Dilawar Singh And ANR v. Financial Commissioner, Haryana And Others
(1)
!" "#$%$&'( $) * +$&,-.!-"+%
$& &#$ )//$%%$&"+0 +1 & .!-"+% 2' 342 2 342 2 4 2 0
!"!#$!"% &' ( & )"*+ , '--. / 0"1#"
&)/ 2"1#"20 - "$!3 %- - 4 5$$6 4 & 576 - 8-& 9!:!#$!"6 &'-- 3 ; 3 &
& - "%!%$!"1 & < '-- & )"*"1#" - -
(2)
$ = & 576 )"*+ "1#" &
)"" '' -
&-8-& &"1:7+:: & & &-) & - + 8- & -
+
&8-& - &)
* ' ( '- *!!%"1##
& -) - &- , - ' & ; , -!*!7"1#6 )
5"*7$ "1#6 & ' , - !6!*"1%1 , - - &2 )
- ""!7"11# &8-& > 3 & 2 - ' (
, & & 8-&
(3)
?
&'-- 3; 3
& < '-- & !:!#$!"6"%!%$!"1 & * - - - = - "$!3 %- &,- 2 ,4 2 - 23
, 32 & ,- & "1:7+:: & &
-23
, 32 , 576
)"*+ "1#" & &
'
)+@A + +, )+@A + +,
' ' &-) &8-&
- 8-&
-
(4)
?
)""7/ 0 =B - 3 8-& ' ' - - &
>
- - & -
& - &
576 )"*+"1#" 7 @
- - &
-
, - & ' 2 )
-' &-)
C +:
+# &
- -
& :
- D - -
& 576 )"*+ "1#" &
& '
)
&2 )
-
&
, - &'
(5)
- -
3 = - & - , - 2 )
-' 5+6 7%-$&,- 8%$77 $&,-"1#*)
/"0)'
:: &/! * +&$8% /!&9"+: 5+0"11#/%0 )':6! )* &!$&,-8% 5) !$&,- 9" 9 61 4 % /"11%0 % )'' "*% 5+ ; - & 8% $& &#$ ) //$%%$&"+/$!!%0#)''"6# , -)
- /!-$/ 6 $2 - 9": /6"7 +!-+5,-4 8%+!-5+ /<+! &9=<+!/< &1 &9!-"+%/$!"10*)''"1") .
/'0 5 :%7* $!$! -" //$%%$&"+ +5- !- &, )+"2 - & , + )$7" &9 &!-"+8% + 5)) :- & &9 &!-"+$:!"$!$") .
/'05 "*"7#$!$" $!"&9+ $&,-8%-"! !" 2 9-1 + 9"%- &9!-"+%!#!1$!$" # &- ?
, -
- ' - - - - )+@A + +,
D = - -?
(6)
& 8-& - C D, - &'
- - ) ' ) -- -- )+@A +
+, -) ; - 3 - ) - & &' ' 3 - -
& - - - ' &
- D - D & , -
)+@A + +, --
/+ 0 = - 3 -- - =
)+@A + +, - D+ - -
(7)
-)77 , . "66%= )+@A + +,;
,/ 0- 4 5$$6 - "$!3 %- /
0
--
--
= & - )+@A + +, & -
2 +- -3,2- "$!3 %- & -- = '
2 )
-' , -) & -
--
&)+@A + +,B 8-&
- +
+- - & )
-' - 8-&
&8- &
(8)
-- & %
3 &
& , - &2 )
- ' + / &#- 1 ! 8$)) ," 5) 7- % ; , + $&,- $!!!= /)'0*$%$ "1#" + E/0=
&
&
- > - F
&
& /0
& , A
& -- C &
-- & & /0B , - & ?
& ?
, G 6 = &-' ' - & , = &
- & )"*+"1#"
(9)
& , - &
1 5 -
& 576 8-& &)+ @A + +, &
2 + - -3,2/ 0 & -- 8-&
&
D 8 &
)$ / 0/*0"1#" - -- & &
= 2,2
- ---
-- & -
-,/ 0 C
& ?
-
)$/ 0/*0/70"1#" 8-&
(10)
"! = ?
-
&
- & -
"" <
' , ,
& ?
& && & &
- &
' & -
-& -)"*"1#"
, ' ' =
"1#" - )"*"1#" & 576 - "$ = -
- - 2 ( 2 4
-"!-"+%<" 7$&,>+" %&"9'
"%> -"!-"+ "<+! 6)"'
"%>