The General Manager, Telecom, Bathinda v. Presiding Officer Central Govt Industrial Tribunal Cum Labour Court Iim Chandigarh And Another

 -1-

 
          

 
 

 !

"#$#%& '(

  ) * + )
*+ 

 ,

  -$ .



 
+


) - *

+

.

 )

  )
* )
 

+
      

 . 

.

./ $

$

/ # $
  







          





        
     

            





             
!




 !  "        





         
     !




          





         
     




 #   

  $         





         
    !!








 -2-
*&  2) * .

 *   .) %&'&()* % +(,&&-+.'/012-34+)&+(2 '+(%&&)+.%2-34+)& 53%)/&6&)0)03(&%7'870(' 9

!!!

35


8+(2 53%%&'63(2&()3
70(' 
 !+(2 35


8 %0:.'//+((+2-34+)& 53%%&'63(2&()3 %0)&'/&%;+2-34+)& 53%%&'63(2&()3
<3%1;+( 70(' 9

!+(2!!

35


8+(2 53%)/&6&)0)03(&%7'870(' 
 !+(2 35


8 *   .)+  4)5 

: )/0' 43;;3( 3%2&% +=3-&'+02 6&)0)03(' +%& =&0(> 20'63'&2 35 '0(4&0''.&'0(-3?-&20(+??)/&6&)0)03('+(26%+:&%'3.>/))/&%&0(+%&43;;3( 0)/)/&43('&()356+%)0&'+(253%)/&'+1&35=%&-0):5+4)'+%&=3%%3<&25%3;  9






/&6&)0)03(&%)/%3.>/0(')+()6&)0)03(.(2&%%)04?&'

#

@35)/& 3(')0).)03( 35 (20+ 0' '&&10(> setting aside of Award dated 12.08.2021 (Annexure P-5) </&%&=: +=3.%3.%)/+'+<+%2&2?.;6'.;43;6&('+)03()3 )/&%&'63(2&()<3%1;+(

/&'& +%& 4%3'' <%0) 6&)0)03(' /& 6&)0)03(&%+(+>&;&() 0' +''+0?0(>>%+()3543;6&('+)03(</&%&+'<3%1;+(0''&&10(>&(/+(4&;&()35 43;6&('+)03( 

/& 6&)0)03(&% 0' + .=?04 &4)3% (2&%)+10(> ) &(>+>&2 %&'63(2&()<3%1;+(0(

@ /&6&)0)03(&%4?+0;')/+)<3%1;+(<+'&(>+>&2 )/%3.>/+43()%+4)3%+(20)0')/&43()%+4)3%</320';0''&2)/&<3%1;+(5%3; '&%-04&()/&+66?04+)03(35<3%1;+(;+))&%4+;&.653%43('02&%+)03(=&53%&

+=3.% 3.%) </04/ 6+''&2 <+%2 +>+0(') )/& <3%1;+( /& 6&)0)03(&%

 -36%&5&%%&2 <%0) 6&)0)03( =&53%& )/0' 3.%) </04/ <+' +??3<&2 -02& 3%2&% 2+)&2

!

7((&A.%&!8 /&;+))&%<+'%&;+(2&2=+41)3 +=3.%3.%)

/&36&%+)0-&63%)03(353%2&%2+)&2 !

0'%&6%32.4&2+'=&?3<* 









 
 



 

 


 

  
!"#$

 

 !$
 %&


' 



( %  
) %

 %

 
% 

 


 





 

 %
 

% 

%% 
 
' 

* 


'


  

 
 
 
 %

 
 %




% 






 
  

 
 *




 

 


 

% 

%


%

 

+

 

  


 

 % 

' 



 %
 


  
 
 

' 






 

' 









*

 



% %
' 
% 

 

 
 




 


' 


 



 %







( %  


% 
)


 






 
%  
 
 


 




%

 


  

 
 %

( %

  




 



' 
B ! ()/&<+1&35+53%&'+0220%&4)03('35)/0'3.%))/& +=3.%3.%) /+' 6+''&2 5%&'/ <+%2 </04/ 0' 0;6.>(&2 =: )/& 6&)0)03(&% +' <&?? +' %&'63(2&() /& +=3.% 3.%) /+' (3) 3%2&%&2 )3 %&0(')+)& )/& <3%1;+( /3<&-&%>%+()&2?.;6'.;43;6&('+)03(35' ?+4'  % +(,&&- +.'/01 2-34+)& '.=;0)' )/+) <3%1;+( 202 (3) 5.%(0'/&-02&(4&)3)/&&55&4))/+)'/&<+'(3)&(>+>&2)/%3.>/+43()%+4)3%=.)

 -420%&4)?: &(>+>&2 =: +(+>&;&() /& +=3.% 3.%) /+' =?0(2?: %&?0&2 .63( +-&%;&()'35<3%1;+(+(2%&,&4)&2&-02&(4&356&)0)03(&% # "
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

/&%&?&-+()&A)%+4)'350;6.>(&2<+%2+%&%&6%32.4&2+'=&?3<* 

' 
%


  
%
 


%

%
   
 

% %
 

, (
) 
- ( 

,&
. 
/ 

 
 

  










  
*  

) (
. 
,/0
,

%
 

) (
. 



%
  %
% 

 
 
 

%
*    
 
 
&



 


%

%
,%% 

 



 





%


 
 &  

% %
,

 





 


%


 


% %
  

-)1'
 
, 

 



 

%
 %

 
&  

 
 
% %
 





 %

%   %

%
  
 

%


 %



 
 %
 



%


 

&  
 

  


% %
2

 &
! %$






 



 %

 -5-   

  

  
 

  

&  


&  
 



&




%

  



 

  

% 
 

%
  


% %




  


 %
' 
!3 
4
,

$
,%
56
!



'3,$




  
 
  
 

 % 
  





  
 
 % %





  


 
&  


 %

 


  
 

 


 %


% %B



/& 6&)0)03(&% 0( -0&< 35 3%2&% 2+)&2 !

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

7/#$:% %+   ';( .
(<< +(2 + )<3 ,.2>& =&(4/ 35 .6%&;& 3.%) %&4&()?: 0(
% / =
>%"#= /  $

/": #% 6>/?

!#" ."# %"

$ %!

% :

/ -$ #7 /

%  $

%!

:

/$+ @ .

%=#% .
''; /+-& %&;0(2&2 .' )/+) )/&%& +%& )<3 4+%20(+? 6%0(406?&' 35 ?+< >3-&%(0(> 0''.+(4& 35 <%0) 35 4&%)03%+%0 .(2&% %)04?&

#35)/&3(')0).)03(35(20+0&7080>/3.%)23&'(3)&A&%40'&)/&

 -663<&%'3566&??+)& %0=.(+?)23&'(3)%&-0&<3%%&<&0>/)/&&-02&(4&.63( </04/ )/& 2&)&%;0(+)03( 35 )/& 0(5&%03% )%0=.(+? 6.%63%)' )3 =& =+'&2 ) 2&;3?0'/&')/&3%2&%</04/0)43('02&%')3=&<0)/3.),.%0'204)03(3%6+?6+=?: &%%3(&3.'=.)23&'(3)'.=')0).)&0)'3<(-0&<'53%)/3'&35)/&0(5&%03%)%0=.(+?

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
<%0)354&%)03%+%04+(=&0''.

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

0;0)+)03( (&4&''+%0?

 -70(5&%03% 3.%)3% %0=.(+? +' %&'.?) 35 )/& +66%&40+)03(35 &-02&(4& 4+((3) =& %&36&(&23%C.&')03(&20(<%0)6%34&&20(>'(&%%3%35?+<</04/0'+66+%&() 3()/&5+4&35)/&%&43%24+(=&43%%&4)&2=:+<%0)=.)(3)+(&%%3%355+4) /3<&-&%>%+-&0);+:+66&+%)3=&(%&>+%2)3+50(20(>355+4)%&43%2&2=:)/&

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

&2 3( + 630() +(2 )/& 0(5&%&(4& 35 5+4) )3 =& 2%+<( 5%3; )/& '+02 50(20(>+%&<0)/0()/&&A4?.'0-&,.%0'204)03(35)/& %0=.(+?+(2)/&'+02630()' 4+((3) =& +>0)+)&2 =&53%& + <%0) 3.%) ) 0' <0)/0( )/&'& ?0;0)' )/+) )/& ,.%0'204)03( 43(5&%%&2 3( )/& 0>/ 3.%)' .(2&% %)

# )3 0''.& + <%0) 35 4&%)03%+%04+(=&?&>0)0;+)&?:&A&%40'&2   ()/&4+'&0(/+(2)/& +=3.%3.%)/+'%&43%2&25+4).+?50(20(>' +(2)/&%&0'(3;+)&%0+?0%%&>.?+%0):3%0(50%;0):0()/3'&50(20(>' 
 ()/&<+1&3550(20(>'%&43%2&2=: +=3.%3.%)+(2+53%&40)&2 ,.2>;&()'35 .6%&;&3.%))/0'3.%)23&'(3)50(20)+66%36%0+)&)30()&%5&%& <0)/)/&0;6.

 -8-   3('02&%0(>)/&6&%03235'&%-04&+(243((&4)&25+4)'+(250>.%&' )/0' 3.%) 23&' (3) 50(2 0) +66%36%0+)& )3 &(/+(4& )/& +;3.() 35 +<+%2&2 43;6&('+)03( !

/& +=3.% 3.%) /+' (3) +<+%2&2 0()&%&') )/3.>/ ?.;6 '.; 43;6&('+)03(/+'=&&(+<+%2&2 /&<3%1;+(0'&()0)?&2)30()&%&')5%3;)/& 2+)&35<+%2443%20(>?:)/&6&)0)03(&%0'20%&4)&2)36+:0()&%&')F G6&% +((.;5%3;)/&2+)&35<+%2)0??)/&2+)&356+:;&()   %0)6&)0)03('')+(220'63'&2350(+=3-&)&%;'  


! A*   .)B ;+(3,  /&)/&%'6&+10(>%&+'3(&2 "&'3 /&)/&%%&63%)+=?& "&'3