High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/1126/2003disposed of

Harkirat Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab

2024-01-23Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary6 pages

""#!

$%&'('"")*'(+'),,-!./012!

3456!78!96:;<;7=!>!)-?,"?),)#!

@4AB;A45!(;=CD!4=9!75D6A<!

?????&EE6FF4=5<!

G6A<H<!

(5456!78!IH=J4K!

?????!%6<E7=96=5!

$%%'),L"'),,-!

MHAN665!(;=CD!

?????I65;5;7=6A!

G6A<H<!

(5456!78!IH=J4K!4=9!75D6A<!

?????!%6<E7=96=5<!

O PQ

IA6<6=5>!

1A?!@(!%4=9D4R4S!&9T7:456!

87A!5D6!4EE6FF4=5<!;=!$%&'('"")*'(+'),,-!

87A!A6<E7=96=5<!U7?)!57!*!;=!$%%'),L"'),,-?!

1A?!&A;D4=5!V4;=S!&9T7:456S!

87A!5D6!E65;5;7=6A!;=!$%%'),L"'),,-!

87A!5D6!:7NEF4;=4=5!;=!$%&'('"")*'(+'),,-!

1A?!14=;E4F!(;=CD!&5R4FS!3&MS!IH=J4K?!

W Q "?!

XD;<!!

:7NN7=!!

7A96A!!

<D4FF!!

9;<E7<6!!

78!!

5D6!!

4K7T6'N6=5;7=69!!

:A;N;=4F!

4EE64F!4=9!A6T;<;7=!4<!5D6<6!D4T6!4A;<6=!7H5!78!5D6!<4N6!JH9CN6=5Y7A96A?! )?!

$%&'('"")*'(+'),,-!!

D4<!!

K66=!!

8;F69!!

KZ!!

5D6!!

4::H<69'4EE6FF4=5<S!

;NEHC=;=C!!

5D6!!

JH9CN6=5Y7A96A!!

94569!!

-,?,[?),,-S!!

E4<<69!!

KZ!!

5D6!!

&99;5;7=4F!

(6<<;7=<!VH9C6S!(4=CAHAS!RD6A6KZ!5D6Z!R6A6!:7=T;:569!4=9!<6=56=:69!4<!H=96A>! /886=:6!HY<! !

\NEA;<7=N6=5!

];=6!

3684HF5!<6=56=:6!

"#^!\I$!

%\!87A!7=6!Z64A!

!"# $%&!'

!')* + ,"-' ./0!%&1 #)"-23

!"-!%%$%&!'

'(2

!,),% + ,"-' 4&!5)!&"6),7- ./0

!"-!%%$%&!'

'(2

!,),% + ,"-' 4&!8-&,16),7- ./

! ,%$%&! 9 9 4&!5)!&"6),7-:;&'#),1%!6),7-:< -),1%! &=6),7-:;&,&56),7-&,1 ;&'#&,"6),7- ./!%&1 #)"-23

! ,%$%&! 9 9 ;&,&56),7-&,1;&'#),1%!6),7- ./.

!,),%+ ,"-' 9 9 4&!5)!&"6),7-:< -),1%! &=6),7-:4&!8-&,16),7-&,1;&'#&,"6),7- ./.!%&1 #)"-23

!,),%+ ,"-' 9 9 >=="-%'%,"%,8%'#%!% !1%!%1" !?,8 ,8?!!%,"=$( .( ,

9/329/.: )=%1 @$ "-% 8 +A=&),&,"9A%")") ,%!: "-% 8-&==%,7% -&' @%%, =&)1 " "-% & !%'&)1 B?17+%," !%7&!1),7 1)'8-&!7% "-% &88?'%19!%'A ,1%,"'?,1%!6%8") ,.C

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

)I)= 4 'A)"&=: 6&,7!?!( >, J 8&+% " @% !%7)'"%!%1 &7&),'" "-% &88?'%1( >"%! ),I%'")7&") ,: 8-&==&, #&' A!%'%,"%1( H, ),1),7 & A!)+& &8)% 8&'%:

#$% &'() &'*) +,-) +.+) +.') +./ ! '0, 123 56 ! $ ## 6)#%4$# 789 !

! %# $9#7 !9$6 !#$9: 0: ; 8%

#$% $ %!

#% <$ %6 #

$9# %5 #

=6$ 6 7 &, 2> : ? 9% %5 # $

@$!

)

## # %5 #

!A88 99 # %!

#$% +&+ %5 3:2:3: ; 7 $ 99 # $ $6$ #$ $6 #

## 88 $ # # 6 $ # 8%

#$%

4$9 !$ 59

$689$#$% <7 # 8%9$ : 1 # $ ) # 7

=6$ + B> : /: ; #$9 3%# 5#

@9#$ #

@$!

<7 # 8%

#$% )% @$# ! !

# !#

!A88 99 # %#$ !<%@ : -:

$ @ 88 99 # @ 8 # 8

# 88 9) 4$9 # %689$ #)# @$ $% 8 #$#$% : (: ; 88 9 D3ECA"A&&./A"FA.,,+G <

<# H 88 99 # I%:&AJK$# "$ ! 88 99 # I%:+AL 4$ !

"$ @$!

!# ! .&:,+:.,.+ !,.:&.:.,&0)

#$@ 97: *: M %

9 5% # 88 99 # I% : .) ' #% $ 3ECA"A&&./A"FA.,,+) # # %#

<6$# ##

8 # 99

#% # N!

# %5 % @$#$% ! 87 5% !$ #

# 4!

$! 88 99 # #% # $%! 9 !7 % $# < $ && !7 % % # %5 # 5# ## # 7 %# $ @%9@ $ 7 %#

@ 6$

# %

$% %5 <$9O

%9 < ! 4$ %5 # $

#$@ 56$9$

O @ <

5$ # % 7 %5 8%## #$9 5% # 9 # .0 ! 88 99 # A P%$ !

! L K @ $9! %5 6$

) 4 88 99 # A JK$# "$ ! L 4 # "$ <%#<%#(,7 !-,7 7

#$@ 97: &,: M %

9 5% # #$#$% $ 3EEA.,*&A.,,+ % # ## # #$9 3%#

$ !$ $ #

!A88 99 # 5% # %55

! "#$ %&' () * + , (-- . / 0*(1 * ) 23( -!

( ,*4 *(2 ( !/ 55/ 6 * !* *21 72

!(7 '89:

:55;<:

=:;##" (+4 ( *2 *

27 '! 2- 2)) 2 , * . 7 +3 * ) !( !1 *2(

,*73

2 ( * 2))772(1 * -!

1 ) 23( -!

* (4 ((27 !- * ) ( 2))27/ >1 *!?. 1 2-- 4( * -2 !- * !: .!7.4 !- * 2))772( 23 !*

2( 2( ?77 2( 4 (( , *

! (( !!-+2 7, 2!*42() * (!3 - 2(/ 5;/ >2 * 72

!(7 ! * ( 2 ) ( *

? * * 2+72(( (2 / 5"/ @. 731 &A:; B 4

,*1 ?*! ?2( * C :3 ? ((1 * ( )!( ! () - 2773 24 * 2))772( *2. ,

2( C ( * 4 2( ?77 2( !* (/ > ( ( 4!3 (!!

!+!

2 +3 &A:< B 27

,*/ 0* DE8( !- * C ? ) !. +3 &A5:F G2 24C

,*1 ?*! !) *2 C (

2( B 4

,* ! ! . 27 )2 !- * +!3 2 *( , .!( 2 / H! C 3 ?2( -! + 2, !( 7 -1 *(1

! "#$ %&' !( ! 0*(1 * ( ! ( !) -!

- * - ,(

* ? * 2 *

! 7( !

. 2 +3 *

27 '! 9( ( *1 *

!!-*2))772( ()*7/ 5I/ %(!-2 2( * ) 23 -!

, * ( !- * ) ! ( * ) ! 23 ,! (

! 1 ?!7 + ?!

*?* 7 42J 2

- * C,4 KLMNOP QOMROS TMU VOVLW ;#5;

'' 6E '27 XI##1 ?* J) , . ? *2 ;Y 7!, 32 ( *2 ( 72)( - !4 * 2 !- * 1 . 4 (( * ) . 7, !- )!(:

! +2 71 * ( !- 4) (!4

! ";< %&' !- < 32 ( ?2(

* * ) ! 23 ,! // 5I 23( ) :

27 2 2+! 2 4!* 2 5# 23( )!(:

27/

!"# $%& '

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

"V "('

$%& '

' () W 5 2A5H5BL TKK6BL X?R/.Y ?E -.--, C6D5C6C ? /;R./R-.--, N=6A65 <=6 BKK6LLB<> =BC I5F6 LB<=5 OL?N> BC N6A6 <=@> D?F5D<6C @C6A 16D<5?> G-GZG-S, =?N6F6A 9?[OL6 <=6 1@KA6H6 2?@A< N=5L6 D?>5C6A5I <=6 EBD< <=B< /Y J6BA> =BC 6LBK>6C >5D6 <=6 CB<6 ?E 5D5C6< \ A6C@D6C <=65A >6<6D6 <? <=6 K6A5?C BLA6BCJ @C6AI?6 OJ <=6H 5R6R >5] N66P> ?@< ?E J6BAR ^@A<=6A, 5 _ `a

V $%& '

' () b&& , /;;: 122 c2A5d 0.G, <=6 BDD@>6C NB> D?F5D<6C @C6A 16D<5? G-S 72, 9?[OL6 <=6 1@KA6H6 2?@A< A6C@D6C <=6 >6<6D6 <? <=6 K6A5?C BLA6BCJ @C6AI?6 ?@< ?E G J6BA> ?E A5I?A?@> 5HKA5>?H6<, OJ ?O>6AF5I <=B< : J6BA> =BC KB>>6C BNBJ BC C@A5I <=5> K6A5?C, BLL <=6 N?@C> ?E <=6 KBA<56> =BF6 =6BL6C @K BC ? K@AK?>6 N?@LC O6 >6AF6C <? >6C5I <=6 BDD@>6C O6=5C OBA> R15H5LBALJ 5 +*"

% $%& '

' () W \2eTf1f//GYf1gf-..:, C6D5C6C ? .hR.0R-.-G, <=6 >6<6D6 BNBAC6C <? <=6 BDD@>6CfBKK6LLB<>, N=? N6A6 D?F5D<6C @C6A 16D<5?> G-GZGY, G-SZGY BC S.0 72 E?A e ?E - J6BA>, NB> A6C@D6C <? <=6 6]<6< ?E BLA6BCJ @C6AI?6, N=5L6 ?O>6AF5I <=B< <=6 BKK6LLB<> =BC BLA6BCJ >@EE6A6C >6<6D6 ?E / H?<=, /G CBJ> BC /S CBJ> A6>K6D<5F6LJ BC EBD6C <=6 BI?J ?E <A5BL E?A BLH?>< /h J6BA>R

! " #$%#%

%& %' !(

) *) *

% + " * " " %&

%(&# *,!

$'*

&"* $*,-

&* . /,-&

*!!0 ( &23

) ## !!&

)1 &2

,'' $ "

)

2&%- &0 %'

&* !%&24

,**

',!!0 ($" " %''

) $ *$ - 5#$%& &

5& " & ! $& &2 %'

%&4

) $

%* %5 *%&%- * * $*,-

&* 3

)

6%,$ '

% +

-#!

8), 3

(%,!"

) &"

%' 9,

% $ ",*

) $

& &*

) # $ %" !$ "0 ,&" $2%& +0

) -3 )%( 1 $3 : # &2

) '

& * ; <

)

) '%$

" -%"

) %$" $ %'

& &* " =>>?@>>=3

) #$ & ## !56AB5C5@5@>>=

#$ !0 !!%( "3 () $ 6AA5@>D5@>>=

) $ +0"

" D B*%#0%' )

%$" $+ #!* "%& ) '

! %'

) *%&& * "* @=>@>@E

FGHI

)%: JGHKL <) ) $ # :

&2M$ %& " N O MP% <) ) $$ #%$ +! NO MP%