Bhakra Beas Management Board Etc. v. Lachhman Etc.




    
 

   !""#



$%   &""&

    




 

    

  

  '

 ()'

" 
  '  )  

 

 !"#$"% & ()!



!# "* + #$"%  ,"  '+#-!  !! #$"%  ,"-"# ". /0

 '  )*"

--++

$-,# - '+   %"#  -- +  3!  !$#  3*  '#4  #  #%  # # .56..776 - #3*+ ###!!" +!!%8'# "- ) 3* ,! -- +-,#3*-"#1-+

!#!4! +", !'! 3* '#4 ##%# #2.69.75:3*"'",,!! %! "'  ",  '3  8'#  ;!  +   "-   )   ++")#  #  '!  ", !!,,) #%#3*+ #;!--++ "'$!# !4-'# '#4 ##%# #.56..776 / -"#1-+ !!,, 

#  -,#   '!  ,"  #%+  !" %+ !4! 4+$"3")!-"!"",'!+ #3 !





".<1.  &5=6(  .61.  &0=.6(  #  .:1<1.  &<=0(  !'

#  !  !++
") +>)  #

+ #) "!! ++* ++"#"4 3 ! #    3*'

"$4

*"+#!"-"#1-+ !!,, "< "!'"+#.:?

+"-"#1-+ "."0 )"

!# +### #.:6:.792 #/.69.79<>)  #

 

$  "  !

  "$     '!  -"-*  ")$

1#,#  ". %!  ",,!%'#

'3+!%4! &$!%!"", ' "!@# %%'- (% .79.& ! ,,#"  A+%,B(!'#"!%'#%!"0&!( #9&!!!(# #/6...756>  #

 "!% !++ + #"3!#!" !

", '!-"-*!"$#! 

"  %-"$!!"",%!".79.% "!%) +"

%

++#" "'#

"!%

$, !+#"#!%+" "'# "

") #")

3 ! 1#,#  ".

#,"4#!"-!!"

'!  + #  )   -'3+!%  -4!  #  ")  -"#1-+ !!,,    ! ' ' "!@#  "%%'- !"  >  !  #  

  -"#1-+ !!,, 

#

+ #*'%%##!!#%+  !","4 "'",!"'38'# "-   

   *    ")  !  -"!"  ",  '!  + #  %%"#!+* #%+  !"

"!%!'#3* 1#,#  ". +!

3+"3 !"# #"3!#!" !

",-"#1-+ !!,,) "'

 2 '!) %"#3* 

* #

'!!3 #'#%!".<",.79.%>)  #

'!-"-* ! -'3+!%-4!) )  %C'!#3*'

3  #")3! '#  %""+  #  4 4  ", 

? 
   4 
"

# & ! ,,#" A'B(3*$!'",'

! !"%

- .7::>)  #

'!+ +")! " + #!'

#!!++
") +)  %C'!#3*'

3 $!#"!,!% !"# #/662.7</ '#%!":", #%C'!!!"% .570, %C'!!!"",'! -"-* !!

# ",



) " ")",'! + #!'#4 #%""+", "/

#2>)  #

-"!"",'!+ #)  ?3*'

"$4  "  6<./.7<6  #  !  $!)  ",  #  # #  /<6:.7<2

"'%#'# -"$!!"", #%C'!!!"% !! ", '

3) "!D%+'!$")!-"!"",'!-"-* #!% #%""+",'!+ #$#! "/

#2!$!)",%!"/&4(",'

! !"%.7::  ," "!%)%"%+*!'#'#-"$!!"",.79.%>! #

!' ' "!@#"%%'- !"",'!+ #+!

3+ "3 %# 0 ;"4 -+ #!",- ! ,"++")!!'), 4#= .   "!%# #/6...756'#%!"0&!(

#9&!!!(", '3+!%4!%!'#3*,# 

".    !++ +  ' ' "!#  !,,%!$  #  )! "'

'!#!%!"F  /   -+  ")", '!+ #F

 2   %!$!+%"'

" '!#!%!"" ! '!F  0   '!! -,"4#""+!F  <       '!  !  3 #  ,"  "= "!#  ",  % * - !F  : +!, <

 "%""$*! -% !)  "!%

. !'#" 1#,#  ".'#%!"0&!( #9&!!!(",.79.% %"'+#

$3$ +!#+*!'# -"-*%+ !4#3* 

#2!-'3+!%-4!")#3*'

"$4'# #%""+", #2 :

 " 

# !! % ",-+ !!,,1-"#

*

##'+*-'%

# '!-"-*3*) *",!# +## ,"4     ++"  ",  + #  ) "  )  ++"#  + #  #  !  ! !!,,) "

$3,"'#"3")!-"!" 

!  '

3  "$4    ) "4     %+ !4!4 #%""+!$!)", '#4 ##%- #3* !"'38'# "- ! !, $"'#%+ ! 4"3")"$ '!+ #

," "!%!'#'#.79.% $"!#
  '!+ #!"-'3+!%-4! 9 ;"4 -+ #!", - ! !!%+ 

)"!'  C'!#"3# +)! !- -- +;!+* )  + #$#! 

##"$"


'#'

!@ !"% .7::)"'+#3-'3+!%-4!)! !4 !",.79.% #%"#+*   "$4",'

3!!

,'+")",'!-"-*!$!!

" #2"4 #%""+'!-"-* # ,,%", '#4 ##%- #3*+ #!"'3=8'# "-  $!#) -"#1-+

$3 +#")",'!-"-* 5 ,  ,!C'!"!%"%#  !"#"'3 #! ,,%",-"$!!"",%!"/&4(1)%!"95 #97",'

" !@ !"% .7::


) %"!'#3* + "$4 '#  %!" 9 ",  '

3 " ! !" %  .7::   %%"' ",

# " !@ !"",) !+

3


% 4!"D!%

+ #-"-!",

?  4 $"! #)"? --'  "

$#!


3*$!'",%!"97",.7::%%!"97",.7:: %!-"#'%# !3+")," #*,%= 


  

 


    
 

 
 
  



 
 !

"




#
!!$ $ "
%&

 

'

 (
 $ 
##
 )

*

'

 *

+,% 
#-
.$,)

    
  
$  
  (#
"  ,
  


/0#)

 

.$,& .   
   

"  

 


#
%
  
 ! 
 ! ( 
 .$,






 $
%
 


 $

 -
.$,)

!1+


 $
"2

".
#
"'" 3 

"1
 
 ,

 
445-6 
 
 +
$ #$
#! 



  )


$ 


%"% !
7!!

0"#!%

4  



 
 
!

888

9 !! 



 
 
  

 
!##%!$
! 

+

& *

.:1
!,
%

".:



(
:


 
 


%
 

 
 $!; 1
!.:

 1
!(
:

"



 ! +

!1 <) 888= 7

," !!%+ 3*$!'",%!"95 #97",'

" ! !"% .7::%

 #4!! !" 4 ! % %""+

#"- !"",)"?",

?  4 $"! #)"? --'  "$#! #2% + #")#3* 

#$#! #2,"-'-" ",4 #%""+)"'+#3-'3+!%-4!)! !4 !", %!"/&(",.79.% #%""+3* 

#2!"3

+,",'")", -"-*  ,"  %

 %",-'3+!%+ ##'+*%"$#3*-"$!!"",%!"/&(",.79. %)"'+#"3+"3*$!'", ,",4 #%""+", + #!, $"", #2

+ #)"'+#3-'3+!% -4!!,!!")#3*

3 ,#," #%""+" #2 .6 ")$ !-%  ""+* %"-",-'3+!%-4! !3!%

++#3*-"#1-+ !!,,3' $*3 !")

?!#%+  !"

'!-"-*!-'3+!%-4!!

+"3!%

++#

-"#1-+

$+!#'-" '#4

##%# #6560.756- #3* 

+ !"'3=8'# ""-

!% !+#/00,10 "2" $304,0,,1 $51

+ %,06*
750,7 80,/,* $3040  .. >!)" "!%!

! 3"$"#'! ) )  +"

,!+#3*-"#1-+ !!,, !)  +#

!!-"#1-+ !!,, " ")!-"!"",'!+ "$4",'

3)  ! '%#  ,"4  !,!  !     - %,'+  -"!"  ", !!,, ./  #%"'+,"



'#

 '#4 ##%# #6560.756!"3!#!'-"

 *)"- *" '! #'! -"-*$#! #2," -'-"", #%""+ .2

  %"!# !"     '4   !#  "  3

+,  ",

#2% "3 %%-#

") !-!



$"3 ,#!, $"'", #2 '#'

!@ !"% .7::>!"+*4 #%""+ ",  + #  ")#  3*     ",  '

3  )   #   ,#  "  

#2

3!++4 ! ")", '!-"-*

4 #%""+",-"-*) !")# 3*

+"% 3$#! #2 >  %   )   -"-*  !  "  ")#  3*     ",  '

#2% "?4 #%""+",  4 .0 >  -  %   3*  $!'  ",  '#4  #  #%  # # 6560.756- #3*'38'#;!+ ""-

 !!-"#= -+ !!,,) "

$3 +#"3")!-"!"",'!-"-* 

!

!

3

 %%-#  !# '#4 # #%

$%

++#  4 $ "'

 4) ;#


#) #'+*+!#'-"3*-"#1-+ !!,,!-'!
*$!' ", '#4 ##%# #6560.756  ") !-", "$4", '

3 

  "  3  %%-#  "$     '!  -"-*  #   

$3 +#"3")!-"!"",'! -"-* .< >$!)", '#4 ##%# #6560.756  %+ !4",

#2

 *

$ !

"4 # %""+'!-"-*'#'

!@ !"% .7::% "3

%%-#

*% "

$3!+

'")! "$4", '

3>, "$4",'

3!" +#"3")",'!-"-*  4  #  %""+  ",  '!  -"-*  

++  "  $  )!

#2

!

", "/

 

#+!4!#" D",!

$#!   ",'

3  ", '

 " " !

"$ '! -"-* ,"  +"% "%+ !4 *!

"$  4 .: >  -  %   !  $!)  ",  '#4  #  #%  # # 6560.756- #3*'3=8'#;!+  ""-

  "$4", '

"$4!" ")",-"-* # ," -"-* !"$#)!  #2,"4 # %""+ 

'  '!  -"-*  

++  "  , ++  )! !     %"-  ",  -'3+!% -4!

;!--++ "'

  ," !

+* +#

"!% !'#'#.79.% )$"!#
  *)!'#," + #

 ) "%"$#3*#,!!!"",-'3+!%-4!!%+ #!" -'3+!%-4! ," "!%!'#3*  ,,!% $"!#
"

%%"#!+* '!#!%!"",%!$!+"'% "3"'# # ,"'! 4 ! ! 3+ #"3 #3*%!".<",.79.% .9 % "" ")

 '!-"-*! 4)

!'3 %4 ",-%  # ,"!!-"#1-+ !!,, " ")",'!-"-* #" 

3 ) "4

 %+ !4! ! !

"$ '! -"-* .5 >$!)", 3"$#!%'!"  !"4!! -

-- + 4! %%"#!+*#!4!# .7 #! --+!% !"&( !, *  ##!-"#",  '  ):

&""&    ! $1'!+  - ?!1 "#  G1 "

 -" 3+  G1 "