← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/3931/2023allowed

Roshan Lal v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2026-05-21Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil6 pages

 

       

     

    

   

 !"#$%&#'#&(# )$ * + ,

 !"#$%-&)$)$.# )$  / ,

 !"#$%-0)1 # )$  / , + 2#%2#&)-#&1%3(#)&4005 !"#$%

00 / #0163$-&)$)$.#"#$%)44005 !"#$%1$ &#1')$'7341$6

   8  9:;

< ;< ;;

: ****

   

    

" 

#  <1$ ##- ) !307



&16#& $%&

(  ) *

 + 

,,-  ) .     "/

0 "        ,1 ,2,% $ %,&   /      4/ (

4 " 

)   %- ,2,% $ %5& /  

    

  4 ! 



/

%- ,2,%/

  $,&

( # 4 

)

+,, 2, %617   

 444 4

/

 4   '

        28 ,2%,   4

52 .    ,2%1 

 "4 !

  

    94

    

- 2 -

/

     ,7 ,2%1$ 5& *(



 /

* 4   

4  "  /

+ 4 .         3     4*"   "*

4

 4 $5&

" 

  *

   "   *         

   ,7 ,2,2 $ :&    /  *   !

 4 )44

4

" %- ,2,%/    " 

 /     4      !  



)/ *   9  /





  

"   ;

 2% ,2,%$ -&

1 ) 

$

 &

,2%-      

      

" /

"     %, ,2,%$ 6&

44" *

"

$:&

""

 * / *



$7&

 

    ( "4 / %1 2:

,2,- $-&

         *

4

  3  4  "" 4,2%1 .   < /

* 

 !

) %- ,2,%4  !  

 /

    

  ;

- 3 -



1 ,2%-

* *



  2%

   4   *

 

  

( 

4



" 4 " 

$8&

*  / 

 

" 4 4   4  4 



444 "/

4(  

" ""4 ./

 *

4        

 =  -25:;,#;.;8%95,:61    %1;%%;8%   



 

  4 

  *  /    *

   

1

(*) 

$

  & 

 %67,   4*

   4     " "# 4  4 

 





*  +  +

"   /        

"  0  4       

       %, ,2,% $ ;6&   "      

  %, ,2,% /

"!/"4   $ ;%2& $1&

=/"           4   

 





)



 %- ,2,% /  

  9       / 

 

  "(  4  "     >

<      

 1 

>

<

"



 

/

   4

" )/  

- 4 -    4  / 

    



 /    *

$6&

 !

)   4 *

 4

"       3

  

 

  " 

     

   ) 9  "*  

      



* )44

4 

4* + 



 . 

4 

1 ;

 *



 2% ,2,%/  4

"  !

) /      %-   "  *  / 

/  

* )44



   4*

 . 

       /  4  

      

<  "

 / "     *     



 /    *

 

 /

 

  / 

     

" / 

   

4 * 9 

  4 



*

4  /"    *   

 "    !

)     





 +

    " / 

*

" $%2&

.            

 "

4 "        %, ,2,%     /

4   *

- 5 - 4  4  . 

 

   

    *        

  

    

"   #  4 

  3      

4 / 

 



4 /  /

 4   '   4

   

  

   " 4  

 *

" 4 4  

    . 

    4 

 *  $%%&

  *    52 ,2,%( 4/4 

     



./



/ 4 * *

"

 *

)   

" 4/

 

   4 

$%,&

 4 "         4 *    /

/  



 



    "/

 "4

    4     3   /

 *  *

  



" "

( 

)$.0'3)$ $%5&

"

/ 

/ 4 "

"9 $  %, %5 

 &/ * /    4      !  

    *   '    

  "   4  

- 6 -  ! 



/

%- ,2,% "/

 *  

"  ;3   9   *   

 ?-@ $%:&

 

  *

 /      4 



  $%7&

  

/    4 $%-&

" $&  

    / ,   <1$ ##- ) !30

 !#

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

:

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

:

Yes/No