M/S Beli Ram Sareen And Another v. Santosh Gosain
!"#! $%! & #' $(" %!
!)*# +)"*+!#(!
!&,! -#+)"*+!#!(" ...
/#(!!*( #!"!""0100 )23! %4 (" 56 # 3! !" * 73"- ! * + ) 5 + *" 8## # (( " 56 # (!( 3"!
!"!03 #"* %!"3!+09 !#!#:%;
!!,-#"#!("""8" " <!#,*" !6+(!#
5!!!" (!#!!- 3 #! 3!6 " + ! * ! # (3!( ""-#(!!*(!#3 )23!% 8 " 56 # ( (! - # "" !(" ! "!6 =3 "!- # "" #" *! # * (#,,+8##8(!(!(!6 ( >09 0+
!* ( 2+%!,- "+ !,+) 5 3
6"!5" #( #!!!!!"#:3(!(!6; ""!# ""(6(!
/#3(8##""8 *!# 3(!(!6! # -! ""40/# 80 (! #/# #"5("! 009 090%! 38(")3-309+8#!! ! 009 #" 5 (" 5" # !6 #!- /#
8"#*5! "*" - ""40 /# 3 8 ((" 56 86 8! )23! % /#3 #""5- 3"!#( " # 8! " " ? 8 *!!" # # "" 8 !3-"@#3(!(!63"!# "6 :A# @; 3##!"8!,+53#""#"!" ( 5!*- #+ # ( #"
6 !" !5 6 ! *#""! #3(!(!6!3 8##3! (! =3#"5 "56#""-#( + 8## 8 ("- " # ( #" 5 !!" ! !5 6 "(-#""! #3(!(!6 1 /#!!+ # !6 8 "" 56 # ( +!3 8###!38 "56#""- #BC &>D"#( +8##8 ("-"#"" #!8!!!"! !5 6"-# !6 ?8*!!"##(3!( -#38##! # "" ? 8 *!!" # # ( 8! 5- 53 " !3!3 (!#*- !!"#(3!
(--# 3(!(!6*"8 #!8! *# 3!-# ("6#3+(( 3"! !"!03 % )23!% 8 *"56#( +8##8 "## "# !6#!- 3-+4+1 80098!
3"- " # # ( #" ((!# # # "" 83 "*#3(!(!68#3(6-6#-E*# # -#3+#3"- 38+1+1 4 ?8*!!"##""#"((!"5!#3! 100053#"("#!!! !3 8##+ #"8 5 5!3, 9 /#(( 8(("5686!( 6 )23!%1 ? 8*!!"##""83"5 5 !(!+# "! 83 " 5 (" " "3!- # (!" -! ,"8
!#+# 3 "5 "?8 *!!"# #" ##""##( #"!3"3 6 5 #!-- " # #6 8! 3#!F" #!- # ?8*!!"##( 8!#8!#3 (!(!6 &" (3-" !"! "" 0100 )23! %4 + # (( 8" " "-# -#(!!*( ?#*#!" !"3 !#(! 0
!)*# + !" 3 !(!- # (! ( #!33 63!-"##! 3!!!"" -# (( "3"! !"!03 %!!,-#"# !(" "" D!"3 #!!!"#(!*#
!"! 0 3 % " # 35 " # * + # " (!* 83 " (( 6 )(! ! !!!- # ( + # 8! +#(( *"3"! !"!03 %+!( 6#! "#3!6(!*+ !"3 #!!!"#!"!(" 56!" ##3!#(!!*(! "#35 "##"3#!("5!#3! ,3!!,-3#"?#535 "
# ( (!"- 8! " - # !(" ! 3- # !"! (" 56 # !" # # 5!F !?3((!#+ !"3 !#((
# ( " ! 3( # =3"- #
!"## %"
!& ' $ ( )%*
*%
!" ## %" ! +
,--*%( * .-
& !"0#1!#/
(
"## # "!21 (/ # #/ ) 3 2
*
3 4 5 &+1611 00 + !" 3 !(!- # !(" "" # 35 " # #!
- 6 ! ! 6 # (3-"!"!"##(!!#8!#3 (!(!6 ?#535 "# !-3"## (! ! # 8! # 3 (!(!6+ # 3( !(! 3 #
! -# ! #!(" !3 8###!("8
3!3"3 C8*!+ (G3!6!"56#3!+ !"3 ""#0+ # #5(" 0 ?#*"!"#35 "56 !"3 !# (! 0
!"!03 % 6"83"! 70 -8 4
9
!
9%%* / %: ; (
< 99 9 9
=
/
"4
8%
9 9%
9
9
%
9
3$
9 / /9
3/= 9
33 = %%
9
9
=
/ / 8 /8
*
9
3 =
/*
/ / 8 %% 3 9
% % =
/%/ * *
<9 / 9 33 % 9 9 % /< =
9
/ / 8 /8 /%/ 9
/ 83 $
9 8 "
< 99
>?=% @ ?=
;9
;/ 9 *
9
/ // *
/
9 3
/ % 9
>?=% @ ?=
;
/ / 8 / ;/
/ *
3/=
33 = 3%3 % / 9
9 / =
9
9
/<
3 ?3 = ?
9= %3%
= 39 % %
33 / 9 =
>?=% 6 "@ ?=
;/%/ ;/ /
/*
3/= 9
33 = / 9
9
/<
3
?3 = ?
9= %3%
= 39 % %
33
")
/<
9
< 99 / 3
=
/ 8 8 %9= $
3
=
/ *
9 9
9
?=
9 *
<
8
" 3
/8 6" @ / =
/ 8 * *8 =% 99: $ 3 * *% %% $ 3 9 =
- 3% / 8 =% 99
= 3
3
9 / =
: $ 9
9 / =
3%
3% 8 =
8 3 8% 33 /
=% 99 9
9 3 / 8
%%* * * / ; * 9 6 && "C 0 ?# !"!#$%&$' 3(! +!" # # 3! # " # # 5! (!* !"! 0 3 % , !! (!3"3( 83 ",! 56 !!!*!6("!" -!3" 3(-*!#!#(( 5 6#(!*
1 7 4 $ 3
% ==
8 %9 9
= 8 / 8 9 = 3
%=
# % 03 0 -8 D D / / /<
/
%
9
8 % 9
3$
9 =
9
33 = @ ?=% 6" 3
# % 0/<
?=
/% / /
/*
3/= 9
33 = / 9
/=
==%
" @ 3
% 3 3 =
8 %
% =
* % / 3% / 9 3/= 9 / %
8
# % 03 %==%% 3
9% *
%%
9
3$
9=
@ 3
%* %
/ - / 9 )/8D (
0
$D /%0
.4# &12 )/8!
6 ( - ' * " % * 3
9 0
3 (/%%
.3
( !
3
% = $
@ *
?/
9
9 =/ 93/=
33 = * ( !
3 /=% %
9
3$
9
9
33 = @ * =
% * %%$
= $
3% / /
9
33 = @ % %*
% =*
$ %8%
6&# %
0/<
=
8%
8
8 =
*% = =
*/
% 8 = /9 = =
9
33 = 2 4* %9 8
$
9
# % 0 /<
3/= 9
33 =
%9* %< 3
93% /8% 9
3$
9=
9 /
9
33 = $
3
9 ==% 38 9 = $
@
9)/8D * %% 9
3
4 =% 99A 3
% C 0 ?#()*&+% ), 3(! +!" ## 3!+8# -#(!* !"!03 %+# "## (!* !"!03 %! "!6/# #"# # ((
#! #" 5 !
- " * " # (( 3"! !"!03 %##8 5 (6#! " # "3+ #!!+ 8 #8 # # 8" #! #
"
"6" ( 68##!"!#3!/# ## "# *8#!+#!85 +#!8 !!8##!"!3"!(( 01 ? # $' --.(/ (,$(.(" 3(! + !"
##3!# "##3-# !"!03 %(!*"## (( !!,-"#3 " *#!#!-+# 8 5 -" (6 # ! #!3-#3 # ("6 # (!"-"#2+#!!+(( 3"! !"!03 %83 "5 5 *5 "- 04 *!-##(!+(!#(( *"3"! !"!03 %+#!(" "" 8!!! " !6 #!- 8 009 " # 3 3"-# -#(( 8+4+1 ?# 5 5! " # # (( 8 " 5!+ " * #!!+ 6!
#*-56"*- (6#5 ("?#"!"(#3!+#! 3!!!"# "- # # 8! #" 5 " " 3 #" 5 ! "+#(( 3"! !"!03 %8 5 ? *8 8# # 5 # " # =3"- !!!" # (!"- (!-!(#+#*8#! 3!35 /#!6#!
9 *!6 (!(# !/#""((!5(! 8# 6"*3!" (#!#( #,- 6+ !-#009*- (6#5("E*8## !*(8 "5!#3!+#(!
6!!*" 5 "8-!"##!(" "" 83 " (6#!!!!!H0 (! #! 730
" 8 G3"
/# !"! "" )(! + (" 56 !" #!"3"! 7 3
%9 =
9 /
= =
=
=
- % 8/ $
3
< 33//
3 / *
9 8/
4
9
8/ =
$ %
= * % =
E #
=
/ 9 / '
& %% * B %%/ @ 9
%%/ * % 8 =
*
% * /9 /
3 %%/ * %%8 =
/
9
@ / =
/8
=% 99=
B
93 9
% @ / * %8 839 %- 3
% %
3
== 8
= 99 $ 9 =
8 9
? 9
.
-
6 . 3= 9
8 =%3 9 9
3 3
C 09 /#3 (8"56#!" ## !" !"! "" # 2 " #!-+ " #3!- # " + # !(" #-" # 3 /#!!+ 8 3 8 --" )! #+ + #
#35"#""--*3"!,-#3 ,# 83 "5("8#(!"8 #! #""! - 4 ,#83 "5("#23! # 0
900+3"!,-8--*## 3 ! "#!"!""83 "5("8#(!" 8,/# !8#"=3!"0"5!*8 " 56 # 3! # # !(" 8 !6-
# (!"- B"!#!3 +#8383"#!(" 8#6 ((!"-5"-#! 7
!
6 9%%*
* =
8
: ; 3
%9 =
9 /
= =
=
=
- % 8/ $
3
<
33//
3 / *
9
8/ 8
4
9
8/ =
$ %
= * % =
E#
=
/9 / '
& %% * B %%/ @ 9
%%/ * %8 =
*
% * /9 /
3 %%/ * %%8 =
/
9
@ / =
/
=% 99=
9
B
93 9
% @ / * %8 83 9 % - 3
% %
3
== 8
= 99 $ 9 =
8 9 8
? 9
.
-
6 . 3= 9
8 =%3 9 9
3 3
C @
9
6 (
( .$3 ** ==
9
= =
9 * *9 / 3
9%%*
* =
8
:
0 ;. $
(
< * *9 /
3
= *
3
% 3 3
3
0
/3
==
8 9%% / 3
9 =
!
6 ) /% $
% 3
%9
= * *9 /
/
#
= =
= 9
*
< A
3
% .
- 1 +
6C ? 9
1 +
6( < / ( .$3 ==
9
= 9
=*
9 9
/ @
9
&
6 89
=
< = /9# 6
* =
9
/
= =/ 9
9
* 3
'
& * %
<
/ / 9 # +
* % % 8 = * ? !/ /%
* %8 = 8 + 9 3 / 3
* - 9
1
6 @
9
1
6
< * 8 %9 9
= * * =
3 =/
9
&
6 %%8 = * =
9
*
< 3
%9
8/
&
6 8
3/=%
*
=/ 9 # 6
8
/
/%
* 3* 8 = 8+9 3/
= F*==% 3 8
F
+& 44
6
9 8
=
* 3%3 % 9
9
/ 4 % 8
8 =
8
9 3/*
* +9 3/
%9
8/
00
= 9
< 3/=% *
9
* %%9 %
8
9 9
$% ==% 3 D 9
8/
=
% $ %
9
4$ 3
%9 =
=
3 / $
/ ==% 3
9 3
= ==% 3
+& 44
6" 8
9 % % = 3
==
=
=
< 8
=
* %% 3
89 9
$% ==% 3 * 3
$ % 9
< 8
(
= $ %
*
< 8
% $ %
&
6 1
6% (*
F
= 9 +
! * 3 /= = 3
/=9 .3 &+ # =% (*
F 9 8 9
? 9
C /# """!#!(" "" "#!! 9+#
8-!"!8("56#!" # 7
44
! #&6
@
==% 3
(
09 =%3
3
=% * 3
* 3 /= = 3
8
= ( 3
% 9 ==% 3 8/ 3/=% 3
!
!3 9#
=
!
!. =3= 9
=
= 3 @ / == * 9
/ ==% 3 == 899 $ /
%%* # =%8*999 $
0
&
!
<
3 .3=
9 9
% 3
%9 ==% 3
=
9 #&6
#
6 #
= 8
F#&6
8
=
8 =% 99=
2
. ?
0+" =
8 % % ' '
" ./8% *
8 ==% 3
# % 0 9
< 9 9
= *
F 9 = *
2 6
@
=
= 8
%% = == 3 1 6
6
= = == 3 3
%4* 3 8 %99
=
- =
9
= =
* =/ 9 % 9
@ =
*
/ =
=
?
!
6 9%%*
* =
: ; 3
% 9 =
/
= =
=
=
- %
8/ $
3
< 33//
3 /
*
9 8/ 8
4
9
8/ =
$ 8 %
= * % =
E#
=
/ 9 / '
& %% * B
%%/ @ 9
%%/ * % 8 =
*
% * /9 /
3 %%/ * %%8 =
/
9
@ / =
/ 8
=% 99 =
9
B
93 9
% @ / * %8
839 %- 3 8
% %
3
== 8
= 99 $ 9 =
8 9
? 9
.
-
6 .3=9
=%3 9 9
3 3
0 .=
%9
* 8 3
*
=
*
9
= 99 $ ?
D*
3
%9
= % $ 9 * *9 / /
* 3* #
= * =
=
=
*
< *
3
% .33 % = 3
*
1 +
6 @
9
= *
=
8
3
% &
63 ) 39
< 9 3
8 *
=
3
!
6 =
99 $ 8
= 9 @ 89
= **
% *
3
%
<= /9# 6%<* =
9*/
= 9
9
* 3 *
'
&
/ / 9 # + %< * ? 9 /
9
D %
<=/%
8+9 3/@
&
6
: ;
0
=
9
/=
2
. ?
0+" =
8 %
% *
8 ==% 3
. ?
0 " 8 =
=% 99
!
6 9%%*
* =
: ; 3
% =
9 /
= =
=
=
- % 8/ $
3
< 33//
3 / *
9
8/ 8
4
9
8/ =
$ 8 %
= * % =
E #
=
/9 /'
& %% * B %%/ @ 9
%%/ * %8 =
*
% * /9 /
3 %%/ * %% =
/
9
@ /
0 =
/8
=% 99=
9
B
93 9
% @ / * % 8
839 %- 3 8
% %
3
== 8
= 99 $ 9 =
8 9
? 9
.
-
6 .3=9
=%3 9 9
3 3
; 4=
3 9 8$
99 $
6 %* 1!
44
6D*
99 $
9 8 %99
= @ 8 9
=
=
%*
3
%D
< = /9# 6%<* =
9 / 9 / =
= 9
9
* 3
'
& D 8/
/ / 9# +%<* %% 8 = * ? ! / D %
< = /%
8+9 3/ .- 1
6 .=3=9
=%3 9 9
3 3
; @
9
* /
3/ = 9
1
6% 3
%9
= #&6
9 /
= **
8/ =/
9
&
6 * %%8 / * =
9 *
< D$ 9 3// /
!
6
< 8 89
= **
% * 3
%
3
&
6
9
9 3
% 9 /
= **
1
69 $ %
*
< 8
$
6 *3
8% 9 +
! *
8
* 3 /== 3
0
/= 9 .3
&+ # =% * 3
8
9 9
$
==
*
8/
/
$ 8
/ 9 * 3
* 8
3
/
9 / 3
.3
3
< 8
=
3
% /
8/
!
6* < = =
D*
?=% 8
99
*
< 8
&
69%%* 8 1
6 4 93 3
3 8
=% = & 9
=% 8 * 99 $
=
8 8 / 83
%
! !
6
3
!
6"@ % = 9
=%
3 % =% 9
3 3 3 *
<
= / 9
% 3
% 9 =
= 3 9
*3
$
6 3
%9 3 / /
/
99
?=% 8/ 3
!
68
3
%* * < = =
3 / * %8
=
9 *
8/
/
9
< 9 /
= * *
1
6 * 3*
8
3
% 93 % = 3 8
.9
3
9
3 3 9 3 /
= #&6
"
9
*=
/93
3 393 / (
3 /= .33 % #
/< 3/= % 9
=
3
% *
3 / 9
/ 0 8 =%3 8
== =
) 3
3/
01 .
% 3
% 9 3 /
3
8/
9 /
3
/
= +9 99 $
&
! @ 9
* %9
* =%
=
9 99 $
* %
& !
. =3= 9
8 =%3 3 C 0 /# !" !"! #8 # 5!F ! 8## # !("#* "#!"!("56#3! )3
##3!+# "#.0 < ) ) #
&1 .4# 0 -8D " 2& # 8# #" 5 (" " # ! #" 5 "=3!" ! (6 + # 3! 56 # (!6 (6 # + # 3! 83 ""
8#(!3#3!"# 65I 74 33 3 * /-
%
9 = 9 = 3 ?9%%* 9
/=
3
/
%%*
3 9
3
/8
? 3
* %*
* ?
-
B = D*
*
3
=
% 9 3
3 / 3
8 3 % 9 9 % = 3 * %% 8 * %% * -
?
=*
!1 9 9$ 9 9 % = 9 3
/ 9 ?
9 3 -
! @
=
%%*
9
% 2( = /8
&+1
8
/=
3 9
4 3
3 / 3
9 3
=
8
*3
@ =
% 3
% $ 8
==
%
' % &1 C ?-#!3-##!"!("56#!" # ! + !-#"(3"!,-#*-5-*
04 !(6 #3"- 3#"*!6"+# 8 (" /#3-# # 3 8 (" + 53 # ! " "856#<3
#*!68
5(( "#(!8
!+(!8#8
3
6* #!"!("56#3!5 (! "-!?(! ## 8!#3( # +# - 35"(
" J(-*8#"!3 #+#* 5"3"5*+ 6#"#!(" ""
5 5!3,3(6 # "# (( 3"! !"! 0 3 % 8 !!3 6 " "+ * ,(-*8#"3#!("5!#3!+#3! 83 " # !, # " # !(" "" ?#5,"!(#!""3+#(!!* (
8""#!"!""0100 )23!%4 ("56 # 3! !" * 73"- ! * + ) 5 + *" 8## # (( "56#(!( 3"! !"!03 # " * %!"3!+ 09 8 " "+ " " # " ((
8" G3 6+ # " # !(" "" !3, %"-(( +6+#
""("
0$%/12 1314 *-!- Whether speaking/reasoned :
Yes/No K##!!(!5 A >