Bakhshish Singh v. Punjab State

  
  


 

!"# $#%&'&()*+,

  

           

 


) -./
/.

-./
// 0#'#(") 0./!&(&1$2%!"# 0"3#4#"&"&(#0' 0&56'3!('!71#46"5$2%!"##(#0!716(8!9 0!8#'35!71$2%!"# 0 00&"!:/!&(&1$2%!"# 00#'4($#("+  !8#'3&($!7 3#  4#"&"&(#0'  3!2#  !440!%3#$  "3&'  %60"  %3!77#(;&(;  "3# 0$#0  $!"#$  <

*1  4!''#$  95  $$&"&(!7  &0#%"01 
('7&$!"&( 6(8!91(!(!447&%!"&( &7#$950#'4($#("'+"*6($#0/#%"&(*+  "3#!'"6(8!9
('7&$!"&(!($0#2#("&( 0!;:#("!"&( %"1

*=

0'30"1-"3#%"-  "&'!%!'#&(>3&%3"3#%('7&$!"&(40%##$&(;'&("3#2&77!;# 3!$"!?#(47!%#!06($

*@ #!075">$#%!$#'"3#0#!

"#010#'4($#("'

+"* &7#$!447&%!"&(6($#0/#%"&(*+ "3#%"%7!&:&(;"3!"!""3# "&:# %('7&$!"&(1!4!''!;#>!'402&$#$""3#&0

3#!447&%!"&( >!'!77>#$;0!("&(;"3#4!''!;# 0:"3#7!($>(#$95"3#4#"&"&(#0'

>&"36"402&$&(;"3#:!(5%:4#('!"&( 0"3#'!:#3#'"!($"!?#(95

+ "3#4#"&"&(#0'&'"3!"0#'4($#("'+"*1>3!0#%@>(#0' $&

#0#("

40"&(' 7!($1!70#!$53!2#!4!''!;# 0:"3#"3#0'&$#77"3#5>!("#$ >!'!4!''!;# 0:%7'#""3#!9!$& "3#2&77!;#3#'!:#&'(""3# 98#%"&(%('7&$!"&(40%##$&(;'2#("3#0>&'#1"3#!447&%!"&(>!'

&7#$(#!075">$#%!$#'!

"#0"3#%('7&$!"&(3!$ "!?#(47!%#13#(%#1 "3#0#>!'(A6#'"&( !77>&(;"3#4!''!;#"0#'4($#("'+"*

0:"3#7!($ "3#4#"&"&(#0' 3#'"!($"!?#(950#'4($#("'+"*>!'"3!""3#53!$ 9##(6'&(;4!''!;# 0:B3!'0!+CC<C >(#$95"3#4#"&"&(#0'"&'

(75>3#("3#598#%"#$""3#'!:#"3!""3#!447&%!"&(>!'0#A6&0#$"9#

&7#$3#0#>!''#""7#:#("9#">##("3#4!0"&#'  "#03#!0&(;7#!0(#$%6('#7 0"3#4!0"&#'1&(604&(&(1"3# ;06($(>3&%3"3#!447&%!"&( &7#$950#'4($#("'+"*6($#0 /#%"&(  *+    "3#  %"1  (#!075  ">  $#%!$#'  !

"#0  "3#  %('7&$!"&( 40%##$&(;'1>!'!77>#$95$$&"&(!7&0#%"01
('7&$!"&(%!(("9# 7#;!775'6'"!&(#$3#0#7#2!("4!0" "3#0$#0&'#D"0!%"#$9#7>) E  3!2#  3#!0$  "3#  !0;6:#("'    9"3  "3#  4!0"&#'  !($  !7' 4#06'#$  "3#  :!4  !70#!$5  (  "3#  &7#  3#  4!''!;#  >3&%3 !440!%3#' "3# &#7$'   "3#4#"&"&(#0 0:"3#/6"3  !($ '3>' &( "3# :!4 >3&%3  &'  !0 !>!5 0:"3# !9!$& 3# 4#"&"&(#0 0!440!%3&(;3&' &#7$' 0:"3#!9!$&'&$#1"3#0# &'"4!''!"7#!'""30##?&77!'3#4#"&"&(#0'!7'40$6%#$ !

&$!2&" !""!(/&(;3'( ""!:/&(;3%@'3!0#0'

!?'3&'3  /&(;3  $!"#$  *

*  "  &'  :#("&(#$  &(  "3&'

!

&$!2&""3!"3#3!'(98#%"&(& "3#4!"39#402&$#$""3# 4#"&"&(#0'F

G 3#'&"#47!( ((#D60#@+ 40$6%#$(0#%0$3!'!7'9##( 4#06'#$"$#4&%"'$&

#0#("40"&(' 7!($>(#$95"3#4!0"&#'!0"

"3#7!($>(#$950#'4($#("'+"*&'%((#%"#$"306;3!4!''!;# $69"1& "3#4!''!;#&'402&$#$"0#'4($#("'+"* 0:"3#7!($   "3#  4#"&"&(#0'1  "3#  '!:#  >&77  '30"#(  "3#  $&'"!(%#    "3#  7!($  

0#'4($#("'+"* 0:2&77!;#!9!$&13>#2#01"3!"&'(""3#(75 98#%"$60&(;%('7&$!"&(2#(& !4!''!;# 0:"3!"4!0"&'4#0:&""#$1 '"&77"3#0#&'7!($>(#$95"3#04#0'('&(9#">##("306;3>3&%34!''!;# >&773!2#"9#402&$#$"#(!97#0#'4($#("'+"*"0#!%3"3#&0 40"&( 7!($3#0#&'(#D47!(!"&(!2!&7!97# 0"3!" '0#;!0$'"3#'#""7#:#("!00&2#$!"9#">##("3#4!0"&#'1&"&' '6

&%&#(""("&%#"3!"&">!':#0#75$60&(;"3#4#($#(%5 "3#7&"&;!"&( "3!"4!0"&#'0#'72#$("" &;3"!($!9&$#95"3#%60"$#%&'&(3#'!:# %!(("9#'!&$"9# &(!7'#""7#:#(" 0"3#0#!'(':#("&(#$!92#1"3#>0&"4#"&"&(&'!77>#$ 3#   &:46;(#$  0$#0  $!"#$  <

*  ((#D60#  @*  4!''#$  95 $$&"&(!7&0#%"01
('7&$!"&(6(8!91&''#"!'&$#

!8#'3&($!7 6$;#  !0&($#0/&(;3/&$36 6$;# *+,

:?

3#"3#0'4#!?&(;C0#!'(#$)

#'C 3#"3#00#40"!97#)

#'C