High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/706/2003dismissed

State Of Haryana v. Vinod Singh

2024-05-17Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill,Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat19 pages

#$# %

& '&( ) &"

#$# %

&*+, - #'.( ' !.&/ 0.&12.,, &*+, - #'.( #0#02 324

!" ### #0#02 324# $

% " & ''($'(() * + ,

- % * ".""% *"/* 0 + " " )('1+ ' 0 "

$2)+ + 0 % "! " +

- "1 -"! %* 3, * 1

- & " 4

1 5 % "" "1 - "

%! 6!1

*$((( '2$'$777 % *

! 6! * %

% %" 00% "*% "" %! & "

" ! % "*"

" ! % "

" * -% % "

""*% %!

"*" "* * % " "- * ! 1 % 3 %%* .

.% &% 3 * % %" " " *"- %" * % % * * * %"* . .% 3* " "0 % . .%3 " . .% 3! 6!"+ - %! * * ! 6!* -*

& 3%"

4 *

%%! 6! 81 "% )

" *! 1 5 * 819:;'% " * 1! " " )(';)<1+ " '=

" <

" " !

$2)+ +% * %"%"

+ - " . (>($'(($ " " )(';)<1+%

, & 0 ! " % % : * 0 + %!

3 + % " % * " )(';)<1+ " % % : * 0 + =

" - 3 ""

% %"% : %

% " %! " 3

"" *&"

" " % 1! ?.$ % " 81@+,* ?.< % ! " 9: ! " @ A% " ?.>% ! " 9: " "" " '=

" + 5 ?.$$ 1 "

?.$'

%% : % %

" .: % " : %

1 &5 ?.

$ -?.'

+& ?.) + ?.< 5, ?.= +

?.> % ?.2 1 ?.B 1 5 ?.7 >

: " % " ! "%"" %!

" "

% * " " "! "1 " "": 3 ! 6 !C"D9!

819: +9: 8% :* ! " " ?.2 % !! ! " 9:" " A " 2 " ?.$ 1! ?.<+,* ?.> A% " ?.$$ + 5 ?.$' 1 "

* " %! "3 "" % % ." % .: % *&" " .: * ""0 " : &5 1 ?.$ % "" 3 +

(2()'((' " 0 " : ?.'

- % ". : 3 +

"" % & .

! "

# $

! % " "

' ( % & )$)*

% & )

$ % & $ % ? A>

A & %- * ! ** & %% > 1 & )%"*

% & % %* % " 9:5 %"* * " /9: "1- ! & 3 + %* * % - 1 " .:

%" " % % * 0 % - *"- & A) " -"

% ")0" ! " 9:+ (<<= 'B$'$777 1 5 " & "3

" ! " & A$ ' 4 " %% 0 " * & ?.)

%%% - + " +

5 1 % ! " 4 $'($'((( " % * %"% * - - 4 $>(''((( ! ";"- -

+ * - 83 * 0 * " *&" " % * *"- % .% 4 '<()'((( 1

5 -"-* *&" ! ." %

0 '2()'((( ! " - 83 * 1 " .:

"-; "% 83 $>(''((( 0*&" % * 83 ! 14 " 83 '2()'((( 83 *&"

%" "%%"! % " % % :% " " " * % "- 0 " : ?.< +

%- "83 * "" 5, ?.= %" "

: ! * ! 6! 'B$'$777 % & .

" &

+ ,

(

% & $#

% &

"-% % % : & $ "" " * ? * "

: "%

* % " * %

* %

: %

"% " % ! "

% %*" 3! - % % 9: B

"" & %

%"% " "

" 1 " .:

*"- " % * % % ").< 4 *% "! & ? " * "83 % %*&" %

% %?

* " " .

" 9:

0 % !? "% * 83 %! 80 % ! * "% !0 . % ! * 40 " : ?.>

5 ! 6 ! % ! 81 %! ! ! 1 " .: " !% "

" % ! " "

" * "

" "* * % ! " %! %" " A "" !" *('(( "*"" " * % "

: " *

%: ?.2 "* ?.>

%" ! 1 " .:

"" !

* 'B0 " : 1

?.B % ! " " .:

% " (<(( " 3 ""% " 0 / % "1 " .

'2$'$777 % " (B(( (B : %!

" " " * " % " 3 & " " 3 & * - * " 3 % "" * "" " "",

" 3 & % * " % - * "%! % 83 * ! "%"*% * %

" % "*% % ! % %"

" 0""

" !%

0"% 3 * & % % 9! " % %"*"

" " " ! " "" " )$)+ +% " " " 7 0"": 3% ! 6!C"D ?.$! 6!C"D%

?.>% . .% *$( "" "

! * " + " *

% *$( ! 6! !" %+ % % % * "- =( (((;. ! 6! +% ! 6!% 4 -% + 4 "" " ! - %"363& "" 0 * &

363& ""%

% % ! 6!"" * & "" : " ""

% " " "

" "" 0" " "

" %"

"*($ 9! (="" , & 3% * * + , - % *"/E " "/ "" * 0 + $( 3 " ! "

?.>

?.2 * % % " * * ?.= 5, & *3 " * 0 + - " ! %" ?.> ?.2 " " " " !* "/ "

" "" "% " * *

"! " ! ! 6! ""3 " * ! ""

"! " %"%" "*

" - %"% 0 % " "!! " !! "

% 83 83 * % ! *

" %"% "! %% "! " %* "00 + " ! - % " "/ " ! !! " % !0 " & "/ $$ " * ! " % * &"* 0 + & * " " " ! "* " %*

" $' 1! " % * " 1! 0 + " " $) " " "

?.>

%%! 6! * ?.2 % .% "" "%! " ! ?.>

* ?.2% ! ! "%" " * % !

% " % ? ?.>

* $((( % % "" % "* %"% !% """

- % !% 0 " % *

* "" " 3 , & ! % * % % 0 &: *

- ! 6! * ""- -! 6!4 ! 6! *"- " * * !% " * ! ! 9! , "" % " 1 " .:

" " "

" * "

" "*? ?.2

*$(((

% - "

" "* !"

" "

" % "*4 &" -

% !"*

% $((;. *" % 1 "" - ! 6! 0 "" ! ! *% * & 3 , ! 6!

%" 0 ?.> ?.2 *% %

" % " " "% !! ?.>

" " "

" * "

" "*

0 % " " "

" % "

"-/ % 0

?.>

% !

"" % $<

" " :

1 % ! "

" .: " "%"*% %! % " % "*% % ! % %"

" " % %"*"

" 0 %

".""%! " " "

" "*"

% / *% * $=

" ": 3

! 6! % "" *$( "" "

! * " +" ! 6!!" %+ %

% "" ?.2 *

* "--

=( (((;. ! 6! % %! ! 6!% 4 -% + 4 "" " ! - 363& ""

% 0 ?.$ 3 " * ?.>

. .% 3! 6!1 - % 9!

?.2 !" "" 0 " % "" " ?.2 0 !"""

4 % % !

"" * . .%%" 0" */ % " * " " $>

! + % " * 0 + " * ! "! "

" "! * %"%- *

% "" "1 "" $'($'((( 9: " % "! %! " % "! %"% *

* % 9! %& *"

" " " "! 1

?.) +& %%+ "

- " % * $'($'(((

%"% *- - 1 " %

$ "! %

?.)

+& * % $'($'(((% ($ $>(''((( ! "-

+ * - 83* %! 83 * *&" % "

%"" % % " + &

'<()'((( 5 1 * "-* !*&" () ! " - 83 * 1 " "-* " % 5 1 '<()'((('2()'((( * : * " %% " *

14 " % "-; " % 83 $>(''((( 83"

*&"

%" "%%"! % % : " "*" * %"-

?.= 5, *% "! ! 6!C ""D * "! & ! 6!? " * "83 *

% %*&" %

* " " . " ! * "4" 1 " "

" %"%* ?.= 5, % *

% " !* %"%- & ! 6!"* ; ." $2

%!" " * 0 + 1 " 3 ! 6! ?.$ * % "" " " %* ;- !! ?.2 1 " "

" ?.$ 3 % ! ;

%?.2 ?.>

0 + " " " " ?.> ?.2 %"% ."

*% !!"" ", %%

* %%- %

% "" !

*% ? !! *

! 0 + " " * ! ?.B 1 ?.7 1 5 % % " "9!

?.'

- 3 ""% " * 1

5 "%! % % 1

5 " 31 " ?.B ?.7 " !

* - ! "" " * " "" ""

* 9! % %!" " * 0 + ! $B 1* * F* + 7 23 &/ 2 8#0

-2 2 9: 5 ;0'< )

' =

> 5;$=; .).&,=

5%. /# 01

"#$ %&'( 3'01 % & * 4 & 56 567 6 01

& 01

* 4 '1 &

& 1

& && & % &

" 1

" & 1

3 2 ) *!!+) , "

- $- %& - 1

3'1 &

" & 1 & & 1

1 & & & 6

% 8

1 8

1 &

& & 2

3 : .).&, << , ;#= % %

$ @!.

02 )80 ; !

&) &

###

,2.=&/& 2 A:/ (./ / &

F* + .

* $ ; 1

1 5

=1 51>? & 01

% 1 &

. )/ !

.!'#

9 /6 8

& " * $ ; 1 51 1

' 1 &

& '

' 1

' 1 8

" & *

& &

& @ '( 1 !%*!" %% * F* + % !%- * 0 + %* &

'$ 0 * ;8 0 BB= ;#0#0CD=

#$# % ? - ; E;A ? * E;A