High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AS/98/2023allowed

Uma Rani v. Rajesh Jain

2023-02-28Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta14 pages

$%&%'(

) "

*++ ,," - %!&!

!/ "

1# 231 4 5

"# 1%4!/ 6, '"(07

,,"4 1%4/%)&0/ ! % "8/(07

1%4- !/,/%87(07

"4 5

(4 " % ) ", )+, " $ % "8 !

9:;<<<=> , 0! ?

) " 74 .

!/ "@

++ ,," ) " & .

!/ "&"0 <

$, "!%&) "!(<<A/ %%

%% 0!9/

44>B(C& ,/!$

%0 0$', %"

0&$ 7 !

",&0 , 18 !% (5,6(7 0 .&08) "0 04;4<;(8 "!D/ // !

++ ,/!$

"+%

%% 4 !+ !

+, 0 ,,"E )+, ""(

"0,', "

₹<(:(:FD!07"

0$'/ %

"<44<4/ &8/(&!

0/0+% ) !

&%"/ ! 0) &" D / " ) "/($&/ 6 + "7 0 "8/ ) G4 , ) ,'( " %0 % 0 !/%8 / !, $ , '(&!

0 !!& 4;<0 04<4<

%") &"

₹<(:(:F0%D"

" "86 "8"0/"8/ "6 "8 %+ % "3 ) 0 " 7 &%

)+, ""(!!&% "8// D ,,$ "!/ "+% " "4 %( " +% " "( / / D! 0 !/ &% 0( 7 0 % &%"

0 0 <4<4< D / / % )%6! ? &"! , 0@4 )+, "" "

%) 0$ &/ 0 !/ &%

"0/ ) !

)6 ) &" "!/D / "0'!( $&/ , )6 +') "4 )+, ""/ "!

%7 0, 8, 0 0 <4<4< "0 !

" / !) / &!

0 /% &8/ 8 ! 0+ !!6 "8/ ) )6 +')

) &"D / "

<:0'!

4/ , !

(D/ /

)+ ,, )+, "" )+, " "<<4<4<4 4 % %

%0 "8 +% , ) "%' ( % D!!&)) & "&"0

444 "

/ !++ %"

(/ D!!

%7 0D /"

&! "&"0 <

44 ";4<4<=( D/ // +, 0 0"

8& ,'"0 , ) 0% ,4 )+, ""++ % 0 "/ D "

!!$ G! / D"

D "

!!!H<4

0&"0 "<%4 44D!

%0 04 0 0"

00& "'0

4 %/ % "8$ //

! 0 !(, %"

0% ,18 !%

%0 0C& ,!) %, %4 =4 ! 0 $' , %"

0 &"!

% / ++ ,,"

)+, ""/, %"

0% , &%) !% 0/ " %

++ ,," )+, ""4 ++ ,," )+, "" ! 0 0&% "8 % !!

G) " "/!/ /0D /0%D"") &"

₹<((F )/ $"6 &"D 0'!$

07" "8/ " " 04/ $"6! "+% 0& 0$

/ ! &% "00 ",

!&++ %! / % ! " " / ! % 8%04 / ++ ,,"

)+, ""/0,!

! 0// %$ /!

"!"00&8/ % ",DD

D %6 "8"0/!/ D!, 7 "8 ".

) ,'(+% 7 "8/!/

/0/ "" ,+ '4/ % , &% , "! 0 %/ "/ !

! "&"0 "<%4 44(% 0,, 0// !

! 8"

0 / D! ! " $& / "

% , 0 "' "

% "'

)+, "4 )&/!

(% "0 0"

% +,'

8,"

8%0 "8! , "8

%) !&!

++ ,," )+, ""!&$) !/ " % 0/ )!

/0 !!& 0&,' ,, 0 ""0! 8"

0/ 0 !/%8 / !, $ , '4 %(, %"

0% , &% 8"

! "&"0 "< %4 44 ! 0 !(% 00 0"

D "

!!$ G"

%, "' !&++ %/ !!"0"0!!&/(/ !

// !/ D!! "( !"

,, $ 7$, :4

& "8/

! 0 "!(, %"

&"!

% , &%.&08) ""0!&$) /C& ,/!$

"% 8/,'%

%0 ;4 /7 "! 0 0!&$) !!

// ! 0 !"0/7

+ %&!

%0%

&,,'4 I4 ₹ G4< !/ 0 04<4<

% <(:(:F4J4 !/ $"6% &%") 0 0<4<4< !!& $"6(!+ D/ // D!0 !/ &% 00& &"!$ "8, 04G4 !

8,"

0 0<4<4<"0/ D!!

0/% &8/% 8 ! 0+ !! ! + !,

+G4=4

D/ 0/ !! 8"&% ! / 4 ! " ) / C& ! "! +& / ++ ,,"

)+, "" "/ %% !! G) " ""0/ !

0&"0 "<%4 44(/ !"06 "$'/ 0 !// !! 8"

D!! "$'/ ,," )+, """0) !&!

04/&!(/ !

! 8"&% !"

0 04 "

! +% " &"0 % " <

/ 44 " 7 &%

++ ,," )+, ""4 4 ! 8"&% ! % 0) /

0(+% "&"0 "<% 0D / "<<,&!

AB KA$B

"!%&) "! !% 0(D/ /% 0!!

&"0 %# ?<4 " " 7 &%

/ ,0 %4 !/,, $

!&) 0(&", !!/ "%%' !+% 0(// / ,0

(

"&%

%% "

"<(

0 !/%8 ( "D/ % "+%(

$ %, $ , '4@ <<4 "!! $, "!%&) "!4 " ,/

"%%' ! +% 0( /

,, D "8 +% "! !/,, $

)0 # AB

"! 0 % "4/ %'"

$, "!%&) D!)0 %0%D"

"! 0 % "("0/ %'!&/ "!%&) "(D/ " /!$

" + 0( %!

0("

% %"!

%% 0( D! + 0( %!

0( "

0 %"!

"! 0 % "L A$B ! 0 4 / %' "

$, "!%&) $ % "80 D!)0 %0%D" "!&/0 L@ 4 " "8++7!4% 1 /"(<AB% ) ", &%!

A44B#<AB 7 , &%!

!<<:A44B#<AB+ G &% &08) "!:A44B#<A<<B==<( /%

.&08 "/

&%/ ,0/ "<

",&0 !/

"% 8%0 "8/ G !

, 8,,'

$, $ , $ , '"0// / ,0

/ !,!

!&) /7

"0 !/%8

!&/0 $ %, $ , '4 D!,%

0 "/

! 00 "//

G !

, 8,,'

$, $ %, $ , ' !(

&%!

(% $&$, "0 ! "

% !

(D/ G !

, 8,,'

$ %, $ , '"$ ! 04H / &0 &$(/ " ,+% ! " 7 &%

)+, ""4 <4 &+% &% &%/ % / ,0 " $ !

/ "<

!! " G)+,

% %!

"&!

,&!

(D/ / ! "&"

D // 8 !, 7 "

)+% 7 "8/

0 $ , '

$, "!%&) "!4

%!+

0' % 0' " % ) ",

%&)( "% , " 0 !/ &%

!4 !!(/ &%& "!//

&"0

!$ !% 8&, %'

"0, 8,,' ,,! "/ % "

7 ,D% "8"0/

(/ !

% ", ' &8/ 8& 0 " %+%

"&!

,&!

4 "&!

0)'"

$ G+ 0 !/%8 "&"0&,'/ 8/ !"0%0

( % %!

"&!,&!

C& % !/ % !

$$,

%% "80 &$$ &/ G !

, 8,,'

$, $ %, $ , '

%/D% "8/ & "4/ !"0%0

% 0 "8 !

D &,0 "

!!% ,' $ " / $! !

?+% %"

$$ , !@"0"

?$ '

"0!/0 D

"'0 &$4@ <<4 " 3 6/ ./%)-!4!/ ,&+(<:A=B 7 , &%!

!=A ,/ B( /!$

"/ ,0$' ,/ 8/ &%/ 0 ! $, 8 !

&++% $$,

"0/0

$ ",'2+ !! $, 20

4/ !/ &,0$ !

% 0 $, ) % , %&)!"

7 ,$, " %

%0( D/ / !/ &,0 , 0 / &%

",&0 /0

G+,"

% !!&"

0 !/ 0/ !

$$, <4 " !, "8++-!41&0 $!++ "3 "

=<( %

%% "8 7% &!+%

"! " "<<AB"0<

$, "!%&) "!( &%!&))% M

+% " +, !!&"0 %# "

!0) 0( "<

)"0 !+% "// D!

0 !/%8

$ %, $ , '4 / "&"0 "< !% $&$, ""0 "&! ! % !

$$,

4/ !"0%0

%% $& "8/ " !/

$$ , !4 $&/ "( !

, 0 $' / ) % &!

0 " ,!

% ,' " / ) % ,!

!&$) )+, "" " %0 % % !

+% $$,

4 "

$$ , !"$ 0%D""

",'

) / ) % ,! $% &8/ " %

%0 $' / +% ! $& ,!

%&)!"

!&+ "D/ // '% ,'4/ !"

!!%'

"/ D "

!!$ G "!&++ %

/ !

( " < )+ 0 " " %' $&%0 " "0 "

%!&! 7 $&%0 "4 !"

!!%'

"/ D "

!!$ G

!&++ %/ !0

<4 ! "/ , 8/

! 0, 8,+ ! "/ !

C& % !

"/D/ %&!

0/!$

"$, $$ , !

/ !

4! !, % 8,+ ! "!$ (/ 0 !"

C& % 0 +% / ! 0

" / !"0%0

9$ '

"$, &$>"0%/ %(/ !! )+,'% C& % $$ , !

/ !

4" %0 % $&/ "7 ,$, )+, ""&"0 "<

(&!

0" %++ % "/ D "

!!$ &8/ !"

)"0 %'L %/ " , %&)!"

! 7 &%$,

/ ) 0&% "8 / % !! G) " "

)+, ""L % +&

%/ / !

" / ! ! " &"0 % " < %4 44 !&++ % 0 $'

4 !"

"% C& % 0 !&++ %/ !0

/ ) (&!

0 ! $, 8 !

&++% $$,

(D/ / !/ &,0"

$ ",'2+ !! $, 20

4/ !/ &,0$ !

% 0 $,

) % , % %&)!"

!7 ,$, "%

%0(D/ /!/ &,0, 0/

&% ",&0 /0

G+,"

% !!&"

0 !/ !+% $$, <=4 "/ !!

(0&% "8/ % ! ) "'!H<( !0 !, 0$'

)+, ""/!/ /0 %, %D %6 0/ !/ +

1F!1"8,0

0$'/% )"/ ""0/% 0 !/ $%

! 0 )"/ "4/ /0$

C& " 0D // " 0/!/ D%

)4/ &%/ %! 0/

₹<(:(:F, $'/ % 0(!/ /0D /0%D"") &"

₹<((FD 0'!+% )/ %$"6 &"4/ /0,

/ !/ % 07" "8/ " 04/ !+

,,'

0 / !&88 ! " /0&% "8/ %.

$/ !/ D%

)(!/ /0 ! "/ !/ D%

)"0) !&!

4/ 0) /"

+D! !!& 0(D/ "!/ 87 ) &"

₹<(:(:F 0"

% / & 0"' %0 &) "4/

&%/ %! 0// "C& ! "D!/"0 % / %$'&!

"4<4<"0/0&% "8/ + )< 4<4<(!/

0 0 "

)6 "' )+, " 8 "! / &!

0 "0 "

0 "'

%'!& (/ &8/!/ &!

)

/ )4 %0 "8 / %! "( !/ /0 +/ " ,6D // 0% 8&,%,'4 <:4 / !

)+, ""H<

/ ₹ !/ /0D /0%D"/ ) &"

<((F )/ %$"6 &"D

0'!+% % "0 "8/ 0( !!&++ % 0$'/

$"6 &"A""

G&% <B(D/ /% ,!/!/ /0 ₹ D /0%D" " ) &"

<((=F ) / % $"6 &" 4I4<4/ "D!07"

"<44<"0 /&!(!

,," )+, "" !!&++ % /!/

₹ /0D /0%D" <((F )/ %$"6 &"D 0'!+% %

07" "8

" <;4 !+ !"06 "$'/ 0 "/ !! "&"0 "<%4 44(/ 0 0"

$ %% D"') &" )+, "" % !!& 0"'/ 4 )+, ""D!D %6 "8!!, !8 %,

!/ D%

)"00&% "8/+ 0(!/ ! $"6! 8"

0/ "0 ) !&!

& ,, "8/ 4/ &%/ ! 0/ %!

+% "8 $&! "

!! )!/ D%

)(/ /08 0 !/ &% 0"0// /!"

, $ , '4 &%/ %! 0/ ++ ,," )+, ""0 0"

/7 "" ,+ ' +'"'

) &" / )4 <I4 !

( )'$ 0/!

0&"0 "<%4 4 !"

!&$!" 7 +

4 0+&

%// !0

"! 0! "(/ )&!!&++ % D /

, "

"$ +, " &) - .-!41F! %) &" / $ "0&!% !(<AB=AB(D/ " /!$

"/ ,0$'/

&%/!

%0 0&"0 <%4 4 !"

!&$!" 7

($& ! ",'"

++ %&" ' &!

0 G+, " / "% ) " "8 %&)!"

++ % "8 " / +% & " !

4 " / !

&+% &%( &!

0 /0 "

, 0 "' % $& /

"&"0 "<

4 &%/ ,0

// D!"

$&/ "// !D

!!&

"! 0 % "4 &%/ ,0 &%/ %/

!) "%

%0% ) "&"% $& 0"0!&++ % 0D /

%0D /"

!&$!" 7

G+, "

"% ) " "8 %&)!"

!++ % "8 "/ )+, "8 "!/ )( %% %D! )) 8/ &% "7 / 0&"0

4 <4 ) ,%7 DD!6 "$'/ &% "

) )-!4 7 "0 % "8/&0"K"%4(<A=B:;AB

0&"0 "<%4 4 !"

!&$!" 7 <4 "+% "!

(% 00 0"

+% 0& "'

$&/ & "7 ,$, )+, ""&"0 "<

444

0&"0 "<%4 44 !"

!&$!" 7 "0""

$ !8 ,%&/ "/ $!

"' 4/ !"0

// !! 8"

0/ D!! "$'/

++ ,," )+, ""(D/ ) !&!

( !"

!&++ % )"'

4 " !

( / / D! ! " % ) !&!

0( / ! "

G+,"

%/ ) "8 0! D/'/ 0 0 )6 "' )+, " + %) "' %&/ % '

6 8, "8 "!/ ,," )+, ""4 4 /

304 &"!

"&!

/ )+, ""0 0"

+% 0& "'%

+ %D% "8

07" "8

") &" 0"0!

(!/ /!$

"% 8/,'

0 !$ % , &%(/!"

) % 4++ %!/ " %

%0/!$

") !% 0$', %"

0% , &%4"!

&"0

44( )+, "" !"

% C& % 0 !/%8

$&%0 "+, 0&+ "/ %, 6 " 7 ,!& 4/ !"

% C& %

, $ , '$'+% 7 "8 &"!$

6!"0 !%

+ 4

!!%'

"8% "! % / / D! !!& 0 $' / &!

0( D/ / D!

0 !/ &% 0"0/ )+, "D! 0 %)6 "8"

!!%'!& %'

)+, "

!4 <4

, "

"$ +, 0&+ ) )-!4 7 "0 % "8/ &0"A!&+%B(D/ " /!$

"/ ,0$' &%/ "!

0 !/ &%

(0 $ !"

0! " 7 ,!& 4 "/ !

&%(0

D!6 "$'/

0//

6D!, !"0// D!"

!!& 0 "

0 !/%8

"'0 $ %, $ , '4&!

0/0"

++ % 0!D "

!!4 / )+, "D!0 !) !!

04 &%!

! 0

0 !) !!,

)+, ""0C& ,

0$'/ ,0 "8/

!) ,, 8,"0&"!&! "$, 4 &%/ ,0!

&"0 %# ?4/ % , &%"0/ 8/ &%+%

0! (/ ,," ! 0 $$

7 , &%D/ "(/ +, "

!% C& %

/ !, ) $! !

, 0 "!&++ %

/ !

, )

) &"0& 40 !/ &%

%% !!& %'+%

"! 0 % "4/ / ,0

"0& &%!

!% C& % // D! !!&

0"0/D/ 0( D!"

/ &% 04 "

!!& %'+%

"! 0 % "(/ $&%0 " !

$&/ "// D! !!& 0"

"'0 $ %, $ , '4 <4/ !/ )"0

"! 0 % " " %)!

7 !

4/ "&!!/ ! "+%

!!&"

$&/ "// D!

!!& 0"

%0 !/%8

"'0 $ %, $ , ' " %)!

4@ 4

&%/ %( "

/ $/ 7",, ,74

&.%K "

%A<B<<;( /!$

"/ ,0$'/

&%/# N"/ !

/"0( " %+&%+ % 0,'0%D "8/ &"0 "<

(/ % , &%+%

C& ! D"

)+, ""!% 8%0!/

&"0!

%07" "8/ " 0"0D"

G) "

7"D "

!D/ ,, 0,' G 0/ ) '

%07" "8 04/ !++% /

% , &%/0$

"7% "

D // +% " +, !

" ",D4 %!&/+% "(/ "&!!/ 0"0&", !!/

0/00 !/%8 "&!$'$% "8 "8 "%

%0!&/ !"0 %&)!"

!! !/ D/ %"

$$ , ! , "8 "

/ ! 7 &%("'0 &$ )+, ""2!!

&,0"

% !

% D"

% 8%0 "8 / !

&"0!

07" "8 , " / &!

0++ ,,"4 / !+ % 7"

"! 0 % " /0 $

" ! D/ % / &!

0++ ,," /!

$% &8/ "%

%0!&/ !F) % ,F %&)!"

!D/ / &,0$

% !

"$,'+% $$,

4N 4 !, % 8,+ ! "!$ / )+, "" !"

$, 8 " "" ,+ '4 "

" &"0 % " <

/ ! 7 ,$, /

)+, ""( " % $&%0 " !/ ! &+ " / &!

0 % $& / "(D/ / "/ "!

0/!& %,' , 04 =4 ,, &%/ %(+% % , "8

)+, "(!& %'"

0 0<4<4<&"0

44D!!

0 /% &8/ % 8 ! 0 + !4 / ! +%

%7 &"0 "I

%,,&!

0D / "<<=

7 0 4 !+

4<<

(% 00 0"

% "0 4"!

0/0$

"! %) !&!

0(/ D &,0 /7 )) 0 ,'% 8,"

"' "8/ !, $ , '4

)&/!

( "/ "&%, &%!

"0&(% 0D &,0 /7 ++% / + %&/ % ! 6 "8 "! ,," )+, ""

%) !&! "8/ ($&"

!&/! +D!

6 "4+

!"0

,," )+, "" !/% " 0/08 7 "/ )/ ,, 0 "/ 4

0/!"

D "

!!$ G "'/ ! 0 "0 "% %/

! ")0 $'/ ,," )+, ""4 :4 " "8++-!4% 1 /"(<AB% ) !=A44B( /!$

"/ ,0$' "2$, &%// 7 %' /&!

/0 , +,' !& %'"

&"0

$, "!%&) "!, "

// D!) % "

)+, ""2!7 %!

"4 ;4 ) 7 D/!$

"6 " "44,7 . -4 ,+ '

1&/)) 0"0"

%(IAB A% ) ",B<:(D/ " /!

"/ ,0$' &% "!&"0 %# ? !,!

") "0// C& %

8 7 "8

!, %0 +%&% %&,

% ) ",3D(D/ !"

! +&,

8 7 "8

, "8/ )+, "4 "'

0%D %D/ , )!// 0 0"

"$'+ !("( D / "<:0'!

!&)) "! &% "%

)+, "&"0

()6 +')

) &""0!&$) &%// /0)0 +') "D / "<:

0'!

!&)) "!A$'%

7 "8 +'

)+, "D / !&)) "!B"0(/

(/ )+, " !, $, % .

04 %!

"D/

+'D / "<:0'!

!&)) "!

&%, "8D // +'

)+, "&"0 <

(""

$7 &!,' "0// D!"

!% C& % 0&"0 "<4' 8"

% "8!& %'

" "%%'&"0 "I

44"0 "<<=

7 0 4" &%7 D("' % " %+%

7 !

D &,00

/ 7 %' $.

8 !, "4 !

%7 0 "/!6%">!!

A!&+%B( ?8 7 "8

@D!

!/ ?%

@% 6! %/ 0%D %D &,0 / ) &) 7 0%

7 "8/ $'0 + "80

!% !"0 !+ ), 8, "!

4@ I4 "4 41" "01 /" %'7!%4"

/,/,"8 7"

A=B3D %,0AB<( &%/!/ ,0!

&"0 %# ?==4H )',!

G) "

/ !++ , )0

""8, 4 !"

"0 !+& (!"

0$ (/"

+,'D!8 7 "$'/ / !& %' "

%7 0 &+ "/ % $' / ,,"4 " /

0 "8!

"'+ ( ! !!

" ,

+ %!

" D/ !& %'"

! !!& 0&"0

8 7 "

++% +% +,'4/ + %!

0 ! G+ ,% '/ ! %!"

4 + %!

0/!!

&" )+ /$, "0 "% % $, ) % , !$, !/// %!/ /!"

+,'

)+"'F %)(/ "!&/) % ,!/ &,0$

/ 8/, 8/ 0 "/ +,' !

&"0 "4 "'!&/

&"0 " !, 0(/ + &% D &,0$ ) , %$

)+, ""4/ )+, ""D &,0 6"

D! D/'/

" D/ )/ /! !!& 0"

!'!// !"

% "! $,

0 !/ &%

40/ "/ "8 7 ++% +% +,'/ 8/, 8/ "8D/ %!/ /!!

&8/ / 8/, 8/ $

&!/ " +% $$,'/ )+, "" D &,0 /7 &"0 %6

&%/ "C& %'"0D &,0/7 % "0 &D/D!/ 8, !&!

%) 0

)) !!

"0 D/D!/ !&!

" "/ %)4/ $.

, "8

)+, " !"

.&! 8 7 /"

0%D

'/ ! ) !!

" )6 / !!"

, % %!/ !, $ , '&"0

! %"

=:4 "

!!%'7 %) "!% )0 "/ !& %'"

!!& )+, "" "% 8%0 7 % &!, $ , '

+%"

%!"0&+ "%

!&/"

( +%"

+!C& "00

!'"'/ "8 "% +,' (/ )+, "" /!,,/ !

"! /D// /!! 0 "/ /!

" +

4"!&/ %&)!"

!D/) !

G+

)+, "" !' "/ )+, "4@ 4 /&!(% "E&!

0/7 "8"

8,"

" / )+% % , "8/ )+, "( "

0%D"// !) % "/ )+, ""2!7 %!

""0/ !

%& 4 $! !

" % 0 !&!!

"!$ ( !/ ,0/ )+&8"

0.&08)

C& ,""

$ !&! "

04/ )+&8"

.&08)

C& , !!

! 0 "0/ "++ , !,, 04 !

,0// ,," )+, ""/!!& !!

&,,'+% 0/ %!

₹

// 0 04<4<

%") &"

<(:(:F !!& 0D!0 !/ &% 00& "!&

&"0! "/ ! &"(! ! !

0"61"8 %!/ 0/0,% 0', $"6 &"4 ! &%/ %+% 0/0 !+ 8,"

0/% &8/% 8 ! 0+ !(/ , )6 +')

) &"D / " <:0'!"0!

( / &! "&"0

44 !0&,'+% 04!!&/(/ ,0 "8/ " 8& ,'&"0

44(/ ! "7 &"0 %43 / / %0 "C&"&)

&%"

444

$%&%'( A 5

B !% H/ %% !

0F!+ 6 "8# !F

H/ %% %$, # !F

4<=