Kuljit Singh v. Baljit Kumar

        

 


 !"

#$%$!& ''

 


  


  

 ()

' * +)  ,     !
"#$%
"& '
(& '")
 *+,(% -+
%'
($$#",(&%!

 +)  , - ' 

)

.


.!

+&"

"&
%'
*(#"

(& ++
(+&)
(
,+
"&
%' "&%(&%
($$#",(%"+&)
-+
,+& +&"&
%'
#(
+-
/00
()
%'
"&%(&% ($$#",(%"+&
"
(##+1 !

/!

#(
+-
/00
(
"&
-"#"&
%'
($$(#
"
,+& +& !



2!

'
"&%(&%
($$#",(%"+&)
3"& (&%
+-
#(*
%+
($$(#)
"

",%
( ("&%
%'
+ 
+-
(,4"%%(#
(%
56!50!/5.6)
&  
#(&

 ","(#
( "%(%
%
#()
7"%()
1' )
%'
$+& &%
'(
& (,4"%%
+-
%'
&+%",
+-
(,,(%"+&)
(
*
$+&
'"7)
"&
(
,+7$#("&% 7( 
& 
,%"+&
.28
+-
%'
+%"( #
&%7&%
,%)
.88.

9'"&(-%
-
%+
(
%'
:

!!
,%;<!

  )

/ =!

'
++%
+-
%'
"&%(&%
($$#",(%"+&
,(&

%(,
%+
(

,+7$#("&%)
(
7( 
& 
,%"+&
.28
+-
%'
!!
,%)

%'
$&% ($$#",(&%>,+7$#("&%
( ("&%
%'
$+& &%!
'
"%
+-
%'
("

,+7$#("&%) (
&,+7$(
"&
$(( ($'
+!2
+-
%'
"7$ 
+-
(,4"%%(#)
" ?%(,%
'"&(-%




     

       

     

      

 

  



 

  

     





 

 





   !

  

      

      

 

  



      !

      

   "  "

   

   #

$   %&

%

'

 $

%

 



 

(   %&

%

'

 

'

"

  )*+, -.

-

,   , .

#

 /0  

1    



 



 

        



   

    2





 

    

 



".

 

  

 ".

   )*+, -.

-

,   , .

#

 /0  

1 ) 

".

 

    

 





 .
1 , 3 

  



%

' !

  

   

  

 

 

$ %%

'



    1* 

"  

 

  

 

   .

      3
0!

+&4&%
%+
%'
7(3"&
+-
%'
,+7$#("&%
9$(<)
%'
#(&

%"(#
+%
,+&,& )
(-%
(&(#@"&
%'
$#"7"&(
*"

&,
+-
%' ,+7$#("&(&%>$&%
($$#",(&%)
77+&
%'
$+& &%)
*"


+ 
(%

56!5.!/5.A)
%+
-(,
%"(#
-+
%'
+--&,
$&"'( #
& 
,%"+&
.28
+-
%'

!!
,%!

B!

&
+ 
%+
 %(&%"(%
'"
(## (%"+&
( ("&%
%'
$+& &%) %'
,+7$#("&(&%>$&%
($$#",(&%
?(7"&
'"7#-
(
C.
(&
(#+ $+*
+&
,+ +,7&%
?'"

"%
(
.
%+
B!
A!

-%
,+7$#%"+&
+-
,+7$#("&(&%;>$&%
($$#",(&%; *"

&,)
%(%7&%
+-
%'
$+& &%)
& 
,%"+&
2.2
!!!)
1( ,+ )
1'"&)
'
$#(
"&&+,&,
(& &"
(##
%'
(## (%"+&)
( #*#
( ("&%
'"7!

$,"-",(##
&"
%'
+ %&%"+&
+-
(&
#+(&
%+
%' %&
+-
%'
"$%
,'4
(7+&%
(&
$#(
%'(%
'
'(
+&#
%(3&
(& (7+&%
+-
!B5)555> )
1'",'
%++
'(
(#( &
$("


'"7!
&+-(
( %'
"$%
,'4
"
,+&,& )
'
$#(
%'(%
%'
,+7$#("&(&%>$&% ($$#",(&%
'(
,"*
%'
#(&3
"

,'4
-+7
'"7)
(
,"%
"& #"
+-
!B5)555> )
'+1*)
*&
$"%
-##
(&
-"&(#
$(7&%)
%' ,+7$#("&(&%>$&%
($$#",(&%

&+%
%&
%'
("

,'4)
(%'
7( 7"
%'+-

-"#"&
' 
(7+&%
%'"&!
++*)
"&
-&, *"

&,)
%'
$+& &%
?(7"&
%1+
1"%&)
"!!
C.
(D'

(%'(&"()
#3
+-
 
("&%"$)
7"%()
1'+
$+*
+&
,+

+,7&%
?'"

"%
(
C.>.
%+
C.>=)
(& )
C/
7(D"%
"& '

(& '(1()
#3
+-
 )
'("1(#)
1'+
(#+
$+*
+&
,+ +,7&% ?'"

"%
(
C/>
(&
C/>!

8!

-%
,+7$#%"+&
+-
%"(#
(&
$+&
($$,"(%"+&
+-
%'
&%" *"

&,
(*("#( #
+&
,+ )
%'
#(&
%"(#
+%
1
%'
"7$

+ 
+-
(,4"%%(#)
%' 
(,4"%%"&
%'
$+& &%
+-
%'
&+%",
+- (,,(%"+&!
* ***  )  *)   )  6!

'
#(&
,+&#
-+
%'
($$#",(&%)
"&
'"
,'(##& "&
%'

 (,4"%%(#
+-
%'
$+& &%)
'(
( 
%'(%
$"%
%'
,+7$#("&(&%>$&% ($$#",(&%
",'( "&
'"
+&
+-
$++-

%( #"'"&
(##
%'
4""% "&  "&%
%+
"&
'+7
%'
"#%
+-
%'
$+& &%)
%
%'
#(&
%"(# +%
,+&,&
'(

"&
(,4"%%"&
%'
$+& &%)
+&
%'
+,3
+- 1'"7",(#
+& !

'(
-%'
( 
%'(%
+&,
%'
$+& &%
'( '"7#-
( 7"%%
%'
-(,%7
4(
"(&,
+-
%'
"$%
,'4
%+
%' ,+7$#("&(&%>$&%
($$#",(&%)
"


1'&
'
'(
(,3&+1#

'" "

&(%
%'+&)
%'
1(
&+
+,,("+&
-+
%'
#(&
%"(#
+%
%+ ,+
(&
?,#$(%+
* ",%
"&
-(*+
+-
%'
$+& &%!
(%#)
'
'( ( 
%'(%
"&,
%'
$+& &%

&+%
*%
%+
%'
# (#
&+%",
*

$+&
'"7)
%'-+)
(
%(%%+
$7$%"+&
(+
( ("&%
'"7)
1'",'

7("&
& %% 
'"7
%'+ '
(

,%"+&
+-
,+ &%
*"

&,
(&
( ,')
'
+ '%
%+
'(*
&
'# 
%'
#(&
%"(#
+%
,+&,& !

) ** .5!

-+
7 (3"&
$+&
%'
$+,
+-
(,%("&"&
%'
*(#"

"% +-
%'
"7$ 
+-
(,4"%%(#)
"%
"
7
"7$(%"*
%+
,($%
(& +**"1
+-
+7
"

&"-",(&%
# (#
$+$+"%"+&!

11.

There is no dispute that this Court can re-appreciate the entire evidence while dealing with an order of acquittal. The High Court has full power to appreciate the entire evidence to reach its own conclusions and it is also open for the High Court, to re-determine the question of facts and law. For this, we place reliance upon the judgment passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra vs. Sujay Mangesh Poyarekar, 2008 (9) SCC 475.

12.

Also, Hon'ble Supreme Court in Chandrappa vs. State of Karnataka, 2007(2) RCR (Crl.) 92 laid down broad principles to be

followed while dealing with an appeal against an order of acquittal, which are as under:

"(1) An appellate Court has full power to review, reappreciate and reconsider the evidence upon which the order of acquittal is founded;

(2) The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 puts no limitation, restriction or condition on exercise of such power and an appellate Court, based on the evidence before it, may reach its own conclusion, both on questions of fact and of law;

(3) Various expressions, such as, 'substantial and compelling reasons', 'good and sufficient grounds', 'very strong circumstances', 'distorted conclusions', 'glaring mistakes', etc. are not intended to curtail extensive powers of an appellate Court in an appeal against acquittal. Such phraseologies are more in the nature of 'flourishes of language' to emphasize the reluctance of an appellate Court to interfere with acquittal than to curtail the power of the Court to review the evidence and to come to its own conclusion.

(4) An appellate Court, however, must bear in mind that in case of acquittal, there is double presumption in favour of the accused. Firstly, the presumption of innocence available to him under the fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that every person shall be presumed to be innocent unless he is proved guilty by a competent court of law. Secondly, the accused having secured his acquittal, the presumption of his innocence is further reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened by the trial court.

(5) If two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis of the evidence on record, the appellate court should not disturb the finding of acquittal recorded by the trial court." 13.

Ordinarily, the order of acquittal will not be interfered with, lightly, merely because other view is possible. Upon passing of an order of acquittal, presumption of innocence in favour of the accused gets reinforced and strengthened, as laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Harijana

Thirupala vs. Public Prosecutor, High Court of A.P., (2002) 6 SCC 470. .=!

&
%'
%+,'%+&
+-
%'
'"&( +*
?%(,%
# (# $+$+"%"+&)
%'"
+%
'()
1"%'
%'
( #
("%(&,
+-
%'
#(&
,+&# -+
%'
($$#",(&%)
7( 
(
7%",#+
*
+-
%'
"7$ 
+- (,4"%%(#)
1'",'
"
"& 
(&,'+
$+&
,,-#
 %%(#
+-
%' $7$%"+&)
& 
,%"+&
.26
+-
%'
!!
,%)

%'
$+& &%)
"

 "
(&,'+
$+&
-("#
+-
%'
,+7$#("&(&%>$&%
($$#",(&%
%+
",'( '"
+&
+-
$++-!
+1*)
%'
"7$ 
+-
(,4"%%(#
+
&+%
($$( %+

%("&%
1"%'
(&
"## (#"%
+
$*"%!
'
(+&
-+
-+7"&
%'" "&-&,
(
#,"

(%
'"&(-%!

.0!

'
$"7(
(+&
-+
-+7"&
%'
( +*
"&-&,
& -+7
%'
-(,%7
%'(%
%'
,+7$#("&(&%>$&%
($$#",(&%
'(
-("#
%+
-&"'

(&
%("#
1"%'
 (
%+
%'
#& "&
+-
%'
(##
#+(&
(7+&%
%+
%' $+& &%!
++*)
"&
%'
,+
+-
,+ ?(7"&(%"+&)
"%
1( ,(% +",(##
( 7"%% 
%'
,+7$#("&(&%>$&%
($$#",(&%
%'(%
'"
 ?'"

"%
(
.
%+
2
+
&+%
7(3
(&
$(3"&
4(
#& "&
+-
%' (##
-"& #
#+(&
%+
%'
$+& &%!
.B!

'
#*(&%
?%(,%
+-
%'
"7$ 
+-
(,4"%%(#)
1'",'

#( +(%
%'
"&-&,
(1&
'"&( +*
(&
#%(&%#
7+#"'
%' ,(
+-
%'
,+7$#("&(&%>$&%
($$#",(&%)
"
$+ ,
'"&(-%
4#   " 

 

  

      

      "

" -     5         

 

 

5 
    

     


      
           

   


  
   !"

!# #!$   %&''(





%&''(


      

   

 


    

 )

*  

 




           1   



  

 5    



 

    

 

 ,  

     

  "   

      



          

            

 

    

  

  

 -   

  " 

 

5      -   

  

 

 

 ,  

     

   

  

        "

" 6 

 +, *

 -  ./

. 0 & "

(12-1  2



  

 )7"

 ,   





  

         #    

    "    

  *

            

 6  43 .A!


(
4#
%+
%'
","+&
7( 
'"&( +*)
%'"
+% ,+7
%+
(
,+&,#"+&
%'(%
"&,
%'
,+7$#("&(&%>$&%
($$#",(&%
'(

-("#
%+
",'( 
'"
+&
+-
$++-
%'(%
%'
"$%
,'4
1(
"

%'
$+& &%
"&
#"
+-
'"
# (##
,+*( #
%)
%'-+)
%' (+&"& "*&
"&
%'
"7$ 
+-
(,4"%%(#
+
&+%
--
-+7
(&

+
$*"%
+
(  "%
+-
7" ($$,"(%"+&
(&
&+& ($$,"(%"+&
+- %'
*"

&,
+&
,+ !
.8!

++*)
"&,
"%
"
(
%"%
#(1
%'(%
+ 
+-
(,4"%%(#
'+#

&+%

"%
&#
%'
(
 %(&%"(#
+
,+7$##"&
,",7%(&,)

.

%'-+)
%'"
+%
+
&+%
-"&
(&
,+&,%
+&
%+
"&%-
1"%'
%' + 
+-
(,4"%%(#!
+&4&%#)
%'
"&%(&%
($$#",(%"+&)
3"& (&%
+- #(*
%+
($$(#)
"
' 
3$%4$%% 3)
"%
"& -%
+-
7"%)
(& )
%' $4567& 3 !83 8 !"

#96$ :)
&  
#(&
 ","(#
( "%(%
% #()
7"%()
"
' 
65; :3'

.6!

'
,(
$+$%)
"-
(&)

(#%
1"%'
"&
(,,+ (&,
1"%'
#(1!

'
,+ )
"-
(&)

(#+
-+%'1"%'
&%
+1&!

+)  ,    ''

 3 <$&3 8 ,; ; 8 %5 =$&7>8 %!& 3 %>!

,; ; 8 8 5!8 ?:  %>!