High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/656/2003dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Darbara Singh Etc.

2024-05-30Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill,Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat18 pages

!"!

#$ % %

&$ '( &% ) * ) (( '( &% ) %)%)+,

"# $%

& $'

(

"# $) *** %)%)+,- % ./ % + & , - , #& %.%%'//' # 0

1 2

$%)" #& #

# %3$ ## 4 # # # # %5.36 2) '7 '

# #

# 89:

;< 890 2 #

# %3$ #+;< #2=

$%&'

(

() *+, ) (( () -%" () ,*% ( ( ( . //0 1( ) ( 2%!34+$-$ )

0 )( +', 5 ( ( . 1(( ) 0 ( 0 ( . .. (( . 6 (. ( 1 ( (.

(( 7) ( .

1( 1( ) 1 ( . ( ( 0 8 .

() (. ) ) ( . 2!

0 .

.0 (() 0 (9 .(( . (( ( ( ( 2!

( / )) (. :

( 1 ( . 7 (( ) ( 6 . ( .(. ( !

3 ) ( 7;2'

<4+*"& ( 0 ( ( 2! ((. ( ( ) (

( ( ) (

) ( (9(( (( ) ( (( ) ( . (( ( ( (( ( ( . ( (( ) ( (( (( 7) (.1( 1 ( . 6 (. 1 ( .3 (( (

(0 ( ) ( (( ( ( ( . 1 ( .3 (( ( (( (. (( ( (

. ((1( ) ( . (.

( .3 (( (

6 7) . ) ( 0 (( ( (

) ( ( ( ( )

0 (( )(( (( ( ( . (.) () . ( /: 9.. ( ( .. (

( 0 ..

. ) ( ) . /: 9..

( . ( 0

( (5 (( ) (

( ( . 7=3< > 6 ((. /0 1( 8 ( ( (3. (

6 7=3< > ( ((..9 .7=3< > ( . 7;2'

<4+*"& 6 ) (. ( .

6 ) (. .

0 3 ) ( . (9 .7 ) ( ( . ) '$) (<. ) ( . ( ( () 0 . 1( (( ( ( . 3. (

0 ( (. ( ( ) ( *! (. ( (. ) !%%

( (( (( . )

0 ( ( ) ( . ( ( ( ( .

?) ( . 7( . ( ( ( ( . ( ( 0 (( ) ( 0 )( (. ( ( . 9? ( . ( ( ( . ( 0 )

7;2'

<4+*"& (( ((0

(( .. ( . ( ( 0 (( )

( ( ) (( ( 7)

6 1(

.. ( $!. 73) ',) (. ( (( (( () ( ( ,*%. ( . ( 3. (. ( ( )

) ( .(( ) ( 9.. )( 0 ( 429 ( ',$''%%%'-!

. !? )

#, "

# %>)0 02 # ; . #

# %3$ #2 , ,

2# #, ? # # 9, @%0 (!2 22

0 'A%''/// /)/%'//% "89

" # $%5 2 $ ')A3 # + , 2 ! ;( , + # 9, @' 0 ! 1 , 2 ,

2 , B, <29, @) 2 # ,;<890 # !!89: + # 9, - @?2 ## #" C#

# 3/$ # # # , # + # 9, @3 D, ! 2 2 D # 0 1 'A%''/// " , , ;< #< # =9,

,2 #"# ,

# 2 , 2- ,+# , 2 # 2 , ,2 # @ #" , #2 0 ,, 2 #/? ,

#,2D# $

%55A 'E), ,!

20 # #2 0 2#!2 '3# # $ # ## # 2 # D # 2 ,2

0 , 2

# 3>$ # # # 2 # ,2 # # # 0 2#2 #

3 0 3

# # # " # , 2 #

# )%) 0 0 ,# # #" 2 , A +

" # # > ( #

", , - , 2 , # " # # ( #

, 0 ! # , # # 2#2 # 2 < # 2 0 #, # # " 0 ( #

,@3D, ! # # 2 "

0 # # # #"

!# " # ! # " 2 2 - " ( #

, # # 2 2 # =9, 2# =9, + , - ,

4 . #

$ % ) ", , , #

( #

$% ) , 0 # #

#" # #+ , # , " # ?' 3>$ #2 , #,2 , - , 0 5 @" #

# # %/ @ " # ?' $ # F ,0 < ,

= *5 0 ( . (

0 ( ( -' ( ) @ A-' . ( ( : (

:2=$>3(.. =)

.. ( ( () > . 7 ( . <B( (

( ( 0 . /0 . # C (( () .) ( ) /0 (

5 .. =) .. ( ( () > . 0 7 ( <B( . /0 (( () .) ( . /0 . ( ( ) 0 . ( . 0 ) (

( ()( ( . .. () D()

.( 0 .

((.(.. ( )

0 ( ) (( (( 2 => ( ()

0 E =)> ( . (( ) 0 )( ( E =>( : ( ()( (( . . 0 ( () 0 ) ) .( ( 3 ( () 0

.( 0 .

((... () D ( ()( E => ( . ( ( ( ( () 0 0

.. () D ( ()( 0 .(.. ( () 0

( ( ) )

.. . .

0 .. ( ... ( ()

0 ( ) (( (( . (.() . ='>5 .. ( .

()2( =$> ( (.( ) . 0( (. ( .(

..( -'='>5 .. ( .

()2( =$> ( (.( ) . 0( ( ( 0 2 (( .(

.. ( A -3 . )0 (0( 2(( ( .( .. ( () 0 .

( . 0 ) ( ( ( (()( ( . B ( (.

( ( . -'='> 0 (. ) . ( ( 0 . .

( ) ( ( .. . F(( ( ( 0((. -'='> (( . 0((() ( . (@ A( () (3) ( 8

8 (. (-'=$>-'='>6 3) 8 (. (-'=$> -'='> ) .. .. . (( ((. (@ => 9.. 0 . G. . ()2( =$>. -'H.

( ( . ( (

..( ) . (.( (=>=>. -'=$> =)>#. . ( 0 ..

( ( ) (

0 ( ) ) ( . (.

0 ( ( 0 ) 0 (

) . ()

. 0

(( ( ( (=>=>. -'=$> . (((( . . . (

..( => ( 8 ( . (-'=$>-'='> . 0 ( . ( . .. ( ( ( : ) .. #( ( ( 00 (( . . ( . . .. ( ( ) () ( .

( ( : 8 (( . B =>5 2 8 (.

()( (=$>='>. -'( (() ((. B) ) ) -' ( . ( ( ( ( 0 ) ( 0 . 0 ) . 2( . . ( . .. ( . ) (0. -' # . . ( 0 .. ( ( (.. . .. .(

. 0 .(( .

.. ( ) ((( ( ) 0 .

-'. 3 .. ( . ( . ...( ( ) 0. -'. 35 ( 8 ()( -' (8 (..) ( )0 ( ( -')3".'%%$A !( . 2

0((()2( =$>='>. -' ( (() ) ((. B. 0 ) 5 0 0 .

52, (((2 B ) ( . 0 ) ( ( . (; ( 52!7 6 ( ) . . . ( 6 .. ( ( . () 0((. -'='>.

3 0 ( 0? %% $2" # # # #"

# ,

@3D, ! #, 22D# 0 1 " , , < # =9,

# , #"# ,

2" # , 2

# 2 , ,2 # + 2 #, ##

?'$ # 2#2, 2

# @3D, ! 22 2 #

# 3>$

# 2 # # 8"

# # #

2#2 2#, ## 3>$ #+ 2# # # C # 2 =#, #

" $ #;

# =#, #2 ,

- ### #+22 2 , - #2 " # %' # 0 2 # 2 # #" # , < # =9,

@3D, !# , D# $ %55A 'E), !

20 # , 2 # # # 0 2#2 #2" 0 0 #+ 0 2 # 2 # ,#

" @3 D, ! #

,,2 #"# ,

, #2 -

+ 0 2 # @3D, ! #& # # # # # %) @ # # #

0 < " D# # # ,, E ##

,, ,,

# ,, " # #" 2 # 2 ## #8" 2 2" # # 0 2 "2! 0 "2" %? + ,0 < ,

! "#$ %&

%'2 # 2#, ! ,

0 2 2- , #& = '% ( ()6 ((((

&& ( )* '

+, ' - #&. /% #/0",'"

"1) ( .(( )( ()6 )

2( #$+1" %& % ( (. (@ =$> 3 ( . 0

( 0 . 8 ( . ='> .

$"&*( ( B ( .( 0 ) . (

( )8 ((... =*> D( B ((( ( ( I()( ((J I (.. (J I0 ( ( (J I( ((J I ( (J B (0 (. (8( ( . I.( ( . J (( . . 8 . 0

0 ( ( =->3 0 () ( . 8 ( ) ( .0 . ( C( ( .

(0) . . 6( 0 ( () ( ) (( (0

) . ( 0 ( (8 ( .

( ( . . .. ( ) =!>. () (( (() )(( . 0 (() . .8 ) ? '$ (

) . 3& (

1+, -#&./% #/ ,

1+ . ) . (((

3 . . (/((. (@ => ( . 0 0 .

8(. ( ( => ( 0 J( ( ( ).( => 5 . ) ( . ( 0 ) 0 8 (( ( ( 6

8 =0>3 .8() .

()( ((?

. (. ( () ?

( (. . =0>5 ( 0

( 0 ( ( 4 . )( B ( ( 0 ( (. ( =D 45 ( /6)++'"

0+,++''

3 %5 ( 720

4 8 9 ( 42++

+0,++

1 /9

( >"

"0"? %3 < "2"# 22

F ,0 2 # 2 # # "

" # 0 + 0 !

4 # " # # 2 2 # 0 %> &

, - , #& %.%%'//' #0 1 , %.

## %5 + 0 # #! 0 '/

# # , , 6* ) ((1 .%)%)+,1 )//3'/'? @ ! E GE$ @ GE$