← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1218/1990dismissed

Tulsi v. Asha Etc.

2023-01-25Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

 



      

 !"#$"%&'&#()*++, -.'&  /00".. (! 1"2'-' '3  !%+ /+"'0#(4"(!'

#2 5)

#(67." 2+-'!&%"++8 .&  2"'"(!)

2+ (9 :;&9<41#% !"$#2!3"00".. (!+ #("$#2!3"2"'0#(4"(!+ === ++8 .& <+  ">-. 2 "%#(4 00" . %3 .."(>"' 9-4>5"(! (4 4"%2"" 4 !"4+,+0 ''"47:!3"." 2("4&'!2&%!-4>"< -2> #(&( &1&. 00" . #+? #$  &( % '" !&!."4 ' '3  (4 #!3"2' 1'+ -.'& 4"%2""&(> !3" %&1&. '-&! $#2 2"4"50!&#( #$ 5#2!> >"4 . (4 '-79"%! !# 0 :5"(! #$ '+ ,@ ' 2"4"50!&#( 5#(": A&!3&( !32"" 5#(!3'< 7: 2"1"2'&(>!3"9-4>5"(! (44"%2""4 !"4++0 ''"47:!3"." 2("4 -7 -4>" . ''< "2#B"0-2 3&2C 

-2> #(A3"2"7: !3" %&1&. '-&! $&."47:!3"2"'0#(4"(!'@0. &(!&$$'A '4&'5&''"4+  #." 2>-5"(!#$." 2("4 #-('". &'!3 ! !3" 9-4>5"(! (4 4"%2""#$!3"." 2("400".. !" #-2!2"1"2'&(>!3"9-4>5"(! (44"%2"" #$!3"." 2("4-7-4>" . ''<"2#B"0-23&2C 

-2> #(&'."> ..: -('-'! &( 7." ' !3" %&1&. '-&! $#2 2"4"50!&#( #$ -'-$2-%!- 2: 5#2!> >" 3 47""($&."47":#(4,:" 2'#$.&5&! !&#('!&0-. !"4-(4"22!&%."D #$!3"E&5&! !&#(%!<D,<!3"2"$#2"<!3"9-4>5"(! (44"%2""0 ''"47: !3"." 2("4&'!2&%!-4>"4"%2""&(>!3"%&1&.'-&!&'.& 7."!#7"2"1"2'"4< (49-4>5"(! (44"%2""0 ''"47:!3"." 2("4%&1&.9-4>"4&'5&''&(>!3"

 %&1&.'-&!-03".4+ , ''-"&(!3"&('! (!% '"&'(#.#(>"2  (4'! (4' '"!!."4 7: !3" 4"%&'&#( &(   

             

  !"&(A3&%3 A3&." 2"$"22&(> !# !3" 5 F&5 G#(%"  5#2!> >"< .A :'  5#2!> >"6<

#(67."!3"-02"5" #-2!&(0 2 >2 03#'+ #$&!'4"%&'&#(3".4 '-(4"2)



         

        

 

     

 

           

     ! "#$#

#  %             

     ! "#$#

 

   

    ## 

 

                        

  # &                   '      (   

#    

            

      

 

  

 #%  ) 

# ? 45&!!"4.:<%&1&.'-&!$&."47:!3"-'-$2-%!- 2:5#2!> >#2!# 2"%#1"2 0#''"''&#( A ' 4&'5&''"4 7: !3" ." 2("4 -7 -4>"  . ''< "2#B"0-23&2C #(>2#-(4#$.&5&! !&#(7:3#.4&(>!3"%&1&.'-&!3 4(#! 7""($&."4A&!3&(,:" 2' (4!3" 00".. (!4"$"(4 (!3 47"%#5"#A("2 #$ !3" '-&! . (4 #( %%#-(! #$ (#(2"4"50!&#( #$ !3" 5#2!> >"4 . (4

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

2"4 '(#(#%%-0 (%:!"( (!#+ (4 !3" 00".. (!4"$"(4 (! '(#(#%%-0 (%:!"( (!#+#(0 :5"(!#$2"(! &(!3" 5#-(!#$*0"2C ( .!#! &(>!#'+,I&(2"> 24!#!3". (4 7" 2&(>H3 '2 #+?@&(H3 2&$D (4$#2!3"2"5 &(&(>. (4&( 7& D (4 !3 ! F+ , A ' !3" %#0: #$ 5-! &#( #+ ? 1&4" A3&%3 !

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

 7""( '3#A( !3 ! !3" 45&''&#( #$ 00".. (! @ 4"$"(4 (! &( %2#'' "F 5&( !&#(#$5#2!> >"3 1&(>7""(%2" !"47:!3"2"'0#(4"(!@0. &(!&$$ '3 &($ 1#-2#$ ""2 (&(3&'02"'"(%"A '&(%#22"%!$#25#2!> >"%#-.4 7" %2" !"4 7: '3  #(.: #( 5-! &#( #$ &(3"2&! (%" 3 1&(> 7""( ' (%!&#("4&(02&.

* * ( !3" .&>3! #$ !3" 0#'&!&#( (#!"4 7#1"< (# '-7'! (!& . J-"'!&#(#$. A<5-%3."''J-"'!&#(#$. A 2&'"'$#2%#('&4"2 !&#(&(!3&' % '"+ %%#24&(>.:<  4# (#! $&(4 (: >2#-(4 !# &(!"2$"2" A&!3 !3" A".. 2" '#("49-4>5"(!0 ''"47:!3"." 2("4&'!2&%!-4>" (44&'5&''!3" 00" .+       

  *++, *

+  % ,   - .,/  %    - .,/