Murali Lal Sharma v. State Of Haryana And Another
!"#$#
! %!& !'##
( )*+# , +, ++ * ****
!"
#
! ,-! . % /012 # $ % & " '( )'
()(* +, -. / 01 2 , " -3 *3 45678 ') ''
()(( +, 9. / 1:# ;
;
<: 2 *39
)5 )4 ()((
'637'647*(*7**(7*9*7'5-7'557*347*)37'()8=:# " 2
$ 71=>" = ;
; /" 2 2-**0)''*5 ? 3 ()(( ; " =
" @ $" *
7 " ;"A / 0 !" !" 72 " # %"
$ :"" ()'(+ " ()'(.
$ ; /
- 2 - $ ; % / " 0 !" 72
" $ ;"A ; ; / $# 69' ; 693 # # '43* ; # " ') ''
()(( +, 9.
$ ;
/; ; 8
-3 *3 45678; " " / " " " ; / / %"" / /;
: // / "0 A ()(( ; " ; " "
$
/A / " ; ;
; /" > ;
"" / % 7 >
$ " 0 $ ; ; / #:&" $ /
/ >% '455 : / ;
7 ;
; " ; B"
- 3 - = ; > (- )5 ()(( /
7 " " / 7 " ; ;
; ,( " ;
; % A " ; " "
: ;
;
7 ; " >
7 ; % " $ ;
%; / / = ; % " ; 2 B" '( )4 ()((+,*.
< " "
7 / $ ">% "" "
'9 ') ()() 1:# ; ;
<: / " <: / "
< / #
/ " ; " ; " " 0 /
- 4 - "
/ , "
;
/ / " " " &
4 "
"
" 8 " ; 2 ; )'
)* ()(* / " , " -3 *3 45678 / ; / # > !" >/ +#88*5**'8()().
#88*5*-(8()() '5 '
()(' :
+#88***3)8()('. (9 ()(( : ('
)* ()(* " / / %" " ""
;
; ; '-'
$ > # ;> ;
; / $ 8
- 5 -
! " # $%& #
'() (
*
+*++ *,*&+*++ ! " - + ././0 ' ' 0- 1 23
0
( % &%1%&
!
#- -
45 6
7
4 08-
0 ) )
7
-9 ) - :
;
- 0 < :
; " < !
#- 1 !
= 4 ;> 45 -
?
7
4
= 5
( 45 <
7 4
7
4
)!
=
=
!
!
4
08-
0 )
- 6 - !
) 4 #9>
&=&=+*++
5
1 **&+*++
=
# %& ,&% ) -
@! !
4
= @ -
0)
) 4-
@)
" -
= ; *%*%+*++ @ -
0 )
) ;> :; 4 -
@ )
" - 4
7
0 <A0 -
- )
#5
9
5
';
; *,*&+*++
(
)!
1*&+*++4 4
5
, ; $**&+*++
( # $$"*
$% )
# 7 !
=
# B 5
#B ;
- 7 - *, *+*++
>-( ' 4
% @ -
0 '
)
) - - 4-
B )
-7 C
-
B )
'5 ( ( 0-C# !
+% *+*++ !
0 4-
@)
7 - 45-
?)
7 !
& ++*++ @;
+* ++*++ #B -
'
#B )
08'
0" 7 >5 A > -
)
7 -
-)
' - " 0 0 <A0
-
#5
D
6 / % "
" / / " /
/ (' < # %"
$ :" " ()'( C " " ; # '9 " " ; # '- $ "" D#$E'9$2 ?$$:?2?<:2E +45 ')(. ')( #& 8
- 8 - / " ;
; & 45 7 & 44 ; / ; +.C / "" ; /// "; " ;
/ / /"
;
/ $$ F +.C / "" ; /// "; " / /"
;
/ F +.C / "" ; /// "; " / /"
;
/; F + .C / "" " <: "; $
/ (' +0 ". '493
/8 +('8. 60 ;
; 8
- 9 - E- .+ 0/.0/0
<
8 = ./
5 8
= .
/
D < ;
7 / A " "; 7 A / " A
$ / / ' ( * $ "<:;
" " * ;
"
6 ')'
;
"A 7 ;;
/ 7 " /8-+ .
, ')'
E)
* .
/./.
/9
=
=
.1/ = 5=
= ./333 ./333 ./333
- 10 - ./
=
>9)
8 D
/8')')' ; 7&// / # $ 0 " " / ; /> / ; ;
" "
; / F0 0 F / $ > /" / / 0 ; /"
"
" *)) #:
"
& / /
: / >
/" / /
: " <: " 4
" A & $ "
/ ; / , "
- 11 - / / % : ; "
7 ;A
$ / ;
/ ";
<: / "
= # , ;" " " (- )5 ()((+, (. ; & ; " ; B" = ; +> .
7 +, *. " ; B"
" " "> $ #/ / " "
% & ;" " : ;
:
" " " "
" *)) # : 8 /
/ " # '9 # %"
$ :" "()'( % &
/ " G H;
/ "
- 12 - " / & " 7 ;
/ "
; " " "
E ; / / ' ( * $ " <: ;
" " * ;
"
6 $ ; / "' : " ; "; # '- ')6 $ # ; // #/; > / ; " " ;
;
// /; ; *)) > // " ; // /; & / ; ;
'4 )3 ()(* 66 3,-! . % /014
% /
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No