Manjit Singh v. State Of Punjab
!"# #$%&%'()
!'*%"+%',- #"%"%'#.
/#.&0& +"!"# 0'*!1 #&2'3#'"
.#&#'"( . ++#4-'536$!"# ."-#2#"%"%'#. .0.%'3#.%"+%',-55 0'*!1 -%&.3#.&-!883%&2&# "-#2.#&#'"2#"%"%' %8#30'3#.
+#$"%'9:.#!3;%"-+#$"%'< "-#3# .%=%'!8 .$#30.# &##4%',"-#$'$#&&%' .#,08!.1!%8""-#2#"%"%'#.%'$!&# 9:
3!"#3 .#,%&"#.#30'3#.+#$"%'& ><>) "-#!.$"%$.0,& !'3 &?$-".2%$+01&"!'$#&$" .&-."@"-#$"@ !" 8%$#+"!"%'
08#20.5%&".%$" !"#-,!.-+!-%1 -#2#"%"%'#.;!&!..#&"#3' !'3!&2#.2.&#$0"%'
6#.&%'5"-#!88#,#3.#$6#.?%& )A"8&'3 B,& 222?-0&4 C#!.'#3$0' ."-#2!."%#&-!6#1##'-#!.3!"8#',"-
'3#.+#$"%'< "-#3# .%=%'!8 .$#30.#!'3 0'3#.%"&6!.%0&&01&#$"%'&5"-#=!D%=0=2#.%31#?'3;-%$-!2#.&' $!''"1#3#"!%'#3;-%8#%'6#&"%,!"%'%&0'3#.;!?-!&1##'2.6%3#3!'3 "-#&!=#6!.%#&1#";##'< ":
3!?&4##2%',%'6%#;"-#,.!6%"?
#'$# "-#%'6#&"%,!"%'%&'"$=28#"#3;%"-%'&0$-&"%208!"#32#.%35 "-#!$$0%&#'"%"8#3"1!%80'3#.+#$"%'< "-#3# .%=%'!8
.$#30.#% -#=!4#&!'!228%$!"%' .&0$-20.2&#;#6#.50'3#."-# $"5"-#=!D%=0=2#.%3 :
3!?& %D#30'3#.+#$"%'< "-#3#
.%=%'!8 .$#30.#-!&1##'%'$.#!") 3!?& .#.!8$!"#,.%#&
#'$#&0'3#."-#$" '3#.+#$"%'9< "-#$"5"-#2#.%3
3#"#'"%'=!?,'"!""!8 '#?#!.&01*#$""&!"%& !$"%'!'3 $=28%!'$# "-#&".%',#'"$'3%"%'&2.6%3#3"-#.#%'%#% 02'!.#2." "-# 018%$ .&#$0".E%% ;-%$-%'"0.'%'3%$!"#&"-#2.,.#&& "-# %'6#&"%,!"%'E%%% &2#$% %#&"-#$=2#88%',.#!&'& .&##4%',"-#3#"#'"%'
"-#!$$0#?'3"-#2#.%3 ) 3!?&E!'3%6 !
"#.'"%$#""-# !$$0 -#'@18#+02.#=#0."%'
!";-%8#3#!8%',;%"-"-# 2.6%&%'&#."#3!&$8!0 %'&01&#$"%' +#$"%' ;-%$-%&2!.%=!"#.%!;%"-"-#2.6%&"&01+#$"%' +#$"%'9<
"-# $" -!3 $!"#,.%$!88? -#83 "-!" #6#' "-0,- "-# 2.6%& 3#& '" &2#$% %$!88?=!'3!"#"-#%&&0!'$# !'"%$#""-#!$$0-%8#&##4%', #D"#'&%'?#""-#%&&0!'$# !'"%$#-!&"1#.#!3%'""-#2.6%&%'
;-%$-;0831#51"-5%'"-#%'"#.#&" "-#!$$0#!&!8&"-#2.&#$0"%'
!&;#88!& .3%',$=28#"#*0&"%$#1#";##'"-#2!."%#&+0$-.#F0%.#=#'" ;!&-#83"1#%'$'&'!'$#;%"-"-#2.%'$%28#& '!"0.!8*0&"%$# 36#."%',1!$4""-# !$"& "-#2.#&#'"$!"-#2#"%"%'#.
;!& 0'3%&20"#38? $'
%'#3 " *03%$%!8 $0&"3? ' -# 2.&#$0"%'!,#'$? !%8#3"2.#&#'""-#$-!88!';%"-%'"-#&"%208!"#32#.%3 ) 3!?&!&2.6%3#30'3#.+#$"%'9< "-#$"-#2#.%3 )
3!?&#D2%.#3' -#2.&#$0"%'=6#3!'!228%$!"%' .
#D"#'&%' "%=# .&01=%&&%' $-!88!''"-#8%,-" .3#.3!"#3 : 5"-#".%!80.",.!'"#3#D"#'&%' "-.##='"-&@"%=# .
$=28#"%' %'6#&"%,!"%'
9 '!228%$!"%' %8#31?"-#2#"%"%'#.0'3#.&#$"%'< . 3!"#3) ;!&3%&=%&'"-# 88;%',3!?%#:
'!$$0'" #D"#'&%'-!6%',1##',.!'"#3!'3$-!88!'-!6%',!8.#!3? 1##'2.#&#'"#3': %" '"-#$'&%3#.#36%#; "-%&0."5"-#.#-!&1##'!'' $=28%!'$# "-#2.6%&%'&$'"!%'#3%'+#$"%'9< "-#$"-# 2.6%&%'=!'3!"#&!.#2." "-# 018%$ .&#$0".%'3%$!"%',"-#2.,.#&& "-#%'6#&"%,!"%'!&!8&"-#&2#$% %$!'3$=2#88%',.#!&'& .&##4%', "-#3#"#'"%' "-#!$$0#?'3!2#.%3 ) 3!?& 2#.0&!8 "-#.3#.3!"#3: 2!&?"-#".%!8 0."$8#!.8?&-;&"-!""-#$'3%"%'&!&#'6%&!,#30'3#.+#$"%'9< "-#$"-!6#'"#6#'1##'!36#."#3";-%8#,.!'"%',#D"#'&%' .
$=28#"%' %'6#&"%,!"%' -#%'3# #!&%18#.%,-" .,.!'" 1!%8-!3!$$.0#3""-# 2#"%"%'#. !& 2#. &#$"%' < . !'3 "-!" $083 '" -!6# 1##'
3# #!"#3=#.#8?'!$$0'" 2.#&#'"!"%' $-!88!'"-#.#!
"#. -%& 0.";083 -!6#'-#&%"!"%' %' 1&#.6%',"-!" "-# !228%$!"%' &01=%""#3 &##4%', #D"#'&%' "%=# . $=28#"%'
%'6#&"%,!"%'5"-#.3#.2!&"-#.#02'!&!8&"-#.3#.3#!8%',;%"-"-# !228%$!"%' %8#31?"-#2#"%"%'#.0'3#.+#$"%'< "-#3#
.%=%'!8 .$#30.#-!6#1##'3#!8";%"-%'!$!&0!8=!''#. -#2#"%"%'#.-!6%', %8#3"-#1!%8!228%$!"%''"-##D2%.?
"-# &"%208!"#3 2#.%3 !& 2#. +#$"%' < "-# 3# .%=%'!8
.$#30.# -!3 !$F0%.#3 !' %'3# #!&%18# .%,-" . ,.!'" 1!%8 '";%"-&"!'3%', "-# ,.!'" #D"#'&%' "%=# 1? "-# ".%!8 0." .
$=28#"%' %'6#&"%,!"%'!'32.#&#'"!"%' "-# %'!8.#2."
G%"-0"#D2.#&&%',!'?2%'%''"-#=#.%"& "-#$!"-# 2.#&#'"2#"%"%'%&!88;#3!%8""-#&!"%& !$"%' "-#".%!80."
#"%"%'3%&2
80$4?