← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5398/2020allowed

Nikhil Sharma v. Union Of India And Others

2025-04-28Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj12 pages



    

     

   

 !

"# !$%&%"'(  ) 

*+ , 

 



  

-  

 ,



 

(  .+ , /  ,          



  

  ! "# ! 

 $ 

%&'(  /  ,  0 

+

 ) "  *  

 

 +   ,-,,,*.,,,, 

+  



" +



 + 



 " / 0"

  

  



" !

123    4



5    

     

  

  

" !

2 6   

 + !  7)    "

   8) ,9    

  "  :

7

%,;,%%,,,<%9, =    (  * 





,9,9 *     

* 

  ((    5

   "5

 <,9

  )     )

 +)7) "

>

=!

7  

= ( 

*=   



)   "* *  

"    

>



?* 

,-,,,=  

  



 " 0"

*  *  

@$!

" )=  

5A   "*  

*B )   '

5" 

   

  

*  

$C

>

 $   +  0"

  

* B )+ 5)         



 ;,,, *   @$!

" )*

5) 

)+  *   " )    $ "

+       "  0"

 5

"    5  

+  5 +

  

5" ) / 0"

    

 5   . 4



5    

    " 

 5) 

 )

5= 

   

)     )    :

      " 0"

  

,-,,, *  5

 

 D@$!

" )/5 )  E 7

+    " 0"

 $ @$!5

" )  5)   *D@$!/ = )  E4



       

 +  " " ) 0"

" 7  " 

 ?

  :* 7 

 ,,,, *    *      5 " )   

5"*   @$!=    

.

 @$?'   

    *   5

")

"?5"    

 

+5   5)7 "

4 ?

 :*7  

+ 5)  

*5)    

5

 )   

+  5   

 

+         *   

)    "

  )5 

5) 

 ( 5"     

      "

 "

    0"

   

 5)        

5    +

)    "  " ?

    " 

"

 $   0"

    "      $C/99  ,F  

    

 

" 0"

!(@$   +         5

5)    F ?      

   7

 

 4 :

-. ,;*    

%&

(   5   / 0"

 

 

" 

")?

 



 :*7   4



%&

(  

       * + +" /   =   *  

   5  5 "    

"

 

* 

    "



 "  

 +   " 5

     

     "   )5      +  5)  

F

 * *



  " 5) 



7 ? + $  "   



   

 !"

   4  

+   " 5  " 5) ?

35 "$  =      " 0  /  

      



  

 

 

   



   

  

 



      

  

              

  



    

     

 



 

   



  



     



 

 !



     

   





                



       

  





     "

  #   !

     

       #

  

      $

    % 



      # 

 

   

  

  

&  

 

%

  

 '  

 '"  

  

 !

 

 (  

      

    

       

    

 

  

 

 

 

  

 

   

  

 )   



 

   

   

   

   

   

 

 *    

    

 

5 



+    B 

 >

    

 

)5

 +   "   (  +5)     

     " 5)      

 5 / 0"

5) $  5"   "*  "

  /0"

   

    5)   0   $   0

 * A

** 

5

"           5"            

    

 4 :

-. ,; &

(       + +  

 " *



*     5      +  5)5G 7



4 :

;<  ,    "   &

 (   

   ?

    +"     

 5





")?

 



:* 7 

  " 0"

+  5   A

 

-

- 4



%&

(  *  *     * +G

/  

 *    " 5

 7 ? + $

       

 #    

 *   5  )



"  

 )

 



   * 

 "  

#   (* 



 *   

  

 "

*     *    

)   "  )5"       

  5  "   

   )   A



     5 B    ) * 5    

   "



 "   + 5G )  +  

 "

+ 

*    "

/ 5"    

 *  (  5        ) *  

*  

+   "

     



A

 5  5)  $

 +

*

 "  

+5

<

  / 5"    

+  "   +"   (     *   *   5  

*  *

+) 

*   

"

 *

 +

* / //   

 

) )         )**       " 

 

    * ")0   ) * 

5    ? + $  5 "  5  )  "



 < (     



        +

 

+    

"    

+ *       

 ; C   

  

""    

 5  +  

 *  )    +   5

 

 

     +  *

+  

    

    

   +

     " "  

5" *  "

 5) ?

35 "$  " $# #%  &' # '

 ()**  +

+  # )) + =  " )  

  5

 5    

  

"" 



*    

 

5 5

 "



 



;

>    * 

5  5  " )    B



+



 

"" 



/

+   )  50   

 *



5



 " 



5   +   

  )  5

   " )



+ " + 

*  5 B   "   *  "5   *   +   9 =   

* 

 

  " )    5 )



"" 

 A  "   )=   

*  *  "

*  

 

"

     



  

"" 

 (  

"

  

 *   

    +  ")  

""  

 

 * 

5G +

 "   )   ) + 

     

 *

+) A   ) "   G  50  = 

*  5 A

* ")5

55

"

5          A  5)  ) + "     *   * 

  * 5    

  +  

 A+"   $

 

 

   ?

35  " $    "

 , 

 +

+  ))-.=   

 A+"  0    / /.

 

  

        

 

  %       

9

 

    %  



  

 

 

 

 

&

 





    

  





 %     

 

  

  

   

 %      

    +     

  

   #    

 

         

 

 

  #      



 



 





    

  ( 

     

"

            #   

 

   





        

  

 

  



  

   

   

      !



     

 

      



 



#     #  !  ,-./012 3 #!! 7  # #     -./082 1 #!! 486  9

 :#     $ -./0;2/#!!/446* .<  2  , =   

)

    "    

#

*  *     

 5        +" *   5  

  )* 

  

)

* *       

 

 5

"" = 5

   

  

   

  :

<;0 5

 " 

  

" )*    +  



,

 ?

+    +    

* 

     " 

0 

 +" 0"

  ? + $  

") 

 *   

 *

" $ 0

 A 

           5 H

%



  

 +  5)     *          "

 15 )  / @$! 5

" )3

5)     1"

 

*      5 *-,5 "

3*  1@$!5

" ) )  3 5)      

  1

 

*      5

,,5 "

3= 

      +

)

        5  "

 



/0  = 



  "     5 + ") 0      

  



 *

   * =  

5 "   + 5)7 "

4 ?

  :*7  5

"   

5

") +

& 

 

*    *





)  ?

35 "$  

 

   

/0"

 ++ 

 " 0!1)%(  0,#( 2+-   )) "  C    +  " 

"

 ? + $  "  " 0"

 * *   " 





)

5 ? + $ * 0

+  *

-  $

 

(  

5  55 



 *

+ 5)     



  )*



+ 5) *  " 

 "  B 0  

 )

 

* 5

" "

 )

    0 

 7  " 

 4  ?

  :* 7  

   "   

 . &  +

"

  "+  %

 ,-,,,*.,,,, 

+  



" +

  = 

   /0"

  

 

")?

 



:*7 

 

 @$! 5

" )  B



 5 





    F = 

   "  /0"

 

5

 

")?

 



:*7 *  

"

       

)  

 ")5 5) 0     

  " 5              5 5  5)  

 +  5)  

") ?

 



:*7   "

" 

  

 

* 0 

   

 

+ *   

G   5      *    A



)

"    A

+  )*  A

+  =   *  

 

 +) *



-   +"  

  )     

 +) 12%3 0



/  ,  

24 2"2

 

  = (

>

 ?@>7    =     ?@>7