High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2844/1992disposed of

Sajni v. State Of Haryana

2015-05-20Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain6 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*+* +

) ,-..- /#'#(") /0!1!&(2/.3!3!/2/43&'3#53677 / /8&"!&(2$9%!"#' /"3#7!($:(#/' /!0;68!/!55!$2#<6"1$9%!"##(#/!72!/1!(! !0#'3&($!7 3&'/$#/:&77$&'<'# '

" =2 >>" >+2 >?"

2>**

>2> =

2 >!($

*=> **2!'%88(@6#'"&(' 7!:!($ !%"'!/#&(979#$ ( "3# !<<#!7' &7#$ 41 "3# 7!($:(#/'2 "3#1 !/# '##5&(A #(3!(%#8#(" %8<#('!"&( /"3#!%@6&/#$7!($2:3#/#!'&("3#!<<#!7

&7#$41"3#."!"#2"3#</!1#/&' //#$6%"&("3#/# :#9#/2"3# !%"'3!9#4##(#B"/!%"#$ /8

/&# 712"3# !%"' "3#%!'#!/#"3!"9&$# ("& &%!"&($!"#$ ?

2&''6#$6($#/.#%"&( "3#-!($%@6&'&"&(%"2

'3/"2,"3#%", 2"3#."!"# !/1!(!'6A3""!%@6&/#2 > 5!(!7'!($

8!/7!' 7!($2 '&"6!"#$&(9&77!A#A/3!2#3'&7!($&'"/&%"&'!/ %('/6%"&( !3!/!0! AA!/'!&( ('"&"6"# #$&%!7 #'#!/%3 !($ $6%!"&(2A/3!3#'!8#:!' 77:#$41("& &%!"&($!"#$

&''6#$6($#/.#%"&(= "3#%"C&$#!:!/$$!"#$+>

2"3#-!($

%@6&'&"&(77#%"/

/'3/"2,"3#77#%"/ 2!''#''#$"3#%8<#('!"&( !'6($#/) D#3/&7!($) *2***EF<#/!%/# *2***EF<#/!%/#

2***EF<#/!%/# ++2***EF<#/!%/#G &''!"&'

&#$:&"3"3#!:!/$ "3#77#%"/2"3#7!($:(#/'

&7#$40#%"&('(/# #/#(%#2"3#7#!/(#$%6/"4#7:29&$#!:!/$$!"#$ +>

2$#"#/8&(#$"3#8!/5#"9!76# "3#!%@6&/#$7!($!'6($#/) D#3/&7!($) +2***EF<#/!%/# ?2+**EF<#/!%/# = 2?+*EF<#/!%/#G "&'"3&'!:!/$:3&%3&'%3!77#(A#$41"3#7!($:(#/'!':#77 !'."!"#&("3#</#'#("!<<#!7' -#!/(#$%6('#7 /"3#7!($:(#/''648&""#$"3!""3#7!($&( @6#'"&(:!'!%@6&/#$ /'#""&(A6< !3!/!0!AA!/'!&(('"&"6"#

#$&%!7#'#!/%3!($$6%!"&(2A/3!3#/#:#/#":!:!/$'<!''#$ 41"3#77#%"/(%!'# '8# "3#7!($:(#/'2:33!$(#A"&!"#$ :&"3 "3# 9#/(8#("2 "3# !86(" %8<#('!"&( :!' $#"#/8&(#$ !'

6($#/) #3/&7!($) =*2***EF<#/!%/# !77!($) 2***EF<#/!%/# !&/685&(7!($) ?+2***EF<#/!%/# ( "3#%!'# "3#7!($:(#/'2:33!$("(#A"&!"#$2"3# %8<#('!"&(:!'$#"#/8&(#$!'6($#/) *2***EF<#/!%/#

2***EF<#/!%/# ++2***EF<#/!%/#

> 9#("3#7!($:(#/'2:3&(&"&!7713!$(#A"&!"#$"3#!86(" %8<#('!"&(:&"3"3#9#/(8#("2$&$("!%%#<""3#'!8#!($ &7#$ 40#%"&('3#'!8#:#/#/# #//#$""3#%6/" /$#"#/8&(!"&(2:3#/#&( "3# # #/#(%# 6/"2 9&$# !:!/$ $!"#$

?2 !''#''#$ "3# %8<#('!"&(!'6($#/) *2***EF<#/!%/# ?+2***EF<#/!%/# 3#'!8#:!'6<3#7$41"3&'6/"&(>

!7! .&(A3 !($ !("3#/ 9 ."!"# !/1!(! !($ !("3#/2 $#%&$#$ ( ** 3#'648&''&(&'"3!"(%#"3#."!"#&"'#7 3!$!A/##$ /A/!("

%8<#('!"&( !" !3&A3#//!"#2"3# # #/#(%#6/" %67$ (" 3!9# $#"#/8&(#$"3#'!8#!"!/!"#7:#/"3!("3!"3#/#&'!%8<7#"#4!/ "3!"6($#/.#%"&(+ "3#%"3#7!($:(#/'&("3#</#'#("'#"

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

7!($2"3#7!($:(#/'&("3#</#'#("'#" !<<#!7'!/#!7'#("&"7#$""3# '!8#!86(" %8<#('!"&( ("3#"3#/3!($27#!/(#$%6('#7 /"3#."!"#2:3&7#("

$&'<6"&(A"3# !%""3!""3#</#'#("7!($:(#/'!/##("&"7#$"%8<#('!"&( &( "#/8' "3# /!"#' !" :3&%3 "3# %8<#('!"&( :!' !:!/$#$ " "3# 7!($:(#/' &( !7! .&(A3,' %!'# '6</! 2 '648&""#$ "3!" "3#/# &' ( !<<7&%!"&( "3#</9&'&(' .#%"&(+ "3#%"&("3#</#'#("%!'#2!'

"3#!86("2!':!'$#"#/8&(#$41"3#."!"#((#A"&!"&(:&"3!'#"

7!($:(#/'2:!'("!%%#<"#$41"3#8( !%"2((# "3#7!($:(#/'3!$ 4##(<!&$%8<#('!"&(!""3!"/!"#9#("3#7!($:(#/'2:33!$&(&"&!771 (#A"&!"#$2 46" 7!"#/ ( &7#$ 40#%"&('2 3!9# !7' 4##( !:!/$#$ %8<#('!"&(&("#/8' "3#06$A8#(" "3&'%6/"&( !7!.&(A3,' %!'#

'6</! 2:3#/#41"3#!:!/$ "3#7#!/(#$# #/#(%#6/":!'6<3#7$ #!/$7#!/(#$%6('#7 /"3#<!/"&#'!($<#/6'#$"3#<!<#/ 45 3#4!'&% !%""3!""3#7!($&(@6#'"&(:!'!%@6&/#$ /"3# <6/<'# %('"/6%"&( !3!/!0! AA!/'!&( ('"&"6"# #$&%!7 #'#!/%3!($$6%!"&(2A/3!&'("&($&'<6"#3#/#:#/#":'#"'

!:!/$' "3# 77#%"/ &/'"712 &( "3# %!'#' "3# 7!($:(#/'2 :3 (#A"&!"#$!($#("#/#$&("!(!A/##8#(":&"3"3#."!"#2"3#!86("

%8<#('!"&(:!'$#"#/8&(#$!'6($#/) #3/&7!($) =*2***EF<#/!%/# !77!($) 2***EF<#/!%/# !&/685&(7!($) ?+2***EF<#/!%/# .#%($712&("3#%!'#' "3#/'#" 7!($:(#/'2:3$&$("

<" / (#A"&!"&(2 "3# 77#%"/ 9&$# &"' !:!/$ $#"#/8&(#$ "3# %8<#('!"&(!'6($#/) *2***EF<#/!%/#

2***EF<#/!%/# ++2***EF<#/!%/# 9#("3#7!($:(#/'2:33!$&(&"&!771(#A"&!"#$"3#!86(" %8<#('!"&(2$&$("!%%#<""3#'!8#!($ &7#$40#%"&('3#'!8# :#/#/# #//#$""3#%6/"3## #/#(%#6/"9&$#!:!/$$!"#$

!''#''#$"3#%8<#('!"&(I+*2***EF<#/!%/# *2***EF <#/!%/# /!77!($J*2***EF<#/!%/# /&44!7!($!($?+2***EF<#/ !%/# /!&/685&(7!($ 3#'!8#:!''640#%"F8!""#/ %3!77#(A# 4# /#"3&'6/"&( !7!.&(A3,' %!'# '6</! 2:3#/#&("3#!:!/$ "3# #/#(%#6/":!'6<3#7$#!(&(A"3#/#412#9#(&("3#%!'#' "3#

+ 7!($:(#/'2:3"36A3&(&"&!771(#A"&!"#$"3#/!"#':&"3"3#9#/(8#(" 46"3!9&(A("!%%#<"#$"3#'!8#2((#3!'4##(<!&$"3#%8<#('!"&(!" "3# /!"#' (#A"&!"#$ 3# !86(" %8<#('!"&( <!&$ #9#( " "3'# 7!($:(#/' :!' &( "#/8' "3# !:!/$ "3# # #/#(%# 6/" $!"#$

?2:3&%3:!'6<3#7$41"3&'%6/"&(!7!.&(A3,'%!'# '6</! ("3#%!'#' "3#7!($:(#/'&("3#</#'#("'#" !<<#!7'2"3# #/#(%#6/"29&$#!:!/$$!"#$+>

2!''#''#$"3#%8<#('!"&(!"

"3# 77:&(A/!"#') D#3/&7!($) +2***EF<#/!%/# ?2+**EF<#/!%/# = 2?+*EF<#/!%/#G "&'("&($&'<6"#"3!"!%@6&'&"&( 7!($2"3#!''#''8#("

%8<#('!"&( :3&%3:!''640#%"F8!""#/ $&'<6"#&(!7!.&(A3,'%!'#

'6</! !($&("3#</#'#("'#" !<<#!7':!'9&$#'!8#("& &%!"&(!($ "3#'!8#<6/<'#":!'(#4&A%36(5 7!($#(%#2!77"3#7!($:(#/'

'3!77 4# #("&"7#$ " '!8# !86(" %8<#('!"&( %%/$&(A712 "3# 7!($:(#/' &( "3# </#'#(" '#" !<<#!7' !/# !7' 3#7$ #("&"7#$ " %8<#('!"&(I+*2***EF<#/!%/# !77!($J*2***EF<#/!%/# /&44!7!($!($?+2***EF<#/!%/# /!&/ 685&(7!($ ' !/!' "3#%("#("&(/!&'#$ 417#!/(#$%6('#7 /"3# 7!($:(#/'"3!""3#!86(" %8<#('!"&(<!1!47#""3#7!($:(#/'

%67$("4#7#''"3!(:3!":!'$#"#/8&(#$41"3#77#%"/2"3#/#4#&(A! 4!/6($#/.#%"&(+ "3#%"2&'8#/#71"4#("&%#$!($/#0#%"#$&("3# </#'#("%!'#"&'("&($&'<6"#"3!"((# "3#7!($:(#/':!'<!&$"3# %8<#('!"&(!""3#/!"#'&(&"&!771(#A"&!"#$9#("3'#7!($:(#/'3!$ !7' &7#$40#%"&('!($:#/# &(!771<!&$"3#%8<#('!"&(I+*2***EF <#/!%/# /!77!($J*2***EF<#/!%/#

/&44!7!($!($?+2***EF<#/!%/# /!&/685&(7!($#(%#2( /#7&!(%#%!(4#<7!%#$6<("3#!:!/$ "3#77#%"/<!''#$&("#/8'

"3#(#A"&!"&(':&"3 !'#" 7!($:(#/'!'"3#'!8#:!'("!%%#<"#$ #9#(41"3#8

= (9&#: 81!

/#'!&$$&'%6''&('2"3#7!($:(#/'&("3# </#'#("'#" !<<#!7'!/#3#7$#("&"7#$"%8<#('!"&(I+*2***EF<#/ !%/# /!77!($J*2***EF<#/!%/# &44!7!($!($?+2***EF<#/!%/# /!&/685&(7!($3#1'3!77!7' 4##("&"7#$"!77'"!"6"/14#(# &"'!9!&7!47#""3#86($#/"3#%" %%/$&(A712"3#!<<#!7' &7#$41"3#7!($:(#/'!/#!%%#<"#$2 :3#/#!'"3#!<<#!7 &7#$41"3#."!"#&'$&'8&''#$ !0#'3&($!7 6$A# *+* +

#/"#</"#/