S.K. Bajaj v. Income Tax Officer
!
"!
#
!
$
"!
!"!
!
!"#$%#&'('$)*+ * ,- . . /0#"0#11#2$1"#1($%3$&!3)#4(2!2#15!67#!33$4#8"$(## 9:8;5#)"< $7#1#%#11#8"$1#2$1"#1($1)$"< /0#"0#1"0#9:8;5#)"(0$:387#1#2$1"#8')"0#8';#("<
% &
'$ (
) &&*+,-..,'
-/*,.*.') &&0.*-.* &&*0*.*- !
) &&*-*.0.*
&)'1 2$ ( 3 "' #
4 *
) &&0.*-.* & !
!'$ ( !
) &&*+,-..,'
-/*,.*. ) &&*0*.*-
4
) &&0.*-.*
) &&*-*.0.*
.= !
" # ( !(
5 #
/+ ))
" (
5!
)
")
#2 5
6
# !(
5
"7
"8
"( ! #
5
!
(
2
#
5 4 ) &&*+,-..,' )
-/*, .*.' ) &&0.*-.*' ) &&*0*.*-
) && *-*.0.* #2 (
" 8!
!
#
"
#2 !
99 9+ '*,:*
*,-'*,:'*,9'*,,'..'/:0'/:9 /9*
!
*. ! )8!
(
/.-..: #2 ! ) " )!
; "
&5 ' ;" ! !
6 !( #
" !
"88 ""
!""
5 !#
-*.** "
2
!
! "" 5
"2
6 2
5
#
"
! "
! ! "
"
' ! ' ! $
5 5
!
*/-* '
*,:* ! 8 "
2 !
8
*/-- '
*,:*8!
!8# 7 "2 "" #2 ! )
( !
:- '*,:*8
!
5
! )
$
2
*/- '*,:* '
!' 8
( ' !
" !
"
!( ( 5 55 5
,'..'...6
3 (
5! !
!
5!#282 !
/'0.'...6 5
5 8!
! ! ! " (
.,.*..* 8!
! 8 #2
#2 !
8
:- '*,:* 1
!
5'
<
$
' !
! ! (
*+...0 5 *,...0 2 "
' ! "" 5
3 (
5!
!(
5 2!5
! ( !(
5 ! "" 5 (
.,.*..'*+...08 "" ! 5
7
8
(
#282
5 ! 5 !
3 (
5! "2 !
5!
53 (
5!# # ! $
2
*.*..:8!
!
# "
! ! ! ' ! $
( ! (
! 5 "
#2
! 8 5 #
" $
8!
!"
!
7
! )
"
6
!!""
# (
9*..*. #2 ! " )!
; " &5 ' ;" !
!
)=0$#!
2$
:
8! #2 !
8
#2
! 8 " ! > !
'$ (
'& )'1 2$ ( 3 "' # ! &
!
!' $ ( ! 1
! ! $
"2'
6 8!
8
<
! " &5 !5
/0 ))
! 2 "" !( !""
5
! 8!
!8 #"
(
8!
!5 "
# " #2 "
!
8!
!
" 2 (
! '
( 8 ! "8
?$0'">.$):!)8!)$"0#1?(."!"#$% !)8 $"0#1(= 13+@@' 8!
!
2
!
#"
!(
5
/+))
!
!
8 ) &
!# 8 """
! ?."!"#$%!16!)!!)8$"0#1(?( 00!9!)-!3!)8$"0#1(= . + @'
/+))
2
# ( 2
5"2
! ! 8!
! ( "
" #
"2 "" #2 "
! 6
'
!' ! 7
#
2
#
) &&*+,-..,' )
-/*,.*.' ) &&0.*-.*'
&&*0*.*-
! !
! ! 2 ""
A 5 #2 ( ! ( 2" 5"
2
5
( 8 ?$55'(('$)#1$%)&$5#!A?(0:2#)0!52!B3!3!3!3
)1 +@ . @'
! !
+
! ( 2"
"
5# ! $
""
$
!(
#
!
#2 $
"" 5
# 5
!
8 "
#
!
"" ( 2 !
"
2 !# 5!
"2
# !" !
6
!
!
2 ! # !
"2
'*,:*8!
!
8! !
"" 5
#2
#2 5
5 #
5 ! # !
<
2 ( 5 #2 ! B(
?$55'(('$)#1$%)&$5# !A=:57!'?(0:2#)0!52!B-!3!3!3 . +C= C !
>
D#" $ ) 8 ! (
""8
5
! $
# "2
5
! !
"8 !
"
5
(
5
2
5 ! $ (
?0:2#)0!52!B3!3!3!3D(.!)8##2E!2$$1!)8!)$"0#1'
+@ $5 @'
8! " #2 C !
> 5!) #2 8! #
9:) '99 9+ $ ' *,:* ( !
" !
"
@
)
"2' !
! 2 ( #"
5 6
5
5 # $
"" $
2 > 8 ( '
#2
"2 '*,:*# "
! " (
") '7
8!
!!
! " ( 8
! !
5
! $
"" $
2 '*,:* !
>
D#" $ !
"
!!
?
!6!22!) ?( .E #1:5!3= '1(" )&$5#"!A %%'= :"'&$1')= . +@' 8! C !
8
! ( 8
2
5
#
"
(
!#" ! $ '*,:*
! # )
"
5 ( ! )'8!
!
!( ! "
"
5 )
?#3: !5 !:)F' !5D( )&$5#"!A %%'=,,/!18=$(0'!12:1= @'
8!
8 #2 C !
")
!
5 !
"2
(
" #
' " ! 5
!8 !
5 ! "" 5
! # ) !
"" 5
"2 <
"
# " 2
" $
#2
5" ' 5 #
8!
!
" #2 ! 7
8! 5!
# '*,:*#2 $
"" $
2 !'
8 " # !
5!"2
8
!!
"
58!
!!( " 2#
# ") !'
"
2 8! !# "
# ( ' !
4 &&*+,-..,' )
-/*,.*.' ) &&0.*-.*' ) & &*0*.*-8!
!! ! #2 &
!
!'
"
) &&*-*.0.* ! "2
! ( 2 !""
5 !# #2
! " ") "28
!( 8
#2 ! !
"2
!
"
)=0
" ! 8!
! $
:
) "2
!
5
!
!" ! 5!
2
B( ! " "
"
) !
8
8 "
2
! (
8!
! ! # ! ) " 2
" 8!
!
# 7 !
!
8
!
)
"2
! ) #2
2
"5 #2 ) E
#
5) &
& 4 *-*.0.* # 8!
""2 8
' ! "
( 8
"2 !" 2 #
2
! "
")
"2
!
#2
5!
*. 2
!
. !):!16=+ 21