High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/4445/2024allowed

Jeet Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-05-03Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri36 pages

!"# "$ "%""

" "$ "

$&' () '*+,+(- ..

!''& /+01 ...'&+&+('2 / / /&&' () 24 (&1'2, ...',5('&,

1+2 /+01 ...'&+&+('2 / / /&&' () 24 (&1'2, ...',5('&,

67+2 ...'&+&+('2 / / /&&' () 24 (&1'2, ...',5('&, "

- 8#9

. !

/ !"/

"#! !$ "

! !$

& '() ***+ ,-,*

# . & , '() /0/1 ,-,* () 2-02 ,-,*

! "/

/ : !.

5""! 67!" ! 57() & ***+ ,-,* 6 5 # ( ! " " ( 6!!

5 ! " 6 $!6 (!" "!6+2 1-

*&<;

&2+= '

5" ((7 !( 8

9! 4,2 -+ 400/ : "96+2 87""

!" 5 ""!! ,--+ (!6 " 6! ""6 ( (! ,2 -4 ,-4+ 9! ,"!! $!9 " !(

6 ( !6$!6 6! ! :" 9 " !( !

"!6 5 $! 9! ,!!

# $

# &

# *

:!!!6 (! " ((7;

<# ( 8 #-, -0 ,-4+

9! '

:" "6!6 "9 $! :" "6 ! 66 7 =!"!40 "6 +2 5! !44'40!! (#)

# *

# (-# )

% # (.# )

# 1 +

:" "! "6+2 5 " 57" ! +2 6!6 !

) "6! 6

> =?." 9 6!6

! !" 66 !) "6 !6 : 86!

!:! !: !! !5) !! : 86!=()

! :! ,1 4, 40+/ ;!! <"!66!" "9"7!"!!6 "( " :" =) "!"!! "7" =) "!6,1 401- 5 )

!:! "!"!6 6 41 -, 40/- 55) ! :! "!4/ -/ 402+6 86! :"!@!! "!!! "6 7" ;! ! <" !66!"

"9"7!"!!6 "( ""! !

5) !'4 -4

5" !6 ) 5 ) : ) "" !!!!61-

"6"& 11 67 5!! -#

34,

#1 347

5) " 7"!! & ,2,""& /4 !! 808#,

:& ''5) 66 ) ! :! "

$!!!6 # : "

"7!!! "9 %9 :!.! 40*/66

86!) A !! ! 5& ''5 ) " 9! /!! --# ,

><&&+, ><&+,#,

2 34 , %

34 7

9& %9

; 7 (.<=

> &

11@$$$4# 4-

: 4020( " . = ( 8 ;

> =?.< " 9 ( 9! ,B46 ( ! 4020 6 '4 -4 4020!,06 ( ! " ( 6!6

6@!" ! "@!6 ( > =?.

! 6 ;

! <

5 > =?. !6 ( !" .

( 9! ,B,-'

-2 400- 5 9! ,B'4* 400- ( . > =?.( !!,0 ( !4020" ! " 6 ( " !66(

6 .B

( 5 9! ,B*"!6 (

!""6! 5 . > =?. ( 9! ,B+ :!!!6!!,0

( !4020 #(

! !! 6"6! (!6#( !

! " 6 # ( 400, ! 6"" ( !

! !6 ( ,/ -0 400, 7 7 C"!! ,'?*$A7, ??A:BC7! $>>>,;#?*$A7,37!)7*74 $ *#.2 ,

# $

;

# 2 >

;

2 #*

*# D .(+'

,+(<=85-<

#5#/#(..(

! #7

:" 6 #(

( ! ! 6 ( !! ,0 ( !4020 :6 !6 !( !

! 400, ! "

5 !"! "6 !

: ,--* 9! ,B24- ,--* "!6 > =?. ( "" ""5 !) " = A,2 -2 ,--0 9! ,B0""

( 6 !" =9A

%6 . " !

" " " "" 6 "7" 6" !

" $! "" "6 . > =?. . ( ! 4,B41 ,--0 9! ,B44"!6$ " "" "! 6-4 -0 ,--0 ;9 "

<"61- " "" 6! " "

-4 -0 ,--0" +2 5

""!! ! !

#*# D866.+7!+/5=/0<;

(8+(5#((#866.

, , ;

# >

# A ! %F AG F HC #

;C 9

*# ;> +7++6.+5(65

-#-#866. ;

# $

2 (4 D

(#.#866.3

C # 4

# ,

C #

(#.#866.

C #

# #/0

+ ;

#, 7 3(4 D ;

()& ***+,-,* " ,-4+"()& /0/1,-,*() & 2-02,-,*" ,-41 696 +2 !! 9! ,B446 "

/ <7>+,,+(, ;'2' *(<,'; )(2 &1' 5'&+&+('2, 4*

! 6 !6 +2 " 6! !

!"6"9"!! ,0 ( ! 4020 5 (

!6! 4'4 ( 402* 5!6 "

! " 6 9! 44 D5

! (

E" 4004"6

400,6 . 6!6 !6"', !66 ( !!

!6!"! !6 6! !! !6! !"6 ( !

"! ! !6! "!6 $! 6!"66 ! ! : !4*!4004; 400,<

!4*"!!

! "

;!< 4+

)!!6 !"6 !! = " ! !) "!+2 "! !) " !) !6!!4* ! ! "! !) 6 6!! !) "6!6

"6 !4* " !) 6! "

!) 5 !) 1- ) !) & ,2,6 !!91- !) 6& ''

"F"7F :!.! 40*/ !6 "(B (7!!6 "7!:!.! 5 !) ! !!691-

+2 6 "

! !6 (! 40 " " "" 6+2 " ! ! " !" ! ! 6 !!6 "! "! 6 !" !6!"66! ! !

5! !6! !6" ! 40 " !6 ! @! 6 " !6 ! 6! " " !( " " (! 9! , "$!

"@! 6 " "9! " ! 7 $! F6 ! (! # !

$ %

&" '

(

) *+,-./ 0, "@! 6"!!6

8!!!6 9! ,B44 " ! !6 . > =?."! ! 5 6! " ""! -4 -0 ,--0 "6 ! !) !6 !" !) "6 G

!*' !" ! !" "6

" !) " 6 9! " "! ! ) " 6 > =?.& & , 9! " " ""! !) 6 6

"=.B ?

8!!!6 ) > =?. ! ) " " 6 "6!! 6 !:! !!: " 67! "" " "7 ! :! .! " 6 1- " ! !6! !) "" !6!

/ <7>+,,+(, ;'2' /'+(2 (<,'; )(2 2',5('&@2; (((5'2&+A' /<02 +;;, ;'2' *(<,'; )(2 2',5('&/(+5& (((5'2&+A' /<02 +;;,

" #! !$ (! "

! !$! #( !

# .!6

( !65

!) " 9"!!"6 !) " 4- "& ,2* "64- :

H! 4022 55 !) !! 80<# ,

$ G

(.00# ,-

5 !6" !5 ! ) H! 4002" 6 ,-4+,-41""! 56 ! !6 ! !6 " ! !) "6 !) 6! 40026!" ,-4+,-41"@! 6 !)

5 !6!6!4* !""!!

""6!!" 4004 !) " "6 7" ""6 !) " " 6! "! " !

"4-

4002"!! "!66

!6 1- " ) ! ! !!6 ,--*!" "!"!>" 6"6@!! " 9! ,B0,2 -0 ,--0 "6 ! " ! 6" """7"9 1- "6"""" ! !) ! " ,-4/ / (" 9! ,B4-

5 !6"67! "! ,--0 9! ,B44 " "! 6-4 -0 ,--0" 61- "!" "

-4 -0 ,--0"+2

5 !6 " " ! 6

> =?.( "6 ( 6 !6 ."69 9! 'B,,2 -4 ,-4-

5 !6!6 . > =?.66 (

,2 -4 ,-4- "! 6 6"

5 9! 'B,! ! ,'F7!*7> ??A#BC7! B>>>,;#F7!*7>

*#/

80#6(#(6# 7 *#/ ,

C #

(#.#866.

C #

# /0

(#.#6.

C # 4

# $

*# D 866.7!/6==

(8+(5#((#866.

7 #A#

# >

#A %

(# , '

(#.#866.3

C 4

# 8# ,

C #

(#.#866.

C #

# #/0

# ,

# 1 %

;

*#(6+C /.8;

#(0#68#86(6

?##+#,#F# H+ + ;

)!6 . #( !6 ".!4004"( !

"6 ."

""6!6 !6@! 6 . "6!-4 -0 ,--0"66 !6@! !"66 ." "

5 !!6!( 9!"" ! ."!,2 -4 ,-4- #( " 6 !6 ! "! ,-4+,-41"! ! ,-4- ,'

!$ (! . ! !6 ! 4004 "!!,0 ( !4020 ! !

! 5 !6 " @! ,*

8 (!!!6 ! " " ( ! " # ( ,-4+ +2 ()& 0*-4,-,4 "",'

,-,4 9! ,B4,"6 ( (!! " " " !

"+2 "6"67! !61- 66

!) !6$!" 8 ""! !!6"6 6 / <7>+,,+(, ;'2' "+&+(; "A(*&'

''2;,: 24 ,+

!" !6 ! !4004 ! !6!!,0 ( !4020 6 ,1

5 !!66!*' ! !) "6 " !) "6 9!F "! !*' ! !! <-# 2 '

# ,

C # #E

5 !6"" ,-4+,-41 " " !) " 66 !)

66 !) 6! " "" 6 !) 76!4* "6 "6

!) " ! ) !

";4,+, () ,<7>+,,+(,- ,2

(! 6 # ( ( (! ! ! 6 "! 6 6 5$!6 ( (! 9! ,B4, !"!" "7;() ***+ ,-,*< ,-4+ # " !+2 ( (!!

" !! !61- " " A! !$!6 ( (!7 ! !6 !!!6! 6 ! !" " 56 6 $!

= ! G !6! "! 6 G " $(*&2+' () :

. 99F 3 F"F56 !6 "F 56 6 !

:"""

! 6!66!"6

" !6$"9

7F8".

"9F!"!6 7"!69 F9

F$!" !! 6! H!$! " 6!6"F

6 9 ! !6! " " !9! ) ""6 6 " ! ! "

"7 ! " $! 6"!6 " !6696 !$!6" '*

: ! $! 6 ( 9! ,B4,"!"$! 6

" "

6""! ! ! !!" 6 " !6 ! !" 6!!,0( !4020" 6! ( 402* 6 !"

66 !"

! !!6 !! '+

:"! !6 ! !! 6 7 !" ! ! 5(!" $! 9! ,B4, " ! ! !6 ! "

$! 5 6!6 6 $! "!6 '1 A !66 ! 6

!4004" ! !!! !4*!6 6 !) 5

!) "7"!61- : !!"7"5

!) "!" 6!6"7 "61- 5 ! ! " 6 6 ! 6! "! !"',

"7"" ! !" "6 !) 9! ,B2 6 "

> =?.""!!"" 6 !) !66 . > =?.! 4,B41 ,--0! FF 9! ,B44 "6 " " ! 6-4 -0 ,--09"

"!61- " ""6!" "

-4 -0 ,--0"

+2 :" 6 " !6

. > =?. " 9 6 "

6 6 9! " ""!! !6 ( 6! !"!!" "6" .>6! " " ! ( "

(! . > =?.9"(

!! " " ! 4004"!

)!" 4004!! ,0 ( !" ( " !

5 ! ! 6 ! "! :" ! ! ! ! ! ,0 ( !!! 45*6

-5/-777 7/

3 %

#E '0

: ,--0 " " 4,B41 ,--0 9! ,B44; 'B4<"!! "! " " ! " 6 ! !

A ! ! !!4* F9F! !) +2 = "! !) 5) 61- F"7F :!6

"7 !) "1- 6!!"6 6 !"

9! ,B44; 'B4<4,B41 ,--06!"6 !6@! 6 ! : !) !4*"!66

5(!" !" ! ! "

5" # F6 ! (! % 82

& 9

)5:5.; 5,0! 8/#$

# ,

# $

-6.

# #

(.0<! ! 8

;D?

#, A ! 8

(.0<! " # #

#E,

# 3

8/#6(#(..6

#E7 D $$ $

! 8

(.0<!

#4# *,

! " 6 ! .( (?9! 6" "4,B41 ,--06 6 ""

5 !! !6 " . ( (?9! 6!(?9! .( ! !"! ""6! 5

! 67" 6 !6@!! 6 ! !

5 6 . !! 4,B41 ,--066 ! !

! " 6 ! !"1- "7 !) 6! 5 ! ) 9!4- 6!! "4- & ,2* 5 !) "6!6"

!" 4- 4022 4002! !69! 40026 ,-4+,-41 76 1- 6 61- **

5!6 ! !66!!

55 !) 6'4 -4 4020& ,2*" 4- "

: H! 4022 5"'4 -4 4020" 1- "7" : !!""6 !"!( ! ! 4004 5 !"6

400, ! G! 400,

: " " " 4020"! 400,6

56 " 4002! "! !& ,2* ! 6 "!" "!7 "4- "

66! "4- 4- 4- " " "!"4-

! ! ! !" " 400,"4- 6 G " !6 ! 66 $

! " 6 ! ,--*6

" ""66 ! ) 6/ (" ,-4/"6!" ! ""6! "!"6! 6-4 -0 ,--0"6 1- 6! ""! " "

-4 -0 ,--0" +2 "6 " !! 6$! 6/ (! 7

" ""!6

!!4* ! !""

( "69!

! ! 66 " ! ! "! 6! " ! ! 6! !

&9 ! " " 6 ! "" ,-4+ ,-41 " ! 40 " 6 +2 "!! !61- ! ;

9! '<"!"!40 !!4'"" 66 ! 6 6 5!406 !4'

!4'" 66 ! "!4004 6 400,!!4* 6 !) "6 !) 5"!

!) 6"7"1-

5 !40 " ! ! : " ! ! " ! !" "!!

66 */

A!"6 ! +2 6 "7! !! !" " !! !!66" ! :! ! !6

.!!!! !6 !" !@! 6"" !6 ! ! 67! " ""7 !( "" "! ! 6 ! " 6 !6 ( (! 9! , "67"! 6 !( 5 6!6!6 !

:9 !" 6!!406! !" !

?" !7!"!66 "$! F6 !(! #!

$ %

&" '

(

-/ *0

!"6

!*' !

!4004" ! ! ) "6 "

!) " 6 9! F F""6 ! !6! """ !! = ""6

!) ""6 !6! "" !) " " ""6 !!

5 ! *' 9! 6! ! "! 6 ! 9! ,B44; 'B4< " !66 66$6!9!

6! 6 ! "6!!4*

5 6"!4*!*' ?! . !(!@!6 6 !4*"!*' " " ! !*'6!4* "6 6 !!4* " ! !

:" ! " : 61- 5!" 5 !@! 6 6 +2 5 !1- +4

!! ! " " ,--0! "6 !" ;4< 5$!" " " ;,< 5 G$!"6

"!61- ! " 6 ! ! " # " !

!"/

/ .. !

8 )7B IB& )6 IB&