High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1275/1993dismissed

Narain Dass And ORS v. Rameshwar Dass

2024-12-16Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj16 pages

!"#$!%&'&"()*++,-

! ) ./

+ 0 + 1 22222 "# $% # & '(#()!* +,(&

# &((#()!* + - #&

# #() ( #!* +,(&

.( #()!* + - #&# ! ///// 0 + 13+ 45 & !-! ( ( + ! 0( & 12!0. ! !+#!!344

!56& 2572!0)8(#

).5 (6 ( (*( 2( 9:9!!344!0( & ;2!( .(

-& (*( -44456& ( #(+72!0.5*(! 12!0.!!+#!!<9443 #! 2 #(0 5&- -&%!-! + !

&# !%((--&!-(! 2(- #

( 56,6 - #%.( -&!. 2#(0'=.# 5(0=>3 &# 2 -& !. 2#(09' ?3.# )5#(0@&,>@&2( >)@& # 9>>> 9%3)

&&( (2!( (0A#,)

-2- =B) & ( "+&'2) ( #(+ .5) # & 1.5!( #((0 &6#4:B%:<) 0,(& &#2##(0& , *##! & 2#.2'& (0& - A&0, (0&) @#. (0& - A&0, (0&! .701@2#!20&# -2#.2'& (0&,#+ %

&## ( & ! . 2#(0 9 ' 3 .# ! & ! . 2#(0 '%= .# 2 - & - # (! ! , ! & %!-! *(!#0( #! !!!!=444)#0( #! (& --(+ - 25%0( ##)"+&'2- # + (!#( - B)>% , +(.! 56 & # ! %((-- & &6 &!

2#( ##(0& -#%.( 5(0+ % &## -&!(!( 2& (. - (-* 2# -&!-! - #&*(02#+& !!. 2#(0 '(>3 &#*(!#0( #! !!!!44& !, ! 50#(+22#!!, #%.(5!& (+2!# +( 4 -&"#%.( +, *# #*!2 &.) (&# 56 & *! # # & *! # , ( .! *(5 5- # C+2( -& !!+)&5 * 2(, -(!- # '(0#% .( 3 & %!-! -(! &(# ,#( . *##(0 && (;2 ( , ,(&# + &#!#&# # )&*(0+!+#5 2!#( )&!5 ! !(--## , !& (.(# !!- # &!

5C+2! 56&*! #(-* 2# -&# !%((-- ! 2+&) ! ,#-26,# -&!&*(0#!65#(( !! # 5(0 ! !(--# # - # # (!( 2# &! 5 -2#&# *##! & (+ &# , # +(-(+ !!)

+(-(+ 2.5#) !26 5 2!! # & ! +#(( ( & !!

-3- C+2! 56 & *! # ) &+) & . & - #(* #(( &*(0#!6'+ &! -C+2( -& !!! &+)&# !%((--, 2! 5(! '#%.( - & .!+(.

( "#6#, .! !( .(

& 2( = , -2#&#*##!& C+2( - !!(&(# -* 2#) &6 &* #!6 2. - 9)>% ( .'(0 (.# *. ! +&0 *# & (! # #6 ! & & ! ( ;2 ( , 0#(+22#!!( !, !1+ &5!( !&!, (+2(*( (+ 0 9 + .( -!(0 )&- ,(0(

2 ,#-#.!$%

!! "

$"%&''# % (

) &

)!!

* *

-4- " (

B A &&#( !&(#*(!+(# + -&(#+ ! C&(5(! ! +2. ( 2 # - &(# # +(* +(. &6 !!#

! &(# #02. & (

2 -#.! &( !(0 - & (

2 ,&&#&# !%((--&!5+ .+ % &##(&# #6! , (! ' #%.( - & !! # ) & #( 2# #+ #!!&&#02. -& %!-! &--+&( , 0#(+22# ! , ,(& 2 6 .#() (+ C % @& #>(#!,#(-# .@&#(-4:B 5(44 & ,!&&!&! 52!# +2(*( !2#(0 & (!#( ! C =( + 6 - & !!*(!,&(+&&!-!&!2#+& !&!).#6 & ,!& 5 2!#( - & ! !

!1 ((0 ( ! & & . !(! &&&# !%((--, + % &##(& 2(! , &2 &!&&# !%((--&*(05+ .+ % &##)&! *#6 #(0& ' #%.( - & !! & 2( -(! 56 & # !%((-- , ++ #!(06 ,! *(! 12!0. ! !+# !! 344 251+ & # !%((-- 6(0 2. - <=)3>% < 00#(*!&# -)&%!-!#-##! -4445- #& ( #(+72!0).5& (! , !( .(

!56 ( #(+72!0*(!12!0.!!<9443& #(*# -&12!0.#!

&2 $% +) ,

- .

-5- .

!! 012#%3

. 4 , .*

* . . 5

5 * . * 6 12

.* 12#$$&

* "

* 8

* .

, -

;

* #% /

2 .

- , ( % $

- () $ * .

- .7 . * * . *

() $ . *

-6- ! * <

. * * 7

2 .

() $

* .

( % $ = 5>012 .

"7* . 2 .

* - *

* .7

.7 -

* 2 ( % $

() $ .-

: 00#(*!&# -)&( 02# + !& 5 -(! 4 #! 2 #(0 5&-& & #-##! & !! C %= + !&&*! # &!C+2!& !!56.( (0& +(-(+5 2!#( !&+)+(.

&#(* #(( &! #!6 ' + #( # & - ! ( -* 2# - !(--# 526# (+2!(0 & # !%((-- + !

& & %!-! &!.(0#!-# ."215 (#6!2#(0

-7- & !6 - ## #( . ! 2+&) & 5 * (! , 2#+& ! - # #( (0+ #2+( -# (!(& 2 & (!!, 51#!, 5(0 2 ! - # +2(*( !#, ( - &( 2# & ! +2..#'DEF #,&(+& # &!5+#*! 2-# . & (!!!&'

(.# # & ,!& +(-(+ ,(&!(! ! +#(( &!5+#*! 2!& !!#0( #!(-* 2# -& %!-! -#+ ( !#, & !! !! 44 C %9#0( #!(-* 2# -&# !%((--,&#(

(.(###( 5 2 +(-(+2.5#& 50(*-#+( .! & (. 6 - %3%. @2# ,(- - @#. (0& ( &

! # ,&#( & &! *##! & & ! , ! 56 +#*(0 2 # (!( !(--#*! # 560(*(0 +(-(+! +#(( , -2#&# ! ! & & ! , 51# & (. - & ! &

( &# -&!50(* !(--## #-# & (. 6 - % 25& & &!# ( & 0( #6 #' #02 &

# &# ,#!26#-+!(& !! , &! +2. .#'DEF(+( +! &12!0. -&( 2#(&.# -

+ !&(- &! - )#(*#(( ( #!6--+!)#% .(*, 2! !#. *!-# .& 2 -+ % &##!, 2! &* 6 #%.(* #(0& + !

& * & #( ( & #(( 2 # &# (. 6 56 &(# + !2+ ! & &6 + ;2 ( &-+2. -#(( &*(05--+! # -##(0 & 5 * (! 12!0.) & + !

& & *! # -&%!-! !(&,(

5 C & &&#, #(*#(( . 0 &#( !!(--# &# &!

-85 +#*! 2 -# . & ! & !(0 ! &#-# & !! , C+2! +&*!, + +( 2 !,# -& +(-(+ &#5(0

! 2 - # # (!( 2# ( - ! 2+&) 56 &(# + !2+) & # !%((--+' ,!0! & #(* #(( - & ! &*(0 #!6'++)&+ +(.& 2 -+ % &##(&

(!!& #(*# -&12!0.#! &2 $% ,

'? 3

5 .

* * * @

3 *

.- .

- .

- *

-. . .-

;

7- - , - -

7* '

&7 ;

* #

;

* )03 ('( 0'

3 % 0A/3

-9-

- .

- * , 8

* - ,

7 - <

-. 8

- .

. * .-

..-

* *

7 . .-

* -

' 8 -

* 7*

2 - #&# !%((-- & &#&!+ !

&& !!

(;2 ( ,#(# + - &#& !(0!& #&82A+&72!0. -&( 2#(&.# -

# #!

!"#$) +#(( ( & , 5 &!).#.( (0 - +(-(+2.5# #5 2!#( (& !, 2! 2#& !!( & - +(-(+2.5#!&(

& (5 !!,(&# + &# 6+)& 2 -& # !%((-- + % &## , 2! 0 !-! .#6 56 .( (0 - # ! +#(( 56 ,6 - 5 2!#( . & #( - , * C#+ - & 5 * 12!0. #! &2 $%

-10- +9,

* ( 5

; (

& ( !) ; ' ")9

;

& ( !%9 ; ' 9"9 * .

- 5 *

. .-

/ *

= D

B E 0 3

. 7 * *

. .- .

- *

* <*

, * 8

.-' *

. <*

, <*

* * . - *

* -

* *

C.-'

* . * . <*

. ' 8 -

5 *

- .

-11-

- .- .

5 .

. .-

5 ..-

%030.3 . & &

5 ;

* F*

G (+ ( +! & 12!0. - & F5

2#. 2## #! % " $& (!G '" $()

&&,&& & 5 .!56 % &##52'&,& 5#(( !)& !!, #%.(5)# *(0&82A+&*(, -&(0& 2#(&.# -"$&#*C#+ -& (!12!0. ( 2!#$% +

. &

; / -

. & *

. 2

, 8

* ./ *'

* , -8

. / *'

5 .- * %030.3 . &

; / -

,/ *' -

-127*

. 7 . A / -

/ *'

: (

;

H!9<F I

..-

5 . .-

%030.3&

5 .-/ *' 3 ( #02!56&#! ( # 2 &*& 20& & # !% + !

& #(*#(( &! ' +) & ,*#) & ! # *# ! ( & ,(

5 C & & -+2. -#(( &+ ( -&(( #&(, 51#!

#! 56 & -+ & & @& # (#!,#( 5# 20& #+ #!

& ,! & ! 5 2!# +2(*( -2#&# + ! & & (. 6 -.@2# & , &!, 5 2%9+# ,6 -# . & &.

# ! , &2 !1+ & *(0 (

25.(! & & (! + ( 6 + # ;2 ( - -+) ,&(+& + 5#%C.(!( + ! (;2 ( -, #( - #+ (!#( 5- #&( 2# = -2#&#+ !

& +(# *( ( #0#!(0 56 -.) &# ( +(-(+ # *( ( ( +( 9 &! #!6 5 !+#!2#*(# 56& F5 2#. 2#(&12!0.# #! 4:B 2#. 2# :94 & %!-! & ,&# +(.! (! # +( 56 +(0 #(+ & (! +2 &2 + !

&& 25.(

( !*+!56&%!-!&* #!6 5 + (!#! 56 & 5 & & 2# ! -(!(0 &* 5 #+ #!!+ +2##60( &%((--

-13- 9 #! ( # 2 + !

& & 25.(

( - & !-! & &# , #(( ) !

!-! 56 &( , + !2+) & %!-! &! &(.

- ( (2! # +!(0 - #

'(0 #(( - & ! ! &2 !.(! & 1 (

- & 2 5, & #( * & 20& & (! #(( # +!(0 ,# *26 ,(&!#,) & ,*#) &6 , 2! #( 0( & (( #-# .+(.(0&&!, #!6#(( !5- #& !!, C+2!(&( -* 2# B &##02.& 5#( !566 -&#( #6 12!0.+(! < &* &#! #! 2 #(0 5&- - & # +(*#( !&*0 &# 20&&! +2. *(5 #+ #! : &- 2!( -&(#+ (!! ,56&% !-! ( & --+ & & !! C+2! ( &(# -* 2#

+(-(+6#+ #!!!(--#5 2!#( !& ., 2! && &# , #(* #(( --+! 5, & #( ! & & # !%((-- ,# + +( 2 - & #( - & 2 & !,&& !!, C+2!(&(## +(*-* 2# 4 ( )& ,*#) ( (( !( 2&12!0.#(! 2 56 & 2 - # & # ! #0#!

& --+ - .# .( (0 - +(-(+2.5# (1 (!!&& ., 2! .'6!(--#+ -# &1 (

-& 2 ( + +#! & 5(!! ,5682A+& -&( 2#(&.# -

"$ ! --(#.! 56 & F5 2#. 2# ( & .# - '" $() * "$&#(#( -& (!

-14- #(+( (&12!0. -&

( !( 2!56& 2 - #&%!-!82#&#)&( ( (( !6 & ;2#(( # +!(0&! 5 ( (2! & 5& - & %!-! 5- # & *2 2& #(( ! & ( & +(-(+ !(0 - & (! #(( (+( )(, +' ,0!56&%!-!&&!, 1 (& (!+ !2+. 2 +' ,!0. -& +(-(+ 2 56&%!-!5 2&!5(01 ((&& !(0 & , * & 20& ( & --+ & , - #%.( 5(0(#(+#(0&+5!-!56*#6*(!. )& ,*#)& #(0&& 5!-!!56. #+ 0(H!(,&!-+( &2 #;2(#! 5 &!!, 2! 5!-! 62% &! + +2## -(!(0 - -+ 5 2 & !-! &*(0-(! &#(*#(( & 5#+ #!!565 &&

2# ! # *!! +2.( #+ #! &&+(..# . +' ! +2. + 5 ++! 2# ! & # *! @& # (#!,#(F & ,(0 1 (

- ! ! ( +2(*( 0,(& &

&# #-+!(& !!( !,&+ +2##-(!(0 - -+ , 2! #!(#(6 5 (#-#! ,(& 6 5+2 & (0& 2# .6 &* !(--# (( & & .#6 #(#! & #02. (+!!#1+!565 && 2# (!

.& (H !#,(0 -# 2.( !+ +2 ( -#(*#(( 52& -(! && .56!(0+ 0*(!+

-15- -# & 12!0. #(! 2 56 & 2 - # & (( #(&.# -

# #! B9

(*(3B9( + +#!)& . , (

2#((0 & +(-(++ !2+ -&+ % &## &.

* ,& &6 ,# (

( - &(# # +(* &# ! ( #( &!#!65+;2(#!&#( #(( &! 2 #!& -+ -#(*#(( (&(# (. 6 2+&*(!+& + .- #& (&# + !#&#&. -#(*#(( ( +(-(+6 !( 2! 56 & + % &## & .# .( (0 - & !(. ( >5 2!#( , 2! &*.#((.+ &2# -& ! #&12!0. -"$ 3

* & 20& & (( ( , ( , ! & #% .( ( (#(+#(0&!+5!-!)& ,*#)& .! .&&#(0& #+ 0(H!56& 2+5!-!.#6566

2#-(+( .&#(*#(( & 5 &!!& ! +2. & ,(0!(--# & 5# *!56&(( #56 !(06*(!+(+( +! 6 & (. 6 -0( #6

#' #&# & C.((0 6 # -# . & *2 #.

& ,#(*#(( ! #

( 5,&#( &(

2# , 2! &+ -(! ( !(--(+2 2 -(!(0 - -+ #+ #!! + +2##6 56 & 2# 5 ,) & #0& - & ! +2. #+ #! = 8 # & - #0 (0 # ) -(! & (0(6 & 5 (! 2 56 & 2 - # & %!-! ( & 12!0.

!565 && 2# &# ( ++ #!(06!( .(

!! &12!0.

!565 && 2# #--(#.!

-16- 9 & !(0 .( + 2 (+(

) (- 6) # !( ! - 0 + 1 *3,- J

;

&&# '(0># ! ) I > &&# #5 $ I >