!&'($ $0%3')"')$%!&'35.'!'%!)"!%

.8 !&'3&" '-&''!&-0-+''%.03',%"'3",+' "'

!&$-)"!!$-0-$% "5',!&!,'."!5'%!03&" '-&''!&-+''%$--)', %

!!&'.'!$!$%'" &2'3%-$,'"',!&'-)+5$--$%-

!"#6, 7,( ,&'" !&'

#)."'5')"!&,%33-$%!'B5$%'!&'-.'3!-"' ",$% ,.!$%

!&'<-'0',32'"."3',)"'=%,&, "5', 004$% D)'-!$%-

! "

%!&' $"-!D)'-!$%1!&'.'B)"!&-+-'"2',-)%,'" # $ % &

' ( & & '

(

( ' ' (

& )

(

& &

' *

& '+ !

( )

) '

( & ' -

) (

)

( (

(

( '

'- ' . $ % ' / 0

1'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''2 2222222222222'

. (

(

'3 &' -$, *), 5'%! &- +''% 004', 3%-$-!'%!08 +8 !&'

-)+-'D)'%!*), 5'%!- !&'.'B)"!%,!&$-)"!$% ))( !

)2 )!6, 7,( ,&'" 4&$0' 004$% !&'*), 5'%!1%!$3',!&'

> 3)!

,!'-%!&',!'4&'%!&'3&" '-&''!4-$--)',"%!!!&' 3%3'"%',,'0$%D)'%! %!&'."'-'%!3-'1!&'.'!$!$%'"4-""'-!',%

@%, &'"'5$%',$%*),$3$03)-!,8 !'"

@'4)0,!&)-1+',''5',! +')%,'"-)-.'%-$% !'"!&'.'"$,,)"$% 4&$3&&'"'5$%',$%*$0%2$'4 !&' +-'"2!$%- !&' .'B )"!1 -$%3' !&' .'!$!$%'" 4- )%,'" -)-.'%-$% "!&'.'"$,,.!$% <-'0',32'"."3',)"'=%33)%!

!&'"'5$%$% )%,'"-)-.'%-$%4)0,&2'!+''B5$%',4&'!&'"!&'-5' 3%+',.!','2'%!&) & !'"&'4-"'0'-',1&'"'*$%',&$-,)!$'-%, 3%!$%)',!-'"2'

%!&'.$%$% !&$-)"!1!&'.'"$,-.'%!$%*),$3$03)-!,8 4)0,+'!"'!',-.'"$,-.'%!)%,'"-)-.'%-$%%,!&'"' "'1!&' 3!)5

"'5$%$% $%-)-.'%-$%!&) & "."!$3)0".'"$,3%+'-)

$3$'%!

")%,!9''.!&'3-' %'5.08'')%,'"<-'0',32'"=%,5'"'08 +'3)-'!&'3&" '-&''!4-%! $0',$%!&'3"$5$%0."3'',$% -"!&!

,'."!5'%!0$%D)$"84-0-%!$--)',%!&'"'0'2%!,!'4)0,%!+'% $5.',$5'%!!,.!!&'-'0',32'"&$-)"! )"!&'"+-'"2'-!&!.'"-% 4&&-+''% )%,!+'$%202',$%3-' 3"").!$%C+"$+'"83%%!+'

4",',."5!$%!&$ &'".-!

# "-!&'D)'-!$%"' ",$% "'

)-0 -%3!$%!."-'3)!'

",'"',2$,'",'",!',

;%,-)+-'D)'%! "%!$% -%3!$%$-3%3'"%',1!&'-5'$-%!5!!'"!+''B5$%',$%!&'."'-'%! 3-'H)'-!$%-!$00&2'!+''B5$%',$%,'.'%,'%!08$%!&'35.'!'%! ."3'',$% -+'

"'!&'3"$5$%0)"!G'2$% $!.'% "!&'.'!$!$%'"! 3%!'-!!&'-$,-.'3!1 3!"'5$%-!&!&'"'5$%',)%,'"-)-.'%-$%1$! 5'%--)-.'%,',,)"$% !&'.'"$, ""'-! "5

@ 4&$3&4--)

$3$'%!!,.!<-'0',32'"."3',)"'=

33",$% 081%3-' " "%! "'0$'

$-5,')!

'!$!$%$-,$-5$--',

+1+0*+*4

55!

&'!&'"-.'9$% C"'-%', '-C &'!&'""'."!+0'

'-C