Rabinder Kumar Abbi v. The State Of Punjab Etc.

  

         

 ! "#$%$&'(')*  

"+')%$,-./",++'

$#'#')$, (!

0$,(.( 1#"#$.)2"+")%#3$,(  $(4)%$)# (!

 *  56  1 - 61  ,$($)#*7 ,"/'#-./",8%9&"#$8,#3$4$#'#')$, , 1"#3")'"8$4.#: .)2"+ , 3'#(3'8%9&"#$8,,$(4)%$)# ,-");",%$$41')<38%9&"#$8,8 ,11",.="8%9&"#$8,,$(4)%$)#

 3$#3$,#3$ $4,#$,(=&"=)$;(4"4$,/":+$"==;$%# ($$#3$2.%</$)#>  +$,$$,,$%##3$ $4,#$,,)#  3$#3$,#3$2.%</$)#(3.=%+$,$4,#$%')#3$%'<$(#> 77 77 - 61 

6!

3$4$#'#')$,;"(;,?')<"("1.4$,')#$)%$)#') .,.")"? $9)<')$$,')< ==$<$8 '== "%86.%3'")"8")%,$#',$%"((.&3)   

"#$,,$)%$,')<
:$",(($,9'&$3$&="'/#3$4$#'#')$,'( #3"#3$3"(+$$)4"'%<,"#.'#:"/.)#')<# (@8@7)#3$+"('(3'( +"('&4":")%)#)#3$+"('(="(#4":%,";)8;3$,$"(=$"9$$)&"(3/$)# 3"()#+$$)4"'%#'(&="'/$%#3"#"(4$, $<.="#')  '!#3$")2"+

)'9$,('#: "=$)%",80=./$78

@ 8#3$<,"#.'#:'(#+$4"'%)#3$="(# 4":%,";)")%#3$("/$'(#3$&"($=$"9$$)&"(3/$)# 3$("'%&==$<$ ,$(4)%$)#3$,$')!'("'='"#$%#

 !

77 ")2"+ )'9$,('#:3$")2"+ )'9$,('#:')#3$;,'##$)(#"#$/$)#3"()# %$)'$%  #3$  ("'%  ,$<.="#')  ")%  (#"#$%  #3"#  #3$  <,"#.'#:  ")%  #3$  =$"9$ $)&"(3/$)#3"9$#+$4"'%')#$,/( $<.="#')  '!#3$")2"+

)'9$,('#: "=$)%",80=./$78

@   $(4)%$)#3"("=(#"?$) (4$&''&(#")%#3"#'#'(#+$4"'%)+"('&4":#'((#"#$%#3"##3$2.%</$)# #3'( .,#,$<",%')<=$"9$$)&"(3/$)#'(4$)%')<+$,$#3$4$A .,# 3"9$3$",%#3$=$",)$%&.)($=(,#3$4",#'$(")%3"9$"=( &",$.==:<)$#3,.<3#3$'=$

$<.="#')  '!#3$")2"+ )'9$,('#: "=$)%",80=./$7 8

@ *7  '!

)"%%'#')##3$+$)$'#(#3$,9'%$)#.)%(8 #$"&3$,  "#  #3$  #'/$    ,$#',$/$)#  (3"==  +$  <,")#$%  +:  #3$ 9$,)')<+%:8"<,"#.'#:"(./$C.'9"=$)##)$.,#3 3'(4":
 ,$"&3&/4=$#$%('A/)#3=:4$,'% C."=':')<($,9'&$(.+2$&## D ('A#$$)")%3"=!#'/$(#3$ 4":4,9'%$%#3"#'))&"($<,"#.'#:(3"==$A&$$%#3$"/.)#"( 'A$%+:#3$.)2"+ 9$,)/$)#,/#'/$##'/$8,'#( $/4=:$$(E 3$"+9$("'%,$<.="#')/"?$('#&=$",#3"##3$<,"#.'#:'(# +$4"'%"(4$,#3$="(#4":%,";)8;3$,$"('#;"(4"'%+:,$(4)%$)# )#3$+"('(#3$+"('&4": 3$,$,$8#3$4$#'#')$,'($)#'#=$%##3$ <,"#.'#:)#3$+"('(="(#4":%,";)")%#3$",,$",(<,"#.'#:",$#+$ 4"'%;'#3')#$,$(#"##3$,"#$ F4$,"))./

$<",%')<#3$<,"#.'#:")%=$"9$$)&"(3/$)#8#3$/"##$,'( ($##=$%+:"'9'(')$)&3#3'( .,#')2/$,1')<30$,(.(1#"#$ .)2"+8

 !1 

$)&$8#3$4$#'#')$,'("=($)#'#=$%#=$"9$ $)&"(3/$)#)#3$+"('(="(#4":%,";) ((.&3#3$4,$($)#;,'#4$#'#')'("==;$%3$,$(4)%$)#

 !

77 '(,%$,$%#4":+"=")&$<,"#.'#:")%$)#',$"/.)#=$"9$ $)&"(3/$)#)#3$+"('(="(#4":%,";);'#3')#$,$(#"##3$,"#$ F4$, "))./)#3$%$=":$%4":/$)#<,"#.'#:/"%$$",='$,;'#3')#3,$$/)#3( ,/#3$%"#$,$#',$/$)##'==4":/$)#

- 61 !

      (2?( 3$#3$,(4$"?')<,$"()$% * $( 3$#3$, $4,#"+=$ * $(