Shamshad Ali v. Finaicial Commissioner Revenue Haryana & ORS
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
- - ./#0+/#( 1* ------ %$*$*&,%2 +
3%2+4+
&00*++*&,%2
%5%,4% #26#,#
&$/%2+
------
%+7&,(%,$ +
8 9 -
. .
2%+%,$ 2- .#,(%%7 3%20#,*:
(5&)#$% 7%$*$*&,%2-
2-
#;,%%+/ /#(<#1:
#26#,#- - - . :
-
9 - %$*$*&,%2
./#0+/#( 1* )*5*1 <2*$ 2$*)1%+ &,+$*$4$*&, ,(*#:
*,$%2 #1*#:
+%%=*,> <2*$ ,#$42% )%2$*&2#2* +%$$*,> #+*(% --
:
</%2%@6
#26#,# #))%7$%( 2%'%2%,)% 0#(% 42>#&, +%$ #+*(% &2(%2+ --
- -
:
7#++%( ++*+$#,$ &11%)$&2 +$ 2#(%:
42>#&,:
&11%)$&2:
42>#&,:
2%+7%)$*5%16- - 2*%'16:
+4*$
( 4,;#@ %,#,)6 )$:
AA
+/&2$ 8$/% AA )$8 @%'&2% &42$ ++*+$#,$ &11%)$&2 +$ 2#(%:
42>#&,B )1#*0*,> &))47#,)6 2*>/$+ 2%+7%)$ )&072*+%( C*11# &-
:
0%#+42*,>
0#21#+:
+*$4#$%( #$ 5*11#>% #$#4(*:
!*+$2*)$ 42>#&,-
71%#(%( )#+% /*+ #,)%+$&2+ /#( @%%, )41$*5#$*,>
D>#*2 0#24+*E 1#+$ 0&2% $/#, 6%#2+ $/%6 <%2% ,%5%2 %;%)$%( '2&0 ,&2 2#$% 2%,$ %,/#,)%(-
))&2(*,>16:
*$ 72#6%( %,$*$1%( $%,#,)6 2*>/$+ 1#,(-
- )1#*0 )&,$%+$%( &5%2,0%,$.$#$% #26#,#:
*,$%2 #1*#:
&, 71%# F4%+$*&, #, %5#)4%% 72&7%2$6:
5%+$%( <*$/ )4+$&(*#,
#, 4,#4$/&2*G%( &))47#,$-
#1+& 71%#(%( (&%+ ,&$ '41'*1 )&,(*$*&,+ )1#*0*,> $%,#,)6 2*>/$+-
- $2#,+7*2%+ ++*+$#,$ &11%)$&2:
5*(% --
:
#11&<%( +4*$ (%)1#2%( $%,#,$ &5%2 1#,(:
0%#+42*,>
0#21#+:
)&072*+%( C*11# &-
- - .$#$% #26#,# )/#11%,>%( --
:
'*1*,> #, #77%#1 @%'&2% &11%)$&2:
42>#&,:
/&<%5%2:
+#0% (*+0*++%(:
5*(% - -
:
@%*,> $*0% @#22%(-
- /%2%#'$%2:
.$#$% #26#,# 72%'%22%( 2%5*+*&, @%'&2% 42>#&,:
</& 5*(% *$+ --
:
0#(% 2%'%2%,)%
#26#,#:
2%#(+
!""
# $
%&
$ '
% (
% &)**+ %& ,*-*+. - 2%'%2%,)% )#0% #11&<%(
5*(% --
/&1(*,>
+ ' / 00 1-2 1 2
3 / 001212 4# /
4.
$
%
5
' 6
# /
&*+0
&*+0 / 7 "
/
#
8 )#9 / "
:
5 #
&);
$
! % <
&9-&**)
!"
.
# '
=
8 % &)*&**+ ,*-&**+ % % . - , #'&2%0%,$*&,%( )*2)40+$#,)%+:
)*5*1 <2*$ 2%1*%'
+:
,&$*)%( #@&5%-
- %#2(- -
7%24+#1 AA )$ <&41( +/&< $%,#,$ )#, /#5% 2*>/$ &))47#,)6 *'
&))476*,> $/*2$6 6%#2+ 7#*( ,& 2%,$ @%6&,( #0&4,$ 2%5%,4% $/%2%&'-
- <*$/*, 0%#,*,> AA )$ &,% (%'*,%( $/%2%&':
2%#(+
>?
> - *,$%2%+$*,> ,&$% 4,;#@ .%)42*$6 9#,( %,42%+ )$:
+/&2$ 8$/%
)$8 #(&7$%( (%'*,*$*&, D1#,(E >*5%, AA )$- (%'*,*$*&, H1#,(H A
)$ 2%#(+
>?
>
7 = $
&@@01AB&@@02 -
!*5*+*&, %,)/ $/*+ &42$ )#+%
!
*,$%272%$%( 72&5*+*&,+ A
)$ /%1( (%+)2*@%( #,;#2 I#(*0 )#,,&$ $2%#$%( (%$%20*,*,> +42714+ #2%# 1#,(&<,%2- /%1(
>
/ ,1@27 = / ?
$ > >
7 = $
C
> >
/ +1&27 = $
41 2
2 $
= =
=
$
#
> > $
> >
7 = $
" $
= =
=
> >
> - 9#$%2:
%,)/ $/*+ &42$ )#+% 2%7&2$%( "
#
$% /%1( 2%)&2(%( H/#*2 40=*,H 2%5%,4% 2%)&2(+ @4$ ,&$ &))47*%( &2 1%$ #>2*)41$42#1 7427&+%+ &2 7427&+%+ +4@+%25*%,$ #>2*)41$42% &2 7#+$42%:
,&$ <*$/*, 0%#,*,> A
)$- - &,8@1% .472%0% &42$ )#+% 2%7&2$%( & "
'( !
%$ /%1( (%+)2*@%( #;#2
#(*(:
#,;#2 I#(*0 #*2 40=*, 1#,(:
(&%+ ,&$ '#11 <*$/*, 7425*%< (%'*,%( A 4,;#@ .%)42*$6 9#,( %,42%+ )$:
:
)#,,&$ $#=%, *,$& #))&4,$ </*1% )&074$*,> +42714+ #2%#:
#772&5*,> !*5*+*&, %,)/ (%)*+*&, $/*+ &42$ )*+,- - &,)%(%(16:
)#+%:
(*+74$% 2%)&2(%( D- &. -E:
,&,#>2*)41$42#1 1&)#$%( &2 ,%#2 2%+*(%,$*#1 #2%# 5*11#>%-
/%2%'&2%:
(*+74$% <&41( ,&$ )&0% <*$/*, 0%#,*,> H1#,(H %,5*+#>%( 4,;#@ %,#,)6 )$:
AA:
&5%2
&))47#,)6 2*>/$+ )#, )1#*0%(- .*,)% &))47#,)6 2*>/$+ )#,,&$ )1#*0%( 2%+7%)$ +4)/ 1#,(:
2%)&2(%( D- &. -EB #))&2(*,>16:
+4*$ )1#*0*,> 1*#@1% (*+0*++%(- -
7%24+#1 *074>,%( --
<&41( +/&<
&00*++*&,%2 2%)&2(%( '*,(*,> '#)$ (*+74$% ,&,#>2*)41$42#1 ,#$42% 2%F4*2%0%,$+'#)$&2+ %+$#@1*+/*,> &))47#,)6 2*>/$+:
/#5% ,&$ @%%, 72&5%(-
'42$/%2 &@+%25%( )1#*0*,> /*0+%1'
#, &<,%2 ,&$ $%,#,$:
$/%2%'&2%:
)#,,&$ +4))%%( +4*$ %+$#@1*+/*,> &))47#,)6 2*>/$+- - 9%#2,%( )&4,+%1 '#*1%( (*+1&(>% '*,(*,>+ 2%$42,%(
&00*++*&,%2-
- , 5*%< #@&5% (*+)4++*&,:
$/%2% ,& +)&7% #,6 *,$%2'%2%,)% --
:
7#++%(
#26#,#-
A-
%+41$#,$16:
<2*$ '#*1+ +#0% #))&2(*,>16 (*+0*++%(-
- %,(*,> #771*)#$*&,
+:
*'
#,6:
+/#11 #1+& +$#,( )1&+%(-
.
!
- -
+;=+ /%$/%2 +7%#=*,>2%#+&,%(
"%+
& /%$/%2 2%7&2$#@1% "%+
&