High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17162/2001dismissed

State Of Hy. v. M/S Parul Foods Specialities P.Ltd.

2020-02-10Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan7 pages

!"#$" % &$ ! " ! "#" $%&%'(

& )*()"+',-)./)$0 %12(3456)(%%'%$).0)$3)')

$(-%1%(+(+'%$

$.7 +(().0456)(% $(-%$%&1'4%'(& '())*+,'-* -%"()(% )$3)')-)& +.%4(-%/$+(&%%7+',82)&-+',

$4%$&4)(%49

)'4 :

1)&&%4;3(-%**+&&+'%$)'4 "%6$%()$30 '42&($+%& %1)$(*%'(0 )$3)') )../+', (-% )11%).

$%&1'4%'( <)&&%&&%% =-%$%+') (%$ 4%&6$+;%4 )& (-% )&&%&&%% > )'4 4+&*+&&+',(-%$%5+%/)11.+6)(+' +.%4;3(-%4%1)$(*%'( -%)&&%&&%%/)&$%,+&(%$%4)(?2$27&-%($)2'4%$(-%)$3)') %'%$).").%&)@6(09 := $&-$(0 (-%6( >)&/%..)&%'($).").%& )@6(09A '+'42&($+).2'+(/)&&%(21+'99B)(5+..),%?-)'12$ ?.+)'0 +&($+6( ?2$27&-%($)0 1$426+', 2((%$ +. )'4 ,-%% -% 6**%$6+).1$426(+'&()$(%4'999B@%*1(+'2'4%$2.% C

(-%)$3)')%'%$).").%&)@2.%&09 A= $&-$(0 (-%2.%& >/)&

,$)'(%4 $93%)$&+% $*999B(:C

:'99A0)4+5%$&+ +%4 2'+(/)&&%(21(1$426% +.7/4%$0 )+$3-+(%'%$0 %&+-%%%(6 -%4+5%$&+ +%42'+(/)&).&)../%4%@%*1(+' $)1%$+4 93%)$& +% $*

99A(

B'%@1)'&+' (-%4+5%$&+ +%42'+( /)& 2'4%$()7%' -% %@1)'4%4 2'+( &()$(%4 6**%$6+). 1$426(+' ' AB99911.+6)(+'+' $*"< /)&&2;*+((%4':

9996.)+*+', %@%*1(+'2'4%$2.% C (-%2.%&-%)11.+6)(+'/)&$%D%6(%4;3(-% +,-%$ !%5%. "6$%%'+', **+((%% = $ &-$(0 !" > ' AA

-.4+',(-)((-%1$426(+%4%&+,-%%+&65%$%42'4%$'%,)(+5%.+&( 2.%

C -% &()(2($3 )11%). +.%4 ;3 (-% )&&%&&%% /)& )../%4 ;3 **+&&+'%$ '42&($+%&'9

-%1%(+(+' $$%5+%/ (-% 4%1)$(*%'(/)&$%D%6(%40-%'6%(-%1$%&%'(1%(+(+' -%6-)..%',%+'(-%/$+(1%(+(+'((-%+*12,'%4$4%$&+&' (-%,$2'4(-)()((-%(+*% 6**%$6+).1$426(+'2.% C (-%2.%& /)&+'1%$)(+'0(-%1$426( %..+'(-%'%,)(+5%.+&()'4-%'6%;%'%

%@%*1(+'62.4'(-)5%;%%',$)'(%4"%6'4.30'.)'4/)&12$6-)&%4 -%'6%(-%6)&%62.4'(-)5%;%%'6'&+4%$%42'4%$2.% C (-%2.%& % $%4%).+',/+(-(-%6'(%'(+'04% +'+(+' 1%$)(+5% 1%$+4 )&1%$2.%& C= >=)>)'4 C=:>=)>)$%82(%4;%./ .&/%)0 1'2 .%' 3# +/&+)- )&+3 ' 3)& 3++3 #3& )4)+3 )#)&) #&3'5)3#'42 @@@@@@ = > $ (-% 12$1&% (-+& -)1(%$0 2'.%&& (-% 6'(%@( (-%$/+&%$%82+$%&0

: =)>6$ $ 7*%)'&(-%1%$+4&()$(+', $*(-%&( 4)3 1$+.09CC)'4%'4+','(-%4)(%'/-+6-'%/ 1.+63 $ +'6%'(+5% ( +'42&($3 +& )''2'6%4 ;3 (-% ,5%$'*%'( )$3)')+'+'42&($+%&4%1)$(*%'( @@@@@@ .&!" 9%' 3# +/&+)- )&+3 ' 3)& 3++3 #3& )4)+3 )#)&) #&3'5)3#'4:

@@@@@@ =:> $ (-% 12$1&% (-+& -)1(%$0 2'.%&& (-% 6'(%@( (-%$/+&%$%82+$%&0< =)>6$ $ 7*%)'&(-%1%$+4&()$(+', $*(-%&( 4)3 2,2&(099 0)'4%'4+','(-%4)(%'/-+6-(-% 1.+63 $+'6%'(+5%(+'42&($3+&(%$*+')(%4F$%5+&%4;3(-% 5%$'*%'( )$3)')+''42&($+%& %1)$(*%'( $5+4%4(-)((-%;%'% %@%*1(+'F4% %$*%'(&-)..;% )4*+&&+;.%2'4%$$2.% C((-%'42&($+).2'+(&/-+6--)5% ()7%' ../+',%

%6(+5%&(%1& =+>!)'4-)&;%%'12$6-)&%4 $(-%1$D%6($()7%''.%)&% $$%'(G =++>-%'42&($+).'+(-)&,(+(&;2+.4+',1.)'&)11$5%4+' 6)&%(-%2'+(+&.6)(%4+'(-%6'($..%4)$%))&4% +'%4;3(-%

%1)$(*%'( /')'42'($3.)''+','6)&%(-%2'+(+& .6)(%42(&+4%(-%6'($..%4)$%)0(-%;2+.4+',1.)'&&-2.4 ;%)11$5%4;3(-%)11$5%4$6-+(%6(GA H6&( (-%6+5+.

B /$7& (-%)11$5%41.)' (-%;2+.4+',&-2.4-)5%;%%'

6*1.%(%4)'41)+4 $;3:&(2.3099 =+++>A H*)6-+'%$3-)&;%%';7%4;31.)6+',6'

+$*%4 $4%$&/+(-)(.%)&( H)*2'(1)+4)&)45)'6%)&':&(

)$6-099C ,%(;%'% +(2'4%$(-%.4'42&($+)..+63099 0)..(-% );5%*%'(+'%46'4+(+'&&-2.4;% 2.

+..%4'6)&%)'3 '% (-%&%6'4+(+'&+&'(*%(/+(-0(-%+'42&($+).2'+( /2.4;%,+5%'(-%;%'% +'6%'(+5%&)&1%$(-%%/ '42&($+). .+63 99 + 2'4 (-%$/+&% %.+,+;.% (-%$%2'4%$ @@@@@@I (/2.4;%+*1$()'(('(%)((-+&&(),%(-)(2.% C (-% 2.%&/)& +'&%$(%45+4%"B 4)(%4CA999;2( /)&*)4% %

%6(+5% $*C99 0+(+&'(-%&)+4;)&+&(-)( +$&(6'(%'(+'+&$)+&%4 ;3(-%1%(+(+'%$ -%&2;*+&&+'+&'(/%.. 2'4%42.% C= >=)> (-% 2.%&4% +'%& 1%$)(+5%1%$+4 -%1%$+4&()$(%4 $*&(4)3 1$+.0 9CC )'4 %'4& ' (-% 4)(% /-%' '%/ +'42&($+). +'6%'(+5% 1.+63 +& )''2'6%4-%$%+&'82)$$%.(-)()&1%$(-%4% +'+(+'2'4%$2.% C0 (-%1%$)(+5%1%$+4-)46*%()'%'4'AB999/-%'(-%6**%$6+). 1$426(+'&()$(%4;2((-+&4%&'(-%.1(-%6)&% (-%1%(+(+'%$-% 4% +'+(+' 1%$)(+5%1%$+4 2'4%$2.% C (-%2.%&-)&)1$5+&;3 /-+6-(-%;%'% +(2'4%$2.% C/)&%@(%'4%4((-%2'+(&/--)4()7%'

(-$%%%

%6(+5%&(%1&0 +$&(.3(-%.)'4 $(-%1$D%6(-)4;%%'12$6-)&%4$ ()7%''.%)&%$$%'(0&%6'4.3(-%;2+.4+',1.)'&/%$%,()11$5%4+'

A 6)&% 2'+(&.6)(%4+'6'($..%4)$%))'4+'(-%$6)&%&(-%;2+.4+',1.)'& &-2.4;%)11$5%4;3(-%$6-+(%6(0A H 6&( 6+5+./$7&&-2.4 -)5%;%%'6*1.%(%4)'41)+4;3: 99 )'4.)&(.3A H *)6-+'%$3 -)4;%%';7%4)'4)(.%)&( H)*2'(1)+4+')45)'6%)&'::99C ..(-%(-$%%6'4+(+'&/%$%$%82+$%4(;% 2.

+..%4 -%,$2'4 $$%D%6(+' %@%*1(+'6.)+*;3!"62.4;% &2&()+'%4+ (-%6)&%/)&*)4%2((-)()'3'% (-%6'4+(+'& 1$5+& (2.% C=:>=)> (-%2.%&/%$%'(*%((/)&+'(-)(%5%'(2).+(3(-)( )11.+6)(+'/)&(;%4%).(/+(-2'4%$2.% C)'4(-%'%,)(+5%.+&(/2.4 -)5%$%.%5)'6% %$%.3;%6)2&%;3(-%(+*%(-%)11.+6)(+'/)&&2;*+((%4 ':

99902.% C (-%2.%&/)&+'&%$(%4/+..'()2(*)(+6)..3 ;$+',(-%)11.+6)(+' $%@%*1(+'2'4%$2.% C (-)(+&&0(-% 1$5+&( &2;<$2.%=:>=)>( 2.% C/2.4;%$%'4%$%4(+&%-% 1$5+&-)&%@(%'4%4(-%)11.+6);+.+(3 2.% C (-%2.%&-%$% 6)''( ;%)'3&%$+2& ;D%6(+'/+(- $%,)$4( 2.

+.*%'( (-%(-$%% 6'4+(+'&)&(-%2'+(-)4&()$(%46**%$6+).1$426(+''AB999+% 1$+$(+'&%$(+' 2.% C (-%2.%&-%11%..)(%2(-$+(3$+,-(.3 )../%4(-%)11%).;36'&+4%$+',(-%%@%*1(+')11.+6)(+'2'4%$2.%

C (-%2.%& -%&%6'46'(%'(+'(-)('.)'4/)&12$6-)&%4$()7%'' .%)&%$$%'(+&),)+'&((-%$%6$4-% 4+5%$&+ +%42'+(/-+6-&()$(%4 6**%$6+).1$426(+'+'99A/)&%@1)'4%4)'4+(&6)1)6+(3/)&%@(%'4%4

$* *%($+6(''%&(B*%($+6(''%&-%.)'4/)&).$%)43/+(-(-% 2'+((/)&'((-%6)&%%+(-%$;% $%(-%!"(-)((-%.)'4/)&'( 12$6-)&%4 $ ;% $% (-% 11%..)(% 2(-$+(30 $)(-%$ (-% 4%1)$(*%'(). $%1$%&%'()(+5%;% $%(-%11%..)(%2(-$+(36'6%4%4(-)((-$%%6'4+(+'&

1$5+&(2.% C=:>=)>/%$% 2.

+..%4-%$%.%5)'(1$(+' (-% $4%$+&82(%4;%./ E )*).&&)(+& +%4(-)((-%6)&% (-%)11%..)'(2'+(+& 65%$%42'4%$1$5+&(6.)2&%=)> 2.% C<)'4-)& $+,-(.3)11.+%42'4%$$2.% C<)'4+&%'(+(.%4(;%'%

%@%*1(+'2'4%$(-%&)+4$2.%)&(-%2'+( 2.

+..&)..(-%(-$%% 6'4+(+'&1$5+4%4+'(-%) $%&)+41$5+&-%.)'4&(4 12$6-)&%4 +' 99 0 ;2+.4+', 1.)' &(4 )11$5%4 ;3 (-% )11$5%4$6-+(%6(0*$%(-)'A H (-%)*2'(&(41)+4

$ )& (-% 6&( 6+5+. /$7 21( :&( 2.30 99 -% 4%1)$(*%'().$%1$%&%'()(+5%&-)5%'($%;2((%4(-%,$2'4& )11%). ' (-+& 1+'( )'4 -)5% $)(-%$ 6'6%4%4 ( +&0 (-%$% $%0-%.4(-)((-%)11%..)'(2'+(+&%'(+(.%4((-%;%'% +( + +'6%'(+5%2'4%$2.% C< )$3)')%'%$).").%&)@ 2.%&09 AI -%$%+&)'(-%$)&1%6( (-%*)((%$(-)((5%$+ 3(-%6.)+*0) $%1$(+&&2,-( $*(-% %12(3@6+&%)'4)@)(+'**+&&+'%$= $ &-$(0 >0+'(-%&)+4$%1$(4)(%4

9990(-% &1%6+ +6)..3 *%'(+'%4(-)((-%4%).%$-)412$6-)&%4(-%.)'4+'99B 6)&%+&*)4%2( $+'(%$ %$%'6%+'(-%+*12,'%4$4%$& -%/$+(1%(+(+'+&4+&*+&&%4 .'())*+,'2 .'*'5)'&+2 */,)*/,)

*7 -%(-%$&1%)7+',F$%)&'%4

%&F -%(-%$$%1$();.%

%&F