Mahender Singh Chawla v. State Of Haryana And Another
!
"#$# %
&&
' ()
&& # # % * + *$,$ '
-
&&& $. %/ % $ 0)
& '
' '
! "# $$$$ ' ' 1 &
%&#'' %()*#+'' , - - , -.
/' "# #)01#023 *4 5(+6/7"#%( 2(03#023, (08%3#2)352#05!(%/'
9 :
#(2##0##*4 5)+ - .
, - ;
- "# , -
# - 6/7"#%( 2(03#023
(08 %3# 2)35 2#05! (% /'
9
-, 9 ' < -
, ' *+ - -
, 7
!
"
6/7 4 52 (
, 6/7"#
,, - -.
/' (001#023 4 5( % .
, ,
,
"
= 7
"
" , *"#+ 2#05!%3#(082)35 301 /'
, , ,5 210)#0##
4 5%>53 3 (022#0##- .
, =, , - "# , 5- - 2#05!/'
"# "#
4 515& 1 ' .
,
- -
#(2##0## 4 5) 8 (001#023*4 5(+, ,- "# #(2##0##*4 5)+-
- - , &
.
, ,, , ,, - ? , 5- -
, , :
- /, ,, , - "# :
- 2#05!/' ) ? , "#@ "#
-, - (001#023 *4 5(+
, , /, , ,:
"# , - 6 '
, - , ,
-- 7
,
! "#
! $%$ " "&%"&
'&&"(&"'")$*+,-'"$$ 20 / - 22 / * + 7
-
, - :
- A -, - /, ,,= -, - *- - + ;-
' 5
!
"
### ### ### $%& !
'
(
) * +,- &
.
) * (
/0%0/%1
.
.
(
!
&
&
(
) * +,- &
& ,
) *
%%$/%0
'
$ , (
(
2
$.
2
, (
$/.
(
!
3$4 3$ / &6&4$
$$.
3$4 3$ / &6&4$ !
.
) 3$4 ) 3$ /
( 2
$3,
(
& $/.
2# /! "#* + 5 8%-
$%/%4
+/
9 &
!
( (
)+: ;+< (
,
( 3%1/%1 =
'
) $%0 ( = ( ( ) $%0 ,6&
) $%/ ( $%3 >
(
(
.
) 31 - /%,6& ( = ( ,
( ( =
(
) $%/,6& ( ) $%3 >
31 - /%,6& (
-
$%/%4 =
( = ( ( (
( ( ,
7
=
(
!
+/
### ### ### $>
'
9?
)
6
@
(
,@ +%/=/%0
) 33$13$10$14A/%>,6& ) /5 >
/0$5 - - ) 4 / &B- - .
9 &
& * C !2
.
,(
D
04 /%/$ E -(
6 ( -04
,@+@&%0=/%1=+,-=<B, (
< (
,(
-
) * ,(
- , !
!
"9?
)
+ /5 / F/5
( !(
3$4 3$ / &6&4$)
3$4 &6& 4$
7
?
?)
/
3$ &6&4$(
?
&
?-
(
(
(
-
(
( 2
.*
> '
C 6 6
? ? 1 '
,(
D
( 2
F F/ , (
(
2
.
2
, (
.
(
!
3$4 3$ / &6&4$
.
3$4 3$ / &6&4$ !
.
) 3$4 ) 3$ /
(
2
( ,
(
F 3.
0 4 /% /$ E -(
6 ( -04 ,@ (
,(
- !
) * !
'
+/
) = ,(
- !
!
+/
(
= ( ( (
( = ( '
(
### ### ### 0
,(
- = ) (
(!
(
3$4 3$ / &6&4$, !
> ) ;
:
!
)+: ;+< (
)
'
+/> ) ;:
!
)+: ;+ < (>
$%/%4
+/
( %%0/%4
+/
* + 2( / /, ,,
, - A ,
-
, :
/, ,,= - -
- , !
' B , ,6 ,
- , ' ' - , ,- / * +/, ,,
= =,
, , @/, ,, = =,
"# , , - ! "#* + 2% / / , #(2##0##*4 5)+ 2' ' 3 && '
(4 4 * $.
5#%67* $ % /
$7 (4 4 * * . *
89
$7