High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2276/1990allowed

Punjab Wakf Board, Ambala Cantt v. Mandir Guru Ravi Dass Pundri Etc.

2024-08-02Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj38 pages

'(')* ./'

*'+ ,-%

'12(2,-%

4 3

7 -

% &# $

.+' *

# + *

/#(0*# +

* $ "

,$ 01 '

8 + $% + !!"" (

2 *3 4 4 9 %

!"!( / + *31 #$% + 56!"! & '

' (%%)* +

+ ,

+ (

+ %34

6 %*3

!*3

4 #

# #%1 "% 4

+% % 4 $%

(!:,6; 4 #

+ (

.8#/ /+ +

*+ % %%% % * # + + + %

% +

4 (+ # (

% # + !5 + 4# #(

%% #

!5 % 4 ( + #( #+ 1

4 ( #+

* 01 '

% % 41 (

% .

#% + :

01 + *!:5

+4 # +

+ <+*

4 ,

# +% %#

, $ 01 '

( $+

4 % ( % 2

$+ 4 4 %

+ + :6

01 + * !:5 , = = +

( ; 4# # + + ( '

+# ( % + + 4 - $+ 4 #% + 4 ( , ; 4 #+ + + + + #+ 4#+ ( ,

+ % %%% + +

%#* 4 1

(

+ +

/%4 (!6 5 / /

&,' 4 / / 4 % 1 1 $+ % % (

+ % # + .

+ !&

# +*!"; 4

% $+

(

& ,

; 4 # ,

4 4 4

+ + :

01 + *!:5 : > > + %

4 4

% ,

?@ 0 + :

01 +

* #

D> & &@ 0

(D> 4

0 4 %D> 5 0 $+ D> ( +

: 0

(4(

4+ + + D>/ 6@ 0 % D>/& @ 0 % >/ + !&

D "

"@ 0

+ $+ (#

D>/ !

!@ 8 E 6 + #+ +

* 4 + #

( ( AB0! C C%

@ 4 + ( ,

4 +

< % 8

+ %% * ; 4 #+

++ :6

01 + *!:54 +( + ,

%% 4

4 % ,

, % * %

( (4 + #

* 01 '

/ + *31 4+4% %( / +

* 3 1 # $% + 56!"!

# # + * 4 4

F$ %& 'H

4 F .2) 6782- .9)2(/.-H + + $%

(!:,6CA=,@;

4 =+ ( # + * #+

3 %

6 :4 3 +* + + :

01 + * !:5 , 4

(<+* " G+

, + $% +( + %

( + + :6

01 + * !:5

+ %4 % %4

% #4

4 %

+ = =%<++ $% %

+ ,% - ." () ( *)#() ,+ ,% - ."

! " !

# ! < < + +

AB/5 +( 4 4+41 ( % AB/:*

01 '

*4 >+ + 4 # + *

# * # ++ # + 4 +

; + (+

# + (( %

+ +

#+ *4++ #( 1 ;

; + AB/54 /+% ! 4

+ 5"!"

4 ( % % +

+ % ( < % ,

%# + + # + 4 (9 1

F '/ 4F .2) 6782- .9) )2(/.-H# #

$% , === === = ===

! === === = ===

< <% 4 + + * + + #

, <% % 44 + (+ %41 ((+

01 * %+ %4 41 (8+ + $% %

6%%+ ,% - ." 0(!) ( *)1 # = + + , === === = ===

# $ 22+ , ." 2 111 () ( ( *)! 4 & === === = === 8+ + $%

< H % %

,% - . "+ - (5) %

3 0() ( * *)00*4 4( < H % + ( 4 + 01 (* ( +

+ * +

( +* * # 4% 4

+ * # # + "

A#++ # = +

+ ,

0 # # & &

# # # # &

' ( )

* * #

' + , --+ .

.' +/ , -+01! + % $% %

,% - . " + ,% - %

%11 (#) ) ( *)!# = + ,

(

-+08++)6 7+

&03

" 2

-% %48%()6 78

# 2

-45849 ) )6 78% & 03 .(831

# # 7 ' ) ) #

# :

7 ;

& 03 7 ;

' & )6 785 # , , "

" ;

* * &03.(831 1 2

-%58%9 # 7 '

# - -)6 789 @ & & # , , 6 # 7 < '

$ 07 <, $ -+0 7 <,

= 6 # '8 .51 ' + &

# &03 ( ( #

# > $ 5333?8 & 0 7 '

# #

, ) )6 785 & )6 789 " ) )6 785 & ) )6 789 # 6 =

, 7 "

# #

# '

' A .; 1 A$ / *

1 A$ / $ -4%' +%- ' + % @ B = , "

8 -04

< 6 '

' A C. 1

7 <, = 7 ;

/ / -49$ A$ 0%4 #! 5 +4% $% %

,% - ."

" +

% 10

* 4+ +$% ( 4 .

%1 3 * +

# +

+#( ( + +#

+#(

41 '

3 !5

+ #

$% ,

9 '

# = < # , 2 5 %

7 * , ,% - ." '101,% - 2 !

!## 2 2

# # , = -04: #

< #

0 # A

2$ 3

(5 ) 23 * $

"(5) 23

'1 0% % 801 8 # ,

= # # D

# # 8 D : < < % +%

, $+ ( ( ( + + + (

< = % 8 +

< % < = % 8 8

4 +

(

+ +% *+ #

+ # 6 G +

* *% + + :

01 + *!:5 + ( .

#% + 5 %

#+ +

( +

#% 1=+

4 + 5

01 + !:5< + + A A=/,5 +( 01 '

+ (

( , + , % + + #;

%% *=

6,6:( = ++ %%%% < % A=&,5* 4+ +

(!" "6* +

3 <% # #% + 4 % *

5,:( ( = # ++

( %

#<% (+ 41

(

% ( + #

#+ +

+ 1 + 5

01 + 9 < + + /# # '+ $%

,% - ." + 9 5*

(#) (

( *)01!# = + + ,

< < # * E' 7 <, = 7 5333.517A A2- "

< #

< # $'

7, = = *

--(.51 7A2 %05

7 < , = C 5333.51 7A ;9 .

. 1

< #

% ' 9 3 , --+ , . 1

# . 1 = #

, = = , =

5*-* :-

#(),3 1

4"#

# 7 7 '

,% - ."< ( (%) %

* $ 2 , .

." 8() ); %9% #!! ( ) <

-% 8%5 -4 8 45 8= =

# 7 " 7 # -04

';" #

7 7 < , = = # *

$,8+;;77

5-5339

7 $,8 ,8+ < 7

> #! " < <% +

41 + ( .

#% + +* 9

#+ + < % +

+ %(>5

8 &

# +* !

!" 4 % # + 4 4 >8

# +* !"* +

$+ !

% & ;

; # +

+ # # + % # + 4 + & G+ #% ( ( + (

+ :6 6

01 + * 4#*

+ %* # + # # ( #

01 + *!

!:5*4+ , !

5" 1

# F G

1 F #

GH F.

1# .

# 88

F B@ G1 #

# H G F.

1 88 HG

# IG 666 666 666 01"F' G

# B 7 -3( ( .+ -3(1 # I .

.1 # 6

# H .

.1B #

H .

.1B # H .

1 # 6 H .

# # H .

.1 .

.+1 # B

F.%1"'

/ @

' B '

8 .51 .91 .01 .+1

8 . 1I 7

B 6

8 8 .91G 8 ,% ""

"=" .

. 1/

8 .91' 0 '

= = .

.51"= 6 8 . 1 / @ F ' ' 6 # 6 G G

# 666 666 666 80 "% 2 & & #

= #

6 # = #

&& % # +(

#* # # +

+ :6 + (4 + +

+ + :

01 + +

#% +* + 9< 4#*+ %

( # 4

+) + +* % ( '

& +

#% 01 + * !:5

4 #( '

4 + % =+

4 + : C&@

01 + * !:5 + +

&5 .

#% ( + %

) +

#% +

# + (

+ :6

01 + * !:5<+* *

( +4 +

+4 9

+ : :6

01 + * !:5 5 ; % %(

# 4 % $%

#8"0 >

+ ,% - ."

! & = + ,

- " # , = ;

; &5 )/ "

" < < # "

7 <, = = ' (- --+

# , = 3 A

< < # 7

' .7 <1 2 & * '

> 7 < , , =

5333. 1 7A$ -5

# &5

# #< # 5

< #

# # < # " 9 + #

&5 3 "

< # , = #

< #

* 7 * # " 2 * < 8 # # ' >#

--5$.*7190

# < #

# < "

# ! &: 8 + +

$% %

2 ,

(,% - ) 9%% % = 2 + ,% - ."

(),3 1*4 4%

( +8#

$ % ,

- B < # & # # "

! &6 % 4

4 ( 3 1 < %

2 %9

+ :

" ." 6 % ? " 1 8 114 %

6 -$ + $ . " # #!"10 0#"101 1 2 * #+ ( 4 %4 7$% 6

# + #+ (

01 ) + + +# 9 9 + $% %

6->.9

.80 ,.)+ +"

79.;.

.-// .-+ ,/<') )(

(6=). ,

# # + # + +* # (

+ A# + 5

01 + *!

!:5 + +

41 =

+ %%+%

+ + * 4#* +

++ + $+

+ + #A# (# (

#+ + (# #+ 41 # 7$% 6 # !5 & $%

/# '

$ 01 '

- /# % %% *( + +

+* ( #4

# +% ( < H %

+ % = ; +*

.% +( # + 4 %* #+

( 4 . %13 ,

+( (#+ 4 4 ++% + +% # # 4 + + ,

49 +

< 4#* # # % 4

# ++

# + + ( % = ( % < = % 8 8

+ %% % * &" ;

; 4 4 < =% 8

4 (

+ = ( 8

+ %( % $%

$ <( < %

+ 7%

@ ,A 1!* # = +

)67,+?

/ # #

35 3- --4

# # &

# ;, #

# ; & 5

"'8 # B 6 #

6 # * 6# /

6 # "

)67,+? * * #

3+ -(+6 8 8 #

) & 5

8 & &! ;

; 49 1 # 4 9 4

? + E 4 ?G G/ E<+* # +% 4 4*

4 % +

<+* # +%

* % , 4 +% ( # # +( ,

+ + :

01 + *!:5 # +* + ,

4 + +

+ # + + 4 + ;

0 + ( ;

+ + + :

0 + *!:5 * 4

# # +

( %= + , (

7)J7,-?

# $ ;' * *6 $#

7 $ ; ' 7,

C # $ ;

$ ;'

# # 7 # $ ; ' :

: ;

-4 ' &

$ $

* " & &5

# ;,

* *

03 7, # 7 -04

# 8 "

#8 &

# # #

+%, # 7

# " # #

# ,

# #

# -"

2 * +

, - - #

$ ;

; # # 7 < , =

= =';=';

* *

7 < , , = 7 <, , = # &993 # ( , 7 # #

6 # &993 "

" $ ;

6 <

# # $ ; # # -4 ' &

;

# ;

; 6 : 9 -4 "

7 <, =

# = 8

$ ; '

# # 7 < , = < 7 <, = = # $ ;'*

7 < , , =

$ ; '

# $ ;

# 2 # $ ;

# 7 < , ,

B '

$ $ ;' # .

1 '

# 7 < , =

# #

, = A ,

# 3 # & &993 . 8(1 D @ !

)67 3 -4+84% + .51 , ,

)6; 0

993 99 995 5 999 99+ 99% 9+3 #533 ( # 6 # # 7 * 6

&993 #

# # # + +

$ ; ' # 7 <, = >&'

# -((7A2 3

= ' + + .51

# #

# " $ ;' 6

7 # # # # # # $ ; "

-4 ;

;

* E$

* / 7 <, = 6 :B /

# * #

# # * * #

# *

6" B

# 03 2

;,5

= ' K =

86 ='; +853 #*

0380+

# *

# 7 <, =

$ ;' 0380+

" C , " ,

' ,

# 7

6 C

7 "

7 %38 % %+ '

# 7 7

& 6 # 6

7 '

# ;,5 2

038 0+ "" $ ;6 93803 " 6 -4 845' +,

$ ;

; '

# & 5 !

& ;

; # %

% #

+ 4 #4(%(( < = % 8 *+ +

+ +

( ,

+ + * 9 + + * # ( # 4 % # 4

4 + = =+ ('* +

+ % 2 %+ + + + (

+ +

% %(

%+ =+$ + # 4

5 ;

; * + ? + 6E?+ 6,E

01 + *!:5*# %= + , 5%

="I8 .

. 1 B

8 .51 + , ' ' =

I 7

8 .51 + + 7

# ' #

, . 1 -%- ) )6 8: % 6 D D # 8 . 1

8 . 1 % %

8 .51 + , . 1 -(0 #

# B .

.51&

# # 8 . 1

# # .

.91"' 8 . 1 #

# #

.01" 8 .51 + +

8 . 1 1 .

.+1/ , . 1 -(0 ' #

' B 8 . 1 0 ,=": % %

= ="I8 .

. 1 , . 1 -(0 B 8 .51' + ' , ' , = =

" # <

B " I 7

.1 # '

# ,

. 1 -(0

8 .51 +H .

.1 # '

' #

# , . 1 -(0

I 7

" B .

.51)6 " <

8 .+1

# #

# .

.91",

8 . 1 1 .

.01" 8 .51 + +

" 8 . 1

.+1"" <

8 . 1 % , .

. 1 -(0

: + 6+ 4

# % % + 4 ( %

+ + :C&@

01 + *!:5 I ( (*

+ + :C&@

01 + *!:5 CA=/,5@4 /+%! 4 4 ( !"

4 # +

+ + 4 +

+ # # + 4 ,

% +

+ #

+ % # * 4

% % '

+ +

:C&@

01 + *!:5

01 +%

+ * ,

+ + 4 + + #

1 + + +

6 +* %#+ + (* ( + % +

J * $ + =+ + ( % + 4 4 + + ( ( + + ( # $%

< H % %

+ 7%

B ()

10# = +

4 , 6

C C C

C CC < # ,

$ $ JA ' $ -%%

# 2 #

< # # # D/ JA$9 I / JA $9I L

# "

C #C

C C C

CCC

# # '

< # / JA$ $9 #

#= #

C C C

C8# 8

# , ,

F' $ $# ' /'L7I -( .

. -(515'9-( # G!

#+( + ( +

A#( + (

4 +( 4

% + + +

+# +# ++ %

#+ %

( + + % + + + + # 4 #

( 4 (

0 01 +

4+ %( #

% % 01 (% +

(

% %+ # 4< +*(9 +

+ + + 4

( + 01 (

" (* +

#+ + %

# % ( 4

! '

(+% (4 + # 1 + ( ! ; 4 + % * 4 # = + #*

+ + 4 # + 14; (% (4 1 (! ( (4(

(

( 4 ( # # +% + %

( *+*

%( # + (3 * 4#* % (

4 # +

1+ 4 /0&

% 5,5:(; 4# # % (

4 4 %

. 8# /

4 + +

% 4

+ = + '

# +1 4 # + 4 (

' 7 $% 6 6 <+* +

+ ( '

#+ % #

;+ +

=+* + + ++

( 5 + ++ ( 4

% % + (

1 + 4

(% 5 * %+ + C@* ( C@

++ ( 6?6(/

).> .),).

, , 3

C$ ,

#? I , I

IM?& IM?&