State Of Haryana And ORS. v. Dalip Singh



   

  

 

 

   !"# $"

%%&& '"( &%  )$

 $"()$ $ * (+

,$

% 

       -"

"

.

-"%  )$ /""0 10 !"# 0

"

"2 1(%0 2 "% 

  

4$&& )

%" %%&   2 ( & 7"%  " $& & &

)" * 



4$&& ) & "    2 %%& & %" 7  + 9" %%&&



      !

:"

 ( & (6+

%" 0 ( & 6"" &+

(6+ (

(



 *$"



( 

& ( "

<   *$

""

!&$ "2 !"# 0 2  &"

= <788> ;;; 8 <5<  <  0 )"  &

)" -$"+ "+ 

(6+  *

$ .( "

)"   +

)"  "%  $(0 ( 

"%  "

<   *$" (

& "

&# +" $

#" &+

%" & ( $" #" $(0 ( "2 +

)"( &

(6+ &$()$0 ( &+

%" 6" "& *&& 9" %%&& 6(  +"

& &* 2

( &+

%"0

&0 

:+

0 5  (#

+ ( 6"" &+

;

(%%" $ ")(+ 0 &"

 ( & "& (%

" !)$





   "%" 



")( $(0  

( =   (  "%  + + 6"" &+



        !

:"

 ( & "%  0

$"

$ 0 (6+ "& *&& 9" %%&& "

"  *$ &* "2 (%$&

(6+ "%   "

+"0 +($ 0 

 

%( " *" 2" *"

2"

++(  $+0

?

 "

)" &

)"

(6+ 

"%&# $& ! @6& (%"+ && 4
 " "A(" ++(  +%&#  "



+

++( 0 4
0 +" 0 *$

+ " 2"0 

?

 "

*$& ".

)" "& "%  &

;

(%%" $ ")(+ 0 &"

 ( & "%  "& (%

% ! @6& (%"+

   

   "%" !!""
##$ %0 & '

(    

    "%" !!)
##*)'

+,  ! !

-

 #

.--./ !  !

&

   

(  0+1.

*&& ! @6& (%"+

(  .
+2 ''

3
 '& 

"%" $ 
##)"

:"

 ( & "%  ("$"

(6+ "%  "  # 6"

 5 $(0 "&"

2") 4
 *" #"

0   0 %"

"%  0 " &6& ) "  "%  %& "  # 6"0

+"

& &*0 "&"

2" " *(& B*$ C

;

(%%" $ ")(+ 0 &"

 ( & "%  "& (%

! @6& (%"+

4 05.

8


6  "%" !!!
##)

:"

 ( & "%  (6+ ")(+ "

6$& *$ "% &+

& + 2 "2 ".

(6+ %"(& "& *(& $* ( =

&+

%"

= ")(+

A(

&+

& " 6" 9" %%&&

>2

)"(  %%& %"
0

($ ")(+ "

$&& ) ( =

+

(6+

"(+ 0 

%"+ " %& " + 6" $

;

(%%" $ ")(+ 0 &"

 ( & "%  "& (%

% !+$& -"$ !)$

  #

 -
+ !% !

!)512  78 ))$*

(%$& ! @6& (%"+ 4("0 4"  / $ $     %


9$*9 !    .    : 1 
+

( - 
+ &&$6 !)$

3'/  
+

0 # &4  "%" !"##

. *""0 D$"?$ !)$    0 & ,'  

;.   512  78  ) *&& 4&( !)$  8

 &
0  5.


;

,.<#-44 51   7    8  *$! 0

(%$& ! @6&

 

(%"+

(6+ 2

%"

 (%   0  &# 2 &"

   <0 "2 (6A( 0 "%  %& )"  &

)" "+ < $(0

)"  + "+ #"

 %" "%  &

(6+ (

& *$

%" $" #" "+  ( 

" "%  %&

  < $(0 ( *$

&+

(6+

""

2"

++(  %""

&"

   < $"

". "

2



& &

)" "+  

 !

E$ $" &"

 ( & %" %"( %%"

6?

*&& "" "& 2* %%& &  !"# +"& "2 + +%()  "& *&& 9" %%&& "2 (%$& "  $2

& $" "



E$ "%  %& & ( &"

 & ) $ " &

)" "+ 

$ %%  -$"+ 2  &"

  

+%""# 6

%("(  $ %% + 0 $ .  -$"+  -"+"#

5

!&$ 4 "0 $ )$ 0 E$& " !"

* E$& " "

("$"

$ "2 *" ")(&"F 2 &"

   $ &  /"0 !"# % -$"+  "#

(+6"

&

&  /"0 !"#  "

=   )"  &

)" $ .( "

+&# /$+ 

1") -$"+ *&& /&2 ,$

-$"+ *$  "#

(+6"

&

& *"  "

=   "%2&# 6( +

)"  "%  

% $+ 6 & +

E$ %" & *"

+

*"

+ 0 %& ?

)" &

)" "2 ""

)

E$ & 4
 *" +  

%"

*"

+

&2 %"

%"

*"

+ "%"( $" 6&*


   

       

          

    

 

    

!"

#$%"%#

  #$%#"%&

  #$%&"%

  #$%"%'

(   ) #$%'"% * #$%"%+ * #$%+"%% ,-



<

("$"

"% 

%"

)"  &

)" 2 &"

   < * 

<



E$ "& 4("0 2 ""

  < 0 "+ &&* (
# =    -.   

  .    + 

 



.7 +  ,7

 , * $$> & .

  





   /01  .

     "



  

2/01 ' .

   

   

  

2/01  .

 

  "3



 "3

   )  2/01 + = 



1   ,> % 

-

H$ "% ( = & &( (

% *$$"

( *$

+ "

0 (

  7%" 0  %&&# 6"2 ( *" B( %"C $(0 && ( *"  )   

;( = & 

2("

)    "& ?  "

2"& %

9" % ?

 "

4
0 +" 0  "" "+"?

B2")C0 *"

++(   + *  *$

%"(

6"2

<

4
0 +" 0  "" "+"?

B2")C (&

$2

?

 "

%("%

)" &

)"0  $# *"

++(  0 +" 0 *$

.( "

)"  &

)"

2"&

% *" ?

 "

("$"

6"2   "  # 6"

*   5

2 >I - 0 $(0 2

(+ $" *" 2") 4
 %""

0 + $(&

$2

 " *$&  " )" &

)"

% &0 2"& *"  "

>I -8    & 4
 "%"(

%" "& "&2 %"

%" "%"( $" 6&*
4 560'7



 8    

!"

#$%"%#

  #$%#"%&

  #$%&"%

  #$%"%'

(   ) #$%'"% * #$%"%+ * #$%+"%% * #$%%"%9 ,*- 

%  ( &"

 ( & "%  %& 4
#"

5 B2"# )C *$ "% +0 "" 

+ %)

"" *$" " 4
#"

5 +   + B2"#



)C

9("$"

""  &

+ *"

+ 0 "&2 %"

"%"( $" 620 $* #"

50 4
"" "+"?

B2"# )C

%%" &#0 "& *" )&# "" 4
#"

5  B)C  B2"# )C





%%& & %" & + 9" %%&&

 %"(&    *(& $*  6"2 ,"$

:& 4&"?

%%" "+  ""

!&$ 4 "0 !"# 0 4$ )"$ -H 

)"  &

)" ( $+ *   &#

( 62 B2")
%"C

4
 ("$"

+ 2") "%"

4
 *"

++(  .( " /&2 ,$

/$+ 

&"#

)"  &

)" *  

E$ % "  # 6"

& ?

 "

9" %%&&

E$   ) "& *&& 9" %%&&

% 2") "%"

4
@ *"

++(  "%  (&

%( 6" $

"

(& $*

$"

%"2" "

)  ""

$(0

%( "%" *"

2"

++( 0 +($ &0 %""



&

)" "A(" )" 



8

E$ ! @6& (%"+

   (%"0 6"2 2"# "# +( ++(  +%&#  "

  $ +# $2

%%"( # +? "%" 

)    $ ))"2

("$"

6"2 2

"( 7&"

"+ ($"  &# 2" " " ++(   "

 +%&# " &6& ) "

(& "

12"

+ "(



2& "& 8 "

# $"

%"2

4 ( $)$ &* &

& 6"2 2

"# B)C "A(" ++( 

++( 

"# (& & 2"&#  +%&#@ $  %"+

"

) + $"

 6( *$

+%"2 +"  6*

+%&# $"

%"

($ ( 2

"# B)C (&

"# )  +%&#

;

0  $&

""

(%$& "

 " %" #

%(6& + " && " *$$"

%"0 "0 2")0 ) "

2"# )



(& 4  &
%"0 " "A(" ++(  *$

" 6& + + " "A("  2

$" " "(&7 "(  %"$6 +

&2 %"

"%"( $" 6&*
$ .   -    4 4,

& 7,,  7,-.477  ,4  --   4, + -   +    

++  !

-  7 &7, 



 .



?

,. 1&4    - ,  - 
-  +@+  1 7 

 . A  4+A 4 . 

4

3

 

  A+A 4 7

  4 &7

 .

,  7  ,& +7

   - ,  3

,7. 

 .  

 71 7 4



+1 7 ,  1  

  4  



 +

 4 7

,- -  .+4 3+  A+A 4

 

7  7 ,&   7 , , .

+ &. - ,    7 

77

 :7  -  A+A 4  . &7,,  7--..  &. , , -   - 4 +   4  4  9*   .  &  -+    ,  A+A    A  4 +AB

#& :    

           

    

/ ;

&###<'<9%=5> >?     ;

)    0

 <0

  * 

 

  0      #<##$#$9%7   ) 

   )       

   )4 

    

*  

   

 

  #'



)         7     

      

     

 3        7 0,  ,  

 - ,.4   &7,,  777 ,-.4          1 .      -    &7,  &   47 ..+.& +

.

  7.* ..

, .   . C(  ,    C 7  0,    -7..

7  
1 7

.'

 . -.

7  

7@6 

 )A71 ..7.





& ..+.   .

&.& +  # 666666 #'  -    4 4, .4-    4 . +,-.4  
 

  ,.

4
1  7

.'

 .-.

7   

7D7-, .

 4,

&7,,  7   ,  1       &.  -       ,     71  

&7,   @   

&7, 97,,  7  4 ,4 .47,-.4A 77 - ,   + + , & &7

17,- 

,  

& + 7

    - ,    ,  & - 

+A+A A  +A A A 4 7  .4 .

77 & + .7-  

+A  4+A A   +A 4 #         7  



) 

!

@ A/ 

@

A,)* @

A* @ A   @AB

 @ A0

  



)    @

A@ 

    

     )           

 

)    

         

    

   7

          



 

 

   )  

 ) #+ 4   )> > )  

7  D   )    

>

>7>  >7 >>>)>  

 

  

    7

  )

D   )  ) 

 

 

   @   A #%     

     /   ;

    #<##$#$9%7   

     

     )     @ > > )A  



  >

>7>  >>>  7 

  

 ) @

    



A  

     )   )    

  >

   7    #99666666 $    7  

- 7 -.   .'

 7&4. + 

  - 74  - &.

7  , 

    ?

   ..    1 -        +  +     4  +       .

#  .- - &.

7 1  7

. '

 .  -.

7    4   
 

7  D7-   , .

 4,

&7,,  7 ,1    &. -         7  ,    -       

-+   3

 -  

7 7.+.-

     +     ,4  &     .C(   ?

+ 7,,  7  4    

 .C(  -  &  + &7

- 7 -. &   


7  

+&4  7.*#       -   ?

77,,  7    7.*1 ..

 .. .  (  , 

' .     ) 

    

  

  

            C 

    

 )  

 )7

  

 )      







 

 

  =.

.  -   ,

&7 &4   4

+        1  +      4   1

   .

.

 

     -     1 ..  & 

,, .4 '71  ?

7

   1 .&

8

--. ,#  # 

 

   

  

  

  ) 

  

   7 









 



(   

  )7

  

 )   ) / ) 



  

 '# .77 C    

    



)

 )  

         

   )  

E

 4

 ;

3F (

7&@'A(9''!&+@#A(+9 ;

41 ..--.4,-.4    4   - &.

7 7 7 -       ,.

 
   (  ,   '&''666666 '  -  97,,  7    .#  .- - &.

7 1 

7

.'

 .-.

7 4 

7  , .

 47  .4 7

.7 ?

7 &7

  ,47

77  - ,  + & 

  . 4  

  &   :7 

7,,  7   1 .  &   &   4    

.

  7.*#     '+ 

1& 1 -  & . 
+.6 + 1.. . 

 ;7  .1 :71 

'

+, 5 
+.6 + 1..  ,- +'

+, . 

;7

E$ &* & *

62 (&&# %%& %"

;

%" 0 2

2" 4
@ *"

++( 

D()+

62 &&* ! @6& (%"+

& '

(

 

  

(%" "

%%&# +0 ! @6& (%"+ 6"2 "# B)C

++(  $"

$(&

?

 "

%("% %"+

$)$"

)" $"

)"  %"+

*  < <

&2 %"

"%"( $" 6&*
"

#, +      7   -7     +   &7, F  4+F

 ?

 & +7

  - ,   , .4     4    F+F  1   7,,  7--.. 3 4A+A  .  &7,,  7 , 1 

+F  4 +F - 



4  7 , 7  

-  97,,  7  # - &.

7 1 

7

.'

 .-.

7 4  

7   , 7   7

.

7 ?

7  &7

    ,4  7 

 77   - ,     +    & 

 :7 

7  9 7,,  7 1 .& &   4

7

.

   7. * #     3 ,

1 &   &   7

 .

&4 --.. 3   F+F ..+  --.. ,  . &  7

     & + 7

    - ,  

+ +  3  - 7 --..   &  , +  ++



, 5   7  .  -- +      --..  

-   7 11 ,, .4'

   

7--..1 +

- ,  "

!"

!!!

3  --...

&, &+



5

- ,  , "

!"

!!!

5

>2

&    % ! @6& (%"+

(  0+1.

(%"0 % ! @6& (%"+

  

(%"

"& (%

9("$"0

(  .
+2 ''

(%"0 ! @6& (%"+ 6"2 ( "

#+ 3- 7 -.

1..9 . 77 71    .     .  '

 7       -      7  . ..7&7 -4- , .

--    .

 

 7,,  7      -  77   --   4 ,-  

1  7 7 D-. 7 , 7 . + -  
7--   4

,-4 ,.

4 

&'7-  ..4& +&.

-      7 7

  D-.  &4 - 77 1   - 

'

  

 )7   

7   

 

)

   

7     

 7*    



   6

 

    3   4   

7   

    "





 )  



    

      

        



  )



C

       )    3   .

  

7



     

7



  





 7   )7   



   "





 )   -





D()+ %

62 (&&# %%& %" 0 +($ 0

%" &0

2"

++(  2") 4
 $(0 + (&

$2

+ 6

)" &

)" "% 

E$   ) "& *&& 9" %%&&

% "

"  *$ &* "2 (%$&

<

 &&#0  *(& "&2

  &

%( "%  "  # 6"

*  0  5

>I - 

&&) 2") 4
 *" %""

 $(0 "& *&& %%&& $2 ")$&# ?

 "

%  & %

" (

*(& "&2



4  05.  (%"0 ! @6& (%"+ ?

 ! @6& (%"+

&
  '&

1#  5.0 "%" $!
- ,#  !")

 $& 2" " 12"

+ +%&#

$ 4
 " &6& ) "  (6A( "" +0 $ &&* "  # 6"0 + *(& +

*$& %"+ $+ "  # 6"

($ "

 " *"

( "(

(" %("% "  # 6"

$"

% *" &  "

!*2"0   ! @6& (%"+

4 05.

(%" & *$ +%(&"# ""+ $(0 ! @6& (%"+ 6"2

<

B*$  $"#C *(&

( 2"&&# %%&6&  +# $2 "&2  *$&  " 12"

+ "2 ("$"

%"+

6(

*$" +%&# 6 
2* ($"# "+ *$$"

$  " 

"2 "

 $ "A(" )2

+%(&"# ""+ 0 4++  +  "

+%(&"# ""+ "A("  " "2 ""

E$(0 %("% &

)"0 B*$  $"#C *(& && "&2

 # "0 % &#

 & % " ( 0 %"+"# %

+" *$ "%

++( 

2") "%" *" 2" 0 %

(

& $" 62



9"+ 620  %%" & "&

&+

( (

")$&# " "&

")$&# (%$& 9" %%&&

E "

&"

 ( & 0  *(& "&2 & *$ ")(+ " &"

 ( &

% ( 6 6"" &+

%( "& "+ ( =  $0 *$$"

( *$

+ ( +

  7%%&&

;

%"  *&&

%"  "& 4("0  %&&# "" ( = & *$ ( =

*"

%"



  7%%&&

 %"(& 9" %%&& *(& $*

")(+ $&& )  

( = " 6" 9" %%&&

>2

%"(& )"(  %%&

%"
)(&"

 %%& *(& $*

)"( $&& )  

( =

"

2

"+&#

)"(  %%&

%"
 ( %" 6" "& "

6" 9" %%&& "

 

( ""



E$ !+$& -"$ !)$

 

#

(%" 6"2 *$" ( *$ "% ( 6 + 6""

%"0 

%"+ " (

)(&"

 %%& +

%" 6" "&

E$ (%$& ! @6& (%"+ 2 ""

 5  %

%& :2 %%&

4 = 58 

>2

4"  / $ $

: 1  
+

(%"0 6"2  "+ )"(  %%&  %%" 6" 9" %%&& $"

"

( ( 6"" &+

(

")( 6" 9" %%&& 4("0  %%" $"

 (&# $

%" ")(+ &+

6" 9" %%&&  $"



$ ")( + 6" 9" %%&& 4("0  6"2 $"

*2



%& &+

(&

%"+ " +

)(&"

 %%&

E$ " H2"

 "

%& "& 

2"( ! @6& (%"+

E$ &&$6 !)$

3'/  
+

(%" 6"2 ( &+

+I A(

&*    (

%" 6" "& *&& 6" 9" %%&& 4("0 $"

(&

%"+ " +I A(

&*  " +

 %%& (6 & A(

&*



E$ D$"?$ !)$

,'   

(%" 6"2 $"

%" "

( &( ( &+

$(0  (""   * 4(" (&

 

%

+&"&#0 4&( !)$

0 5.


(%" & 6"2  (

"+ +

%"   $"

 %%&& )0   $"

(&

" %&

9("$"

4&( !)$

(%$& ! @6& (%"+ 2  <  %

:-

42& "# =   5 

 0 &"

 ( & 2"# 2$+ &# " % 0 $(0 $  " +" %& &+

%(

&"7""

". &+ *$ "% )" &

)"

%&



"" "&

;

%"

*"

+ & %" 0 "" 

+ &"

   < # &

)" )"  "+ <

-"

*"

+

"%&#

+" "%"( $" 6&*
  )  

    

   

      #'%% 1 . &+

 .7 +  ,

" 

  

  7  .  / "C**9@9"$C%$$ 9%)%   $ "$ 8

%( (

(



 *$

%" $" #" "+  &"

   <

$ & &

)"

E$"

""7++( 

%"(

"" ". &+ )" &

)" *  

E$ % &"

")" "" 

+

*"

+ 2 &

)"

)"  "+ <    <

*(& "&2

 

%( 2

&"

   < "

&"

 <   $2

%"(

""   7%%&&

&+

%" & ( $" #" "+  ( 

"

;

 "(+ 0  %%" ( 

*(& " 0 2

2"+ +

%"

*"

+ " ?

"(



  2&(0 "

(  &"

   < *$

&# %" "& )" 

0 %" "&

".

"2"0

%" 0   ( *$ "% &+

%" $"

"+2 2 7(+ $* ( 

"

%""

(  &"

   <0

2

0 ")(+ "

6$& ?

 "  60 ( &+

*(& +I A(

&*   $

%" (0  *(& +"

)" .( &&* %" %%&   "& *&& 9" %%&& &#

%0 +" 0 *$

( +""( "& *&& 9" %%&&

% +" $2

(%$& $

,%

2* 62  "(+ 0 "& *&& %%&& " (%$& %" %%& +

5

&& %  +&& ( %%& 0  #0 $&&  %

2* 62 ""

"#
""$"%

 

  &'()'(*+,(-./012*(-+30(4!

(+23 &'()'(**(,3*)-56(!

(+23