Gba Workers Union v. Chandigarh Administration And ANR
!
"#$%#&
!"
# $
'
( )* + ++
% & ' $
()
$ * +, ! -.
' /
'. ' $ * 0 "$ (
1#2*3#.2*1.21)
,
$ 4 -
5 7
8 09: /
$$- . *7:74:2 -
$ ;<=7
> >: -4( $ * 0 "$ (
!$"
6= /" $"
"'4 ! 8$ (
8((
" -
!
,$
!
!
?
$ * # $ *
$ '- "
"$ ( !!
"
(
! -
# $ *
!"
!. (&4
$'"
$ # $ * 0 "$ ( 4"
$$- . *7:74: 4
&4 ""
0 "0
- @ 7 >&4
""
>: $"
6= /"
, ! / *'-
7 '
0;:" $ "$ (
- - !-4-" ,/
-! " - $ / "$ ( "$ ( $ / $$
/
6=/ $
$->- " !> @ $ $$- &4 ""
$ 0
$$
!4 "
-
."/ $ 0
$$4&4 ""
A '"
!
/-4 &4 ""
1/'" - 4
- ? - $/ . (&4 ,. (&4
""
$ 0
"
!4 $
!
! " $ * 0 "$ ( 1 8
!B (
" , ! /
'4( -( / "-( $
/ $$4. (&4
@
6 "$ !
/ $
$ 6 7
8 09: 4
- --/
!!
: ,
'
- $'
. 0*7:7:74:
,# * / 4( !" - ! / $$- $"
,5 " " > /!
- 4 "$- /
: ,
'
- '. 0*7:
,$$- $"
-4( $ * / ' -(
2/
" - -( '
'
- / $$ 4
,
:,
$
! 2
/"
*
! $"
' 4
"
': ,
4 $'
. 0*76:
# $ * + "$-( 4"
$$- $"
,' "
( , (/ " 2
- ?
! (
"$ !
/ $
6
; ( $$- $"
,
--!- (
$ $ $ . *7<:C $
!> C
>
,"
!$"
$'
"
$-( ': ,
'
- '. 0*79:
$$$-
$$$ ' "
( @ . (&4 ( 9( $ 8$ $ * / 5 "2 -, - D / / '
: , " B$ - 5 4 4"
- ! / $$-
! $"
4 4"
4( $ * 1 /
"$-$$-
'
:,
D /" "$ (
!
$ ,$ /'$
0( '
'4
-'
!" ! (
' ( -
!" "
- $ - $-( 4- $ * 4 - '
!'"
$
- '
!4 !
/
$ *
!!
4
"
! !0 -
-
! /
!"
-
2
2
(?0 $" (7:/
-
!$'
- - $
"$
- /-- ( "
'
$ D
!8 -
# $ * / 4-
2
;9 2
-! "$-(
! 2 /"
!
-
2
6606 ==2 - 02 ! @ ' "$ .0
,
"
5 - 0/
" $ "$ ( , " !
!
-(
-'
! $ / $ * 4 6= /" - !/ "$-( ". !( 8
" $/
!-( $ * - $$- 4 &4 ""
, !
! $"
6= /
.
" - -( 6=/ /
"
/
!
$. 0*7:7:
-
! $$- '-
/ - 4/ $ ' $ * $
4 &4
-
! &4 ""
, ! . (&4 , !
!
$ ( $
!
$ - * ;= $(
!
&4 ""
, !
$$-
, $ /
"
/ / / - 4( ' - - ' "( 1/'
$
! - '"($ - * 6EE9
!
&4 ""
. ( &4 $$-
# $ * /
--( "$- $(
$
* 6EE9 /
$ '
<
! &4 ""
$$- / -4$
4E ,
$ 4-/ 0
!
"
#
$ %
& '
% %'%'& "
$ (
) %* $ & + ,-. / 0 + 12
# ) %*
$.(2 + 3
$ (
(- #
$ % & '
% %'%'.+
4
!
,52 +
# #
/ "
$ %"
%* $.,2 + "
&
$ % ) 5
#& + 6
7 &
) %* $ + "
$ (
"
&&
%8 '% %'% #
$ %
# # &" , 6 "$ !
/ $
/
$ 9:+$ ;+3:+ <$)3+$ $ <) :.%2 %'% =%(8
> ( %'%
3 ?3 + &
) %* $ .
2 .
2
& + ,-#&
% %'%' "<=
;
@ 5
+ !
6 +
) %* $ .,2 & + ,-
4 "4 "
" & 9 2
!&4 ""
$
$$- / "
!
( $'
4
!/ !
'
< 9 ( $ $ 4 . 0*7<: -( 8$ $"
"! 6 2
! " $$'-
"
. 0*7<: $ * 6=/ / 9 - $ --
-
78 $! (: /
, --
- / -( $4("/ ($ . 4 5 -(
"$- / < $ * $
"$ !
6 -
! $ . 0*7<: >" $$'-> ! 6
E $$ 4.
( ,/ $
'( 8(
6 #
!'" $
/
/"
$ * ' $(
- $ $$- --6=/ - $ 0
,/ $ "
- $ * , $ *
$-( $$- - !/ --
8 4 "$ ( 2 4
"
/ $ / $
$
/ !
!
! $$-
, $
- $ 6= /
--A "
1 $
$$"
!$- 4 ' 6= /
$-(4( $ * +. (&4 $" !
< (/ $
* 6EE9 -(4 " 5 $$- -4( !" . *7: "$ 4
. *7<: -(8$ 2
'
/ "
!$'
. *7<: ($
4( (/ - '4
-' $'
4$ -( --!- #$- 4 -4($ /
$ " -( '" ' 4 " !
$$- - 4( $ * 08
/ 2
("
- -( 6;(
,$ / -( $ F"
/ "$ ( /
-
-- $
!"9 6 , "$ (/ ! $"
4( '
< <
/ "
!
$
, "
!$
"$ ("
$ -( $ F"
2
-$
"$ ( / 2
$$ "- . G&
$ "$ (
4
!'((
!( 90=;0 , - ' -
! (
, - "
-/"$ -) -( 1/' - ! "--'- $0 '
$
!;B B , $
B/ - -"
.
" $0 '
$ 2 - 4 $
$->- " !> 4 4 / -
!6=/"
, $ ' - <0 / !
!6=/
$-
!
$ "( . &
-$
6=/
/--(
1!
! $$- -4( "$-( "$ (
5 "$-(/"
$
-(
!!
5 (
4("$-(
/" ---' $
/
!
!
'
!
!
!
!$"
, "'
! 4 /"
--!- ! $
'
!4 $
$$- $ * /
9( $"
4"'4 ! $. 0*7<:
.
$'
/ -4 -(
/ -
!$$-
!$"
(
4(' " 1/'/
(
4(' " /
$ 9( 4 5 >"$"
> 2 ' "
" $
1
(9(
$ $ 4 . 0*7<:
#- 4 $-
'
% 1 !
/ - 0%#1!!
* 2 /
! -!
$'
. 0@ / $ $ -
!
/
!
. 40 76:. 0@
-! . 0 *7<:
$. 0@76:/ $$-
!$ $"
- 4 "4( "$-( 7:. 0@ $$$ ' " ""
!
!
!! $"
"$-(/
9( " / $$-
"$"
$$- --4"'4
! 8$ $ 9(
! $'
& .
!-) !% 1 ! -/ - (/
$$- . 0@ (/
$ / 5 4(. 0@7:"
! .
0@76: - 4- -- ( ( - , '
"
& .
!-) !4(4 '
! A " " &
"
&
) & B $
" ) C" #
&
&
& ) ;
D
4 &"
)
: ! " 6
& " ) C" & # &
D
4 &" 5 & &
&
# & )
.%2) %* + & " ) ;
&
D "
& "
&"
&
A&
) ;
D
D"
" &"
& &
&
D "
&
)
.%2) %* +
& &"
" ) ;
D "
"&
D "
" 4 ""
& &
& #
& &
&
#
)
.(2) %* +
&"
#&&
&
&"
#
& & +
#& &&"
"
D "
&
)
.%2) %* +
A&
&#
& D
&
#
# &" " &
) & B
D "
& " ) ;
4 ""
)
.(2) %* +
) C" && &
"
E 1 .& '
-* 09< -!
/
"
D !" / -4$$- 4-
$ /-- ,
'4 '4(
-& .
- $ * 1! $'
. 0*7<: - "4 !
2 $$-
""
"$-(/
9( $"
"' 4 ! 1 "D !
!
-'- (. 0*4(. $" / $
"- "
4 $ 4$
! $$-
!
$"
/
1 !
$ . 0*76: 4 $
5 !
" D ,$ !! ' >"$"
> "(
-
$
- - '
1 >4-. $"
! "##$%&''&&( )* !+, , ' ! "##-%''- . . )
! "$%''/0 *
, ! "$% 0''$/$
1 . ', 1'! ! / + #)"#2 3", . 0* $
$
$ 4-/ 2$-3' *
2
4
$-3' *
2
4
F.
2$ # &"
" & &
#
& #
& "
&"
&&
" &"
&F .2 #
1 #
4
#
& #
G .
2
;
""
" ;
" & ;@
.
"2
&
& .%2+ &
.
2&&
" &"
& &"
"& && &
& &" #
.(2A
&
.
2
;
"
D "
&
"
&"
#
"
D"
"
&"
#
&&
&
"
#
"
&&
&"
#
.,2A
&
.
2 ;
"
&"
#
4 ""
#&
& &&
4
4 "" .*2+
;
"
&&
.H2
& &&
&&
"
.H2 ;
""
# & " &"
"
#
#
.(2
"
& C > !
#
&
&& # #
""
.-2A
&
.
2 #
"
&&
&& & #
#
#
# &&
& &&
"&#
.82$ # "
;
" # 4 &
,
&
&"
& " "
.
2&& &"
& &
"
. 2A
.(2 #
.,2
"# # &"
&
&"
&
&&
&
#&&
D&
"1
"
"&
"
"
4 4 E
1 >4-. $"
! -! $'
. 0@ ' 4 -' $'
. 0@ $ 4-/ $-1 ) 2 ,
2 4 ,
F .
2 +
&"
#
& #
&
&
#
& &&
&"
& ""
#
&
;
& &"
&
"& &&&
& &"
#
> !
&&&"
&
&
# .%2A
&
.
2 ;
D "
& "
&"
#
&
"
D"
" &"
& & &&
-
& "
#
"
&&
&"
#
.(2A
&
.
2
;
&"
#
4 "
" #&
& &&
4
4 "" .,2+
;
&&
.*2
& && &&
"
444E ,$'
. 0*/
-4(
1 >4-. $"
! "##$%& ''&&(/ -8"
!
-'- (. 0*
, 4 ' -(
!4D '. 0*
!$
(
/ $' ' 4- $ "$-( -
! " 4($
!8
!
"$-(" !/ "$-(" / / -/
4
5
- 4-
"$-(
!-! "4 /"
2
-
"
!"$$ $ '
(4($ '
!
-$ " ( 2-. 0* !
' '
$-
,
"$ 4(. 0* !"$-( /" /4! '
!4 "$
! -$ 4-
, $
/
$
. 0* -4
4 4-
-
! - 8$-
"$ -'
$5 )
.
2 ) %* $ & ) %* I#
#
D
# & &
") %* J && #
5
1
D
) %* I
"
.(2) %* $
#
;
"
D
&
&"
D "
.%2 D
&
&
.(2#
;
"
&
&"
#
;
"&&
4
#
"
.%2) %* $ C " C& & & " C
) %* I
D "
D "
"
;
" " D
#& -/
&&"
#
) %* $
.%2 &"
& &&
D
&"
1 "# & #
& .2
.
2"
& .
.
2 &"#
D
) %* ; #& &
) %* $ # ) %* ; + & " &
&"
&"#
C
) ' , *, 2, + + 4
2
4
2
+
2 + *
+
,
,+ 2"&% 2$-3 22, ,
* ** * 6
, 2
,2
,
*
2
4*
2 2 ,
2 , "2% ,+ 2"% + 2, ,22
+
2
* *
2
+ ** *
6
,
2 *,
7,24, + *
2 , A
#
&
C #
;
.%2) %* $ )
&
.-2) %* $ & "
.%2 #&
& #
"
& &
# C #&
& ;
C & &
C #&
&"
#&
" ;
" "
;
) ' + &
" ;
)
4
0 & 1 ) %.2 +
#
&"
"
) ' + #
;
!
#
&
&"
#
#
& "
.%2 ) %* $ &
&
C
) ' + & "
#&
D&&"
&"
#
& "
#
& "
.%2) %* $
& & #"
C
" ;
#
&"
&
C
" &
& &"
E -
!. 0*7<: --(-
5 - $ " -
76:
/
$'
' " ( ""
$"
-! $"
"$-( /
" '
' " ( --4"'! $"
8$ $ "
1 8 9 :
! 1 "$$%$''-/5 5
4. $" /
- '- (. 0@2 -
$ ;<= " 4( " " <9;E
, '
92
; "#/5%0''$$0/ / - ! - / 4
/
.
!-$ " - ! ( 4
! -;7:7:
2/ - -4 4-
! -;79:
2/ - -/ -$'
-
"- - 2 ?4 &
"$ 4(. 0@/-4 4- '
/ / / " $'
!$$'-
92
. 0@/ "
;E
, " "$
4/ 0" .
0@" . 0@ . 0* 2-
" . 0@ /
. 0* 7/ /
:
2
" ( / $'
--( " $'
2/ $
! <
<&&
-/ "$
$- / -$$-( - - "
'
!--/"
- 4. 0* . 0@
$
2 ! ' $
$-
- /
<
<&& ' -'
!
- '- (7" :. 0@
,
' ! / 0" . 0@4 /
38 - / ! 8
" " ;E .$ / "4 "
!$'
. 0@/ / ! -
!
-
?4 &A 24 '/
$ "
!$'
4 &$#
.(2
) %*
#
H'" # &
& &&
&
E *
, ! "$%0''$/$ 1 >4-. $" !
". 0* 4 ' . 40 7<: $'
"$"
, - 4 ' 4D
--( '4($'
. 0* ,-' 4 '
0 +"
) %* $ &
#
& &
#
#
4
& .2 .
2&"#
1
1# &
#
;
=
" )
.%2 .(2 & &"
;
=
" D C&
&"
1&
D " " &" &"
#
&
,+ 2"0% *
*
)
.*2
;
&& )
.H2
;
#
# #
&"
1&
& C
+ "
#
;
4
&"&& & "
.-2#
&
D
#&
)
.82 #
;
&
.
2
4 &
. 2 "
#
0 & &
;
"
) %* $
&# 3& -H + & .
&2 3& *- &
I !+
D
&"
&&
&
&
& & 0$
&&"
" &
&"
&
C
) '.
2 + E )* !+, , ' ! "##-%''- . $" /
!
-'- (. 0 -
$ ;<= 2 -
$ 7" " :
;=9
5 $ $"
-(0 ,-' $'
. 02 -
$ %* < !
&"
F.
2$# .
&# &# 2#
&& & &
#
& &&
& " &"
4 #
""
"
;
" &;@
& &"
#
&& "
.%2A
# .
&# & # 2 & &
.
&
& .+
2 + -H &"
&"
& &
&& #
"
&"
"
.
2
&"
.(2
"&
.
2
.%2 " # &
"
D "
#
&
.,2A
&
.
2
.%2 " #
&
&
&"
#
# # &
& &&
4
# E 888H 1-
!$'
4
--('- 4 ' 5 #
& & "
) %* $D
&"&" & & ") %*
<
6 &
&"
) %* <&"
#
&
& &
4&
" &&
"
C " &"
6 &
# &
&
&"
&
" &"
#
# &"
& "
#
&" 4
&
& # "
& "
&
&"
""
C
&"
) "
& &
&"
4 &" "
#
4
#
"
& &" &"
"
# # #
& &"
D
"
"
"
& & &" & &
&"
D
"
4
# # # &"
D
" "
# #&&
&
& "
&"
# C
.%2) %*
<
&
"
& 4
#
# "
.(2
D
"
D
&&
<,
+ ,+ 2 "0% *
, +
+
2 2
,2 4
*
) 2 ,
+ +
2
+
* +
&
#
& #
D #&
" "
# &&
#&
"##&
& "#&
&"
D
"
#
"#&& #
"
;
& # "#& &"
&
D & &
+
"#
&"
# &
#
#
&
#
"
D
.&
# 2C " &"
"#& #
E #
!. 07: / -4(
7<:$"
! --4"'4 !
,
""
/
" $
. . )
! "$%''/0 1 >4-. $" $-1 ! /
/ - $"
- / "$ ( . 0@/ " '4 ! - ' " ""
!
!
!! $"
"$-(/
$ 9 ( " / $$- / "
, 1 >4-. $"
$ 4-/ + & # "3
.
E2
) %* & + . + E2
& # "
*
8 % ,
8 &
#
&
;
& & "
$ 7
) %* .(2 + ;
&"
#
H'" # &
& &&
4
H'" &
& # #
H'" *
8 #
&"
&
4 "
% ,
8 #
#
" : "
&
) %* +
" :
#
& "
#
& #&
D
#
"
: *
#
"
&&%( -
" : &
-
&& & &" E 2 --4' 1 >4-. $" / -
!
. 0*7<:. 0@76: 076:/ -' "
!
$'
-$"
! --4"'4
!
""
/
" $ A
-"
8
I"
!$'
H/
--"
D !
!
"$ - -(/ 4- $'
/
--( '- , "
! $'
5 - ,
8 $
$'
"/ -- I4 H (4
!
(
* 8 $ 4 !
?4( 1 >4-. $"
(4'
'
/
$
4- ! / '
/ % 1 !
- 4( 1'! ! 1 $$''1! 1 (&
$$- / 4"
4($ "$ ( = &4 ""
. 0*7:
!$"
=/"
E9/" / / '4( " ,&4 ""
$ $$ 4 " "
,,
-/ $
-
!
-
! 1 ! (
4(&4 ""
/ -4
4D -/ $
,&4 ""
" '
@ ;
&4 ""
' /
-
/ $
,/ $ /
$
$
< , &4 ""
""
6
!$"
"$ ( =/"
, "$ ( -/ $
-
! 6 ! &4 ""
'
! - ""
$$-
!$"
/
9( $$"
--4" '4 ! . 0*7<: "$ !
!$"
'
!4 ""
8$ (9( /
4-
-/ 2/ 4-&4 ""
$$- / ' ;
'
/ ! "
!$
!
4&4 ""
4D
/ $
, $ " &4 ""
$
;
4
" 4 ""
'
/$ (/ $
2 / -(
"
- / $
- /
""
6 , - '
! 4
""
9( / $"
/ -4" '4 ! 2/ 4 ' (
&
%-
%''
%-'#
#
" 6
$
%''
# )
.,2) %*$ 6
#
D
#
H' " " ('
%''
+&
& %
%''
" :
& &"
('B "%''%#
"
H'" -
& )
.,2) %* $#
>
.,2A
&
)
.
2 ;
"
&"
#
4 "" # &
& &&
4
4 "" E +
& #&& &"#
". 6
2
&"
#
H' " &
& &&
4 "
H'" & &
#
E &
"
#
H'"
& " &"
E $ -
/ ""
/
9( $$- $"
"'4
! ,
"
(
"$ !
6 ,
$
"
2
-
!
'- ( ! ,
-(- "
8"
!-!- ( 6 1 >4-. $"
-
-
$ 4
4(/"
/ 4
4
$"
"'4 !
76:. 0* - $$$$ ' "
! ( ""
!
!
!$"
/
$ - " 4
4
"
$$ 4($$$ ' " (
$ D / - 4$ - 2/ -4$ $ %345 / ++ !
.$
!B# J #$4- J B*