High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/439/1990dismissed

Housing Board Haryana v. K.C.Gupta, Etc.

2024-08-01Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl9 pages

! "# # $% &'( $() **

, (% -./%* ( #

! "# # $% &'( $() **

, (% ( &0 (

! "# # $% &'( $() **

, (%

() &0 (

1( !

(

*2'+) 3

(%0 0(4 3

(

5++

# (02/%* 3

(62+3)/%* 3

( 5++

*( ( ( 9%+ *

&%+( ** + + :) $% &'( $()% (

1%;:.%(

"44<% +9 (

4 44;%&4 0:

* :) ( +.%( 9 ++ :)

++

+ # '( ( &0 3 +% 9

+

:) ( ( ( +.%( ++ &0 % 9

:) &+ ( +.%(

""

( &(4. 3 +% # > " "

( &(4. 3 +%

# "

( & (4. 3 +% ># "

$% & '( $()** 0

( :

(( 0 3

**+ (4

* (909 9 ++ & <% ( 0% :% + %*:) % (

&( 0% 90 0( ++9! + 54 /(%*5/ : ?9 (54 /(%*?5/ 64 +@ 2 (

6@ ++ *+ ( 0 (

03 **+ ( ( ( )* 0% ++

&(

0% &(

9% (!

5/ A #

> ?5/ "

> 6@ "

> 9 *+ 9 0 A #

>(5/ )* 0% #

>(?5/ )* 0% "

>(6@ )* 0% & 0 *( *+ 0 + 3 +%

(4 & (

(:

(()& %(+;%

<% )5 %( (

*+ 5/ )* 0% 9(

% &(

0 *( +% ++

4 % (% 0% %+ :

( ( A

$% &'( 0( (+:;

0%( (%:4

*+ 0

$ ( 1%(0

)&(

9 0 * (.+% #9

4

9* (4

(4 +*(

0 + :% + &9 0 * ( ) ((4

++ 9 0% *+ %+

+)( 9 (4 %+

4*+

%* 0% :) *+ 5 9%( 3 (( 0:

0 4* + 9( % ( ( ( %( 0% 0 4% 9 + :+ :

3 (4 ++

C ( +.%( 0 4 % *+ 3

;%&4

""

" & ;%&4

+9 + :) (+ *+ 90(

&%+( ** +

0++9

++

+ + 3 *( * :)

*(% 0 % (!

! "

# $ %& %!

'

#

( )*% %*% +

+ ,"

" - "

./ 0'.

%1%%*

!'

#

( 223 %*3- "

./ $4 )&5**-+ $

+! "

'

6 , "

" 7%**" + + 25&

%% (

89:1

%1& %1!;

.;0 -

7

!

' )&%5<&5!

+%&2%&&

!

=$ ' +&&&

! ;

+%13&& :

!

!

'

> +)&1**&& + ?

!

%&=$ ' +)&1&&

!

;

@ ))523 +1)%&&

+2*15&&

! $1=

+22*&& +1%2&2&&

! $%&= +1%2%&& +15121&& A+15-5&&B< ;

4;0-

7<

!

# )&%5<&5!

+1&&

!

=$ ' +%&5&&

! ;

!

+3*2&&

!

'

> +%)*%5&& + ?

!

3=$ ' +5*&&

!

;

@ 3= +%23*2 +2&&

%% +%&&

! $1=

+%&3&& +)&%&& A+)-%&&B< ;

8 A-

7<

!

' )%5<&5!

+2&)&&

!

=$ ' +2&&

! ;

+3&&& :

!

!

'

> +33%5&& + ?

!

3=$ ' +12%&&

!

;

@ 1= +13 +2%&&

3 +%%&&&

! $1=

+15%&& +%%3*%&& A+%%*&&B< % ;

- ( !-

!

! $

A %)

!

%2$ (

!

!

%1 -

"

"

'

C %1$ (

%5 -

-

"

"

' -

" ;

-

;

;

-

( ) !

" -

:

D

C * (%+ :3 ;%&4 9%+09 9 : (3 :)

3 9

+ +9

'(%+ 0 0% +)

0 4* ( +<% ( ( 0%

%04* 9 0( *

(0(& 80

:( 2%* 0 4% %&0 9+( *(% *( 5*(# 9: (3 ++

4 *

4 3 9(&+) )* 3 *(#0:

(4 :) + ( % +( 9 ++:)+ ( % +(

**( +) )*&(*0 + (((9 % ( &0 +) ;

3 9

+ +9@ 0( *

4 9 : (3 4 %+:

++9 909 4% 9% % 0 4* 9( ( + <% 4 0 :

0%

'(0

+ + + 4

45 9%( (: (3

'(0 *(3

+ :( 2%*

( & ++) B (490 %+:

%% 90

( 4% 9 :

&+ 4 9% %0 0 4 +(: (3 4 9 0( *

4 3 ( &+)

** +9 ++9

?

( % +( 0%:4

( (

0%+ :

(% 4

** '( 03 ( &0 ( 3 ( 4% * ( .+% #9 ( &0 ( 3 (9 +)

* %+ ( (%4 %

" *(% + 3 (

+0:

++9 5

%:4

( ( 0%+ :

*(

( & '((4( 3 ( & 0 4 ) (

'( :+ 4

*(4

( +9+ 9

;%&4 90 00:

4 *( * :)

?

( % +( 0%:4

*%

9 0( *

*(* *(*% :) :%

*(4

(03 :

4

0%

*( ** + 03 :

( 9 0 (%4 (*(% :

(

: 4

++

+ + :)

** (3 :

4 5 %( ((&% +)4(

0

) (0%(( 0% *( *+ <% ) )

( :) 0 .%( 9%+% ( %*( ;% ( &0

*(++

80 .%( 00 (+ ( % +( 9 ++ ( 0* (% ** (:2 # &

90 003 :

*(% 0 :3 ( ( 9 0 +9 ++ (

( 80 &03 :

09 :

* (3 ( ( ++ &+ )4 (03 :

0++ & :

( 0 .%( +) **( 0:

( + 4

*() (0:

4

4 :

*(

5 **(

.%( 0 0 + 9 0 ( *

9 *

90 0 03 :

*(

'( %+

2 0 % (%4 90 003 :

4 *(

:3 ;%&4 0:

( &0 +)0 +

** (

+ + 4 4% ( +03

:

++9 80 :3 : (3 9%+ + ( 43

**( ( :

0+% +( '(

;%&4 0%+ :

(% ** +

'( + 4 0 ( 9 0 .+% #9 90

()*(4

(( *(3 ( (( 3

*( 0:

3 9* %+ ( (%4 : (*(% :

( -

* & 3 9 :3 (%4 ++

&%+( ** +( 4

**

A "

%*0 + ++ * &4 %**+ ) 0++ * 3 9 :3 ( ( !""#

# $%&'%&()*&+,-./0(&+)1.&23 &)01 $%&'%&((&*1('+45&3 &)01