High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/12447/2014allowed

Avtar Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2015-07-17Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul6 pages

!"# #$%&'()* +,-./"$01

,","$ . 2 .3&3 /,-, &$4-5-$#,1 .3

36$# $,3 % 78 / 82 91 ,1 .. 6., .3'!-'$ :36-6 .3;-(5 -'': #,3 4 $,< 3 5 . .. #,. 6., .3.$,< 3 =91 ,1 .,1 4 $,31&'#5 . 6., #"$,1 "0 3,< 3

. 3 $,% .;",/-"$")#+!-, .,1 6 ,","$ .

. /-#-1-.)) &$4-5 .-0$-1-./"$01)#+!-, .

.// -$0")#+!-, .. 36$# $,3-$#,> ./-'"'?-&31-')#+!-, .. 36$# $,=

1 6 ,","$ .1-3"' #,1 6. 3 $,6 ,","$&$# ./ !,"$@ .

.A&-31"$0,1 .# .#-, #@ "$ * #-, #&$# ./ !,"$3*)==)*>)@)C . 0"3, . #-,

'"! /,-,"$-!11":-.-)"3,."!,?1-$$- / !,"$=*-## #-$#/ !,"$

== # ' , # '-, . $ ) :1 . 5( ,1 &#"!"-' -0"3,.-, 3, '-33 1-# #"3;"33 #,1 -66'"!-,"$"' #&$# ./ !,"$=. =

;+ #5(' -.$ #

.,1 /,-, 1.&01 ,1 -66'"!-,"$) ,1 6 ,","$ .!;6'-"$-$, 3 D3 3&;;$"$0,1 "$+ 3,"0-,"$0"! .)$-; '()/&.5-!1-$/"$01:1 :-3$, B-;"$ #5(,1 ,."-'&.,-$# +"# $! ,1 6.3 !&,"$:-3 !'3 #:",1&,!$3"# ."$0,1 . 6., #-, #=2"# ) 3&;;$3 : . "33& # , / &.5-!1-$ /"$01 . 1"3 -66 -.-$! $*=-$#$,1 3-"#3&;;$3)1 1-#. 6., #,1-,1 :-3-'. -#(5&$##:$. +"# $! "$,1 &.,/1-.6. ,/"$01)

/)&#"!"-'-0"3,.-, 3,'-33"$!-3 >C&$# ./ !,"$ =C ) '"! /,-,"$) ?1-.-. . ,1 3-"# #-, !!.#"$0'() ", :-3 . A& 3, #,1-,1 ;-(5 0"+ $3; ,1 .#-, .-66 -.-$! 1 -66'"!-,"$&$# ./ !,"$=.

"' #5(,1 ' -.$ #

.,1 /,-, . .3,-$-+ .; $,,1-,,1 3-"#:",$ 33"3-;-, ."-' :",$ 33-$#,1 "$+ 3,"0-,"$0"! ."$,1 !-3 -$#),1 . . )1"36. 3 $! "3 33 $,"-'.,1 4&3,# !"3"$,1 !-3 1 -66'"!-,"$:-3663 #5(,1 -!!&3 #"$!'&#"$0$,1 0.&$#;-"$,-"$-5"'",( &.,1 .),1 6.3 !&,"$ +"# $! :-3!'3 #5( .# .,1 &.,-$#-,,1"33,-0 )3&!1-66'"!-,"$&$# ./ !,"$= .

"3$,;-"$,-"$-5'

: + .) ' -.$ # &#"!"-' -0"3,.-, 1-# #"3;"33 # ,1

-66'"!-,"$=.

$,1 0.&$#,1-,,1 +"# $! -33&01,,5 6.#&! #"3$,-$ : +"# $! 5(53 .+"$0-3&$# .% E

" ## $%& ' %( )

$%& ' %( # *

( (

+ # !

! (

" ! )

- . %# . , (#

! " # ! / $))

% !

, (# - . %# (

) ( * 0 1 E2 #

# ! ) ( 3

4 *

( + (

# +

(

! #

(

5 #

( ## !

6# ! (

& !

# ( (

! +

(

( #

% ) ) 8, 9:

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

" 3&00 3,,1-,,1 5-"'-5' :-..-$,3,1 "$+ 3,"0-,"$0"! .&.5-!1-$ /"$01: . + .3 .+ #&6$1"; 8 -.$ #!&$3 '.,1 6 ,","$ .&.,1 .!$, $#3,1-,,1 ,."-' &.,31&'# 1-+ 3 !&. #,1 6. 3 $! ,1 "$+ 3,"0-,"$0"! .5( -#1 ."$0,,1 6.+"3"$3 $31."$ #"$1-6, .2,1 # .";"$-'

! #&. )5&,:",1&,'':"$0,1 3-"#6.! #&. ),1 ,."-'&.,1-# !'3 #,1 6.3 !&,"$ +"# $! +"# .# .#-, #*=1 3-"#.# . $:1 . # -'3:",1,1 -!,,1-,,1 "$+ 3,"0-,"$0"! :-35&$##:$"$ -$,1 .!-3 $,1 ,1 .1-$#)' -.$ #!&$3 '.,1 . 36$# $,3-!!&3 # 1-+ !$, $# #,1-,-3;-$(-3= !,"+ 66.,&$"," 3: . 0.-$, #, ,1 6.3 !&,"$:1"!1,D;. ,1-$*G( -.3,!$!'&# ",3 +"# $! -$# ", :-3 $'( -, . "$#"$0 $ &.,1 . 4&3,""!-,"$) ,1 +"# $! ,1 6.3 !&,"$:-3!'3 #+"# .# .#-, #*= $3"# ."$0,1 -!,,1-,,1 "$+ 3,"0-,"$0"! "3$ ,1 ";6.,-$,:",$ 33 3)5&,1 5 "$0$,-+-"'-5' $*=-31 :-3 5&$##:$"$3; ,1 .!-3 -,?1-.-.&.,),1 ";6&0$ #.# .#-, # @ #"3;"33"$0 ,1 -66'"!-,"$ &$# . / !

,"$ = . "3 $, 4&3,"" ##&5,)-3;-$(-3= !,"+ 66.,&$"," 31-+ 5 $0.-$, # -$#","3-3-!$3 A& $! ,1 . ,1-,,1 +"# $! ,1 6.3 !&,"$:-3 !'3 #)5&,,1"3&.,"$#3,1-,$$-66 -.-$! /&.5-!1-$/"$01-3 "$+ 3,"0-,"$0"! "$,1 !-3 "3$,"$, $,"$-').-,1 .)1 :-34&3,"" #.

> ,1 . -3$,1-,1 :-35&$##:$"$,1 .!-3 -,?1-.-. !!.#"$0'()"$#3&53,-$! "$,1 6. 3 $,6 ,","$-$#3 , -3"# ,1 .# .#-, #@ 6-33 #5(,1 ,."-'&., $3 A& $,'()-!! 6,"$0,1 6. 3 $,6 ,","$),1 -66'"!-,"$

= "' #5(,1 ' -.$ #

.,1 /,-, "3-'': #-$#,1 ,."-'

&.,"3#". !, #,-.#$ ;. 66.,&$",(,,1 6.3 !&,"$5( 3&;;$"$0,1 -. 3-"#:",$ 33" /&.5-!1-$/"$01-$#,-'': 1";,5 B-;"$ #"$,1 !-3

7-0&,,7