State Of Haryana v. S.K. Gupta

 

 

!

 "# $  

 % 


&'('

)

%*( +, (&-'-+
))


 
   
 


    

  
)

 
   
 


    

      .#/

 )



0

/ 

  ! "# $$%  


& 

'( " ))%% 

('( ")($

***

0

/ ") / +

"#($" %%$#)((' " ,(-( .( )) %

/

0( " 1('2(-#2 ' 2  ,#3 1'( 4 +5654+778



4$'$      #  2($  )) %  ,'(  "# 

2" %%3#3 "'#$#32($$,&,( " ,%(.


 :

!#'' 2 % $#3 "'#%#3(' "# )) %  )% # #''4 )($

 ."(  .   )( $   9,4 #-##( %  3#  .  )% 2$  9$  9)#(  (  +;

6< +7<7  $  $)   % )(2$#3.## # $ 3 # "#  ", #(' "=9#& )(

#)93$($, #3$( $ $6+ +7;<'( 2(-&(' 5;

::74. ) $ $". - )( ('>9#( 3# " %%3#3,( "($ "'#%$ 2#-#%9# '()  #?92 #( @

)(( #2 9# . 2(  $,& "$'$  ,& ##3 - #(9)%## &(,?2 #( $(# # . 9,#

")% # #''" $$' 9$$ "(- #2(#- 2.# ?9#( '',&)) #3(''#2 # #(9 9 (%% 
.  2" 34" $ $. '(9$39#% &# "$)   %=9#& 9% #3#) #3(' ")9#" ($ % # #'''#%$ )%#2 #(  #3 ")%  1# ")% #

 ", #('

")% $#3(' ")  # #9.' $ $ '

 "&%$ -#$2 # % ,&?9$3  $$2$ $/< 6;

+77+

$2% $,( "($ (,#%%3 % $-(#$  %(  #$

"$'$  '(''2 #-2(-&'( ")% # #''9 #%  =9#&. "%$ 3 # "## 22($ 2.# "% .

!( )% # #'' $$'$  '#%$)   )) % #$?9$3

$ $  /< +778  % $  $$# #( %  # #2  >9$3 
# 

$##$ " )) %'#%$,& "$'$   $# " )) % )'$,& ")% # #''

"0# ))%%   921$(.

"%#, &3  "$'$  ("(%$ %3 %=9#& ##



"#, 21$() "

4$'$  ## )) %,'( "#

" -" $ "

2(9% $A #$ "2($.# ""# ,% # 2

<

!( "  "    " -   9$   2(29  '#$#3  $)   %=9#&"%$ 3 # ")% # #''#-#(% #-(' )#2#)%(' 9 %?9 #2 " ,'(9$ (.# .  )($92$,&# "(' ")  #( ", #(' "$(29  $

 (' " #3''#2 ."(. ( )#

(, 2(4A #$ =9#&)( . )) $ . "%$

=9#&. , $((-#$2 .  %('(9$,&,(

"$'$  $#$( )($92 "'#%('=9#& )(2$#3 $ ")($92$

2()#('($(29

."#2".-A"#,# $ 0#$#3 ".  , 2"('

9%<(' " ."#%9? , #-#%-#2B9#"  $ )) %C9% +7@/ " '(9$ ")9#" ($ , $( "'#$#3('92" =9#&2(9%$( ,9 #$

"#   '#$  (   (  (  # '  .# "  "  2(29

'#$#32($$,&,( " ,%(. ( # %2(9%$ ,'$ (,& "

2(9% ($#)% "'#$#3

;

 "# 3 

2(9%9,# " # %2(9 -#$# ?9$3  $$2" 3#-%#, & "

 ("(%$ '"

=9#& ."#2"" , 921$(.,& "0# ))%% 

" =9 "##3"

,3#- " ))%% 

" -2(#$$ "9,##( $,& "

2(9%

 +6

9 %(' ") )4,((1(' "#   )) %"(.   ))%#2 #('( &(' "#)93$?9$3  $$2.  (-$,'( "#

."#2". )2#'#2 %%&?2 $ )) % "  #$)$#3,'( "# '( "%  ( " 

"$2 $ % # #'' &" - #$# "# 39(

##3 " 3('9) 9 #( "# #(' "-#.

"#,% $ 3 3  #3('92" ())( 9# & "

# ( .   $ $ ") & $,& "

2(9%#?2 $

++

"#(#%%3 %# &(#'## &# "?9$3 ) $,&

,%(.

22($#3%&  )) %#$##$ $.# "(($ (2(

+/

$#3 ))%#2 #(BC #' & " %% $$#)($('


))



 0

/  JUDGE D" ") 1#3 ($ ( D" ")( ,% (