High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1996/1990dismissed

(O&M) Punna v. Mohinder Singh & ORS.

2015-03-11Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal21 pages

!"!!

!"#

"$ # $%&%&

%&%

'(&%& )))) " %

"*"' ++ ,- #"& ', & .!,-

" *"' / //

,-,#"&001 &#"!.'

!"! !

!!. '"2 /' !. !!

"!!! !! 3 ".!! / !*,-

4 5 & % + ,- 1

&06&#"!7'2! %.

," .

.!!. !! ,"* !," . 82 ' "! . !,- !' &

9:'!

/8+ +.! %!&

,'. ! -

" !! ,!%! ;.%&! !. !

," .'2! %,-! "

'&! &! 3.

!," .! ! " ' 0!- +/& ! .'

. ! " .! #.

' !%!'

' " .! ' ! !

'. ',

" ," !

8 + 8 / ! . & -&!' ;- !

," .'2! % "! !' % 6%' ;-. ' ,

" 5! & ' / 8 / . % !,

' '! %,-!!% +/ 5!

''! . ',

" ," !"!

.,-!

"!!

. ," .2! % ! !2.

" ! +& .!!.

'%! %

.0.

"!! .

.&.!!% ;-.

- ;-1 "4; "& +< !=! 1 ">? 5! ."! -

% ,-!'

!-!! - ! ' ' ! @"

! "& ' ! ! ', ' , ! 1% 1 ! " *!3

;- ! !".!! .

'2! %&.!!% ;- ."! -

", 2 !!'

' ' !1 " + "

! 1 '!

A!!!

,'.

! ,-.- !9

% +

"B7 A!!! +.

B7 A!!!'+ 8 /

" &

"B7 8 A!! ! ' / 8 /

" %B7 A!!!

"B 7

A!!!

' "!

"B7 : +A!!!',

"B7 :

/A!!!',B7 : A!!!% !*

"B 7 : A!!!

"& .!'B7 A!! ! , . / 11B7 : / 5 18* -! !!

3 . "! - ! ,- !

' / !1 ". %*"'/ //

. , . ! ' / %

.! ,

" %

. 3 %

5!*"' ! 1. ! ,-! .

1%*"'

++ 5! "

. 8 !*,1C'" 3 .. -! "! ,-C

@! ! 1=

&.!.! !! % 8 !*, 1&.-

,-!'' '

11.&!"

', - .! !

11& ! & , 3 .

'" !

11&

!%, , !1!" <?<?

<?11<?!,"

- .'"!%"! .D<,?! !%" ''' . "!%"! .<?, ! %,-!1,--! . !' ," &.!!'- , -!% ! ! !' .! !

-, ' , 3 .!5! &! , -,!- .&, .! ! , 3 . 4'"! .!

!-, ,

-!%"!'E'=

5! .," -!9 " ' ' 0!

&!, 3 .! , ' 5!1 ' !

, 3 ..!!! ' !

A!! ! ! ,- !

/ !*,- 45

!," .% !!

'!"!

.B A!!!

. .

- %! 3 !!

% %" 3

;-. !

- !1 " A!!! ! %

. , % " ! ' ;- 3 ! ' ! !" ,"

,-! 8 . , !%" . !%

!/ !*,

4 5 8A!!! !',-!

% :<? !*,- 45

+ @ ',2" ' !& : / !*,- 45 !:

&'()"

*+ ,

,+- .+ ,)))<? 5! 6%' -

.,-!,!

F-

! ' *&,*& <0? , <? <,?.!"-!"-!

. !'," G%!

3,-!6%'- . !'," ,-!,-!H ! .!!'

!''' !&!

! F! <? IE

J! F -

!"! :.%

'! <?C! '"!

- !-*"' !!-&, ! ''' ! !%" !

'!"! ! .!! !% , !

," '/ , . , *

.,+) <?

/ .!"-!"!--

.&"& :.! !'

:.J <?A!!, '

!- K''' E -H& <? .! ! , ! - !

% !.! ! '

! - '' - , *' '' - !-"!K'E- 'H& <?.!.* '!- !8!- "& 8+&, !''' ! &.!. & '

!- &K E- ''' -, !*'H& !

, ! '! .! ! ,-!', !%

! :.!

".! <0? <?-'&!

".! <?.! - '

! ''' ! 8 %! !,: !

, E-!"! - ! !!, ! ! &!

'-,&-! "- ! "! !.

" '

" , - !- '-& .'&... .' % !! , ! ! ,-!.! :'

! !E "&.! ,-! !"&!

!%!"! '

! <? !" ,:

<? !

." 1

C6!%"*% ! K:::::H!1

& "%"! J.

! '2" !

3-!!2 &!

K'H!% !

.!!!

,!%" ," ' ! -" -'' -

"!.!!!

' <?5! ! !

,!:

! !% ' <8?<?5!!

-! !

! '

'E'!

- ' E"!' , <,?7! ! ! '! & !'-,&," &!!

'!%,'!. &! 1

&.!! - ,*! % !*, 5-<L 0 //+? !' ! <?0 ''! -' - ! '& ! " , !

,- ! % & , %, % <?0 ,*'""!' !

!& ! !

! ',,-!'""&,!'"", !

,!"! !'- < ?0 !!!" ! 1

,*-.!!!'- % '- -! !'-!

. <+?0 !!!"&!1

& ,* &

- ! !" ! '"",'! !'- 3 ! -!, - ! .! !'- "! % ! !M 5! .

!! ," .2! %! % *,- 4 5!- :

! !&'.

+/&

' ! 0.

"!!- +/& 2 , ! -A: 2!

'& 4', ! ! %

" ! E!!

. %" , /: - ,2 2 , ! #', !- + :++ !.! !

! ' .! '/8<IE:?

- !

," !,"

. ! ,-! 1

&06&#"!&IE:&! F'! + %! ' ! %- 82 ' !

&.!! . ! (!". '!-

+ <IE:8IE:?!

%! '2"!' ",

!' / !*,- 4 5 .!! !,"

,. %.!' ' '%! %

.5! !.

.!%"

'!"!

!," .5! &.!!.

! % ;-. !

',<? !1 " ! &!! -'

!- .!

! ' : '!' '!1 "

."! -

! 3 !!' ! 0

! & /&<? !1 " !:

&)/ , ,0

,* , ,1 . ,

*+ , :<?%! 3,- !N6%'!6%' - . !'," ,- ! . ! *, . ,- ! ,- !& E :

<? ! ', ! . ! *, . ! !- # -& /D <,?! ', !&E ,

&< ? !

-&!

! "! ! 6%' ! !

.!!. , ! < ? %!- .!!%%" ! & < ? !

, ,& -'

'.!'!% <?5!, %"! < ? ,, !

,! <?0 - < ?- !

-% %

,:<?&! < ?

,',.! ,-! "! ', 5! E"!

', !

! .!!' !

< ?3 !

&! .!!'!

,' ,!

0 ! .!!' ! !

&! .!

!'!

,',!

! E ! -! < ?!

,',!

!'! &! - !

, ' ' ! ! ! '! < ?!' '2 3 "#$ 4 "! !" :: <? 5!

O ', !?

*, . !

! 4.&.!! ! %! 6%'&!

,'!%%! 6%'.!

-! .!!'-, !*,4. 4. !

,' !%%!6%'.!

'! !

8 55 6"3$"::<?5! % ! *, - 4 5 & & ! 5-" 4& &.!!

.!! % !!,- <? 5! ! % ! ' ',<?&! ! '&!

<?!

! ! / !*,4. ! 4.& ! '- , " '' - , ! ''' !&.!!!

, !!, D <?! " !' !

"'' -, !'''

! & ! % ! ! '&.!!!

, !!, &!

% & , ,- ! 6%'.!! % ! <?!% . !C 1'' 8 !*, .,: <? ! 4.&!'-,& !

,E !!, D !

E !%

. !

% & , ,-& !

6%'.!! % ! <%? ! . E, :1 ! *, .:// ! .& !'-,&!

,E !! , D ! '

E ! .!

%&, ,-& !6%'.!! % !D %!! . ! 41'' ! .!

%&,E,-& !1

! <?% %,:<?&!-!

- " .!! , !''' !.!! .!! % !M + 3&.!!,

! %-&.!!! 9 !',-!

% + ,! !%!

'!"!2"!

," . !& % 0! + ,-! 1

&06#"! !, !.0!&!

' !! ."! ! '!E- !

. .! !!

." ! '!E-

!," .5!1

&06"!'

' !! ,* ' !5!2!". '!-

+<IE:8 :?!%, -E!,!." !

! E -

"! ! / 0! " 7,- " '89: 9:&;>, E1&.! " :<? !*,- 45! !! / '!!

. ,% ,!! -!5!;>, E1'' ! -

%&.!"

-,"!,- ! !' %'%! %

..! %! '

5! ' / !*,- 45!!', .

- ! 7! ! ,

," .&!.!! 6%' ," !: ' - !' ,- ! 8 . ,% "!6%'> '

:<?<,? !*,- 45 5! ,-! 8 . !% ! !3' : <?!,%:P:%! ! !

!3!2!

.! !," 0 ,;<

7," '899 25(%C

@! !1! !/ !1 "!, E -,-<?

! & . ,- - '

!'.- %. !,*!/<? !1 "! , !'!.-!/<? !1 "! ,"%

+&!E '! <?&! ' + .!! ,-/<? !1 "' -&<?

3 ,- ! ! 1 6%'&<?

3,-! 4.!*,4.&<?

3,-!,-! 7! E ', !*,4.! 4.

. , ! .' + / 0!! ! / !*,- 45 ' ,"

,. ! 8 + !

- +&!.!!!'," <? !1 " ,!! ! *,- 45.!!! % !!

,'!%%!6%' . !

-N! %&%"

!*,- 45

/ . ,%!6%'. 8 +!

-IE'

' /<? !1 " ,!,"%

' +0%. & !1 " . ,!%".-" %" !' <?<?!

/ ! *, 4. "

'' -, ''' !.3, ! 5!"!& "

/ ! !'",! ," -!% ,"! "

;%"! , ! 1! !- ! 5! &! ! +. ,2 !%, !

.!!. ", ! !-!' ''' !1 "5! +<IE:/?.!

",--% '"2.,!'!"!,

!.!!.,,-.- -

%%%F2!".

'!-

+. !.! '

! '!E-! ! ". -.,-!

!% ' 5!,%'- " =,.,0, * 1 !E !%"!

'!" !

,3 -

'! !& -!

. ,3 D -&! !',-!

. %,

%! -&! ' !6%'!'

! !," !! ! !" 1 5!!

.!*"' ,-!1, . ,' . -!

"',-! ;- 2! ' ' !" ,"

! !

! 2- 3! '

! ' . '

/& <?<,?<?<? !*,- 45 &! 9

2-, 0%. &3"% ! !',-!

- '

/<? !1 ". "

-3,"%

8 +

!,, %"%,!

'-!.!! .' !E-%! ! -

& ! &!. !! /

!*,- 455! -%I%! ;- -%! ' -, -! !

' !*,- 45 !! . !! -' 5! & 3 . %

. "

- !! 8 Q . %

'!!! ' ;-, % %!. !

-0 8 +, !E'

/<? ! 1 "&! +3,- !*,- 45!,"%

+%. !' ,!!

% /<?<? !1 ""% ,;<

=,.,0, * 1 5! &3 . %

!*,- 45 0%. /<?<? ! 1 "&%

! % ! ;- . !

3,-!*,4.!,"%

8 +!33,-' E +& ! & ! ' "

-&38 %

5!"',- !

%:P:% ! ", - !

! ! 3 !%" 8 ,

%!1 "!

<?<,?<? !*,- 45 .!!!1

"! !

% / ! !

. %" + 3 !33'9 '! ' / *,- 45&! & !,! , ", ,--! '" 3' / ! *, - 4 5. -

5!&% 8 &!

- " =,.,0, * 1. %

!%- !- ',"! 8 !*"'&!

! , ! E ", - , E - '2"

,;<

=,.,0, * 1! ,

' ,-!;>, E,-% !' ,./<? !1 "&!3

! ' ! + "

-3,

,"%

8 +5! &!%"

, ! &!1 ! .

.!"F% %!

-% ''! 0 "$1 !6$

.''%2('>