High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2000/1993dismissed

Charan Dass v. State Of Punjab

2025-12-04Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl27 pages

!"#

"#$%"

" &

''(( )#$ *$ +, "#

# *#- "+ .

# 0$ ( .

/ # '

%".

*$ +,.

#' 2 # *# / !"3(.

/ #' 2

'# %$(# ''(

( , '$#$ " & !"(( %

'# %$(# ''( / $ ( (#

8 ' # 9$%.

3## 7"#,6

' 7"

((%( /

88 7"#,6 ''(

3 ( ((%(.

3 !"(( % ( : ' ;# ''(( / ''( ( (

&# $ ( "(( % #( 7(( ;# ''(( 3 (6

7 $ < #(6 $,3 8 / '# ='(

' 7"

' 3# '$ "3 %3 < $#"# $,3

'## ' 8 .

'# % 7# % ''(( "#% " $ "##.

" 7#

# $, 9$%.

3## 88

"(( % '# ='( # 9$%.

3## / 8

# '# ='( < $,3 '# % 7# ,

, 3'( 3 9$(

# # 88

$,>$ ' # 9$% 8

$ 3 ((% 3 $ .

$ $"# ((6 $ '# % $(3 ' 8

< $,3 ("$%".

3'$% 8 7"

(

$$ ,$ 7"

(%" '# .

''# 3'$% ' 76 '$ "3 < $,3 =''(( ("$%"

3'##6 3'(6 ,$ "

7#- 6.

"$.

8 #(/ 7"$ %/ ( #

% (7 <

$''# " #%$3 .

(# $ ( #( $'

? @,( $'#3

#'#

#%$3 #

,"( 3'$% # =''((

7#-

##(6 6.

'## ' 8 .

" 7#- '# 3# "

6# "$.

#%$(# 3'(6 " $(

' 7"

7"$ %/ $ ''#$ 6 "# ''(( 7"$ /

$ "7 $

"3 < $,3 /

3'##6 3'(6 #%" " 7#- '# 3# "

6#.

" $(

7"3 3'(6# <

$''# " #%$3 .

(# $ ( #( $'

? @,( $'#3

$ % % && % #'# '

! ( < $,3 #( 7(( ;# ''(( "/

(7 ( 7

? @,( $'#3

,/ 7 "$.

#( 7(( ;# ''(( #/ $ ''(( 3##$.

3 "$( #

&# $ ( #' 2.

"# " .

$,3 #( 7(( ;# ''(( #

# 7"

(7 #/ $'"( $ ( 3#( #/ 3 < #%$ 3(6.

3'##6 3'(6 '# #3 " '' 3 .

" $( # ' 7"

7"$ % $ 3 < $,3 8

# 7"

#3 '' 3 (#

##.

3 ''(( 7#

( %# #>$# < $,3 '#$( 8 7$( "7

#3(6 %3

# ' 76 '$ "3 .

#"#

# 7"

#3 '' 3 (# ''(( < #%$ 3# ( (7 3'##6 3'(6

#%" "( ' " # (,(

# 7"

#3 " # (

#%#

'( $'

? @,( $'#3

#%% % )* )% *+, #'#

< $#"# $,3

'# .

3( ((% % '#

# $"

3 '#6

3 ''((

#%".

"$.

#(/ ''((

# 7"

#3 " '' 3

#3(6 76 '$ "3

< $#"# $,3 '# $ #/ 3 ((6

%#$

+ #

#6 '# (

'#$

88 /#$ ''( ( ''(( % 8 3 ?%"

< $,3 ("$%"

"(( % ,$

# 7"

(7 ;$#"#

' 3 #/ 9$% 7"( #/ ''( ( .

$3, $'

''(( "/ 3 ?%"

'#6.

< #%$ #( '( '( $'

" $'# 3'((6 3 / " $'# 7"#

((6 ( #%$(#

"# # 3( "# #%$(#

"# 7# "$.

(3 #%$(#

((%(

7# '$#$ 3'(6 < $,3 '#$(

7"# "7 '#6# # #( #%$(#

3 ''((

#3(6 ''(( 7#- #' ,( 7#- "$# "#% "3 7# 3

$# #%$(# 3'(6.

(3 '#6 7"

#%$(# 3'(6 < $#"# $,3

$'# %/

,-%#$ "#

#%$(#

3 '#6# #%$(#

? @,( $'#3 !$#.

# # #$3 ($ "#

7#- 3# "

6#.

' "6 7# ( #%$(#

"# 33(6 # "# ( #%$(#

#,##6 ((%(

,-%#$

< '#6 '# ''( , 3#(.

#/ 3

&# $ ( #' 2 ( '' '# ''( ' #%$3 #

,"( #' 2 !

5" "# (# $ ( '# '#$ ''# ,- 7(( ## #( '

'# ''( 3#( #/ 3 #( 7(( ;# ''(( #/ $'"(.

# "/

( "# # ''(( ( $ 7"

((7 '#6#

' - .

*%%% %

- . %/0 % %% % % %% % % & /0 *%0 %

%,,%/%%01&%&*

< " 3'##6 3'(6 '' / '' 3 ::

# 9$%.

3## ((6.

" 7#

# $, 9$%.

3## # "(

>$#6 "(( % (

''( ,# # 9$%.

3##.

7" / 8

' # $, 9$% 88

# ''((

##(6 < $#"# ''(( "##.

/ 8 .

''(( 7# 7"$ "( >$#6

3$ 3( %3

'#6# #%$(#

# '( -

7#- "#% 7(( #' ,( ''(( 7#- "$# ''(( 7# 3(# #%$(# 3'(6 2 , ( 7

(3 '#6 7"

#%$(# 3'(6 ("$%".

88 .

#/ ''( 3 #/ 9$% " !$#.

"(( % ,$

'$ ,# "

## ?%"

(

3 '#6 $ <

3 ( 2#

9$%.

3##.

'((6 ''

'$#(6 3'##6 , /

#/ ##

% "# 7# /#( # #

#/ ## ''(( < $#"# '((6 /## ''(( 7# ' 7"=#3 "

( %# #>$# 3

# 7"

#3 '' 3

'((6 3 $( 7"$ % $ 3 < $#"# 2 3(

'# .

3$"

#(/ 3'(#

$# #( / 3 $ '#$( 7$( "7 '((6 ## ''

'$#(6 3'##6 , / ::

BC* '((6

'' 3 $( 7"$ % # 3 $ 7#- 3'##6 3'(6 < $#"# ,#/ 8

BC*A / 7#

%#$ " 7#

( %# #>$# 3

# 7"

#3 " '' 3

$$ $(

' 3# '$ "3 #%$3 #

,"( 3 %3 ' 3# '$ "3

#(# ' 88 .

#+ # - #

(7 ( 7

? D,( $'#3

)* )%*+2

$'#.

# ,#/ '#$( 8

#3(6 "7 %3 < ,#/

#(# '# % "#% "

$ " 7# / 88

,$ 3 # 9$% / 8

# # /#( 3 " $,>$ 8 ' < ,#/

*$ " $"#6 /3E 3 $

"#%"

#(# '# %.

3' $"#6 $( "/ /#6 7(( # 88 .

#3 < >$#6

# "(

/ >$#6 $( "/ ( ## #"

>$#6

, 3 ((% # 3'(

$( /#6 7(( "/

< "#

3 *$ " $"#6 3 ''# #3

#(# .

$"#6 $ 3( 88

' 3' $"#6.

;# ''(( 3 ''( ( '# ##

#3 '' 3 ''(( 7" ''

3'##6 , $(

' (

$# #( 7(( ;# ''(( # 7(( # #/ $'"( (/ '#

'' 3

'#$ BC* #'#$ "# ,(7 !"#"

$ %

# #&

' ( !

$ )* ' (

' ( ' *%0%%0 /% 34 55 6!5-.***& /*7/89%0

& %

0, -44:%9&%/%* 0&*0 +,-+.. /0

( '#$( 3 7$( "7 '((6

'( , '' '$#(6

3'##6 , " 7# (,( 7"$ $ 3 <

'$ #3 '' 3 "/

"(( %

# "/ /

"(( %

'# $ $ 7#- 3'##6 3'(6

,/ #3 2 (3 #%$(#

/# (

# $"

'#6# 3 /

'# $

8 .

7# =#(/

%#$ " 7#

( %# #>$#

## 8

$(6 C", BC*A #'#$ "# ,(7

!"#"

$ ' !

1 '

2 3 $ 33 $' %%,/*%0%%0%%/0%

& % 0 %,/%%;*% ,45+6- /0

( '#$( 7$( "7 3

#3(6 %3 # "/

' 76 '$ "3 <

# 7"

#3 '' 3 2 3(

((% ''((

# '#

3 '#6

3 A ? @,( $'#3

)*)%*+2

$'#.

' F "

"# ? @,( 9$%.

,#/ $ # #/ +$#'#$ .

3'##6 3'(6

#%" "( ' " # (,(

# 7"

#(/ #/ #$( #3 # #/

3' $"#6 3'(6

$,( #/ 7"#$'

#/ 3'##6 3'(6 .

< $#"# ,#/ 3'##6 3'(6

#%" "( '.

"$.

1/# 3 #/ .

3# .

'$#$ #3 " '' 3 (#.

/ "3 7"

/( >$

# #

,# ? @,( $'#3 7""# #/ #' "# .

7" 3(6

" 3'##6 3'(6.

(7 <

,#/ ?%"

"( '# +$ # #' "#

7# #

#/ 7"# #/ #' "#

#3 #6

$# $

/# #6 7# #' "#

" "## #((.

7"$ %/ "3 ''#$ 6 "$.

% "

? @,( $'#3 !$#.

7"( ?%"

((7 ''( ( .

,#/ ## $ "( 7"# '#(3 #6 >$#6 % 3'##6 1/# 3 #/ "( # ,$ "## , .

,# $ .

#(6 '$ /

$# < $#"# ,#/ 7"

#' 3'##6 3'(6.

''#'# $"#6 '7# " "#% "3 $ # #3 #=#(/ $( 8 < 7$( #(/

,/ .

#' "#

$# ''

8::

" #3 C " $ 7#- (( 8 "$.

7#- '# 3# "

"# 6# / .

'' 3 (# #' 3(# #3

'# .

'' 3 (# #' " $(

3 7"$ % #

# 3'

(/ '#

,/ $((6 $''# '# #' #'#$ "# ,(7 7 <;*& %& % %% % !- - % % =%9&, 0 &

%%009 <: *% &7*%% %% %9&% =%9&%% , % % % &%%0*%$ *%% &% % % * 9%%0% % &%&%% *90%*0%* */,% %>&/ / &9 8 9 $

' 8#

8 !

9 $

;

5 &&& &&& - << < &%& %9& & %* % &

% =0%9&%/ /% 0*0%% &$&*%

9 / %:

*%% % % %*

% =%+ & *&% &%0 **/ %%9&% %%9& %% <*%& & %& 9% %0 % % 0% -4454

%% * ?0 *

373*/%@0$% <: *%

&7*%%% %9&% % ,% % %% % 3 '

= =

* :

?*%&&/ & % %9& %%0 0 % % %+ */0 &&% &% & %9& *

9% %%0 0 %+ % % * **/ &&* %+

& *&,&*%0% %9& %%9& 7*%0/ *

*/ %%9& >&& &&& ? < : *% %

% =%9&/ 9%%0 &%&% % * %%$* %* : *% %&% 0 % % &&*<% % 9%%0

& % %% **% * ?0 * *& *,%& &%%0;*%0

%*,&*%0 % */ %%9&< 9%%0 %%0;*%0%%%% & **% * &* ;*

% / & *%0 % %;* %% % */0 % %9& # % %9& 7*%%* & %%0 0% %9&% //% &&% &%9%9& %* % &%& %9&$ %*

&%&% % % % / %%0 ;*%0 0, & *%0 0 */ % %9& %* %9& %%0 0 % % , A& & / +*&% % % . %%089%%9%

,%9&%//% /09 =&*0%%* % % &%&%9 %*&%% * %%9*%0%*%*%

& %%089%%9 ( @

B9%&*%0 %+ & *& %%0%9 &%0%&*&%9& */&%&&* **/0,& *&%

&&0,0%%%9&&&% & % & %9&%%9 %*%0 & +*9& %%089%%9CCCCCCCCCCCC $ * / /% %%0 89% %9% % *& 89% %9 9 0 9 &;*&<9&;*& % @%=& *% &* %

%9& %%089%%9&&% &

% & %9&

)

! " A ' +?+ B+C $" ?4?' "$ D )

' $( A -4/?,

,7+4+?7' $ = $

3 ' +?5B-C $" +4'

3 ' +?5 (3" $ 55' (@ )* 3 ' $( A +75+/??

+7+,+??' %*' +.-B+C $" 6+5

)

%* = "* ) '

+?6B7C $" ,75 6 <<< % 0 /%9 , % / %%089%9 % , &*%0% %9&/0&** % % %,*&0< % % % & % % 0 & *& ;

;

' '

;

; &*%0% % =%9&/0&**% %&&% & % & %9&% & %%* % % %,;*%0 % %% **%

* ?0 * , &*%

% % % * % %%0;*%0&*%0+ * % A%& %

%% =%9&&&% & &%& %9& 3* ++ &&& &&& E

;

% % &%0 ;*%0 /* % % / / %* % % %,*& % %&%0*9*% +,&&& &&& +7 3

+..0.6

;

) F

;

@ 3

9 ;

< % &

&*%5

9/00 & /

&*% &%&%

% % %<: *% & % ;*%%%&9 % % % % %&*% '# '(

3'(6

,/ ,# ? @,( $'#3 !$#.

3$"

,# ? @,( '#3 !$#.

( #' "#

'# +$ # #' "#

, /# #

#/ ## #' "#

6# :::8 (

, ((% 3 % "3 7"

#%# $ F6 ;$ + %"$,# 6( < # !((% <

D9 # % #'#

, 7"#,6 3'##6 3'(6 % 7"3 '( #6 '# %

7# >$" $"# / : ,$ $,>$ (6 " 7#

: :

%#$ "

3# #>$#.

? @,( $'#3 ,#/ ( (7 3'##6 1/# 3 #/ C

$$.

%/# 3 #/ # / "3 7"

' ( >$ .

3$ #%#

3'(# < $#"# ,#/ #$3 '( #6 '# %

$ % 3'##6 3'(6 7$(

( # 3'$%

' 76 '$ "3

,/ (.

'( #6 '# % 7# % 3'##6 3'(6 33(6 # 3 7# >$".

'# ( "

7 3 ".

3'##6 3'(6 '

3(#

,-%#$ (.

? @,( $'#3 $'"( #(/ %=#3

$ 3

"# %3

# ' 76 '$ "3 (7 ( 7

,/ $((6 ''(

#$3 '#

,/ 7# # %#$ "(( % ( (# $ ( #(# '( #6 '# %

% '( $(3

$,>$ (6

%#$

' 3' $"#6 / '# # .

7$(

(

# $,>$ 8 ' 76 '$ "3 ((6 7$( #(/ 3

'# .

((% % 6,6

# '#

3 '#6

3 8

' # '# 3# "

$# 3 " #3 8

#/#.

#%"(6 ,#/ #(

'$ /

% '( .

/#6 3$"

3' $"#6 3 ' 8

#3 >$#6 #

/ '# %.

( %#$ 88

(- +$#

$"#6 7" ' ##.

# '

>$#6

, 3 ((% # 3'(

$( "/

3 < 7$( ( #(/ 3

? @,( $'#3

*7/ %9 *+ % #'#

.(-.

## 3'##6 3'(6

#%" ' 3# "( '#(3 #6 >$#6 7$(

"#%=#3

"#7

$$ '$ /

$# #(/ '#

#'#$ "# ,(7 < & &%%/% *%%

%/ % % % % %9& %%00+/0*%0% %9 9%* %, % 7* &0 %

= =

* %%%/% %%00%$

% ;*%0&%%9 & % %%9 &/7&9& %% &*0%9&%+% % ;*%0 > % *% *> % % &%%%

%9& %* % >*9 &%&%>,

%&/%/%%%%0 0 %0* /&0 /% ,&* /0% ,4 3

;

0 ;

<: *% /* &/ %% /*/

*% % % %9& &&*

% %/& % *0 %*% &/& %

*0& *&<: *% *%% % %&A*/% % &% % %%9& /& % *0 , % %, % % &% % %9& / 9 *9*%& %%*%;*%0 * %3* (' 3*B% : *% &0 % % %&% % &% (! -- ,

&,/ *& *& ,% %,*9 *%, & * 9 / %& /0 %*%

% ;*%0

= ( (*

=' '

* */ % ,%%%9% %9&*0% *%% %&%/ % ,&0 % %/< % %%0;*%0%A & % 0 * + % &** % % &% % % %9& *9*%<% %,: *%&%0 %%% % =/& % *0 * % %,&& ;*%0 9 * %3* ('

A 3* ,+ F

9 $

< &&% 0 7* &% /0 : *% /0 % */5"*

@%&"* % <*

5% E

*+ % *% $#"#

###

( ? @,( $'#3 ( G *7/ %9"H #'#

-*% *% .

("$%"

"#%

'((6 ,#/ 3'(6 , #3 6 ,#/ "#

3 $ ((%

3'(# "#% "#%

#'#$

'#%#'"

7(( #(/ '#

,/ # #'#$ "# ,(7

- 3

,647++'

G !"#"

$ A +??/(" / 9H '

' "/ I ' % "' %

%%" +,,+ =

: / % % '

-- % 5 *00 3 !) /0

( A ++7? J .?/) ,67++ &&& &&& &&& ,, 3

" +,,+ %%"

+& % % &%, & %

*%,% * & *& % % % % &% &%

" 1 $

? @,( $'#3

$'#

$%" #( $'

(# $ ( ,

3'((6 # <

3'(6 7" #' "#

'' 1 #( %# '# "# 6# 7 A8 " 7#

A .

'## (' "# 6# <

(# #3 !33 # ? (3 ## ? (3 5C( .

$ 33(6 '## .

"( $

"$.

? @,(

$'#3

#$3 "(

3 $ B/

? @,( $'#3 ,#/ (%( '

#(6 (

3'##6 3'(6 # '#, # # /

$# 3'(6.

3'(# 7"$ %3 36

## 7"

?7/#.

'$(# #$3 7"#

'## C'#6 #3 # , $'

(# "# '.

?%"

!$#.

$'"(.

("$%"

#( # 3 %# <

'# .

" "/

# "

#(/ '## ( " #.

#"# " #(/ %=#3

#3 " # 5"$.

7$(

$#"# '(

A $ ( #>$# 3

%#$

+ #

#6 '#6 "/

'#$ 88 < 7$( #(/

#/ ''( ( 3 3 #/ 9$% " '#$( (# :88

BC*A

'#$ 7$( (#(6 "7 #/ ''( 3

88 3(6

'#$

## #/#.

?%"

3 '#6 ("$%"

?%"

/#6 #%" #/ ''(

3 3 #/

9$% ?%"

' (6

( '

"# # "/

( "# ,/ 3( '# ''(

#%$3 #

,"( (# $ ( # $ ( 3 / ;# #%$3 .

( #(

,"( $'

? @,( $'#3

$'# ,

3'((6 # <

$'#.

$%" #%$(#E

"# (

#% ( ''(

,# 5#,$ ( "6 3 ' '( % "# #( #' ,(6 7(( "# 7#- 3(# #%$(# 3'(6 "6 7# '##3 # $ %#( !I!@ '# 7#- '# # % #3 3# "

6# 7 3 '#3# ( 7

? @,( $'#3

&%%0,

)%+9#@9#'#

"$.

( #%$(#

"3 % (7 < ( ' "#

"6 7#

,-# # 7# >$/( #%$(# 3'(6 "#

" /# % "3 ,$ '# 7"

7# 6#

#%$(#

? @,( $'#3 # ,#/ "#

( ##$' #/ '# C 7(( ,6 6# "( "# $(

' 7"

((%( 3

# < ( $ (#%

$3,# '# 7"

$# 7# #%$(#E #' "#

( 3 7# %/

"$.

,#/

#' "#

/(/ '# '( >$(6 "# $ # #(

A ! $

< 8 <

'# .

( "# ,/.

"# '#6# #%$(#

3 7#- "/ 3 #' ,( 7#- "$# #%$(# 3'(6 5"#

" "7 '#

+$ # .

3 $ <3'# (6.

'# #/ /

'# " , 7$(

C 6# "$.

(( 7"

'#3# (7 ( 7

? @,( $'#3

#@9

$'# #/#.

'# ''(( $ ,(3".

3$"

'#$( " #/ ,- 7$( "7 '# #3 "# '.

'# ''(( $# / 8 ("$%".

$'#.

$,>$

( "(( % ,$

'#3 3( .

3$"

6 3( #% ( ''(

( "#

#%$(#

"# #/.

"# 7#

' "6 3# "

6# #/ "#

" /# % "3 5"$.

7$(

$#"# ''(( #/#.

#%$3

7 $%" # ,# "

"# '(

# #%$ ,# #( # ,# ;# ''((

5"#

$ ( , # #%$3 ,# " ((6 7$( #(/ 3

#(/ #3

8 $ ( 3 ''( "##3 ( 3 '# %$(# ''( (

6# "#

/$# ( "/ 9$%3 #( 7(( ;# ''(( #

# 7"

(7 #/ $'"( 0'

/7 ,/ #$3 .

#( 7(( ;# ''(( # $'"( '# ''( , 3#( 3

(( ' 3(( $ ''( .

"(( '

/7 ,/ #""#"$

% %&'(&')*+',-./01)',*2/'3!

'*12 %&'(&'))'+2)(,45'!

'*12