Jasbir Singh Sandhu v. Ut Of Chandigarh
!!" # !! $ % &" !
!"#$% & '()*% ('*!% +',)
!'
()"
* #"+! ,!
( !-* #"+! ( .
* #"+! /"!
& !!" ( 0! &!*
1
1+ " + !"* * ()0! 2* #"+! /"
(-- +. & !!" /1 -
0 11 /+!1+ "345 !
6783999 ! /""// + & 1 +!"674*:;4*6;6*3;7< +!"6*: ="/>&1"# !+ +!*3975 &" + !"+ * /*!
!"2 >&1"
&0"/ +!"6:* !"
!3;?3;67&2"6783999 + @ - !" !
+"2&1! "
2 !" 2- # +1 &0 # !!"!+2 "
!+""! !!"" <78<<=749,&0 /"1!
A &"1+ !
> *, "/+ !1 , +"#+!
# @
2 ! !
;;3;77; &*!
++ * ", # * +& , +1 "+12 // +"
!
&"1+ "1-"=33;73: # !!" +"/ "1!! 2 !"/ & , +"
"3633;73:* , +1" !!!
!+ "/ 2@! @,* 21!!, "+12 !" /"/.B $.
1!"22 " "+ %*
2 ! & !!" ! + +!"66* * , "& 23*77*777?</"+ 1! !"/!
2" -*
;=*777?< ,!
37*777?< ,!
> - & + +""! A + 1!/! !
1!* /1 !"
0!, & !!" +2 !"2 ! 2@! @, &"1+ 1" +"
!! 2 !"/"!
,! , " !!
! & !!" ,!
& ! /" "21! +!"6:!
- 3999 & !!" , "# && !"
& & !!" , !
!
+ "933;73:!
/! + 11 & !
! 2 /+!1 B +"
1/"& !!" "
! 11/"!
& !!" * *&1 !
!!
& !!" #"1# /1 + /! 1& "/3=- "/!
+ ! &"1+ /+!
# + ! 2 - !! +"/ "1 !! 2 ! "/ +"<++
& +"
+!"38: , ,&"1+ + !"
-!! 2 !"/ > "!
,! , +"
/! 1& "/3=- "/!
+ ! 2 !* 2!!
!!
& !!" "1 2"/4;- // /"2 2 "/12 ! +1
&1 ) 1 $""-! - % !! ! !2 !/"2 "!+"!"&!1* , 1 , 11 *
B !! +"
1
!"1 "/!
& !!" "21!!
!!""0&1+ !
&0"/ +!"6:*
+2 !"!
"!+ "/!
&"1+ !
- ;73:, ++ & , !
! "!
& !!
"1 "/!
& !!" !! 2 !!"!
&"1+ 1" !! 2 !
+!"38: +"
+1(!! !1* &"1+ 1"!0 !
&&"!"/& !!" # !1, + ", # 1#!!" 0! /"2!" 1"#11 ,!
&"1+ 10,!
! "!1# !"& ! //+ ! # + !!
! !"
20 "
!++ ! "2!
+"
!-*, + & 1+2 + !"!
/ !- + !-"/!
& "&1 "/!
+"
!- &"!
!!"& + + !- 12 !"/ & !!" * 2!!
! 2 +1+ +0 & +"
+!
!
& 2 !!
! "/ !
" &"! !
64;73= !! !
!
2"
1! "/! !2 !"/!
12 !,!
, + & !!" //
#11 ! *
B +"
1/"& !!" "
1-20 "
! + !
! # + ! !
& !!" 21
//+ !!"&"# !
+ ! 2 2!!
!!
+"/ "1 !! 2 ! 2 - & 1 - !+!
- 2 /+!!" 0 &!2 !!!
! "/ + 1&&1+!"*!
+"
!"! C !""!"!
2 !"/!
+ &"!# #1 "/!
2! 1" +" 11!
/+! !" 1""0 !" && +!
!1+"
!!&&"&! ! & !!" !
!
+ /"+ !"/"21!
, + +!"/! "2 &" + !" +-+"
"!1- "
2/"& "
"/"
!3=- /! !
+ !!!
! *!
" "!"++ &!!
+"! !" -1 +"
1/"& !!" !"
+ &" + !"# " ! 2!!
!
! /! /2 "/ !
+ !
&" + !"&"
+! # + 1 "/& !!" !!
! ,11 2& !
&"+ "/!
+ &" !
!!"!
&" + !" ,! 011!
"# /+!!"++"
!*!
& !!" +"! 11", 1!!
! "/!
"!
&1 "/& !!" !
! 4;- "1
& " // /"2 ! +"+ & !!" !! ! !2 !/"2& 2 !!
! "/!
" *
/! !1 >2!"*!
"+!" # "& ! C +""-! --&/!/"+""-! - ! !2 !
#11 * !
& !!" !!
+1!! !"*!
" "/" 1 "2 +1"
# ,"/2-"# + "*& !!" +!":69 /1 & !!" 0 11 1"!
& !!" "35959"/;73= 0! 21 +1 /(-- +.0 1 1-34*;73=