High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2113/1990allowed

(O&M) Mahipal v. Jaibir

2015-01-22Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri12 pages

"!#$!%&$ & "'&() &$$!* + !"

,-+.'

/ 1 !) #

+ !

"!/!

,-+.'

/ "

!-$+) !

+3/

# $"%

&#'($"% & $"% " )))) 4 # * " " " * +"*, " " "" -

$ " !. "

"" "*$/($( !.$+"*,""

& 0 1"" 2 ( " 0 !* "

, +"*, & ! ( 0 3 %$ !*

" ! & 0 1

/ "* *

4, 5 , &"" " "

"" - * " -467! #857"!., &"4" "5

$( + "$(. ."$!"* *

$ ""

" " , &" 9 ( 3 " %" * """"" 467!#:5' "

" .#

"" "!* " 9"0, . ""467!#85 ((" $( ."%

&% & " "": 8 #

"" " !."*% "!., #

." " " ! "

,**, " "" % " " !. 3*

;

.% " & "+ ";

"<( "!.,., $

= " ""("

.7" % " ""

("" " " " "" ""( " ", &"" 3, "

""467!#85("

.7"" (

.",".".7"

,"( ", " ""

" " " 9"

0, . " *% " !. , " ." ! "," > $$ & "

(*"

(% "

.3"!.

" " "

" " " 9"0, .@ ? ""

"" "@>##

? "" -"" -

$ ( " $ ( .

" % " ""

: 8 >## 2 ? *% " !. , , $ (,@>## ? " "

=, % ""$ (

@># : ?

.% " "+ "@>#

2 8 ? ,!

,@># - ' " %%" A "

& " *, "%"% !

""" " %

1 "

2( """ % " " 1$:"8 ( """*" ""& 0 1,

"" " ,,!

9"0, ." "" ""

,( "!." "" " (

."$ ""467!#85(!"* *

/*** %" * "+"*,"" $ " " !

" " """ "*$/("+"*,"" "!. & 0 1"

(","( " (" #

!* ** %" * +"*, "

" "" -

!. " & 0 $

" * " , ", $ !

< (( " 1 % " $ "%$ "

$ &# '($ "%$ "

& $ "%$ "

""* * " 1 " (, " * " $ ! < ( "

, ", $ ! !

< (% %", $! <

(

! "" , !"""

!. (. * " , % % ! < "* " ( (

""""" 467!#:5(% "

.7"

"( "<( . '

(*! < ( % %" ( < " ,""!.& !.(.

* " ? "! " """" 467!#:5(% ""@ ? "< .@

? "" 67! #8 ! * - "" -( . @ $ "%$ "

, .3 $

( (

""!." ", &"! * "

"""" 467!#:5"

: "(, "

$ " , $ , !

% ".(.9(% $&#'($"%$ "

* & $"%$ "

"" " " ( % , ," #

,"("% "$( % "

" 9" " "

$ :4

"$B'C5$ "" "

!","! " "%

(

," ""

,"$

" , .

!","! %"" "!. "!.""% , .>"$" * ""* , .(, *

! "" "!, 9"

0, . . % *

( , . % B' C$ " ( ! % "

. ," !

" !. "% , . $ ""

" " , .

! % : B'C$ % " , % * "","

8 &

, " ! ," , ( % " " %" 1 *$"""$

% ,. *%*"3*"3 , , " * ! 9D!

E+ 9* &

$ 1

2 E+ 1" %( ( 7 " !. 9D!

/,!.9*&

/,!. - ( ""(!.

9D!

, & !""

#$ 4

5 &&

"* ""* , .

(, * ! "" "

!, 9"0, . . % *

( , .9$%( ( ""(!.

9D!

,& "%(7 "!.9D!

E+ 9*& "9D!

/,!.9*& % 4 5" % 4 5$" ! * """"% """ , % "" !"!.*%" !!" ..* "" "

% ,"

("% * " ,". % "" %

$% ".

- "

(<%

", &" ( ( " ( .

(% "

3"!., &"'7 * "

" "" "" ( %" %"+"*, 7!#-"" 67!# 6% "* "+"*,"" (","%"+"*,67!# ". " 67!# ? ""*%

-8 -:"+"*,"" "!. "

"" "*$ /( "" - 2 -8 (

*"!., &"4" "5'(.,

"* % ". "

" . (,*7( "( !+ , " @ #

"" "!* "" .

%* ! %" !. !. " " .

9"0, .# ." "* & ! ( , " , "

" . 7 ""$ & 0 1" * .3%(( ""* ""67!#8((. . A "& 0 1" " ,.

#? 9 *"#?,F, ""!." "((. .A "

& 0 1" * .! %" "*!.

(. ( , " !. " " $ ( ,(( .(" " 7 ""' "*!.(. ( , !. " " " < ( "

*,"" ".".,"" *

"* ,,$ ""67!#8 ( "(!* " *. " ' ( !+ " < "

A " & 0 1 ( * ( * "*"", .%"!.(. ""67!#8" "

."",3.

,3 !

< . "* ."

" " : 8 $

" " % 2 : " , &" 3*+ " ", &"

, * ""( .&% & " " "": 8

!. *" " , &"

, * ""

, "

( "!." " 2 -2" "

"!.&% & A " 0 1(+ "

,3*! % !.% " , " " "3( "* "*+ "

. (

"* . + (

"" "*!3

* " " (

" " " ,%

*', %

" " " (%*3( "* * " &%

& !. *" "

, * " " .!". " " " %* ," .

< . " ( !* " !. " " (. . 1" %(( "!.& &

245#A -!

" !

","! "< . 2

D9"A( 6"

$* $"( ,* +9"

, .

, ** + , . .$

, ** !" < .

, **$"!

" , ** % ( . $ ," "! "< .7 . "" .

"1 $ ,**"% "

( %* "

""( .!+"

* "" "$ " " " ""

.(. . % " " A "& 0 ,"

! , (.! A "& 0 , .

3 ,

, "* "$*

.$( "

. "* ((< * .

,%" "" $" . "1 "!<"!.( % !. !* $ ( " % ""

9(% $! %% !

. *

" ""3"% * "

*1 " ( ( ** "*' % " , % ""

..* , ( "* " . (" " *" !, "

"*, "" 1%( !%"$ "

""+"*,""

& 0 "" -

"!. """

"*$/( ""+"*,"" "" 2 "!. """ ! "*$

/("

,""

"" " "" - * " - % " "

"!"* *

"$ "* .$

" "*" " 5 6 &/-&(114178