Hardev Singh v. Financial Commissioner Punjab, Mini Secretariat And Others





  
 



!

 " 
! 

!#$% (%)*+*&, 

-- #.(%/ 0*,12 ------ %$*$*&,%.

3%.+4+

4,7#8 &$2%.+ ------

%+9&,(%,$+

  : ; -

0
  0 

.%+%,$  .- 3*<#+ %2+%694.*= (/&)#$% 9%$*$*&,%.-

.- #.9.%%$ 0*,12=  4,7#8- .- 02%..> ?- 0*,15#= (/&)#$% - - -  0  =

-

; - .#>%.

)*/*5 '*5%( 4,(%.

.$*)5%+  
&,+$*$4$*&, ,(*#= *,$%.

#5*#= *++4#,)% ,#$4.% )%.$*&.#.* +%$$*,1

= 9#++%(

99%#5+= 4,7#8

+2&.$ :

&66*++*&,%.:-

- .*%'5>= (%6*+% 02.*

#12/%%.

0*,12= 9.%/*&4+

0
 %2+*5

0#2*8= 9.&)%%(*,1+ @%.% *,*$*#$%( '*55*,1 #'&.%+#*( /#)#,)>= @2%.%*, 9%$*$*&,%.#.(%/ 0*,12

+2&.$ :9%$*$*&,%.:

,<#.

0*,12

+2&.$ :.%+9&,(%,$ : @%.% )#,(*(#$%+-

- ++*+$#,$ ,( .#(%=

0#2*8 @%55 ++*+$#,$ +$ .#(%=

0#2*8 .%)&66%,(%(



)#,(*(#$4.%

#'&.%+#*( /#)#,)> 95#)%( 6#$$%.

8%'&.%

0#2*8

+2&.$ :
&55%)$&.:-

- ;%#.,%( 49&, )&,+*(%.*,1 )&69#.#$*/% 6%.*$+ (%6%.*$+ )#,(*(#$%+= '&4,( 6&+$ +4*$#85% )#,(*(#$% #99&*,$%( 2*6

0
 /*(% --

- -A

%%5*,1 #11.*%/%( #1#*,+$
&55%)$&.:+ --

=

9.%'%..%( #, #99%#5 8%'&.% #$*#5# !*/*+*&,= #$*#5#

+2&.$ :!*/*+*&,#5
&66*++*&,%.:= )#6% (*+6*++%(= /*(% --

A- - 0$*55 #11.*%/%(=

9.%'%..%( .%/*+*&,

  8%'&.%

)#6% #55&@%(= /*(%

= @2%.%8> 6#$$%.

8%%, .%6#,(%( .%)&,+*(%.*,1 *,$%.+% 6%.*$+ 8&$2 )#,(*(#$%+ 9#++*,1 #, #99.&9.*#$% &.(%.-

A- #'&.%6%,$*&,%( )*.)46+$#,)%+= '*5%( )*/*5 8%'&.%
&4.$ +%%<*,1 .%5*%'

+= ,&$*)%( 2%.%*,#8&/%-

-

9%.4+#5 +2%%$+ @&45( .%/%#5 @2*5% *++4*,1 ,&$*)% 6&$*&, )#+%= &9%.#$*&,

 @#+ +$#>%(
&4.$ - - - %#.(-

- %.% @&45( #99&+*$% .%'%.

)&69#.#$*/% 6%.*$+ )#,(*(#$%+

*-%-  (#$%

A

)&,+*(%.#$*&, !*/*+*&,#5 )#, +466%( 4,(%.
 

 

 
    




  ! "!  #

  $  %

  & 

'( ) 

    *  + ,



 !  

-    ../!

1

2
/0   &    -

.&6 #8&/% .%'%..%( )&69#.*+&,= 6#(% &4$ ,&-

#.% #56&+$ +#6% #1%-

4.$2%.= ,& (&48$

6&.% %(4)#$%(

8%*,1 C $2#, @2& +$#$%( 2#/% (&,% #$.*)= 2&@%/%.= 0$#$% 4,7#8 ,& 6*,*646 %(4)#$*&,#5 D4#5*'*)#$*&, 9.%+).*8%( 9&+$ $2%.%'&.% )#,,&$ +#*( *,%5*1*85% &.

(*+D4#5*'*%( #))&4,$ 2*+ 5%++ %(4)#$*&,#5 D4#5*'*)#$*&,- -

(6*$$%(5>= @&.<*,1 #$2* 4.4(@#.# @2%.%#+ ,&-

@&.<*,1 +%)4.*$> 14#.( #,&$2%.

#5/%.# &@*,1 2*+ ,#$4.% (4$>= 2% @*55 ,&$ .%#(*5> #/#*5#85% /*55#1%.+ (*+)2#.1% (4$*%+ ;#68#.(#.-

)#+%
 



  

  E )&4.$ 2#( &8+%./%( .%,(%.*,1 +%./*)% )&664,*$>= 9.%+%,)% %,+4.%( %/%,$ ,&,#/#*5#8*5*$>= +49%.*&.

D4#5*'*)#$*&,+ )#,(*(#$% #.% ,& )&,+%D4%,)%-

 

-A

/*(%,$5>= 2#( #99&*,$%( ;#68#.(#.= @#+ '4.$2%.

#''*.6%(
&66*++*&,%.- )#+% !"  

 #  $%  &&##  '""#()) * 

 +E @#+ 2%5( !*/*+*&, %,)2
&4.$ )2&*)% )#,,&$ 5*12$5> +%$ #+*(%= %/%, *'

$@& /*%@+ #.% 9&++*85%= 4,5%++ $2%.% #,> 9#$%,$ *55%1#5*$> &.

9%./%.+*$> $2%.%*,- $ @%55 %+$#85*+2%( ,&$ &,5> #99.%)*#$%+ 6%.*$+ (%6%.*$+ #55 )#,(*(#$%+ '.#> 84$ 9%.+&,#55> *,$%.#)$+ @*$2 $2%6- 24+= +487%)$*/% +#$*+'#)$*&, ,&$ 5*12$5> *1,&.%(- - 9.%+%,$ )#+%=

+%$ '4.$2%.

.%6#,(%( )#+% )&55%)$&.

'.%+2 )&,+*(%.#$*&,E 9.*6#.*5> 1.&4,( $2%.% #55%1#$*&, *55%1#5 9&++%++*&, &/%.

9#,)2#>#$ 5#,( 9%$*$*&,%.-

-

!4.*,1 )&4.+% 2%#.*,1 9%$*$*&,= +9%)*'*) D4%.> @#+ .#*+%( )&4,+%5 ,&-

.%'%.

#,> %/*)$*&, 9.&)%%(*,1+ &.

%/*)$*&, #1#*,+$ 9%$*$*&,%.= 2&@%/%.

2% '#*5%( .%'%.

#,> +4)2 6#$%.*#5- 2% &,5> (&)46%,$ .%5*#,)% 95#)%( 49&, .%+&54$*&, --

 .#6 #,)2#>#$= @2%.%*, 8%%, +$#$%( #.(%/ 0*,12

%$*$*&,%. @#+ 1*/%, ?2#+.# 

  

 A 5%#+% >%#.

E 2&@%/%.

2% ,%*$2%.

9#*( 5%#+% 6&,%> ,&.

1#/% 9&++%++*&, 5#,(- )&4,$%.

+#*( #55%1#$*&,= )&4,+%5 95#)%( .%5*#,)% 49&, .%9&.$ -A-

 .%/%,4% &''*)*#5+= .%#(+ 4,(%.



45   /.

   26 7888"0 

   

9 6 :88

0 )      +   %     !    * +   .%6 
% .
1%2   /.

;< -

0*6*5#.

.%9&.$  --

= +48+$#,$*#$%( %,$.*%+ ?2#+.# *.(#@#.*

 .%1#.(*,1 ?2#+.# 



A ).&9+ ?2#.*'

  ).&9+ ?2#.*'

 ).&9

#8* A- 24+= 6> )&,+*(%.%( /*%@=

%..%( +%$$*,1 ;#68#.(#.-

- /*%@ #8&/%=

 9#++%(

4,7#8= +%$ #+*(%-

%+45$#,$5>= #55&@%( --

 9#++%(

0#2*8= #99&*,$*,1 3*55#1% %2+*5

0#2*8= 6#*,$#*,%(- - %,(*,1 #995*)#$*&,

+= *'

#,>= +2#55 +$#,( )5&+%(-

 0  

!

--

+7<+ 2%$2%.

+9%#<*,1 .%#+&,%(

 "%+

& 2%$2%.

.%9&.$#85%  "%+

&