(O&M) Narain Singh v. Sohan Lal And Others
! "! !# $$%% " &' !
# % "! !# "!$" " ( !)
") "! $$%% " *!
"*!!
!
( )
") $" +$ ,& ! "!)
") $" ----- + ".$$%% " ! %"!/ ("
"0
$ 12"!3" % %+ " 4 )5 ) ( "! %$
""!/ (" "
$ 12"!3" % % 1.
4 ) 5 ) 6!
! "! " $( " / % 12 $".$%
!
# %)6
5"! , % "2)$ " !
%%1 " $"! %"
" 7 %
.!
# % % " $( " / " " . ! ( " "! $
% $ "! $%
%" % % ( 0 %%2 1 "!$% ") " "6 "! "!"
" & %% ) 8! % * %% !) + " " 5 !
" " 1 " "!9 "% :;"6 % (12"!$%
"!
"! % 6 "! " .!
# %$ ( ")6! %1"!
.
. 6 %" " $
)1 .!
"! "% % 6 $%
$" "! "!2 0<.00) 0.0 ) <<.<0) <.< =.
;" 6 "!
"!
!")" "% "" "! "% +$ "!
1>")! " ( ""! % ( "!$%
6 1"$ " ! $
%$ ) %" 6!
!"! "6 % = + " $$ "! " ; "! 6 "" " "(")
"
$% ( 21/ " 6 "! " )"!$%
" 1 $ "! " $$"2) "! " !
1 %
%% 6 "!$ ( " )
" )"$$%)"! " 1 1 ./ ( ./ $ " "
6 ;"6
% "!
" "! " 6 1 12 "! " >" !
1 12"!+ " "
/ (" " 0 "!% ($ "
%=)
'7?.
$$%
"
!
1(12 ";"!
1!% "
0 "!
" "! % ( 7 $ " "! " % 6
" %%2 %" " $ " ) "! ) " ( " %)"! ("
6 "
,
$%
" 6 %) 6!
! "! "" "! 6 "" "
"("6 "!( "!$% "6 " " < 5("!$% "!$ " ) %%6 6 ( 12"!" %3".
.7.
! "
#
$
% &
! !
' (
) 0 " %"! $ " 8!" %3" "! " %12"!$%
"! %$
""! / ("
6 ( 12"! " $$%% "3"% ""! % "!$" %
# % "!$ " 6! ;" 6 1( "" 12 % % $" " "!
"1"!"!3"1%6!
"! " %12"! $%
6 ( ""! " 0@A+$ 12 "! + " "
) 6!
! " !
1 !% "!
" "! $ % ( 7 6 "!
" " 6 % ( " "! $ 12 "! $%
"6 1( """!
""!$%
!
"!6"!
"!6 $ "! "% "! " "! % "! ")6!
!"! ("$ 12"!$%
"!6 # % "! 1( "" "!
" "! 3" 1%6 !
% !"%2 1! "! " 0 @A+ !
%2 !% "!
" "! 6% " $ " /
"
# % ""!" % ("
2 % "! "!
1( """!
""!/ (" "!3"1%6
""
1%
.=. ;" 6 % 1( "" "!
" 1"! "! 3" 1%6 !
%2!%"!
""! " 0@A+) % !
1 $ ) 6! ! % !
1 $ ) "! ) "! !
1 ( % ;" 6 % "%2 1( "" "!
" "!6 "! / " "! 3 % 3" 6 1 "( "! $ " 7 "! / 1 & %% 3(( # % " ") < !" "! 9 < ": ; $$" !
"" % 6 $%
. * ! * +,- . /( 0
* #
!" #$ 1 ( * 2 3
#4
5
# %&#
'1
* * 3!
# #
" 1
3
0 % 5 , * #
(" )*)+"'($, (6 * 7
* # %&! $$, "
,
( 2 #
" % %, $ 2
* 2 3
4
# %%
$, & * 8
%%'"
' -./ ' 39
,6 8 39
,6 8 # %& 01-+- ( "! "! !
) % % $" "!
.
. $") 1( "" "!
" "! %% % "2 "! / (" $ 12"!3"1%6 "!
""!26
"$
"
"!
" % % % $ " ;" 6 1( "" "!
" "! $ "!$%
"! "% 6 %2"
1% ! ("! # %1( """!
""! " 0 @A+ 6 $ 6 "!" %%6 2 $ 6 "!" 2 !
1 % ) "! ) "! (
"1 " 1
% "( " "! !" "! $ " ) 6!
! % !
"! "
" 7 ;" 6 " "!
" "! ) 2
) !
" 1 1 ( %) %!
1$
""! "! ! "! % 1 1 !" 1" "! ( # % 1( """!
"1"!"!3"1%6!
A ( "!( "" A"
!
"%2 / ""! " ( " "!$
% "!$%
"! "% = ;!
"!1( ( 12% % "!$ " !
$"! 6!
!6 %2(( 8 $ ! $ ) "! $%
$ ( @A" ("!2 =.
6 6!
!$ " "!
"$ %2"!
"! "!$%
" (%2 (/ # % !
1 %" " "! " %
" ! () "! $%
" 6 %" " $ " %2) 6 "!" "$" ) .!
"!
@ "!
6$ 12"! " "! (
" %% 0)6!
! %!6"!$ "!$%
" 8! (" "!
" "! $%
!% !
!6 ! $ "! " % "! ") ( ") "!
.<. ("""! " 2$ 12 " 2
" " ! (% 6! ( $$%
" 8! ) "! ) $" "!
" "! $%
" 6 %" " $ "! "% < % 12 " $ "! " 0 @A+ $ 12 "! + " "
( 1 $ % "! !6 "!
" "! + " "
$" $ ,6"% 6 % "!
" " $ "! " % * " " "! ) " "! " = = @A+ $ 12 "! "
" 3%% " B ) 6!
!"! $$%
%12 "
" 6 / ")"1 ";" "
12"! "! "2"!
""! $$%
" %"$ $ ""! % ! $ ""!$" ""!" ( $" $ " ) %! $ 2 ("
2 "!!
$
" $ ! $ ;" 6 "
"!
" "! (" @A 6!
! !
1 $ 12 ! (
" !6 "!
%" " $ "! $%
" ;" 6 "! "
"!
""!6 "6!
!!
1$ 12 "6 "!"! "! "! %% "!
""! " "! % " 1 " % "
"(" 8! 6 " 12 "! + " "
"
" "!
" ! !
" $" $ "
<)6!"!$%
"%! ("!
! !
6 "! $ ("
C % "
"!
" "! $%
" % ("!
""!% 6 "! %" " $ 1" %"6 1""! ( " "! . %% ;" 6 > " " "!
" "! + , "! $%
" 6 1" !
.0. $ "!"!
%, ""! ("
2 C"
""!
"! %" " "! !1 % !
%"
""!
""!% 6 $ "C6"""
""!
""! % %!6 "!
""!$ "6 "! > "(" (C6
"!1 6!
! (")! " ! % " (" ;" "" "!6$ %" %%
% !
1 "( 12 6 2 $" $ " 8! 3") "! ) !
! "
" !% "!
" "! " 0 @A+" $ 2
")
") 2( ) 1 "
" " !
%%2 % %2 "( "! !" "! $ " 0 1") $ " !
"
" "!
% !
1 $
""! ) " "!$ $$"! (6 $ ; 2
) " $("!
" %6
%) "! $ "! 3") "! " 0 @A+6%"1 "! " %12"!$%
12"!$ $%
" "!3 3 % )
!""! 933: 9* ( ! :
%
%
#
%
%
#
# : ; % ;
#
: <=
> . =
%
; % %
<=
>> ? # :
:
.
. <=
>>>.
# =
# <=
>9 8 %
6
<=
9 8
# % = #
# <=
9>
#
# #
@<=
9>>.
=
#
# # = # ;
= <=
9>>> 8
:
! # #
! ; #% :
! % ; % ;
A) 8! " "% 6% !6 "!
" "! " 6% " 1 12 "! 1 "! "! " 6
" "! 1 "!3 %3"6 $( " / " ;"
") "! ) 1 "!
" "! ( "" "%2
1"
%%2 1 "! 3 % 3" 6 % "%2 1"
%%2 "! $ $ 5"!) "! 3"6 " ($""""2 " / "!3 %3"6 " ($""" " ; !
"! ! "! / (" % $ 12 %
% "! $$%% "8!/ (" "!
* !* $
. . %6 "!"!$ " 7 "! < ")6! "6 !% "!
" "! 3 % 3" " !
"! / $ " "% 8! $" "! % 6 % 6 "!
/ (")1""! (6%" (""! "! $$%% "1
"! " %12"!$%
6 " / " 6!
!) $""% % 6 ( 1% " %% "!) " 6 " $" 6 "! "! B ( !
6 $" 1"6 $ " % 5 "! ( )"!/ (" "!
( * $ %6%"1
$$%
1% ( % %2) "! / (" "!
2
* $ 6% %"1 $$%
1%""!$"
8!/ (" + * ! "! 3" "!
3 * $ % "! 1/ " " "% 6! $ ; "!
2 3
% 5 $ ) " * ! "! 3" !% "!
" "! 3%% "!
%% "
%$6" " " / " ;"!
) $$%
/ " $% "!
1 ( 12"! " %3"1""! $" " 6 %%612 "* ! "! "6 ( "
1%2)"! " "!
6 " " "% " 7 "! < "8! )"! / ("6% %" ( ""! "! $$%% "1
"!
" "% "6 $ 1 "!3%% " "$ 2 " / " 6 %;"6 !% 12 "! " * ! "!
" "! % " % /
" !" "!$ " "! "$$"2 %" 6!
! "6%1 " 7 "! < ";"!$"
)"! >" " "% "6 %2"!>" %% " "! $ "!$%
12 " )"! )"! "6% "11 ;"!
( 6 * $ % >" " "%6
. . % %" 6!
! "6 !%"!
""!3 %3" "!
/ )"! )"! / ("6% %"1 $$%
1% ; "!
7
,
2
$ ) "! 6 " "!$
% ", $( " / " ;"6 !%"!
% "! $%
$ "!
" ! 6
" % $ "! " $$"2"! " % "! ")"! / %"1 " 8! 6 $ 1 "! 3" 1%6 "!
; "! $"
) "! $ 12 "! $%
!6 "! $ "!
"! "!$%
"!
") "!$%
(1 2 @ "! $ 12 " !6 "! %" " $ 6 "! "! $%
" "! " 2""! 6 $ "6 12D
"!
" "! $%
6 " $ "! " % E "!
("
) "! / (" 6% % " ( " "! "!
$$%% "8!/ (" "!
* 8 $ %6 "! ; 6 "! "! $ " "! / ("6% %" $$%2""!$"
)"! !"!
1
2 $" "! " % 6% 6 "! / ("5 "! ( )"!/ (" "!
39,6 8 $ 6%" $$%2 8! (% " %" "! "! $ $ $! % "! 3" " "! % "!
" "! $" % ( " "! (
%2 (
"
F!"!$ , ' G' F!"!$"
1% G'