Nimrata Shergill And ANR v. Shop Owners Welfare Association
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH CR-1072-2025 (O&M) Decided on : 22.04.2025 Nimrata Shergill and another ...... Petitioners
Versus
Shop Owners Welfare Association ...... Respondent CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKRAM AGGARWAL *** Present :
Mr. Rajesh Garg, Senior Advocate with Mr. Varinder Arora, Advocate for the petitioners.
Mr. Raghav Sharma, Advocate for the respondent.
*** VIKRAM AGGARWAL , J (ORAL)
!" "
#
$
()* + &
,- .
% " # '
'' /
0 (1 * +0,- #
2 "
3%( ))
45 *3
(45 #
5 6 3(
% ) 45 #
5 6 - "# 7 8 '
/3
0 9
'
5 # # #
("" ' 36 1 #
# # '
(*.05 -
" (
!" " ' # '
$
*. 05-
# # *.05-:
'"
# '
"
"
% $ 39 ;"
$
# '" 3 "
< 36 1
#
<
'" '
' $
()0
<
#
#
&$
' # "#
$
# 9 &$
9"' $'
!"#$ !%& ' ( " ) *.05%05 - '"
$
#
/ ' $
'
$
" &
$
&
# " '
" 9"' !"#$ !%& *- 9"'
)
' =
#
$
# 6
#" 9
# '
(> *+ ,-, " '( .. "/ /"" 0 , +1 . " 2 3 #
& , 41 2 1/
,+ "
,5 1
# #
?
# # '
"
#
" "#
$
% (* - &
()# #
9
( # #
"
#
' ' .
"
@ ' ( # 9
# A: (# '
1) (# #
AA 1 # A: 1 @
(1##
"
B ' &# ''
'
''
( )
< # & 2$ ()
& 2 $ " #" 0 ' () # 6 ) () ' # ()%
$
*9-
()* + (),-> *" 5 " " 1 / 2"""" 1/ 2 *" 1 " 5 " " 3" ,5 (*
- $
()
.
#C5 6,7 " 1 " ,8 /""
/ "" 2 "" / " 99& 2 :'6
:(2/1 " 1 " "" "" " .""% ."" 3 " , 7" ,8+"" "" 3
1/ / 2"# . ;. ." ." 1 " /1 3 . , (*
- $
.
' " # 9
),7 " .1 3 #
,8'
(& " ." / .3" 1 " .3
. " .2 3 "" 2. 1 23" .
" . 32 #
% 2 1 , '(& " ." /"" 2 .3"" 1 " .3
. " .2 3 "" 2. "/
1 23 " . " . 32 #
% 2 1 , '-(<3 . / . 99&&& 2 :'6 :(2"
1= '
( ""/
"
. 1/ 23
"
. . 1/ #
% , (*
-
"
#
'
.
"
#
(* - =
#
"
" 2
(*
- #
" . ?
# +
9
9 , ' 9 #
# $' %> % 3 , 2&
, @ "
9"' $ "
'
" "
"
'2
# $
D #
$' & " , ,1 3%2' ( 7 ? '0(7+- "
;
' #
#
'
" '
" 9 '
'
(*
- $
#
"
*
/AA0-#
'' '
# 7 #
. . . "< / - ')(
'
( :6 ?
, . # "
# # ?
, . C5 *@ " " 1 /1 ?
'( + 1 12 ".2 # = =" ""3 .3 "" /2 "" . # 11. # , '(+ A A 1 "" "2" "/ "" . 1 . 1 / 1 "" """ " 1 .= , '( 1 # 1 . " " 1 . " , ' (<" " 1 1 /12.
.. " . 1% , ( % 1 "1 "/ % .
/ . , (& 1%" "
"1# "1 1 4 1 .
# , (+ "1"" "
" 1
13 / "/, (+ 13 /
/ 3 / 2 "# 3 / 1 ,+"2 3 "" 3 1 , '(+ 21 "/ . .. 1% ,& " " 4 3. 1 # "1" " " 1. .1/ 1"", '(&" .
. "" 2 1
. "
/
. , '(& 11 . 3/3 2 " " 1/% . 3 , '(+ . 1/ "" 1 1 " . # 3 1# .
"" , '(+"11 / /" .
1. "1 ,5 (*
- $ 3# " 4 -'
)(
:
?
, $' # "# 9"' ?
" E 2# '
"
?
, . .'
# # '
$
# .
F G "
9 "" "
2
' # # # 92 '#
#
H " ?
" E 2 '
"
?
, . .'
" # 9
E 2?
" 9 # ?
, . C5 * , 3 1 1 1 ,+ .3 A A
A 4AA .A2 /1
/ 3 "" ,+23 A A1 3" " 233
" "" . 2 / 3" 1 , & 2 A "/ .. 3 3 1 "
3 1. "/ A . /AA A, ;3 2
. 1
3
2 1 # /,+""
/ 3 " 1/ /A A " . 2
/"
2 3 "" /, + 3 % 1 3 / "" ,'? . " , , #B ,2& 0)" --0C ,,</ 2& " 6-C
,> D2
'(
'
( 66?
( " E . '
,,E,(0
1 $ # , "
" 12& " 0 ,
,& # . , !2& 0)" - " 13 A. A A A 1 /A A . ,;3 2 / /14 . " 3
."A A,
,+"
A A 1. 1 " 1 # 21 / . .. 2 % 1 1 " "/ 23
1 2 1 " #% "
1,'> ? ,/2 '(
'
(-0 C <D <B
, ,F1 B ,2'(
'
(-- ,
, & . "" 3 / /""/1 1"" 3
.3 " 1 ,+ "3 " 41.
, A 3 . /" , "3. " 3
. " ,A+ /" /
" ""/1
1 . . ,+. A A3 A3 1
3A2
,& / 1 2 A A 1 3 " . ,
-,+ "1"/2 1 . " /2 ""
"#/24% . " ""
,& % 1/ " 3 1 . " 1/ "
1 , .; 1/G
3 7 . 2>,)2", :
?
A--,/ ,+ "
. "" .
/2'
( .
/ # 2 '(
. " 2 '-(" 3. " 3 1 . A, 3 / /2 2 " 1
" 3/ 1 4 4/ # 1/ . #/ 3/ 1 1/"/G 3 2 .. G ,
'?" !"/ , %&
,26')(
'
(--)?'6(
6 # . B , , .B ,2& -" 6- % E , 7 7 . 2 E. #2':(
)):
),& , ,! %2'(
(66-2 # / . ." "
. . 3 / 3 3 1/ , , / , ,,</%2
'(
'
(0-),5 (* .- $
!"<.'
!"#$
!%& ' ( "
) $'
4 = "
$
> *'
( " 1 4 " .
" .
" 1/ "/C '(+"" . 1 " 3 . . C '-( + " " . 3 #
% C ')(+" . " .
C '6(" .
,5 (*.- # '' #
. # # I I# '= " # #
" " #
' " '
9 " 6
9 " ' "
#
# ' #
"
#
" ' " # 9
"
# '
"
'
# " " "
"$
# # $'
""
3 "
@ 9 "
J
#
# ' "
#
'# " # "9
#
2 9 " #" " # '
$
"# 9
<#
# ' #
#
' B '
### "
# # #$
.
#
# '"
!" "
$
# Pending application(s), if any, stand(s) disposed of accordingly. (VIKRAM AGGARWAL) JUDGE 22.04.2025 mamta Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whether Reportable Yes/No