Genpact India Pvt. Ltd. v. Union Of India And Others
!" #$%& ' '
() $*!$%$+%, - %)&
'
'
& .
/'0 0 0 .
/'0 1
!
"
!
#
$ !
% #& !
'& &( !
)* +++++ 0 0'
, - )., -/
*
)
012212 .!3 4/ ($ !
*&& * .! / )& " (
($
5 &
$ 6 2.7/ ! . 8! 8/ 9
$53 6 & 2.:/ ! ($; ) &
< 3*
.
*/ &= )<
"
$& ) 3
/2
2
) "
>$ !
)
$ , - &
"
!
( ($
.
/ ) ? & & )
) (== ) )?
< )(= ) ) )
&) ) & ( .
/ % )
) & ) "
8 .
/
( ) .
/% $
)
) & ) &)&
$ ) (
= )
$ &)&
$
(
5" 6
($
&
& $ ) && ?
= ) "
"=3 & $01 & $
(* ) !)& 11217. !/"
. / $
& ! (
($
( @
))
($ &, -
)& 9
& ) ?"=
$ 7
7
*$ ! ( "
3 !3 )"
@ &# $21A 214
"
>$
41214 & )
<
*& ) 2A 2: 2A 2A:? <
"
$& )
3.
/ = ) &"
: ! "
0B *
! 21A 4C * 21A % $*&& % D
* )&
- - ) B1721C.!3 7/ & 2: 7B : :20? " ($& ) ($
9
$53 6 & " "
$; 3 C :0 :0?
*
)
) (
( ))) ($ ; & 71:21C( # *&& *
.! / "
( = ) *
, * &
3 41A21C " " 8 &
$ 8
9
$3 - & 3 )
& ""
"
1B221C &"
*&& * )& 3 ) " 1A.2/ * ! "
B
) 71C21C "
) ) B1721C ($
)
($
&
$ 9
$ 3 & 2.:/ ! !
) $
"
) ( # *&& .! / )& & & 71C21C
) )
B1721C ) &
& ) 2: 7B : :20?
"
41A21C" "(9 $"
" & ) = "
"
($ . /
"
)$ &
$ 2A102121.!3
C/" ($ # *&& * .! /)&
) & 2: 7B : :20?" $
" ="
($
5 &
$ 6 2.7/ ! 9
$53 6 & 2.:/ !
2A102121($
)*E F17122121( * "
"
2C1212 .!3 0/
2A102121"
& & (=
$
012212.!3 4/
0 ( ($ !
! $
"
)
($
"
)
($ & ) ) B1721C
$
& ($
"
)$ 5 &
$ 6 "9
$53 6 2.:/ ! *9 $ & ) 2: 7B : :20? $
"; @ & 3 42 0 12?" "(; &
($
"
( & 9 "
)&!
214 &( 214 - (214 21C(;
1C22121 1212212.!3 7 B/ $ &$(
) ( (=
(
) 012212 !3 4!
" & & ) ) (9 &"
.00
($
&) 012212.!3 4/ ($ !
! $ $($ ) ( ($ &
($ * "
) *E F1712 2121
2C1212.!3 0/ & &
: (& $* 7B * 1 ! >" !
! $ =& $"3 )& " &( ) " & ( "@
$ ($
& &
$6 $") !
&
$6 2.7/ ! "
5 " 6 5 &
$6
& $3 &
5 &
$6 F
(
& "
) "$7 $ "
5) 6 "
& )
) 5 " 6
)$ $ ( " &
(
)
= & )
3 $ ! & *
) 5
6( $ 8) )& ( "
8 &
&
(9 ) (=@
) $ ( " &(
$
) 5 "
A 6 &( ($ & !
( )& ($
( 5)65
6 ( ) 5 &
$6 (
8 ) " & " 5 &
$6 & &&
" (&
$
&)
!* 7 7B B B2 02 0B A A AB 1 :
5 &
$6( "
) )$ $ $
)
&
$6 !
! $ ) $ G !
! $ $ = "
) 5( 5 9
5 &
$6 ) &5( 6
&) &
) ) &
$ & ) )$( "
" $ 3 & !
) (&
)
$ 7 &) 012212
) $ & $
141C2121 *E F17122121
$
) &)
4
&"
)4 !
! $ $(
( ($ ( C &
(
&)
) & & A ( $ "
) ) ( $
) &)
) (
) " )$( "
) !
! $
)
!"#$%$
!"#$%$
& ' ()* +,
-.!.
) (& )
5 &
$6 ) & &
) &
)
( $
5 &
$6 ) & )
)
$
, - ($
(
(53 6 "
3) & &" ) ( ($ 3
(
C - - ) 201214.!3 2/" ($
" ( $)
"
, - & ($
5& 6 5 &
$ 6! 9 (&
5 &
$ 6 3) & ) &( )(
$ &
( ) $) $ ) $
"
( =($
)
&* $"
$ 3
)"
E&$ = )
2A1212
211C212 ($ *&& . / &
$ @ % & * ,
3 * & F"% ) &
"
( " ( ))& 5 &
$ 6 -2A1212 & " 211C212"
( =
"
) $ "
0
) ; ) &) 012212.!3 4/; ) &
($ ) & & " & (&
1
! (
$ " ) @ )$ & 5& 6 ( )
($ & )$&
$
. & /( )
($
) ( ) $
(
) ( & & & )
! &
*/ !!011$!2
!
"
$
% & ' (
$
(
) * +
) ) $
# (
) *
& (
, )
* *
(
# ) * -
) #
#
% '
$
#
.#
#
) * + )
/
(
)
,
/
#
) * -
0 !$ 1!!#2
!
#
)#
!
1 (
!
2 (
(
#
) '
43
) - + )
0
3 25 #
)
,
(
!
2
(
!
2
#
#
'
#
(
) -
0
3 "4 )"!2 !
#
) #
#
#
)
)
0 1!
5 !
#
) #
(
/ 7 ,
8
) 6 * )
0 ! 2 5 #
)
,
9
8
(
) 6 - )
:
(& & & ($
"
(
)(
$ ) $&
2 ( ) & )$ &) ) "
& ) &)&
& "= & )
& @ * 72 ! (
)
&" "
"
./"
(
$&) )
)
$ & ! ) )& " $ $ = "
) =($ $
$ $&)& $( )
(
( ( &"$ * 7B ! ( "($ (
)
"
&
$ ( &$ ?
) &
( " )
(
5 " 6 ) !3 2B ) &
&) & " $
<
$ & ) ) ? - ) (&
& $
)
( & 5 &
$6
7
) (
"
) &
; $ & ) 3
& $D& $
? " $ ( "
) (9 $ (& 3& $& $ $ ) $ - ( (& (& & "
&) (
& E )
)
&$
"
"
( 3 5 &
$6
! 9 $ , - ($
!.!3 /(
5 &
$ 6H @ ;
"
($ $
0 03024 / 2
'
8
+ 6 ''''''''''''''''''''
< = '
:
0
0
B
0
#
#
#
' 0>
#
$
# , ?0
#
5'+ @0 ),2 $!011$4!"!/.$ !011$$1!0!
+ #
'
* +*
"
#
*
A
8
#
#
"
#
0
"
'
8
0?
#
8
-
#
'
#
#
,
#
6
#
' #
#
:
<7
*
- 6
'
'
B7
*
- 6
/
C
,
# /
C
#
/ C
#
@
DD
, ,
0
0
' #
51$ DDE
'
DD
=:
'
A
0
=, : #
-6) $
# , )+F*- +F*-0
= : #
-6 $
# , )+F*- +F*-0
= , : DD
0
,
#
0
,
$
# ,
# # ( #
"
G
F
+H
,
# ;
++
# #
4
# ;
+
#
51$ DDE
#
'
DD
'
0
#
'
0
'
0
'
0
,
'
0
'
0 '
#
'
C +*
# ' '
#
#
# ;
)56*789 : !011$4 =G
:
DD
'
0
>
? / 5 I #
/ 5I
/;
# 6 +B ( /
')
'
# ,G
'
> *)
,G
'
'
9
C
, # / 6- ( /
')
;
"
,G
#
21
/ 6H ( /
')
'
E
5' % )+FFF - +FFF
'
- #
( ;
111
, G
'
' 0
' '
' ?
658* (773)83)5 65)*;6*+ / 2
)
'
8
+ -''''''''''''''''
6 = :
,
#
0
/5("&6- 0 +)
'
'
2 ,
'
#
"
# < -F
> ?
) C & "
%
E "
C & !
#
)+F-B -< +F-B( 5
66
'
,
' >
? 8
# */;
# +H
'
'
"
'
DD G
'0
'
'
'
'
#
22
(
"
'
'
;
'
"
'
# ,
'
'
: .B/ .B/333333333333333333 2.:/ ! $ "
" (
9
53 6!
;
) 7.2/ 7.4/ &
& ) $ "
$ 5 $6 3
@5 &
$6 $
:././
3 & 5< $6 :.2/
3&$(
&= )<
0B *
! ( & & ) ($ 3$ & $ )
) (
$ ( &
)
&
! 3$)) 3 "
$&
) ( &
< 3
,$ "$ ) &) 012212 .!3 4/
) (
27 ( ) @
) )
) $ ( " & "
)
) 5
:
(
) 5 " 6 (( (& )
5
:
) & 9 $
( &
( 3) & E3& !.!3 /
" " & = ")
)
&) 012212.!3 4/ :
&) ! 1A1217.!3 / ( "
)
(5 &
$6 3 9
" -!)"!)0% ## %/ (1$ (1
56*) 7J5$5)/
#
= (
: # < (
:
'
(
7J5$5)/!
#
)
' # ;
2B
)
0 7J5$5)/ !
#
(
7J5$5)/!
#
#
;
;
)
0 7J5$5)/ #
# #
#
3
# (
,
=(
/ 7 ,:
(
# = (
)
:
7J5$5)/ #
,
(
/ 7 ,
'
(
/ 7 ,
!
#
)
7J5$5)/ #
(
'
'
(
!
#
)
="
!
#
)
: #
20
3 (
(
)
&"7 J5$5E"$5
#
, !
*65, (=)7>(*78)83)5 65)
)
#
, -##8/ 5!#60! $!.1!
(
/
!
#
"
!
#
)
'
' (
/
' (
0 #
(
'
0
#
0
#
, (0 1!"!
#
# (
= )$
# :
(
)$
#
!
#
.
!
#
2: )
(
(
8
#!
#
"
!
#
)
'
!
#
!
#
)
) #/
)$
#
(
!
#
# (
)
# #
/
(
!
#
) $
#
# ,
,
3
/
* * '''' '''' ''''
* - 60!"# 6$$
#
(
8
(
#(
)
&
!
#
#
(
/
# !
#
$?
)783*
765))8( ?
!$3
)
!
#
#
!
(
!
2 (
(
!
2
2A
!
!
#
'
)
3
?
3
& ) ++ (
!
#
,
(
!
2 (
(
!
2
#
# '
# (
8
9 2/;
)!
#
!
(
!
2
,
)
$ )"!
(
)
(
/ 7 ,
)
/ "
!
"
/
( 2
(
/ 7 , !
#
#
G !
#
/;
)
!
5!
#
#
24 3!! "4)"!
!
#
#
#
# 5 #
#
' (
/ 7 ,
, 1!
5 #
#
(
(
/ 7 ,
8
?
!
5 #
,
9
8
(
7 #
*65+ )5 655 5) + ($
# (
/ 7 ,
!
#
=/
9 # : E ;
(
/ 7 , 2 #
%
!
#
B *''''''''''''''''
+ ?
-!0 -#*$!
!
#
/
9 # # (
/ 7 , C 3
8
2C !
#
#
#
$@! 4*!
)"6.#!
/
# !
#
=!
#
/
E
: # !
#
8 '
#
#
# (
/
C/2
(
/ 7 ,(
)
# ;
.
3 # /
(
C / 2
) *
3
;
.
= ( :
) 3
!
#);
/ $
#
= /
:
71 *659 *5 -8*78 9 *60! !
#
)
(
/ 7 ,
(
/ 7 ,
(
/ 7 , *H
# !
#
+H
(
/ 7 ,
!
(
) & &
)) ($ &, - & )$ &
"
(
(
= & " "
(=
5 " 6* 7
"
( ( ( )" &
& ) "
3 ) & "&
($
* 77
"
( ( ) "
&* 7B
"
( ( "
)
&
"
((
)
) !
"
$
"
$ & ) "
&?
7 " "
( (
$
)"
8 & * B
& 3 $& * B2
"($
"
( ( & )
$ & ) & * 02(
)
$ * 07
"
* & & E= &* 0B(
)
(= "
"
"9 ($ * A
& * & & E= "
( & &
* 1 ! $ " & "
"
* :
&$ (
) ! * & & E= &$ &
! ( )& ( "
&&$(&& < ( "
/5
# !"
#
#
#
#
%/) '
!"
!
'
#
!"
%/)
72 #!
#
#
#
'
:
! 11217.!3 / ( "
$ ( )
($ $ " "
$
" & !
5 &
$6 2.7/
!
"
)
& ( 9
$5 &
$6I @ ( " & ( )$ & ( )&
($7 $ &
$& & ( ($ 5 &
$6 &
( " "
. 7 $/ ( $ . ) / " & 3 $3 $"
& 5 " 6 !( !
( $&
)5 &
$6
"
&(
5 &
$6 2.7/ ! (
&
" "="
( $& (
"9 )?
7 $
77 & "
$( ($
"
( )
201214 .!3 2/ ($ ! *&& % D )& ) ) 2: 7B 47 C24? !
#21: # $ &(21: &= )
$ !
)
( &
$6
) ($ &
" ## # #
,
,
3 !"
3#
)
%
/
/
3%/)3
( #
!"
#
3
8
(
.
, #
, #
/
# (
3
3
3
3
$ ! !
# /
$
H+
3!"!/$
3
3
3 ,
#
7B #
3
3
#
:
"
# #
#
#
8 3
3
##
#
# 0 &
#
#
# #
#
#
'
# '
#
#
!"
#
)
#
%/) ' # 3
5#
70 #
#
:
) (& (
&) & & " = ) 201214.!3 2/ ( ( ( ) " " 11A21A "
) & E " ("
$&
) & &5 &
$ 6"
2./
212 212 5 &
$ 6" & (=?) $ ($" &
")
.
8& 8 / $) ( " "& ( "
& !
5 &
$6 3) & ) &"
"
& &
D 211C212 ($ &
$@ % & *
,
3 * &.
$E )/ &
$6 ( 2 22 5 &
$6"(" & 3) & &= )
7: 5 &
$6( 2./
212 2.7/ ! $
(
$) 5 &
$6
) & 3 ) & 3
$
5 &
$6 " E &) 012212 .!3 4/ ( &
)
)
"
( ) (& )
5 &
$6 ) & $ (
)
/ " ($ !
! $ &) "
"
&5 &
$6 ( ( ) & ) & ( ( 5E #
:
:
/
/
/
#
#
/ /
'
!
) $
)
"
7A ) )
"
) &( &
$6 3) &
) & ( )) !217 .!3 /" & =
"
-A! .!)!#) >#.# !0!6!!* '' )669' ) ((
; $ & 3
) $ "(
" :
,
;
'
)
#
8
+B
"
; $ # ,
#
D
D , 8
#
(
'
#
, 7
#
8
# ;
74
# .!)!# '
/ +++ ') +F<+:
>.).8# !
B 9 , )66 >8( &* " " (9 & $ & $" 9 ;
;
)
$(& =
"
)21 ; )& "
( "20. The decisions cited have uniformly held that res judicata does not apply in matters pertaining to tax for different assessment years because res judicata applies to debar Courts from entertaining issues on the same cause of action whereas the cause of action for each assessment year is distinct. The Courts will generally adopt an earlier pronouncement of the law or a conclusion of fact unless there is a new ground urged or a material change in the factual position. The reason why Courts have held parties to the opinion expressed in a decision in one assessment year to the same opinion in a subsequent year is not because of any principle of res judicata but because of the theory of precedent or the precedential value of the earlier pronouncement.
Where facts and law in a subsequent assessment year are the same, no authority whether quasi-judicial or judicial can generally be permitted to take a different view. This mandate is subject only to the usual gateways of distinguishing the earlier decision or where the earlier decision is per incuriam.
7C the view expressed and refer the matter to a bench of superior strength or in some cases to a bench of superior jurisdiction. $) $ & "
" & =(
" = ) 201214 .!3 2/
)
( 5 &
$6
!
) & @ & "
) ($ &
( ) "
("
$( ( $
&) (
* 2: !
"
"
) & + < $!.1 !& )
; #
!
#
'
'
#
! #
: % ) )&
)* "
)& ( "
8 & &
(9 () (=
"
( ) =($
B1 & " & (
) *E F17122121 (
($
4 " & !3 (
" =
#
,
,
,
3 !"
3 #
#
*.#C0!.141$ .!!# 1!!!A!1/ !0%. $"%$! $4.. 1!. $ $$.0#.
$0!# $/ ! "0!
C " & " $
"
) 5
=
:
:
))
()
=($ &
)
)& $"
( ) )& !
.!3 /
&
$
B
( ) $& &
)& " )
($ & "& ( )
$($
F ) (() "
"
&
) "
) )5 &
$6( " & !
&
) " (( ($ ! ( )?)& &
& ) && ?) &
& ($
)& ( )D 211C212 70
( ) 5 &
$6 " " & & ) .!3 2B/
"
( " " )
! & $
$ $ ) &) ) (; & $ = ( " & "
$ $ "
($
& $ E " & = ; $ &)
) " &) "
$ && ( "! ) &$(&
B2 ; )& !3* -. )#.($$ . !
*.6.5$6!!8/3$. .! '+& )66 ?" (
" $ $&= ( )
$& (; ) ($ & ( & ($
"
" ( " " "
( () )&$ ($ & & *
) )
($
) () @ ( "
"
&) 012212.!3 4/
)
(5 &
$6 2.7/ !
& 9 9 $ ) B1721C .!3 7/ ) ) 2: 7B : :20?
(
) (9 "
E
"
& 0 0
1
'
'
!./ E = )? G?F E ( G?F