High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/440/2002allowed

(O&M) Daljit Kaur v. Upkar Singh Etc.

2015-02-05Mr. Justice Paramjeet Singh Dhaliwal8 pages

!"#$"%&'(& )*+$,- +.$#" /// + " 0"1#1

23$")

45$

+5"1 /// 12

66666 "4# !% 7" "$+37$5$-$ ' 8$+ "+52+ " "+5"12

9#+ +5 :$"

&;(<<< +5 7+"

+1 ,$ *1 "

!# $, =5"

$+" * $1 +5 "

!# $,> "

"8"% 1('?'@ :

+"1+A(B2"$

#*"*+5 $+ $22, (CD(<<:

+51+1'$+"+5 $+5$4 ")

45="15"+'

+5>'5 15#1 11#45++!$++$5 E4$,5 "1$4 ")

++5$

$ ,221 +5$22, " 5, ")*+$,- +.$#"="

15"+'+5>"$++$5* ++52"2"+% 5#1$4 ")

+5"

8$,,$ *1+52$"+ 1' 11#1:5 5:" "$* !%+59#+

4#"+$"4 8 +5 9+2$4

( F5+5"+55#1

12#+ 1, $!,+!$++$5 G

F5+5"+51$""1

+55#1

12#+G

, ? +""

4"$,$1:,,$1 #* +$"%8

"*+5 2$"+ 1'

4!+5+5 11#1

$8#"+5!-+"1'E 1+5'

$22, +5"$++$5* ++55#1+5:$1

1* 11 + 1$4$

1++5 1"

"+5$++55$1*

1 ,"8 2+ !%

41#2"8 1"%-#"

+ +5 1#"+#

""+ ,C+5 1+ +#+

$ 1"8 2+ ' +5$1! ,$ * !%+5+5$++5 2"++ #

")+ :5"!%+5"1

$,5#1

+$++$5$!,' ,$!,++5$, $

++5 1,4$,5 "1+ 1'

+5#1',$ * +5$++5"

"1#"1"*

5" +$

1,4$,,% # + $!,# 1,"+55$1,$ * +5$+1

2"++ )+

;=(>=> +$8$ ,$!,++5,4$,5 "1+5$

+5#1'

"8"1

4+5 *2#4 "

"'+5 1"8 2+ 1, $!,+!$2+ ; 5#45"12

+1(+ ,4$,"2"1 +$+ 81+5 :" #,%"2"1 + !%$# 1,!#+ $22$" !5$,+5*

##1,%"*$ % $+1$1$,1 +5 $%$

"11

4$"4#* +1 1H# +,%' +$3

4 +5* $1 5$8

4 ! 2" $4$

1+ 9 2$"+'

$"4#* +1:"5$"

+&:$1$,12" $4$

1+9 2$"+8

" (;(? C

$-8

45' ,%1 +55$

(;(<<

*+"85 #,$"$

+$#1 !%"$15$

4, 4 "

4+5'

2" 11"

+"1+"12

+1(+5"

5$, 4:

5" 5#1!$

, $ ,$ * 2+ !" +5 "

!# $, " 4"$ + *2 1$+ "# *,% $+5+5 "1 !"#45+$!#+!% 4, 4

4+55"

!# $,8

:$"

&;(<<<$:$"

*2 1$+ 1('?'@ :

+51+1$

+"1+A(B2"$

#* "*+5 $++52+

4,%':

"+5

485 , :$1$4- +)

45'"12

+&5"

D )+ ""$ %"" 1$22

$1 !,:

!"# $%&'$! " &""&()*!+" &+, -&$! %+ !.!(/"%+ ,!(!!

2%,!,")&"")! $$3%+4 &"%(/$&--)&$$+"'!$%&'$!" -/()&""&()*!+"-&$!5+&*!$#5 0(((1+!*&%+!-%,!+"%&$)/-!&+,")!'/%$,%+4-&""&()!, "%"03%")")!*&"!%&$&+,")!-%"!-")!! &+,")!$&+, %**!,%&"!$# & /"!+&+" ")!! " &+, +!(!--&# ")!! !+6#*!+" '!$+4%+4 " & 6/,4*!+"

,!'" ")! ")&+ &+ &4%(/$"/%-"&+,((/ %!,'#)%*

2%,!,")&"")! "!("%+& ,!,'#")%-($&/-!-)&$$+" !."!+,"&+# !"#- !(% %(&$$#()&4!,3%")")!,!'"-/4)" "'!!(2!!,J <

"#1$, +5 1 2"8 *$31 + ,$" +5$+ +5 2"++

$8$ ,$!,$4$

1+$++$5* + "1

$,5#1 ,$!,+$$

19*2+ 12"1 $,

$+#"*$

4+5"!%+5$+ 1 +,:+ +5! ++5,4$,5 "1+5:55$8

+ +51$

5#1 "*+5 " $1 $+5"$

$"$,1,

4+5"

5*$++" *"

!$+$!,5"$" #*!"$#+5"

1,$",%5,

4+5$++5:"

$22$"

)+ ;(=(>=> 1 +

,# 5 1,4$,"2"1 +$+ 81

4+5"!%+5$+E 1+5$" + +, ++5! +#

"+5 ,$#1 "

1"4$"

*$%!*$ +

! "5 11#$*#2 "$ -#

!"$"

$+ 5+5 1#"+$1:,,

#$ %&' ($ )

*+ ,- ( $ *

/( 0 ! 1 :5"

+:$1,$",%5, +5$++5 2"++ $8$ ,$!,#

")+ ,$!, ,%+ +5

2"1

#, +2$11 +5 1,4$,"2"1 +$+ 81 $"$C 1-# 1",8$ +$

""$ %"" 1$22

$1!,:

I7 8&3&,!(!&-!,3&-")!6/,4*!+"

,!'"&4&%+-"

3)* ")! *+!# ,!(!! 3&- &--!, )! "!("%+ * &""&()*!+" +!*&%+!-%,!+"%&$)/-!/+,!($0(((13&- &2&%$&'$!")%*%+ !-+%-3%,3&4,%-)&+%'!%+4+"& 6/,4*!+"

,!'"(&++"&2&%$ ")! "!("%+/+,!($0(((1 )! "!("%+ /+,! ($0(((1 3)%() 3&- &2&%$&'$! " 8 &3&56/,4*!+",!'"0+3,!(!&-!,15")!! !5(&*!"&+ !+,3%"))%-,!&")+ (" 5 9:

)! "!("%+/+,!

($0(((1'!%+4&2&%$&'$!"")!,!(!&-!,%+ !-+3/$,+" &--+")%-3%,3&-)%-$!4&$! !-!+"&"%2!+,!")!-! (%(/*-"&+(!-5")!!%-+!-(& ! *")!(+($/-%+")&"")! ,!&") ")!6/,4*!+"

,!'"+ (" 5 9:

5)&-!+,!!, ")! !-!+"!2%-%+%+ /("//- ( 5 1*$++"$4$

$*#2"$ -#

%+$ +5"$1 -# +:5" 1"2"+

/( 2$ 1&!)33 3 "

!%$"

5+5 1#"+:5"

+:$112 $,,%5, +5$+8 $:

:$ $

+$8$ ,2"++ )+ ;=(>=> ,8$ +2"+ 2$"$;+5 1-# +"

"$+

"! $,#1 1$22

$1!,:

;

"*&#&$-'!+"%(!,")&"($&/-!0(1 -/' -!("%+0 1 !("%+ ")!,! 2%,!- "!("%+ *&""&()*!+"&+, -&$! )/-!-&+,")!'/%$,%+4-03%")")!*&"!%&$-&+,")!

-%"!-")!! &+,")!$&+,%**!,%&"!$#& /"!+&+"")!!"&+, +!(!--&# ")!%!+6#*!+"1'!$+4%+4"&+&4%(/$"/%-" &$&'/!&,*!-"%(-!2&+"&+,((/ %!,'#)%*)%- -)3-")&"!.!* "%+%-&2&%$&'$!+"+$#"")!6/,4*!+"

,!'"'/""&+# !-+3)*&#'!%+ --!--%+ ")%- !"#&+,%-&+&4%(/$"/%-")!3,=6/,4*!+" ,!'"%- (+- %(//-$# *%--%+4 %+ ($&/-! 0(1 -/' -!("%+ 0 1 !("%+ 3)!!&-($&/-!0(((1 -/'

-!("%+0 1 !("%+ 2%,!- "!("%+&4&%+-"&""&()*!+"&+,-&$! +!*&%+ !-%,!+"%&$)/-!'!$+4%+4"&6/,4*!+"

,!'")/-5")!!%- &($!&,%-"%+("%+'!"3!!+")!"3($&/-!- -/' -!("%+0 1 !("%+ ")!,!)! *! 2%,!- "!("%+"&+ &4%(/$"/%-"%+!- !(" )/-!-&+,")!'/%$,%+4-'!$+4%+4 "&+,((/ %!,'#)%*3)!!&-")!$&""!($&/-! 2%,!- "!("%+"&6/,4*!+"

,!'"+$#%+!- !(" ")!*&%+ !-%,!+"%&$)/-!((/ %!,'#)%*J (( +$ +5"-# +$"

$+ 5+5 1#"++ +,

& ) $ &

/()!1 $,15, 1+5 , $"$+5-# +""$ %"" 1"2" #

$1!,:

I )&2!4%2!+&")/4)" /$(+-%,!&"%+"")!&4/*!+" ")!$!&+!,(/+-!$5'/"!4!"*#%+&'%$%"#"&((! "%" $&/-!0(((1 2%-"!("%+ 0 1 2%,!-")&"+!*&%+ !-%,!+"%&$)/-!&+,")!'/%$,%+4-&""&()!,"%"'!$+4%+4 "&6/,4*!+"

,!'"")!")&+&+&4%(/$"/%-"&+,((/ %!, '#)%*5-)&$$+"'!$%&'$!"&""&()*!+"-&$! 2%,!,")! !"#%-+"- !(% %(&$$#()&4!,3%")")!,!'"-/4)""'! !(2!!,!("%+- 1&+,

1 ")!,!,! %+!")!

"!*-=6/,4*!+"

,!'"&+,=$!4&$! !-!+"&"%2!)!-!&! ! ,/(!,'!$3 =/,4*!+"

,!'"*!&+-&+# !-+&4&%+-"3)*& ,!(!!)&-'!!+ &--!,&+,!(& &'$! !.!(/"%+)&- '!!+*&,!=!4&$! !-!+"&"%2!*!&+-& !-+53)%+$&3 ! !-!+"-")!!-"&"! &,!(!&-!, !-+5&+,%+($/,!-&+# !-+3)%+"!

*!,,$!-3%")")!!-"&"! ")!,!(!&-!,&+, 3)!!& &"#-/!-%--/!,%+&! !-!+"&"%2!()&&("!")! !-++3)*")!!-"&"!,!2$2!-+")!,!&") ")! &"#- -/%+4-/!,

>*")!-",! %+%"%+5%"3/$,'!-!!+")&"6/,4*!+"

,!'"%-& !-+&4&%+-"3)*&,!(!!)&-'!!+ &--!, &+,!(& &'$! !.!(/"%+)&-'!!+*&,!",!-+" %+($/,!")!$!4&$! !-!+"&"%2! -/() !-+%+ !!+(! (&+'!,&3+ *")!-!,! %+%"%+-")&"=$!4&$! !-!+"&"%2! & ,!(!&-!, 6/,4*!+"

,!'" %- !+"%"$!, " ")! '!+! %"- 2%,!, %+ ($&/-! 0(((1 !&,%+4 !("%+ < /")! "% %!-*#2%!3" 2%,!-")&"% &6/,4*!+" ,!'",%!- '! !")!,!(!!)&-'!!+ /$$#-&"%- %!,5")!,!(!! )$,!

*&#& $#"")!!.!(/"%+4/""!.!(/"!")!,!(!!&4&%+-" ")!$!4&$! !-!+"&"%2! ")!,!(!&-!,53)-)&$$'!$%&'$!" ")!!."!+" ")! !"# ")!,!(!&-!,3)%())&-(*!")%- )&+,->*")!& !-&%,$&+4/&4!5%"%-!2%,!+"")&"")!$!4&$ ! !-!+"&"%2!%-+" !-+&$$#$%&'$!" &#")!&*/+" ")! ,!(!!5'/"%"%-")! !"# ")!,!(!&-!,%+)%-)&+,- * 3)%()!(2!#(&+'!*&,!'#")!,!(!!

)$,! "!"&?%+4 %+"(+-%,!&"%+")!&'2!-&%, 2%-%+- ")!,!5&* ")! %+%+")&"")!3,-=6/,4*!+"

,!'"%+($&/-!0(((1 2%-"!("%+ 0 1 ")!,!,!-+"%+($/,!)%- $!4&$! !-!+"&"%2!&+,")!! !5")!$!4&$! !-!+"&"%2!%- +"!+"%"$!,"")! "!("%+ ")!-&%,($&/-!+")%-2%!3 &* "% %!,'#")!'-!2&"%+- ")!!$)%%4)/"%+

. $ &) 53)!!%+%"%-)!$,")&"")!-+-5'!%+4")! $!4&$! !-!+"&"%2!-5&!+"!+"%"$!,"")! "!("%+ ($&/-! 0(((13)%()!."!+,-+$#"")!6/,4*!+"

,!'"&+,+"")%- $!4&$! !-!+"&"%2!-)!$!&+!,/,4!)&- /")!'-!2!, ")&"")!3,-=6/,4*!+"

,!'"&-/-!,%+($&/-!0(((1,+"

%+($/,!)%-$!4&$! !-!+"&"%2!-)!(+"!+"%+ 8)&%& %-5")!! !5!6!("!,J ( 5 1*$++":$1$4 +$+ $4$

!"$"

$+ 5+5 #"+$

:$1"1,8 8

-# C("2"+ $15 6

( !"

!&7) &3) 1:5 5

+# :

+5+5,$:,$

+5$", "-# +1 +,%'

$-# 2" # (?"2"+ $1 3

2 6

73 78 '$"

$+ 5+5 1#"+5$1

1#11 $12+$+$1# +, 4+5$

+1$ -#

+# :

+5+5

" !%+5$", ""

$+ 515 41$

1+2#"+5"$

+5$+)+ +$22, $!,+ +5$11#

"+57+"05 ,1+'(<DD 1"4$"

'2$"$?+5 $#+5"

+% 1"2" # $1#

;

!&+!, (/+-!$ -!!?- " (+"!+, ")&" & (!,/! !-(%'!, !+ (!*!+" (!--&4&%+-"$&+,*/-"'! /+,!-",&-& (!,/!")&"(&/-!-&+%+"!,%("&4&%+-" &""&()*!+" ")/4) !+ (!*!+" 2%,!, /+,! ")! %2%$

(!,/!,!)%-&4/*!+"5%+*#2%!35%- &$$&(%/-5 ")!!%-+*!&+-'#3)%()")! 2%-%+- %2%$ (!,/!

,! (/$, '! %+( &"!, %+ & (!,/!5 3)%() %- %+,! !+,!+"$# !-(%'!,/+,!")!&+,!2!+/!(")!# !&"!%+"3,%-"%+(" %!$,-&+,(!"&%+- !(%&$ %2%$!4!- 3)%() %2%$ (!,/! ,! 2%,!- !+ (!*!+" ,!(!!-(&++"'!& $%!,"!+ (!*!+" &3&,-)!" @!)%($!-("%"-!$ %-&(* $!"!,!&+,")!!."!+""3)%() %2%$ (!,/!,! 2%-%+-&!& $%(&'$!&!'/4)" ")/4) ")! " @!)%($!- (" %"-!$ /() (!,/! &+, 3!-&!-!"/"/+,!!("%+

9 ")!"@!)%($!-(" )!! !!+(!-"%2%$&+,%*%+&$ (!,/!-&!&2&%$&'$!

+$#%+- &&-"&?%+4 !2%,!+(!+&")5!+ (!*!+" &""!+,&+(! 3%"+!--!- &+, (* !$$%+4 ")! &"# ,/("%+ ,(/*!+"- 3! /+,! !("%+ 7 %- %+,! !+,!+" &+# 3!"!(2!/+,!")!%2%$ (!,/!

,! %"-!$ '# &""&()*!+" ")! !"# ")! 6/,4*!+" ,!'" ")!,!(!!

)$,!-!!?-"!-""&""&()*!+" ")!

!"#!+ (%+4")!&3&,&-&,!(!! %2%$/"5)! -)&$$'! ! !("$#&"$%'!"#",-'/"% ")!!(2!# *+!# %--/4)" *&+# !-+/+,!&+&3&,& "!-!(/%+4& (!"% %(&"! &*/+" *")!$$!("")!+")! (!,/! ")&"")!$$!("3%$$ $$3-)&$$+$#'!3)&"%- 2%,!, /+,!")!&+,!2!+/!("%"-!$ A (? .2

8 : +5++$, +% $+1 $

"#*1+$ 1 $1

1#11 $", "':5 +5"+52"++ $8$ ,$!,#

")+ ;=(> => ,$!,++5,4$,5 "1+5 ")+ ;=(>=> $11#5$22, 1++59#+ +5:$"

" !%+5 "

!# $,'+5 *2#4 "

"1#"1"*

5" +,4$, +$

+5#1' 1+$1

( )H#,,%'+5$22, +5 1$2+

1"8

2+ 1$,,: 59#+

4#"+ 1"

" +2" :

+5+5 *$++"$++$5* ++52"2"+%,4$,5 "1+5$

#"+5"+ 9#++5 "1+5$++5 1$!,+ 4+

15$"4'

9#+

1$+ 1$+ +5 "#

"9#+ :

+5+59#+

#"+ (& )

+5*$++" 12

, 4'+59#+

4#"+ :#,

$, 1+59#+ +5 ":

+5"* +51"*+5 " 2+"+ 2%+5 1"

K$4#++L ( F5+5" 2"+"1,$,2$2"1*$%!$,,: +1+5-# +G1 F5+5"+!""" ++5 2"+"1" +G1 ? F5+5"+5-# +15#, !"2"+

+5 41+G1