(O&M) Gursewak Singh & ORS. v. The Punjab State Electricity Board & ORS.

 



    
 



  !""#$%$&'() 

! "  ##$$ " %&
' ( ) *+""&$," "-.!/)"

$ !"  
# " 000   '

 *+

 


 

1 " " *!2 " $!+#"!

" !

"3 45 61 " "+ !"" 
#" "345 

,"%"&!' 2 !#

/!7," " ##$$ " 
  8$ 2/!7," " # " --- 

 .

( $, !##$

$!+-##$$ "#$

  

   !  . #  

   

"   !  "    "  9##$$ ": 2#

" *!2 !!,!"!

#!

< $ =  6 =

+-$ !

+>!/ /

"  2 !"-

* ,"

,7-

$!+- ##$$ "

"# "! ") *+""&$," "-.!/ )"

$ !"  

" !"" 9# ": , 

6 # $!+-" 

"##$$"<"7 !*!2 "!"!6?

6 (   ,"   ,  !  $+"

   " " 

    "  2 !"-

* ,"

,7-/

$!+-" ##$$ "/" -#$!!

" ""-# "" 

$

"  ""+$$,


&< =?  @)$!$!+-" # " !7$ !2 A,"!+" " 2 !

 ##$$  

$ !2

6 .

 6.

/ ""!"
2# ! B $

$/ ""!"7 $$.$ $!" $ " $ 7

#$!

#" 2 "/# "6C !"  #+ !##$$ "#-" $," "-, 7 !"  2 " $-+ $$ !+-"  !# "@7/ " " #+

 !  -+ $$, 7! "" $ " ,

1  ##$$ ","!" 

$ # )&.  2!"!# "
 57 !, #" 5 D !"!

 6

$"   + $$, 7!+- 2+C "$-/""  ##$$ "E # / "   "+$$ ,

   !

,"!   !  "  ,+$  27!, ,"

" # ", $$ ! $$$/+ "- ! " " -"  "- ( ##$$ "##, !"  "&A,"

7&

 ! "6 !,2"

" "+ $$ 
 =5#



"" "+$$,

!" ,

 !+

,"!

!" !# "  !2 "##$$ !# "!" ! 2 "$  " ,

7 !, #"!"! = 

"

$$ # "6 $!""" ##$-

 (   ##$$ "  $$!  " "  +,     "    $,"

/" -,$! " ""  "

,# !

!  $ ! " ", "/" -!2 !!!2"" "  
6= 5

2" # "  (    "    , ""!  +- "   # "  F  "    ""

""2

$!+-" 2/" -!2 ""!" "" $," ,"+$$,

+

,, "
&<=?  !"##$$ 6; 6

;= +"!

!" "! "6 ! -, ,  "   , " $$!

#+ " + $$"" 2"

2/ "+2 ""!" "" #+

!$- !"##$$

# $/

;?@C !"#- " 2 " $-$," "-,  !,,!

$- #

"+ $$

6 D5

 =

;? A"+ $$ 6  ?

;?+C """ "

2  > / 

;?  "  > / 

   !

!  " 

$$-  !# "  "  "- , 2#"

,    , C ,"   #-2

2#"

, /" "+$$,

!

,"!

?

;D##$$ "!# "!
 5"!#"#-2

 6

!2


 ?5  = 

F22!

"$-"  " " ,

"!$$

" "" ##$$ " !!" #-2 " , 7-2 "  !" "+$$,

  "$-!

,"! ,, #-2 " ,  "+# ! 2 " $- $""+ /" # "#-! $ "  " =  "  7$,  " #"

/ $$



2!

=   1 "   "    "  

"  "   ! "  6   !   7A"

 $ !" - "$!"#, $,"3)G 6 1 "      . #  

 E  ,$ 2  

"  "  " $ !7A"

3)G  1 "   "   #$

     "$!  "  "   2 !"-

* ,"

!,7-  "2 "3)) =
$  ? ." " #"

!!,!7 ,

##"  7$  D < !

" ,$ !!,2 "-7 ,#!,!+- " #"

 !" +2 2! + $ /$ !" $<"

!"  " #$

7 ! 2# !*!2 !!, !"!

##$$ "# ! ##$

"" *!2 !!, !"!  

  ,    !

!  +-  $ !  !!

$  G " ,"

>!/ 7 !*!2 !!,!"!6?

; H$

 7!/" ##$$ " 7

$!" 

"
$ , !##$

(   +2   2!  +-    2 !#  

/  $ !

, $#

" !
  8$ 2/$ !

, $#

" # " 7+ !! !,!  + #!

" 2""# ! 2 "/$ !, $ "   ##$$ "   !  "  &A) /  "   #"  +2 ""!  +-  !7,"  ! 

 . / ##

"!8,$<22 +-" 

? " $<"7 !!!"! 6 ?

 " " !

,"

","

 " " $,"

"$$!

" 

$! " !

+ "!8 !, $, !!" "" $,$,22 7 "!

" #" " 2!-  6 ?

"+"6 #2 "

2"

 "  , $    "   # "  F   #"  &A) /   #,

,$$-""!" "" $," ,2" " "+$$,

 $-

,"!(  ,+$,

" $," ,2"

2" ",2+

!#$@!!!" "" $,"

 ! "+ "!"  ,+$8 !, $ "!  " "  2  &A)  #"    "   $,$  ,22 /  "  " ! "+$  !" "" "+$$,

" ! "+

"!  "

$$  6 ?

    ,, "    !

   "   "+$$

/" ##$$ "2 !" "

2 " 

$!

2 ,  , $"!

?I$#!,"

" ,#)16 

!

  / ,$"$F #,"""

!" "  !7 "!"  #"   

! !# - ,$$-, , !" "

,##

#"&A)6/" ,# !

!!2"" A" 
6= 5 !  "   ##$$ "     "$!  "  ,7  "    !  2 "  2  "  # "  +,  " -  !  $!  "  ,

,"  "   $," ,  "+$$

$$$$- $2""2 " 

 "

" 2 $ !, $ " ##$$ "/ $ !  , $    "   # "  #

"!  "  " "  "   # " A2

!G1 + <  !/8G< " 

, +G $ 

, ! " +  "  " 

" ,!/ ""

!" "" 

D " $,"

"  2 ##$$ "

 F

$"

"$$" ,

/ ! $" " !# "!"  !2 "

"$$" " ,

  =

/ $," "+$$  ,

   ,

,"!    = =

  8 !  , $ "!" ""  !$-

,

" "+$$ ##$$ !"  " - "$ +$"#- -!2

6 @7

!!"  7$,  $ !, $ " #"

/" ## 2

" ,$ 2 "G1

+  <  !/8G<!#! " +  " 

$,! ,,!

  "  "    !  ,!  "   "+$$  $," ,  ,

   "  ##$$ ",

,"!  = =

( #" 8,$<22

 ! 

 .   $#"" ##$$ "+,# ""2 " 7 "!" #"  6 ?

 " 

" "

$!+-" ##$$ "  =

" !" ! <"" "" $," ,"+$$,

,

,"!  = =

@!" + ,2#$ , ! " <"/" ##$$ " " "

-$ "

2$! 7

$! ##$ ,"



"2#"

#,!



"" # "  ,2#$ , " ! <"!2 ""!$-/ , ##$ ,"

 7 +-" ##$$ "+  " " $<"" -#

"

2 !!

"" +7/

#" ! 

 / 8,$<22 ""!" "" $," ,2" ",

,"!

2" ",2+

!#$+" !

"2

 " " $,"



"$$! """ "+$$ "

    + ,    "   ,+$  $!  "  ##"  "   ,    "  ##$$ "" ""+$$,

 ! "+ ,

,"! " " 

+-" # "+-" 

  (   ##$$ "  #!,!    7 ,  "  #7      " 6 ?

" "+$$,

,

,"!5"!

,"" "

#

"

2" 

$!+-" ##$$ "$!-#

/" - ,$! 7 $-#!,!" C !+" 77 ,"#7"  !"  "+$$,

"!5,

,"! "7

"   $,$  ,22    6 ?

  (   +

  7 ,/  "  ,$  "

+$ " "#7!+-" # "/" $," "+$$,

 !+ "!,

,"!  = =

 !"  ! " <"

= <2

"" , !#"  ,$ 2 "" "

+,

" "+$$,

,# !+

!2!+," -,$! " "" 2+-#"

" "+$$

" 2 , / ## "$- 2

7$$"

##$$ 

$!"#7$"" ,#

$!+,

-,", !,"$# #" " # ""  $/7

,,#"! "   2 "" "" ##$$ ",$! "

#"" "+$$+, "!

/" # " *"

!

!

  "+$  !" "" ##$$  $"@ !#"!$-,22 ""!! $"

#-2 $," "- 2#"

, C" "+$$,

+

,, 
&< =?  !" "" $,"

2F" !,2

;  ""2 "" ""  $," ,2"

"$$! " "+$$

(" C-/" "" $," 2#"

,  # !7-2 $""/  2#$- !

 ,H2  !,"/ #7!" " C !"#-" , 2#"

, " $""+"  $!"!( /" $# $"+

#" ! ,, #-2 ""

 " # "*"

!

" "+$$,

 "$ +$ #-2 !2 ,, !2/

-/""  ,# ( /" +

+" $C"

$

7$7! $" +

2

" # "##$

"7

" *!2 !!,!"!

#!+-$ !" $<"

2!+-$ !

"##$$"<"/" 

"##$ !

!





  ()