Nirmal Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others



IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND

HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

  



 !"

#$%

&&"

' (
#  )(*+  % 

&
 , -./0 #

12#34
0 4#, .3







 


4#, .35






  





 

!"#$%


&

& 
 






( 



 

 

) '

*



 +,"



& 


-   
 
.


&
/


 
 

.01
2
3

,+ ,$ +,4
 

$
+ 
$"

$5

0&

 
 
6
7


 
8 


*




' 
 +

 

 


 
7 





 '

9:





  



 






  


  



 
!+

&

      

   

    ! "!

  # $%$ 

'



 
& 


 

0



:

# %

9:

'
& 


 
!+

!"#$%

&


 


 

 
' 



 

 



!+

& 
 



*




& 

  
9:



 

7
;!

+




 
   








 

7

6 "7

 '


 '
'




  
 




7 


 '




 
0




 
 "






 





* 



7



'



''





7




' 

 
7
* 



  #"7

 


 '


 '
'







 


 
7

 

 
7


'

 





!$


&&


 


 '


 





!$


'

 



)


   

 '


 '
7


 


 '
 
'








 3% "7



 



 '
 

 




 



 
!+
7  
' 
  



  


 '



7 
< 

 


 



 '
7




=

 

 



*




 



 
 







' 



 


 

 
 



7 




 
97



7 




 




' 




/ 
7

'


 '>
 





 

(  



'

9 
& 
!"#$%


&&
7 



7





 '

 


 

 
!+


&& 6( %"7

 '


'
 
!"

 '



 '>
 




) 







' 



  


=




 '



 
!+



 

  
 


 '









 
' 
 

'


'  6%"7

'










 "




  


  

 

' 
 

 

 


 
' 


 
+,,


&&


$





<
 

 


&&


'

 

 

'

 


 
 

' 
7


 '


 

* 
'


 



 
'


 
!+

7 

 

 
+#7%


&


 










 
 


 






 
 

 
'

 
 





 



 '
 

 
$

+


& 
0





 


 '









* 
7 

 





' 




9

 
  

  









' 
 



*







 
!+


&&



 

 


 '

 




 
' 
 
7

< 

8

0

 '
7
 

 
 "






 






'


 
 

 
7

 


''






 
4,
 

*





 


 

 

' 


7

 





* 
7 


 

'


 

 
!+


&&




 

 '



 



' 
0
 







 


 


!+


!"

 


0

 


 

 
!+

 '



 


 



 


7


' 

7 


 
'  



 








9 
& 



 
 

7


 

7 


'   


=





 '



7
'

'



' 



 

 
!+


&&


 
 7
 

 '


(
 



'

9 
&  0

7

 '



7 


 





 
 



*



'


 
!+
7  
( 

 



'

9 
& 



 
' 



7


' 

+,,


&&
7
' 
  


''





7




 

 "



 
4

 






 

 

 
!+


&&





 
!+


&&
7




 
(

7 

'
 +,,5


 )



 
 
'


 


 

 




 
0
 7


 
   
7



 '





 






 
!+


&&

 

7



' 


?


 '





' 


 


 
!+







 
#$%

 
!"


&& @
$ =
 
 

 
' 
 '


<
& 






 



*





' 
* 

7  

'



 

 
!+

& 
  


'

 
& 
 !"

 # $"

!%

&&'&
&(

) "

* **  !% $! + ,*- ! 

&&.(&
 


,+ ,!

+,+4



) "

  )* 
&&/&01
  


,!

,!

+,+4 0
 7


   

'
 


  
'

9:





:

# %



7 

'


  



'




& 


 
- 
/
7 

  



'

 
 
!+

&



 
- 
/
'
 



 '8

 


'

 

'
)  


  2

 







  


 
& 





' 




 
& 




' !

A
 


 


& 

 


'

 




 
& 
/ 

9

 

 





 
- 
/



 
 
 

,"

+,+4 "


1  
 



'
 (







 
- 
/
7  




(MANISHA BATRA)


JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No