← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1359/2020disposed of

Baljeet Kaur Alias Baljit Kaur And ORS v. National Insurance Co Ltd And ORS

2020-02-26Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina20 pages



        

  ! "#$     

  !

  "

 %#&  '(%  ) *  

 # $ %&"'() 

"

*  +   * " %+ , " ( 

-   

./

 $ ( , *%'  .0 " .

%+ 1 -2 $   ( ' 334   5$ (56.."  "

..  (,     ," ,   ) , ,,  )

 "".)' 7 % 8

9   " /

 "

    0   " .

 %+    $ (  , *%': +,5$(*5;0  ."8

  0 .    *  "    ,    8, ,"  %8("  ,"  %

"8 " "%+   ,"+<.,=%( %   2'

<=, %"'8   ,

8 , ""  ,  ,

,)%""+"+% '8    .> ?*$8 

    7@ ,  " #?+ , (   "<ABC ( 

 /// ,    !8(0 C@* 8  "   "+ "" 8 8 7%,%+$(*  * "" 8 C"%+$(* 8  "   +%+ ,"+.8  

%+   23

-'(0&   !

1,     3

-'4 "+

8     %     ,.    $  (   ,

*% <D0 . 8+  6 .

,"  "")  1 -2 $ ( , 0  )+  ," ,'"  '  )"   

  *$(*   (,   

0.     .  ,                   )+1 -2 (  A.

 .  ,%+8 . 

  '  .  "     ,C. ,  . 

 E 2 *   

  ',+   )8   ." )C 8

%  )    0" .,     

  $ %&""".  , %,   )+  ,"   ) " ,+1 -2 (  .,"8) 1 E ,+ 8 .   ,    8        ".    ,.+'    $(*.) 8 "

")

%$    ' ,$  

( ' 338  " ")  0  $(*8  %,

  , ).   "  /  ""  " " %,

   

   %$    ' :

 '5 %  5;8 ),%.   8    .   9 %,  ,"") 

" 88%.  % 8 "

.  

  8""

  

, -  8 ,      % '

 ,") ")  FGG 

)  '

38 ")  ," ) )8 0    FGG "   +,

  %      "8 $(*8   )   ,+  0     0       *  ")    "  8 #=





         

 !!"# $%   & '!( (%!

)'* +,*  !!   -.  $$!.  $#      (!-   '!*  -!.* /0*1'!  2 +3/4 3/ 444*1'! +3/ 04*1'!  3/ 0443  / 444*1'!   -$ 

2    

 

  !"#$"$%

4 # * (!-  '! !!

%!!$" #-$*  !5"(%!('-.6  6'  3 1 -2 ( 8  

 :

";  +>") #= 78&    

 

 

9.-' ' -.

$ '"*(!-  '!-.* $$!-  .$ ! -'*

'  -' (!!(!! !!$%  - --  ! %':

-$ 

    +  +  8  %.  ,        )+,  ,1 -2 ( "" %    " "+%.,,C""  $(*

     ,"   ) ,, %+ )+ ,+ 

 )%+ ,  ""+ %  

+ ,* 41-26 ") 8  ,+ "   )C.0+, , "+ 0 8 0 )

  '8 

   ,  )+)%FGG   )  '

3   H   

% * "    $(*<0 .

 %*" 9+". % $      '      % .  ,  8    8

+ 

 

*+$-8

%  ,    0       ,    8   .

" ""+" FGG  )

 '

3  *&), 9+ ",.9+ $      '  

    0      "8  )  , 1  3'3'/ ' ' ' /' -'  " "(  

  '  -

'  C

/

  % '  + 8. + FGG  , "   +   8  ) 

98) 8   .88 '") 4

6 0  %8 ,   7,,+#= '



         

  !!"# $%   & '! (%!

)'*+,* !!   -. $$!. $#       (!-   '!  -!.* /*0*1'!  2 +3/4 / 444*1'! +*/ 04*1'!  */ 044*  / 444*1'!  :

*$    '  

%   7+( " .  1 -2 (   *."   % ,"+8 "

. *$   :(,,;( '

:( 

;8  )

     3

 ,  

)  1F2-:D;

$ + * "8+ '8B1  

,.(   1%=  :2;1 / (  * "    % 

9+   8  %.+,")  ( %+  1 / . %  :2;'8  .

- "  0  8 $(*7.8

8 )    %+%+ %.

 

 *8+")  #= '

((4  $$!*  '

   *    !!"#  '

  !!    *-!.;< 7  8&$'$   -  "* (!-  '! !!!

%!!$"   (%!('6' ' ( (%!)'*+,*  ""  $.- -.$

 . ' '%! ':

 2 1 /   % ,, 3

8   8 #= '!)

    

   4!#.='.' ,* (!-  '!-.* '

>.'!  -.    -     ! *  !!"  '

'--.$' 5  

 (!-  '! !!%!!$"

  (%! ('  $'$   5# %           #    "

  -$!!#  %.$' '-  -! >   '$'$ 

 -.    $  3      (!-

 '! !! - (%!('   !!    $'$       2   ($  04      (    (-! )'*   8

 '

>.'! -. -

! *    (!-   '!  -.*     $'$  >'#'$.!-  -$ * -$  $



# $!5"!# .- !%='.

!# ='.:

  ( .+'          *%      " , .   

  :

";8 

8 

 ,.) ,, C

8 .%  +  8  7 %   .   "     / * 8*%    %  " ,".)%,#= 7  $'

!      !  "

        6' " !-$'  ?0!4%"   !"  !  "         @! 4 '  (  !  0   - '    

$

 .A

!)'> A.A# ('    (1  B 

8,    +     +,+ +*:

 ' 23<-;$. "  '!!!C6'#(' $" $$%   8     ?  0!        %.   -$ -' #' " .

'   .C6'#(' (!!(!!$ %-'-( *   !%'  '    %"          >'#-   A

!A#('*   (!!$%   -'    -$          (!!%-' -$ 

  !%'(!-  $$  (!!  ' $# (!!  '

- (' %. -' !-   ( '8 ?0!  " #  ! -:

- *  "   .

  8    %)      0  " .

'8 ) . %   

  :

"; "  .   +      8 # ?/+2+2 +* !!"#" $

 .

(';

74 !*  !  ' !      $   $8 ?0!* ,,*%. -$ -' # ' "!.   .

'    .C6'#('(!! (!!$%-' - *   !%' D  ' !      $  '   '$' $ .

! '!  

'  "  -      5  '      $

4 '(-$. '

 *! ' ! $ $!!'$ >'#- A#(' 1>      7  B!  4 '  (-$.  D  %  ?    (!-   '!*  >-  E   :

#(%!? 9)B++   ++,  B - +,+ +

?"!*-'



'  $ :

D  ' !      $

'

-  $B  !.$ -  $ %='-  $  " # /#!. D  ' !     $  B

'

- $. $-  $  - C6'#('-$!." 8 ?0!   4  %"     %*     ++8 +  C6'#('

!!$-$!."$%   -  8 ?0!  "!" F $  :

3 *   

  :

";8%   ,      ",."+

" ,   D0 .1  -2  D0 .8  $(* 0 "

     ") +""  ) 0    "8  ),+ 

 )  '"   )+ 

    )    "0    8       )+  ""   

,"  . %  +8       "

" .    ,8  C" 88 + 

 ..).))8  +    +



 ," "+% ,+     

 

%+%++ *     

  %  .,  9.?*   ,"+!) $( , *%'(,H @'

3 (A

#

:

;( 28    %  8    , ..%+8. ,  %  *  "".    8  % C% . % %..,  %   3  

4 6 8"  .?7 @ 8.%+ .8  #7)'  !!" .(!-

 '!!#='  :*. % 

" , #?( (%!)'$$!.  :*       3  ,  F  GG        )

"  #= ?*#+

  

    

      ,  -      !!"#  $%       (    (%!

)'*  +,  !!*        -.  * $$!      $#    %.

(!-  '!*-!.;

 ,*,   4& '!*/0*'! 

     !'

%    2    +    !'

%/04'! 8*2**+*** ,/0*44 '!+*/0444* '! 2 !'

%*E+3/4 * / 4*'!  2 !'

%

 !'

%

3/ 44*'! *

* *8**/ 444*'! +    !'

%  /  40*  '!    2* / 04* 044*/ 0444*'! 

8 !'

%*+ + !'

%   2    ,     !'

%  /  4 * / *'!   !'

%*,*  +*  */ 44*'!   !'

%*3/ 444*'! 

 !'

%3/ 40*/ 04* '! , !'

%2,  !'

%*/ 044*/ 0444*/ 4 *  /   '!      2    !'

%/ 04'! +  !'

%*/ 4 *'!   2 !'

%4       '!  -5    $%     -5  ' $% *!%$% 

 ( (%!)'*+, !!   -. *$$!.$#   (!-  '!:

      ., %+    %       9.  "$ )$(*H('4

21 F! 368""+"" . 3 8 # A%# % '

-

 *4       >'       (!-

 '!  " !- !.    -*  -!.  

'  

  (!! %.  -'''"   D  1%'     '!  $





>'   "" "$%   ()(

$$! !6' 

$

 .(%!('G 8 D  '  !"      $$!.

$$1'!+ , 1> ? 0! 1'! +#!-    F (!! !!" -$!!#.$'9 !-   '!  $



   >'          "  "*   !-  '!       5    !!"

$':

        "     %        1  

 

,  8,, 1 /  .1%=  :2;1 /  +  $   ( ' 33(  ." ' '1 -2 (  %.")     8?,+

   @  +") 8 

0 + "  ,  )+'8  ,+ ")8") '8  ,C.

"8  %+" "( 1 E1  -2 (  ")  % C  1  ,C 8 % )"   ). % ,  0   , 8  ," ,%+

2 $(*  ") ""+8=. , 8 %.  ,  80    )+ ,+%+8 , '8 .8  ")   ," 8 )"  )    +        % 

       8   7 , + ")1+' . )8 ,8,  )+ 

  ,"

%8

.) 8   ))  8 )%+

,  8 "    ,,  I ""+.+" 8, %%," 

,, 

  )+ + ,8  C" % ).  , % )%+ +'

A1 ,1)1 ': - ;1--2' /#= 7$

'!!" -  .

- 

%$" '

%#  '

!>'

   '-   '!    $'  '!     -*    - 

*    !#!  >'

  -$!

  % # '.$"H'#  6 >'

"# ='!"  "'! "!!.=' !:

B,  ," 0  8 

    .")    0  8  ," +)8

8  *0 . <% %  % . +%+",.

 

 8C

FGG  '8 0 )+8 "0" 8.%+%  "    "+.)  "'8  % ,,C  ,C.,+ "% 

 8%    ,"  +  C ,,

4 ",+6..  0"D0  8 0 %+ FGG  H  ,+  ) 8  8 , 1 / :2; $ (*+'8 *%   %+ , .1%  :2; 1 / ( *")  FGG H

 )  8 +"  0%8 +  #= 71'!. ,   !!-.*$. !' !! $

!!"

*-!.;

 .$ ('" '. 6' * (' .$ !-. '# 53  ' ('* ! .$ !-.

'# 5 ..-" $.- %"#3   " *      ('  "  -    *     9.$.- - '!'

  !'

  '

'!*>'#-   !!#%   !'# ('    !.    -  .  #   $ * 5"!#-'

/    9  -.    $  .  $ !  -.     '# 5'!'

!'

   '

'! *-.$.-'# 5*     -.  *  !!  '!.      !!"# $'! *-!.;

'-  #! '3  -  $ "- "$! -"  *   -. *-    "$!    "  "-.-  >'

* 

.*" " $$!*   '-  6'  ('*"

'  $#3 -

 $. 8/.-'$'!'

!'



'

'!*4 * .* !! ' -   %   '

'!  2/.-'$'!'

   '

'!*  * .* !! ' -  ' $.-;

)%*" ! '

 $   $ !  -.      $.-  '#    5*   !! ' -" -.  "      -*    "    %

$ $ !-.$.-'#

5*  !! ' -"   -.  "'!  %        -     .'   '



 $ !'   5*  -. :

, -.

/  0C%. $.- -.*!'#  $.- -. !% -! * -. 6' .%!$   >'#-  * .- ! 

- $$.* . :

 * % ' 9+ '

 88+  ' '1 -2  33(  .") .8,1 /

:2; $ (  ") 41-26 " "    ,9 % ,"C  %+   *%  ( .+'  1   -2      %    8    ,+81 / :2; (  8 8=  8 " 0  .8")  1"  .

. ,..

  " ")  , ,', 0  ,.")  *

" " 0"

88 " 

8  !,0,?. " % .@ *+').8 % .%+ ,+ %   %+,, 1 /  (  .1%=  :2;  8=    . )")  .8 % ). ' "  ")   " )" '1 / :2;8 ""+ " )+"." .

*,". '

 ' +") ),  

  " 88).%     "  7     8    0       8  %      ,).  ( 

3

2 $  &"   +  %,                ,       0     8      $(*    %.

 "         ,         '  8  0  " .

".



 .  ",

,"B  8  0"   8+"  .   8  ,+  8   ' )  %C ,,+C"*% 8% 8    0" .,

F    .         

   .   ,'        .8*8 "

 $'-   %.) 8   % 8+8)%% 88 "

   

-0 " 

,,%.. 1 / :2;$   ( ' 33

/ * ',". %+. %8), 

   " 88).%" 7  80  8 $(*    88 ,

      *+8  %" 0" , +8"  % , 

- (           ..   

'    "  

8*,".  *   , D0 .<$( , *%'88  8 ,",  888  , ,  ""+             "+  %+  0  .

  ) ' 0" '%+C. ",   ,  " ,"+5 C(  

 /// ' "+ ' 

   , %.7 C  ,  ,+



             ,    +  * *%8 %,"888C   . &  % % 

F  " 8 "%"      8 .

,' ,+  "

3

         ""  %     *%    

"+  %  %+

  .%+ ,,.D0 . <$( , *% 

%'9+.8+'    

%"

8 ) , .   '    '

%+, "., ""+.8     %C%+..."  " +J  8"    .  $

( , *% 8     ,    88C  ,   ,

0   8 8+"+%  (+  %+8+    %)8  +   +' +' + ',  ,8

"".    / *  0 $   C) D F*(!D