High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2301/2003dismissed

Charan Singh v. State Of Punjab

2015-05-21Mr. Justice K.C. Gupta15 pages

! ""## $ % & ' "

'()!!

' * * ! )!

& * +*% & ' ,,,,,

-! "" # !& .

'(! #

*/ - 0 */1"

2!'(

' 3 !4 % #5 !*64%67

" " ( "

( * 8*

# "

( *

! " 9!

# 9 ! !

: 3 * 95 2 !!#7* ( * ## ;!

*2! #

! ) 0! ! 0 ' %) #2 !! ##! # <!!2 ! #* !

!! ! = !*!#! # ! ! -! "!" ! ! ! 2! ! ! !

6#'!5*! !* ;!

!"> ! *! ( !"-! 9 # 2 ! ! ! ! ! #! !

#('-!(2 ?9 "

!* 2! !

* ! * #" ## 3 > 3 *

! -! 2 ! '(!" 9 <! ! " 9 # 2 ! "

! ! !

% !2 #!"2 !!"# *4

% #!!# 0 !< *2!! -!

% # @ !"#

#/4 34%2 # !

% #0!" 93 3 #=" #* / 1 #0 2!! #9 2 '(

;

0 #2 ' ! ! !

! #2 !# @ !

"# ! !

! #?9 *% * 2! !" " 1 > 3 * 4

% # !"# ""

"# = #'0'

# #2 5 7

!" !"# 5! 7

5 7 ! " 9 2 # 0 " > A *!" 92 " ' ! '

#) */ 1 #0 ! :% > A *+ " !*)'% !

( * " ! !"# -! 2 # ##(9 A "# * !

## 2 " 34% ! '

#) */ 1 #0 .

*2! : * ! ! -!

*! 2 # #

* / - 0 */1"

*2! !

34%* 2! !! 6"# #(6 # # -" *" 9 %< 4;

!* %< ) * % 2 * %< )= & B #* %< :

9*%<! B #*%< ;

*%<3 C !

#*%<A4) & !*%<. '#!

' ! %<

% # !4 ( *!" #

"?9% ( 2! ! #2 " #" 2 0 " *?9% # "#

'() % 2 *?9%

*?9%:

9 '( ! "# * ?9% " 9 : ! #% 5 !* 6%67*?9% # #"*?9%38 '(! *?9%A#*?9%." ! #9 *?9% # #" ! *?9%

( 2! !'

2 0 " *?9% ( 2! ! #! " 9 2 0 " * ?9% " # ! * ?9% : * ?9%:8 * ?9%:8 /4*?9% "# *?9% 3 ""# *?9% A ""# * ?9% . ""# ?9% ! 2 % -! ## !

"" ! !" # ' =2* 2 #'(! -! #

# # !

=*! "" # 4 9" !

' 6 ( 2 ! # 2 ! 5 7 %<:" 9 !

: 3 * !2! #

) 0! ! = 2 ! #* ( : ( * #

!<!!2 !

* " ! =

!! # !2! =!#! # '#( '0! ! #2 ='

# 2 #'0'(! = '#( "

"! ! !0" @ ! # ! 2##

! # !> ! * ! ! !

! !" !!

# ## # > ! !*! # ! ( ! !' !! !! # !! ! ! ! !

-!( "

3 % ! *!( "" ! "

!*'

! '# -!( ! "

!! #2 !! !

* ! ! "

!2 "! 2 !!"# *'

!"#

# !! " ## !

< !! !

"# 2! ! ?9%:>! ##2 ( ! 0 *!"# 0! #=" #*/ 1 #0 2!! 9 2 ! # ! ' !) 2! ! ?9% 5 7 %< ! ! !

: 3 *!2! #

! ' 2! ! 2 '

# ( '(!" 9=! ! !" 9=2 ! #

! !

2 " ! " 9 > ! *! 2 (-! #! " 92 # (-! 9 ! ! ! ' ! ! ! ! -!

* !( 2 ?9 "

!*2!2 '#= ! 3 = # 2 !

9*% !*

!2 "! !"# *'

!"#

#!! " !< 2!!

92 = #! !"# 5 7 %< ;

" !

3 3 *! # ##(9 ! 9*2!2 ' !'(!"#

)>9 *! 0 9 # # ("

! '( ( 9

2###" -!!( ## $ # 9 2

#( D '# 2 " -2 #2 '2 0 ! ! # ?9 * % " " 1 ! ""

# # " ! '"( ! ?9% 5 7 %< 4

% # !*

!" *"!

#2 !!"#

#2 " ! B 0 !2 2! ! 9 # 2 ! ! ! "

! ! -! 9 ?9%: !

= ?9%:8 @

"# !'

2! !

#/4?9%:8 2 ! = ! " ""

"# ?9% = 0 " '0'

#2 ( ?9%

#-!"

#2 #'( ! 2 !! #6 6 #2 ;

& 2!

! '(!" 9 2! !2 # 0 " (?9% >3 3 *! 0!" 9 #!" #*/ 1 #0

! ""# ?9%3 ! #9 9 *! !

! # 2 ' # # 2 ! #" 2! ! 2 0 " ( ?9% > A * " :

%2 > A * + " !*)'% !

( *" ! ' ! -! 2

! ?9% 2

"# * ! 2 !

## '( =>

2 ! 4!

! !# # !"

" ! # ' ! * # # !

#( !

'( ! "

#( !

-! # !

# "" # #

9 !

2 -!" ( ! !#( "'

##"# # ! ##

-! " 9 2 "

'( ! ! # -! 92 '& " ! ##

#( 2 ( ! ## 2!""# *! ! !#( '

#4 !" 92 #!

(* 2 #!

#( !

## ! # !

(2 '(! 4

*!" 92 '(! " " 2 !! B #* !" ! !

##( "# !" # ' # # ! !

! # ( 2 ( # !/4 -! ## 0"# : 3 * ' %)2! ! /42 3 -!# ( 2 ( #

!/4!

'9"# '(!" >#(! * !" (

## -! (# 0# ! (2 ! # ' # "# ! -!# ( 2 ( # !

D9 "# 0 ! !

! 9 ! !#( (! # -! 9 # & ( ("

'( !" 9" ! ## -! ' # ( -! @ " '( ! !

'# '-!2 0* (*9 ! *

' # 1 ! -!" ! #9 ""!" -! ##( '

! 2 !!" ( "

##(2! D9 2 2 !

##! #2 -!"'

'# !

' 0 '(! # !*! # ( !" !

! * # # ! !

' # ( ( " ' #

# 0 ' ! !

' #( '(! # "! % * # # !#( "" ! # # ! !

! # ( ! #*! # !

!#(!#! #( !

3 4% -! " 9 !

##( ' '(! %<! !*2! !! " #(

! ! ! *! ( !"-!

##' ! (

9 -! # " # # #( !

'#! #2 !" 92 " 4!

! # # # !"

2 !! !#"" ! ! / ! # # ! "

##2 " '(!

! "

# !

# ! $

%&'( % )&* #(*! # ( 2 ( " ! !"# -! ## 0"# : 3 ! 2 "!"# 3 -!# ( " ! !"#

! #

(*!2* !# ( 9"# !

! * ' ' 2'(!

-!" !

!" !

#('#" ! ( !(2 ! # ?9 "

! !2 '# ! ##

! ! ## 3 ! 2 #! !

! (*! 2 "!"# -!# (!

##(9"# '(!" *! * ' 2 !" # ( " ! 4 !

#(* ## "" ! ## ! #

! !

!("! !"# -! 9'# ( !

#( " 9 !

'( !# " ! !"#

"" ! !"# *!( !

# ' 2 !! ## ! #! !# ( " !

#( 4

...5 7 #"5% & ' = ( 7* !

'!#!

#! !!"# 9

##(

# # ( # ! " ' (

#( ! # ! " 9 !

#( '"# 2! !!" !

#(4! *!2 # ( (2! "!"# 4 2 !

'*# ( # !/4"# !" "

" % D5 7 2 #( -! " 9 !

##( !

!!# !'( E !E!#!E"

" ! # #(*!2 9 0 & ( !!" !" % ! & !" " 9 #2 ( (!2 !"

<! ## * "

'#( 0 # (*! ##( "!( ##( '# # !02 !! #(!-! '( ! (# ' # ( 9 # & !'(

!" 9-!'0'

# #2 " 9 !"# # #(!2! " !" 9'(! -! " ' '# #(! !

!" 9!

9 # 0 & !'(" ! ! !

4! *!" 9 !

(9 # 0 & (2!2 ' "'(!

*! *! # # !

!2 9 # & (!'( " 9" ! ! * !

2 ! -!

95%<:7

##(' '(! ( %< ! ! -! " 95%<:7 %< !

##(' '(! ( %< ;

* 2! # ##(9 !" 9 -!"5?9%7

! #9 # #(!2!

2 ! 2 ' !" 9-!" & ( !!'(

9 %"!!

" % D5 7 2 #( %&'( % )&&&* -! !

0! !

##( "# '(! ! !

! ! " " ( 0 ! *! ! " !" !

-! # (" ! "

#!'(* *" (

!" 94 !

2 2! "* 2 ! " ! '@ # $ # '#

'# " !

# ! ( ! ! (

! # ! ! * ! 9 #

##( "# ! '(###

! ## -! "" '(! ' '# % D5 7 2 #( > " ! ! ! '*4 !

6 !

' #( & '( ! # -! ! "!#-! "" #'

! " #

% &

$ &

! " )