High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1859/2002allowed

Kailash Chand v. State Of Hy.

2015-07-01Mr. Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul9 pages

#$%%$ &#'()*+%,$%! -(../

&&#+

(/& 0) 120

(&) 0

.,/3'&

0 0*(. .,(((&&/3'&,+

4 5 . & 6( &/ # '&&7 &. ##' *(.8 */ '&( 9:9, 9::, 9%$ 4 &. &&3

'&(9%: 5,9;$,9<:/$% =/*7/>*/7& ///&/ ?$$ % $%%$,///& (((*/7,

'.@*./&.&7*&+*/ '&9<: +/ (&'/.&*/77*((&#(3+(/ & +## ( $,%%%?

/ /#*&#+& ##,& */7((&#&.

. '( # &. ('*&, *&(., ( &.& $ $%%,&.('*&A,6.6(/*7.&# B *@ /&.<+(#7,6&&.&8*&&

.6((8+ B2>> &&. 6.((6(., ((&#&.&,'7&.('*&A,6.'.&.('*&A 6&&&..*(#&.& B.&.('*&A//& &* ., . #+ 8( (&&/ ('.7 # .

#&/2>> #/'& *@ &.&. ./ ( &. ('*&A 77 & &. .*( # &. &

''/7+,'& *@ /2>> 6&&&.

.*(#&.&6.&.+&./.(((&(. .+ C*/#.8*&&.('*&A8*&&.&/.( ((&//8*&&.('*&A3(&7&..*( &.A& /+, '.+&47&.7#('&8(56('3/6.'. &.&#(&//3+&.78*&,&,/&&/&.&&. ('*&A6(6&..#9 %% &< 9% &.3*( /+ & *@ /(&&&A

6.'.6( '//8+ 7./&(8((, A

?$6( 7(&/7(&&.&& ' &&.//*/

'&(9:9,9::,9;$,!%:/$%

*73(&7&#&.'(,&.//8/+#&. ('*&A6('3/#6 % $%% .//8/+ 6((*8>'&/&(&&8+ B$ */ 7. , 6./&.&&.((8&+#.3787'&&/* &.('*&A'*/&8*/*& .&6((&/ % $%%/6(7&/'+A/ '&#&. 3(&7&,&.&6('.//(*8(C*&+,'.7/ #&.#&/##'(,&6.'..//&7*&+/ '/&

(*& # &( '(, &. ('*& A/

*@ ,#&.#&.('*&A, B$ . 7.,6.6( (&&. '.+&6.'.6('3/$"

$%%, B9

./,6.(('&.//8/+#&.('*&A6( &@*&#&.6, B!2>> ,6../(&./'(/ &. $ $%%/,&.#&,77&&..*(#&. &#&87(7/8+.(((&, B< >,6../

( .8*'7&&..*(#&.&&! %%

/778'@&:

9% $ $%%, B$ */ 7.

,6../(*8>'&/&.//8/+#&.('*&A&(& &/(/'+A/&.&, B9 *8.(.

./, .&7./ B;(&80.2,#&(, 6.3/&.('/(&A

= .3(&7&&#&. '(6(&/8+ B; /-*, B:

7., B 0 >, B" (.-*, B%&

7., B('&07 , B!(&8-*/ 7.

/ B: 2

B.A/*/ '&99

,&.& //&.&.6(#(+'&/&.'((&.&(# &./'(/(*('&/&.&(.6(36&.. 87/ & 8'@6/ '(( 6.( &. /'(/ 87/ & *>> '*&+/,''/7+,.&(//&3.## 6&.&.& /#',&.&//&/*'+ 3/' #& 77 &.*7. &. 3/' / .7 / '*(#&.&(,&.&*&'C*&&/&.&#&. '.7(*(.8*/ '&(9:9,9::,9;$/9%$ 4/ &.&&3*/ '&(9%: 5/$% 8+8(37 (*/)

D. #(& / ('/ '.7( */

'&(9:9/9:: &(3/&.#&.&

./ 7 & &. .*( # ''*(/ -(. $ $%% *&&.(3/'7/7+

*(##'/'& .7# .((& 8(&8(./8++83/' .( +((&8+ B&.& 6(:?<+( / &.(& &&&.7(&/ (<? +( .('*&.(&'/& 3&.8&.'&#'&#&.('.'&#'&#

/'&7./&#8&.

B/&(&.& ./(&*//*&&.!&.?:&.'(( ('*/& /+ '(( A& &.& 6( 8 $!

< (/&&/&.&../73&.7 8+A& ,&.(83/'# 37&.7# .8#&#&.((.( &7&&.''*(//&.(&8((*/&.&

6(83 +(#7 ,#&.83 ((,'.7(*/ '&(9:9/9:: &/*&7(&&.''*(/ . &./ '.7 7(& &. ''*(/ ( 7/7 7 '#& 3/' &. # (.6(&.& ./3*&+7&&..*(# &. ''*(/ . ( #*&. 3/' ''*(&'( &. # # 6.'. & '*/ 8 #/&.& ./88(&*'&/3&/ # 37 &. '#( # &. .*( 8+ &. ''*(/ .((*77(&#'&

& 6( .( '(( A& &.& .( /*7.&

6(.37##6&. &.''*(/ &( (&/&. A

?$&.&&.''*(/ /&&/8#&. '.+&&.&.6(.37 3##6&. &.(''*(&'(.&. ''*(//&'&8*/ *&&.& 6( .37 ## 6&. ''*(/ / & 6( # &.( ( &.& (. 3(&/ ''*(/ $ $%%

-736&.(88&(/&.8('#

+ 3/' # 67#* (&&, &. 8#& # /*8&.(&7&&.''*(//.'&8 '3'&/#&.##'*/ '&9;$#&. / / AAA AAA AAA AAA AAA AAA AAA .(&'.7(7(&&.''*(/*/

'&(9%$ /&.&&3*/ '& 9%: /($% ./&.# .( 8'+3/ .//8/+6('3/ #&.6/&6(/&#/8+.&3(/ #&. ./.(8A/( B9, 6../3//&#'&#&.8/+ .(& 3(*77(&#&.(/#/#'&.&(/ //8/+/(&87&

,&(3/&.#&.& 6((& ( 77 & &. .*( # &. ''*(/ &. #&#$ $%% &.37&.''*(/ 6('#&/8+ *@ /2>> ,. (&7.&6+//&.& ./3(&/.(.*( &.&/+ *&&.A&/+&. '.+&. /&&/&.& 6(6&..#9 %% &< 9% .('.# '&*/#&.37 #$ $%%*&$ % $%% ,3+&. 37*(&.386&.& 6(((7

&.37./( &.37 & 6(+.//8/+6.'.6('3/#&. 6$ % $%% &.((83/&.& ./8(*8>'&/&8#./&.

&' 87'+#/&.&&.(A*(8&6&. (/ '/& # $ $%% / &. /&. #

63,&.((&6/'.( .+ @(&.'.6.'.'& B/&

@6&.'*(#/&.# (&&& 3(&.&A&@(#>*+6/&'&/ &.(# .&A

'3/#

2(.6(&.&'(6(/&'&/ + # &. 3(' # 6.'. 6( (& # A& B(.3&A

&7 & &. ('& # ' (' 8+ ('&#'& .(&6(*8&''&+ 3/' # &. .*( # &. ''*(/ / .( &3(,6.'.'*//&&.''*(&.& ./ 8 *& & /&. &. (/ (( . .(&&.7'/&&.((73&(& A

#&A7&.3(' (&.(& 3(' 3/ /3'/ *&+&' '.7( 6&. #& # 7 *&+&' '+(&( / '& /(' # *' 8('*7 .7' /&(/(&6(&((8&'&&. ('#+&.7'#/7( */

7.4 B$5 #&#7&&. &(.( (&&/(#6()

88'*(#/&.'*/&873( &. & #

2 0/.*8 / .&@ 0/'7,.3(&&/&.&&.8/+./ */7/3'/*&+&''.7(&.8+ 8('*7.7'#/7( ./&.

+((*&/*&(.+A .'*(# (.+A '*/ 8 /* & /67 / ('#7((&.6(/+(&&/ &..(&+#'( &. 7.& # #(/ /' 3/' 6'&'.+/#&''*(&&.'*(# /&. &.( '( . '*/ 8 &6 ((8&( 7/7&./&.# &.(.6(*// /,&.#&,&.6&.6('/+,(../

! '&&/ (*'/ 8+ >*7 & &. 6 / &.#&/67&/&.

'/&((& 888#&.(&.&A&@ #>*+6((&.(# &((' &.&&6(&'(#(7 '((8(/''*(&&3/'&. #'&( (&8(./ (.*/ 8 '((&& 6&. &. .+&.((#&.7*&#&.''*(//&.+(.*/ 8'((&&6&..('' .('&8(/ #(&'( &.83''*(&'('& + /*8&( 8*& ''*(/ .37 *// /&.&.6.8/+6 ,&.'.7( */ '&(9%$/$% '&8(*(&/ .'.7*/ '&9%: ((& (*(&8 .(3/'''*(&'( &.##6.'.&'*/8#/&.&&.''*(/ ./(&7&/&./'(/&'&(*'/./ 8&&/&.

'((#(*'/+ . ('*&.((#/&&*&+((8 &3#&.''*(/#8&&7&.'((# (*'/8+ 03,&.('*&.(( #/&3&.'*(#/&.&.('( ,# &.((('.7*/ '&9%: ( #( (#/&,&.&(&/('3'&/*/ '& 9<: . &&.(&'.7/&.'C*&&#&.& #&.

&(&.'(#&.('*&&(#&.&&.('*&A 6(7/8*&<? +( &./+#&.'/&,6.(. 6&&. #737#//&.8*##,(.6(&'/ 8+ B!2>> 3&. /2>> &.&'/&.&&.

((&#&.&'/&.('*&A8+737.(7 '37&.(7,&.('*&A67+6&&&..*(#&. & (&6.&./&.#&((*7.&&83/8+ &. ('*& 8+ /7 ''*(&& 3/' ( #& &. ('*&A'./&..*(#&.&,(.6(&( &.37&.37#$ $%%/(&.#67/+

$%%, '.+&6('3/&.376.&. & / / // .37 + ./ &. /('?((7 # &. ('*&A 63, ., & , *'&&+/&&/&.&&.37#$ $%%,&.('*&A 6(6&..8&69 %% /< 9% &(6.&. 3/'&.&&.&./'&&/#'8(A*&'*( 6&.&.('*&A .//8/+#&.('*&A6((*8>'&/ &(&&A&8+ B$ */ 7. ,6. //&#/+A&@#>*++6.3&.8/+ 3 &.6(8/7#.37.+ .3*('&.( 68+&./'(/6(&&&. (' ''28&+

(&.&F

#&. (' ''28&+,.* (,76&.8/6(#*/(&&.*/6#&. /'(/ 0+ 8'*( .* ( 6( &'/ &. */6#&./'(/(&(*##'&&./&.&&.('*&A ./8(*8>'&/&#'8(A*&'*(8+&.& >*+, 6.&(3, 6( #*/ &. // 8/+ 6. & 6( (*8>'&/&(& & ./((#&.&&.&&. ('*&A / 6&. . 8&6 9 %% / < 9%

$ $%%'&(&@&.'(#&.('*&&./

&.&&.&./'&&/*&.('*&A 78+ &.#'&&.&&.&'7&836&.&.('*&A 6.'.#'&6(&&&.@7#.&((&.+87/& /##&'*&(/&.6((&*77&.&#&. ('*&A.8736/8+&.&/*'.7 .+('((*&.6*/&.&&.('*&A./8 '(&7&+ .6(<? +(#7&./+#&. ''*'/,&.*(,3+6'(&&.3(A*&'*( 6&.&.& (&/83,&.(*&(&C*/&'(/ (&6.&.&.('*&A.(#'&&/(*'/#&&.'&# (A*&'*(&6(&.& 6../'&&/. *//&.6.//8/+&.6(&. &&.(& '.7/&.#/7(&.#&/((*(3/&8+&. &*&

36#&.83,&.(*&#/(&/##'*&&(*(& &.*7/>*/7&#'3'&/(&' .(, ''/7+, 6/ / &. & ( 'C*&&/ # &. '.7 7(&. (8 .8/(#*(./8+./.( (*&((.(&//('.7/ "# *+%,$%! $%&'