Hawa Singh And ORS v. Bul Singh And ORS

    

      

 !" #"$%&%'() * +%',- '#!-".&  /"!%!%'".& 0".&1& 12+%',- '#!-".& /"&3'#"'!&
 
 
    ."&"'!( .++ ',* '4#5$ !" .!-"3"!%!%'".& .+16%!+ ',* '4#5$ !" .."&3'#"'!&!) 777
     89

- 22"'," %' !-" ."5%&%' 3"!%!%' %& ! .#". ''":1." ; # !"#< 3 &&"#=>!-"2" .'"###%!%' 2 %5%21#,"
+.%54

- .?-% #.%.#".%',$%5%2%63.%&'6"'! !-"3"!%!%'".& . 3".%# !-.""6'!-&' $$1'! !-"3"!%!%'".&$." !%', -1.#2"%'!-" .""1& ," !-"3 && ,"=>!-"."&3'#"'!& 89 .%"

$!&   !-" $ &" 2" #%', ! !-" %2%',   !-" ."5%&%' 3"!%!%' ."!- !5%#"@1#,6"'!# !"# A  !%!2"# &12+%',- '#!-".&5& 12 =+%',- '#!-".&* &#"$.""#=>!-"

1.!   !-" 2" .'"# %5%2 1#,"
. %54 - .?-%  #.% '# !-" 3"!%!%'".&;."&3'#"'!&C&*"."."&!. %'"# .6$." !%', '>-%'#. '$"%' !-" ."" 1& ,"   3 && ," 2>%', ' D"&!".' #22   E%22  &<<CCA '#

CCA '#&%!1 !"# !5%22 ,"%62%%"3 && ,"- 5%',*%#!-  ""!' !-"*"&!".'&%#" !-"& %#?- &. '16=".&*-%$-- #=""'2"

! .%',."&& '#1!,."&& !-"."&3'#"'!& 89 -" ."&3'#"'!& -"."%' %2"# ' 332%$ !%' 1'#". .#".  12"  $632 %'%', -%'#. '$"=>!-"3"!%!%'".&;."&3'#"'!&C&

89 %'!-" .""1& ," ."& %#3 && ,"=>!-"."&3'#"'!&-"2" .'"# ##%!%' 2 %5%2 1#,"
+. %54 - .?-%  #.% 5%#" @1#,6"'! ''":1.";4# !"#< -"2#!- !!-"3"!%!%'".&C&*"."5%2 !%', @1#,6"'! # !"#  A
''":1." ; '# *"." '! 22*%', !-" ."&3'#"'!&!1&"!-"3 && ," .%',."&& '#1!,."&&!* .#&!-"%.-1&"& '# !1="*"22  $$.#%',2>4 !-" 332%$ !%'1'#". .#".12"   * & 22*"# '# !-" 3"!%!%'".&C& *"." #%."$!"# ! 1'#"., $%5%2 %63.%&'6"'! . 3".%# !-.""6'!-&%'.#".!"' =2"!-"":"$1!%' @1#,6"'!# !"# A
''":1."; 8A9 ! !-" !%6"   3."2%6%' .> -" .%',4 2" .'"# $1'&"2 . !-" 3"!%!%'".&&! !"#!- !-"#%#'!$- 22"',"!-"%631,'"#.#".'6".%!&=1! $'

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

-" 3"!%!%'".& &! "& !- ! #1.%', !-" 3"'#"'$> !-"3.$""#%',&4!-"6 !!"- &=""' 6%$ =2>."&25"#="!*""' !-"3 .!%"& '#!-"=&!.1$!%'*-%$-!-"."&3'#"'!&*"."$632 %'%', - & &%'$" =""' ."65"# '# 1.!-". !-" 3"!%!%'".&C& 1'#".! " !

122>$632>*%!-!-"@1#,6"'! '##"$.""# !"# A
''":1."

89 ;3 &&"#=>!-"2" .'"# %5%21#,"
.%5 - .?-% #.%%' %5%2+1%! AB %'$ &"!%!2"# &12+%',- '#!-".&5& 12 =+%',- '# !-".& 8B9 F" .'"# $1'&"2 . !-" ."&3'#"'!& ' !-" !-". - '# *-%2" #6%!!%',!- !!-"=&!.1$!%'$632 %'"# - #=""'."65"# '#!- !%' !-"$%.$16&! '$"&4!-"."&3'#"'!&#%#'!*%&-!33&"!-"$2 %6 3"!%!%'".& . &"!!%', &%#" !-" %631,'"# .#". "&3"$% 22> %' 5%"*   !-" &&1. '$" ,%5"' => !-" 3"!%!%'".&C& !- ! !-"> *12# 122> $632> *%!-!-"@1#,6"'! '##"$.""# !"# A
''":1.";3 &&"#=> !-"2" .'"# %5%21#,"
.%5 - .?-% #.%%'  %'$ &"!%!2"# &12+%',- '#!-".&5 12 =+%',- '#!-".&F" .'"# $1'&"24-*"5".4$'!"'#&!- !!-"."%& '"2"$!.%$32"%'!

-"6%##2" 3 && ,"%'&! 22"#=>!-" 2"$!.%$%!>"3 .!6"'!%'.#".!&1332>"2"$!.%$%!> !!-"!1="*"22%'&! 22"#%'!-" %"2#& !-"3"!%!%'".& 89 F" .'"#$1'&"2 .!-"3"!%!%'".&&! "&!- ! &3".%'&!.1$!%'&  !-" 3"!%!%'".&4 ' 332%$ !%' *12# =" 65"# => !-" 3"!%!%'".

."!-" 2"$!.%$%!>"3 .!6"'!."G1"&!%', .&-% !%', !-"32" .6!-" 6%##2" !-"3 && ,"!!-"%. %"2#&*%!-%' 3".%# )# >& .6!# > 8<9 -"& 6"& !%& %"&2" .'"#$1'&"2 .!-"."&3'#"'!& 9 ' !-" 2%,-!   !-" 3&%!%' & '!"# =5" & 2& !-" 1'#".! ?%', !-"3"!%!%'".&!&$.13121&2> #-"."! '#$632>*%!-!-" @1#,6"'! '##"$.""# !"# A
''":1.";3 &&"#=>!-"2" .'"#

%5%21#,"
.%5 - .?-% #.%%' %'$ &" !%!2"# & 12 +%',- '# !-".& 5& 12 = +%',- '# !-".&4 %631,'"# @1#,6"'! #%."$!%', !-" 3"!%!%'".&C& ! 1'#"., $%5%2 %63.%&'6"'!  !-."" 6'!-& . 5%2 !%', !-" @1#,6"'! '# #"$."" # !"#  A
''":1.";3 &&"#=>!-"2" .'"# %5%21#,"
.%5 - .?-% #.%%'

8A9

%'$ &"!%!2"# &12+%',- '#!-".&5& 12 = +%',- '#!-".&4%&&"! &%#" &!-"":!."6"&!"3  .."&! '#%63.%&'6"'! * & .#"."# *%!-1! ."&.!%', ! !-". 3!%'& . &"$1.%', $632% '$" *"5".4%'$ &" %21."! #-"."!!-"1'#".! ?%',!$632>*%!-!-" @1#,6"'! '##"$.""# !"# A
''":1.";3 &&"#=>!-"2" .'"#

%5%21#,"
.%5 - .?-% #.%%' %'$ &" !%!2"# &12+%',- '#!-".&5& 12 =+%',- '#!-".&4!-"."&3'#"'!& *12#=" !2%=".!>!! ?" $!%'%' $$.# '$"*%!-2 * 89  ""#2"&& ! 6"'!%'4 '! '2> *12# !-" 3"!%!%'".&C&

122> $632> *%!- !-" 1'#".! ?%', ! '! 5%2 !" !-" @1#,6"'! '# #"$.""# !"# A
''":1.";3 &&"#=>!-"2" .'"# %5%21#,"
.%5 - .?-% #.%%' %'$ &"!%!2"# &12 +%',- '#!-".&5& 12 =+%',- '#!-".&4=1!!-">*12# 2&65" ' 332%$ !%'="

."!-" 2"$!.%$%!>"3 .!6"'!*%!-%'!-"&!%312 !"#3".%# !%6" &3".#"! %2&,%5"' =5" '."$"%3! !-" 332%$ !%'C."3."&"'! !%'

.6!-"3"!%!%'".&C&!&-% !!-""2"$!.%$%!>32" .6!-"6%##2" 3 && ,"!!-" %"2#& !-"3"!%!%'".&C&4!-" 2"$!.%$%!>"3 .!6"'!*12# ! ?" 33.3.% !" $!%' %' ."&3"$! !-"."! %' $$.# '$" *%!- 2 * ":3"#%!%1&2> 3."

". =2> *%!-%'  3".%#   !* 6'!-& .6 !-" # !"  ."$"%3!  332%$ !%'C."3."&"'! !%' 89  "5%&%'3"!%!%' 22*"#%'!-" ."6"'!%'"#!".6& 
+D 2%  )   1#," 6%!

1.

Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No.

2.

Whether reportable :

Yes/No.