Sawinder Kaur v. Punjab School Education Board And Another

  
  



!

 " 
! 

#$#%&#'

()

* * %()(+),#'

()

* -* ./01)'#% 2/+%

****** #3131()#% &#%$+$ +)4/5 .,6((7 '+,/31() (/%'

/)'

/)(36#%

******

#$8()'#)3$
 

9 :  *

.

2

 


 
  






 




 
  

 !!!!!!

2

;

* 
 
 "

 
#$ #% &#%'

()*
+',
 
-

. &
-

 
- 

-
 



*

 
&/ %& &#%'

()*
+%#,
 
-

 
*
 "
   
 

-


 "


 *

0*
 


* 





 *


*
"



 


- 1
 
"

2* 
- &





+- 

*"* %334

51

 
"

6


"* 7

*"* &##8



*
 

 

9 * 
&#%4

6*- 






:

*
;*


< " 
 


+- 
"

 


*
< 
(


,

="

 -77 
 
:

* ;*


< " 

 
*
*

%$ #> &#%8






 
#$ %% &#%8

 
*- 
 

 



 "

0?


"


 
:

*
;*


< " 

  "*


*
< 



 
"

*- ;



 "
*

< 


)

&#8$%%%/
- "
 
  

 

 
-
 "
 
-@* 




"

&##'+&#%8

:







0?

:
1





  -77 
 


*

>%%>4#@+

 
- *- 





*






 
  


*

:

*
;*


< " 

:
" 


 





 



*


>%%>4#@+




*


*

<  
*"

 
 






- 

?

%&
  
*
 "







 "
  "



 


*+ A5 "




5   "

 




*+

.

.



@  
 " .  5 " %

:

*
;*




  %&48$/>
B
'

++++ &


;

*


  %&48$/

> ++++

*-1 
51 %&4$/>

'

5 " 

* 
"   =

%&48$/

> ++++ $


 
"


  %&48$/

> ++++ /

9"
;*

   %&48$

/ ++++ >

6 
C 
  %&48$

/ ++++ '

"
6 %&48$

/ ++++

< -
"
   %&48$/

> ++++ %#

*- 
5   %&48$

/ ++++
4



*


 *

  #& #4 &#%>
"
2*


=
"

 



2* 

 

 

:

 -


-
 



:
 
 

 
 "


 

*+ A

*

>%%>4#
 

 - 1
*



;

*
 *"


*-  
"



:

*
;*

(


*,

 
(*
*,



 







* 

"




- 

   


"

 -





: *



 

-

 

*


< D
< 1
* *

:
 




:

* ;*






-

 

 
* 1"


 *
?

 
 **



-
 1


 

 -


"

  
 *

   




*
 -   


  




-

:
*
*

-

E* 
<  
(* 
 ,
*
%3>'

*
$(),



-
 
*
/

 


 


;

*
 *"


*-  
"

 
* < 
(*
 ,

 

 



 


:


 

 
 

 "



 

$

5*



*- 
 

 


 * 




*
< 




 
  




E


 "
*


 



 

  


 *

"









- 


  




 

*
-

*- 



 
*

1"

  *

/

5*
*
*- 
 

 



*- 
 *

 

 
*

?






*
 - 
 


*

>%%>4#@+



*
 


*

:

-"



1"
 *
  




- 1
*
 
-

"*
 



-

*-

?



 

 *
 

-"
 
*



*"
  




*- 


  

-
* 

- 



*-

?
 
-
*

- *



 

 


1"

 *
< 

 
-


-
"*






 *
 
-
 


 

 
-
  
*

* 
1
 





-"






*



*-
;



 5

*


 

 
"


*


0?

"

 -77 >


 


*- 
 


-"
* 

 "

 
-



 *- 
:

*
;*


< " 


*"



 
  

5*
*
*- 
 

 


 

*- ;



< -
"


*"


 "

 

 -77 *-
;







*
 
0?


-*

  
  


 "



*-
;



*


  

 
"


* 



6
*- 
 

 
*-
;



 

*
 


 
*


>>$%&@+  


*
 


*




>%%>4#@+

*


 
 
 
+ +

*-
;

'

?
 
 
*


 

 
"
*" 



 



-





 


 
*


 



 
-
*





- 1
*



-"
 
-

*- 
" 

 

*



5*

 

*


 
 * 


0

 
  
 


 

 
&$
 


"



*- -
 

*

 
-

*-

:

  

5*

)"

*
 


5*
  


"

-

?2*
:-*

:*


 
"* 
 
-
*



 


-
 

=


*"



 &> #% &#&#

5*
-

*+ A


"






 
*

+< 
 

 


 "

  
$ % &#%'
()*
+',
-

 -
 


0*
 "

 

 
&/ %& &#%'
()*
+%#,  "

 
 

 


5*



*


 

 



"


2* *
 *
?
*
"




*- 
 








:

*
;*

(*- 


,

+2*


< -
"
*-1 
"

 

 *

 -77 
 *"

 
+< 
?

 



 



 

*

> 1
)


 
-




*




*

 
 
 


*-
?

"*
 

+2*



< -
"

*-1 
"








 -77 
 
-




 


0*
*"
 

"



- 



- 



*- < -
"
*-1 
"

1"


*

 



 "







"

"
 

1"
 * 

 


*

>
 1

)


 

-

- 1
-
 


  0
*

.




*
 


* -

%3 $ &#&# %#

:*

*







  


2* *

*

"* 
 

- 
 




- 

 
+ +
*-
;




 

*
 "

 
 
 "


 *


?


 

"* 
 
-
*


 
 "

*



 
*
*-
;



-
  

:

 "

*) 
 
*+
6/%<#$6##3 (= 36# 8#3131()#%
6/%<#$6##3 1$$+#'

3( .6+56>/%/) %





  


 ;

*

  (G
*,
  


*-


:

*
;*


   (G

*,
*-
;

 9*
 
(G

*,



"

 
(.

,
 


 *
"* 

 
*


*


>%%>4#@+
-
 "







"





%





 




*-1 


5

*


51 *-  <  (G

*,
-
 -77"

*


%3'%8&38@+
(= 

"
 1
* * 

*

*, 
 


:

* ;*



 
(G

*,

 
"


 
(
,
 


*
"* 

&
:

*

 "


 
-
 :

* ;*



  
(G
*, &

=*


 -77

*



*


3>34>@+


*-1  51 (G

*,

"
 






*



;

*
   (G

*,

 ;

*

  (G
*,
+  


*



*


:

* ;*



  (G
*,


 
*


"



:

*
"

  
*"
E5
 
 
*



;

*
  
(G
*, 



 
 
-*"



 
< 


*-1 
51 (G
*,

  

+
 

*

 

 
*


"

@"




;

*


 
* < 
(G
*, -
"

*
 


 
 









-"

  
 *


*-1 
51 (G
*,
"

  
 
-
 

* 
 




 
  @
-*
*



*


"


"  


*




*


+ 

$

< *

"
* 1



 



;

*
  
*
<  (G
*,
*-    
* 

 
 
-


"

$


*-1 
51 (G
*,
-
"


*






 









-"
   *

/


;

*


 
* < 
(G
*,  
*
$
( ,
(-,
(,
*
'


*

-


E* 
<  
5*
*

/


< *

*
1

 
 

*-1 
51 (G

*,

*- 


  * 



 
- 

"

>
<
"



;

*
  
*
<  (G
*,
  *
  


 *


>%%>4#@+

 


< 

>

*-1 
51
(G

*,
 
*
$
( , (-,

(,

*
'

 *

-

E* 
<  
5*
*

'

<
"


*-1 


 
*
<  (G
*,
 
 *   



*


%3'%8&38@+




 < 

:

 ;

*
 *"

 *-  
"
  
*
<  (G
*,

 - 
-
*
*
 *

-

E*  <   (* 

 ,

*
%3>'

:

*-1 
 

5

*


51
(G

*,
*- 
<  (G
*,

 -

- *
*

*

-
 E* 
< 
E  (* 

 ,
* %3>'

%%

:
  




 "
  
*-
;



*

 "
 -77


*


%3'%8&38@+
(=


"
 
*
* 
 *


*
,
 




 -77 



?





 
*- ;






*
"
:

*
;*


< " 

 0?

 
 


 

-





0?

 
 
 





*

"



:*
 2*

 


- 1"*


 * 





*-
;



 
" 
 
 
 
- 

 "




 
*  
 



*-
;



*


 


H %&

?

- 1"*


 
 


 
 
 


*- 

)
5*


 






 
 










*+ A>
I 



* 
H


2*
 
" 


 
 

-*
%%##
-



0




 

  


" 

:

 


 *


 "
* -


" 

*-2*


 
  %###
 
-



0
 
" 




 
 




?

"


 
 
"*"
 *

*
"*
  



 


  *
 
- 
 
- *

  




*-2*  
 
-

?


*""  


 

 

*" 



I
  2*

 
*


 "*"
 *



  



 

5

 



  


  



 
: 






*
"* 
 



 


 

- 


*"

 5




 "



:
 *
 
-
 


 
 
-

- 

*

 
 
 
 



   * 
:
 


 "

 


5*
 
1



'


** 

-"

 
 

5* *

* "


 1

 +

 

1


- *
 
 1

  
*
I
1


  
*


 "
*
-




5*






:
6"
5*
 




 
- -
"*
-
  
:

 
  *

5





 

  
" 


5


1

 


*"
 "


 

  

 

2*


*
-
-

 "
* * 

* "



 0
H
:



5*
:

 
" 


 

 *
+ *
:
5*

"

-  -


:

 "


5*
*
-
"

I 

*
-

H
:
 
  -
*

  "



 1 *
-

-



0
  "

" 
-*

  
-
 

 "

 
  "

 





 

"



  

 -
1
*

 *
<*
 "





"


%%##
 

-



0

"*



*









)


"



 
.

 


 "
* -



"  

*
-


 1

 "

 
 


 

*
-
 




* 

 "


  
*
"
*


 "*


*
*


"





 

"
 
   



  
 
 ) 


5*

"*"
 *
 


 

*"






- 1
=
 
*







 
*

 

- 


%8
-


- 


*
 

*

 
2* 

"* 
-

%8

 5*
:
5*
*
"



2* 

 
 %4

0*


 

 


 

!
"



##
 


$




*+ A)) )) )) ?

**-



 

*

 


2*

  "

 -



  *
<*


 "




 

 







 

 


2*






* 
*
-
 

%8

. 
 

6"
5*




 
  
%!& & '
(  )
 !)
*+
"


$
,
 



*+ A)) )) )) 




"

 

""
 
-
 "*
 



 
* 
 -77 

*"




""



 1"





 * 
 -77





-
  

%$

  

- 
. 
 
 

+'
"

 $
 /
#0)




*+ A%>

"*



-
 1 
-

 




 

:*"

 
*  

5*
  

 





 
 


"
* 
-*

 * 
 


 
?


 
 -
 


 
 

)


  
"*

"
*
 * 










;

*






 



;

*




 







*
-

 

 ""

 

 




 




;

*

?


;

*


 
-
 


 


 

 

8'###@+



-



 



-
 



:*"




 

 


  



 
- *-  

*

)



* 
"


"
-

5*


*


 

)  

  


*

 
-



 

 

-  %/

:
 



-

<


## 
,
$)




 
+'
1 '
  -2
32


  
  
*  
 "
 
*

 


 
"
  
"





*+

-

A)) )) 

-








 

 -77 
 
-  -




* 
  "

 

* * 
  







 



 

* 

*


:  "






 -77 -*



""
@


  "

*
5 

* 
"   

* 

*

 




 "

 -77 

*

 
-

*


'

:
*
 
-


  


*"



*
-
  
*



?


 

 
%!& & '
(  )
 !)
$ ,

4
$
 /


5*
  " 
&4

 



"
 
*

""
*

-


"*
 



 
*  


 -77
?

 
 
 





 ""


 "


*
6
  

-


* 




"
 

* 

 

 
-
*

-
"*
 -77
C 
*


 
 
 




- 
5*

- 
. 

 

+') $
 /
#0
?

 
 
  
 
-
 "

""
 


  

 
*


 

:
*"
*


*




 

* 
  "


 J


 *"
*
 






 


J
 


 *"
*
 



  

=

- 


 



 
 

5*



*  

*"
*
 

* 

52*



* 
2*  
-


 

 1

 

 



%>

0
 "

 


 
-
* *

*+ (, I
2*
 

 "
   "



-
 



(, I

 

 



*
-



 
- 


 
-
* 
-"
-
-

%8
 
5*

?

(, I



- 
 

*"

 

2* 

"* 
- 
%8


5*

? 

5*
* 

2* 

 


(, ?



"
 -77 



*


""
 
-

"*
 

*

 -77

 "
-


 "

 



 "*
 


 "

"" %'

 




*

 -77  






 "
 -77


*

:  "





-"
""


 "
 - 



*
 


*
-
:

*
;*



< " 

 

-

*-

:*

* 
*


 
-



 * 
 
*

2*
*

 -77 


*-
;

%3

?



-

5*
 

 
 "
 




*

- 

*
 
- *  



 "



2*

-77 

* 

*

*

 
- " 
 

* 

*
*-
;





 
*


 
 

:
  
  
 
-
 
- 


 "





*
 *
 

 "





 
 2*

&#

* 

 *"


* 
 
 
-

 
*
 "





- 

*"
*

" 
-

 


 


#'
1


 





 


"
*

 "




&%

I





 


&&





 
 
-

"

 *
 


 

 



2



!

* -*











Dinesh I
 1"@ 
  I
 -