High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1789/2022dismissed

Yadvinder Singh v. Bakshish Singh

2022-09-13Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj5 pages

!"!"#$#%%&!'#(!)$*$+,-,'(!)$.)/( , !0!(#(!)$'(/)- ')$+)$#(!)$)/+,&#1)/2+#1"!$/!&!$3( ,#%%,#&

)- ( , -,#")$" 0,$(!)$,+ !$ ( , #%%&!'#(!)$ ( , "#0, !" #&&)4,+#$+( ,+,&#1!"')$+)$,+

!"# !$% ,#%%,&&#$(+,/,$+#$(!"#33-!,5,+#3#!$"(( ,6*+3,0,$(#$+ +,'-,,+#(,+7 %#"",+81( ,/!-"(#%%,&&#(, )*-(!$ !5!&%%,#& ) )/2*% )+&!$3( ,6*+3,0,$(#$++,'-,,+#(,+7 .%#"",+ 81( , !5!&*+3,9- !5$ :#0*$##3#-#(#3#+ #-!4 ,-,81( ,"*!( /)-%)"",""!)$814#1)/"%,'!/!'%,-/)-0#$',/!&,+81( ,-,"%)$+,$( %&#!$(!//4#"+,'-,,+#3#!$"(( ,#%%,&&#$(+,/,$+#$(

-!,/&1( ,/#'(")/( ,'#",#-,( #(( ,+,/,$+#$(#%%,&&#$( 8,!$3)4$,-!$%)"",""!)$)/( ,"*!(&#$+0,#"*-!$32;#$#&0#-&# ')0%-!",+!$; ,4#() <0!$ ; #()$!) 2.0!$ ; #"-#) ==>= 9>: 29<: 7=9>: .=92: "!(*#(,+ #( 5!&&#3, #%# #+8#"(

) ..*8, "!& #+#*-, "!&#3#+ #-!!"(-!'(#0*$##3#-#"%,- 6#0#8#$+!/)-( ,1,#->.#$+0*(#(!)$) >>??,$(,-,+!$()#$ #3-,,0,$( 4!( ( , %&#!$(!//-,"%)$+,$( /)- # "#&, ')$"!+,-#(!)$ @ =%,-#'-,#$+,A,'*(,+#3-,,0,$(()",&&+#(,+.

,%&#!$(!//%#!+( ,,#-$,"(0)$,1#0)*$(!$3() "

.=()( , +,/,$+#$(#3#!$"(#-,',!%(#$+.

4#"/!A,+#"( ,(#-3,(+#(,/)- ,A,'*(!)$)/"#&,+,,+ (( ,(!0,)/,A,'*(!)$)/( ,#3-,,0,$(( ,"*!( &#$+4#"0)-(3#3,+4!( ( ,(#(,#$;)/$+!## #-%*-/)-#$#0)*$( )/ "

>=5!+, #%#() .<+#(,+ > 7#$+!(4#"*$+,-(#;,$ 81( ,+,/,$+#$(( #(8,/)-,,A,'*(!)$)/( ,"#&,+,,+ ,4)*&+3,(( , "*!(&#$+-,,+,0,+ $.

( ,"#&,+,,+')*&+$)(8,,A,'*(,+ 8,!$3*$+#1#$+)$( ,$,A(+#1!

, )$2 ?

( ,%&#!$(!//5!"!(,+( , )//!',)/( ,*8 ,3!"(-#- #+#*-4 )4#"!$/)-0,+( #(( ,, "!&+#- 4#"$)(#5#!&#8&,")( ,%&#!$(!//4#"#+5!",+()')0,)$( ,$,A(+#1 , %&#!$(!// 4,$( #3#!$ )$ 7 ?

8*( ( , +,/,$+#$( +!+ $)( (*-$ *% )4,5,-( ,%&#!$(!//3)( !"%-,",$',0#-;,+814#1)/#//!+#5!(+*&1 #((,"(,+ 81 # )(#-1 ,-,#/(,- ( , %&#!$(!// 0,( ( , +,/,$+#$( )$ < ?

#$+ -,B*,"(,+ !0 () 3,( ( , "#&, +,,+ ,A,'*(,+ 8*( ( , +,/,$+#$($,5,-%#!+#$1 ,,+()!( $( !"'#*",)/#'(!)$( ,%&#!$(!// /!&,+"*!(/)-"%,'!/!'%,-/)-0#$',)/')$(-#'(+#(,+.

,+,/,$+#$(')$(,"(,+( ,"*!(81/!&!$34-!((,$"(#(,0,$(#$+ -#!",+%-,&!0!$#-1)86,'(!)$"&!;,

0#!$(#!$#8!&!(1,"()%%,& ,('

#$+)$0,-!("%&,#+,+( #(!$ '()8,-( ,+,/,$+#$(!$(,$+,+() ",$+ !"")$#8-)#+#$+$,,+,+0)$,1#$+8,'#*",( ,%&#!$(!//*",+() &,$+0)$,1()( ,$,,+1%,-")$"( ,+,/,$+#$(')$(#'(,+ !0#$+( ,

%&#!$(!//#3-,,+()&,$+ !0#"*0)/.=)$!$(,-,"(@CD%,- 0)$( #3#!$"(/*-$!" !$3)/(4)8&#$;"!3$,+"(#0%%#%,-"/)*--,',$( % )()3-#% " #$+ "!A 8&#$; "!3$,+ 4 !(, %#%,-" $ .

( , +,/,$+#$(-,(*-$,+( ,&)#$#0)*$(#&)$34!( !$(,-,"(8*(( ,%&#!$(!// -,/*",+()!""*,#$1-,',!%()/( ,"#0,#$+0!"*",+( ,8&#$;"!3$,+ %#%,-" 81/)-3!$3( ,#3-,,0,$(()",&& ()'#*",4-)$3/*&&)""()( , +,/,$+#$( ( ,-#5,-0,$("!$( ,%&#!$(4,-,#&")+,$!,+#$+!$( ,,$+!( 4#"%-#1,+( #(( ,"*!(8,+!"0!"",+

/(,-')0%&,(!)$)/%&,#+!$3")/( ,%#-(!,"( ,(-!#& )*-(!$ #&&/-#0,+",5,$!""*,"#$+( ,-,#/(,-( ,%#-(!,"#++*',+( ,!--,"%,'(!5, ,5!+,$', %)$')$"!+,-!$3( ,%&,#+!$3"#$+,5!+,$',)$-,')-+( ,(-!#&

)*-(+,'!+,+ #&& ( , !""*," !$ /#5)*-)/ ( ,%&#!$(!//#$+ #3#!$"( ( , +,/,$+#$(

!""#(!"/!,+4!( ( ,6*+3,0,$(#$++,'-,,+#(,+7 . %#"",+81( ,(-!#& )*-(( ,%&#!$(!//%-,/,--,+#%%,#&8,#-!$3) )/ 2#$+( ,"#0,4#"#&")+!"0!"",+( -)*3 ( ,!0%*3$,+6*+3,0,$( #$++,'-,,+#(,+7 ,$',( !"",')$+#%%,#&

,#-$,+')*$",&/)-( ,#%%,&&#$(+,/,$+#$( #"#-3*,+( #(#" %,-( ,#3-,,0,$(()",&&+#(,+.

( ,"#&,+,,+4#"()8,,A,'*(,+ )$.

#$+#"%,-( ,%&#!$(!// !0",&/( ,"#!++#(,/,&&)$*$+#1 ( ,-,/)-,!$"(,#+)/5!"!(!$3( ,)//!',)/( ,*8 ,3!"(-#-)$2 ?

, 4,$(/)--,3!"(-#(!)$)/"#&,+,,+)$7 ?

, #"/*-( ,-#-3*,+( #( ( )*3 ( ,)(#-14 )#((,"(,+( ,#//!+#5!()/%&#!$(!//)$7 ?

4#"

,A#0!$,+#"#4!($,""9E:8*( , #"$)(+,%)",+( #(( ,%&#!$(!//4#" #5!$3 ( , -,B*!"!(, /*$+" )$ ( , "#!+ +#(, ()4#-+" 8#&#$', "#&,

> ')$"!+,-#(!)$/)-,A,'*(!)$)/( ,"#&,+,,+ '')-+!$3()- *-#$# &,#-$,+')*$",&/)-( ,#%%,&&#$(( ,#3-,,0,$(()",&&#&")+),"$)(')$(#!$ ( ,,A#'("#&,')$"!+,-#(!)$( ,-,/)-,( ,(-!#& )*-(#"4,&&#"( ,#%%,&&#(,

)*-( #5,,--)$,)*"&1+,'-,,+( ,"*!()/( ,%&#!$(!//81,5,$!3$)-!$3( , +!"'-,%#$'1!$( ,%#10,$()/,#-$,"(0)$,1 ,"*80!("( #(( )*3 #"%,- ( ,%&#!$(!//#"*0)/ "

.&#; "4#"%#!+#",#-$,"(0)$,18*(( ,-,',!%( A !"/)-#"*0)/ "

.&#; "

,%-#1"( #(( ,!0%*3$,+6*+3,0,$( #$++,'-,,+,",-5,()8,",(#"!+, /(,- ,#-!$3 &,#-$,+ ')*$",& /)- ( , #%%,&&#$( #$+ ')$"!+,-!$3( ,,5!+,$',)$-,')-+!(!"'&,#-( #(( ,#3-,,0,$(()",&& +#(,+.

9A :4#"%-)5,+81( ,%&#!$(!//81,A#0!$!$3( , #((,"(!$34!($,""#"4,&&#"( ,"'-!8,#$+!(')$(#!$"( ,"#&,')$"!+,-#(!)$ #"4,&&!

, @ "

&#; "%,-#'-, *"( ,#-3*0,$(( #(( ,#3-,,0,$( ()",&&+),"$)(')$(#!$( ,#0)*$()/"#&,')$"!+,-#(!)$!"4!( )*(#$1 0,-!(#"( ,()(#&"#&,')$"!+,-#(!)$!",#"!&1'#&'*&#8&, *-!$3( ,')*-", )/ ,#-!$3&,#-$,+')*$",&/)-( ,%,(!(!)$,- #"%-)+*',+( ,+,%)"!(!)$)/ +,/,$+#$(#+5!$+,-!$3 4 )#+0!((,+( ,"!3$#(*-,")$( ,#3-,,0,$( ()",&&#"4,&&#"( ,-,',!%(!$+!'#(!$3%#10,$()/ "

.&#; "() !0 , 0#(,-!#&,5!+,$',8-)*3 (81( ,%&#!$(!// #"$)(8,,$-,8*((,+( ,-,/)-, ( ,')$'&*"!)$+-#4$81( ,(-!#& )*-(#$+*% ,&+81( ,#%%,&&#(, )*-( )$( ,0#(,-!#&!""*,"!"8#",+*%)$%-)%,-#%%-,'!#(!)$)/,5!+,$', (( !""(#3,- *-#$#&,#-$,+')*$",&/)-( ,%,(!(!)$,- #"#-3*,+( #(!$/#'(#"*0)/ .&#; "4#"-,',!5,+81( ,+,/,$+#$( #"#&)#$()",$+ !"")$#8-)#+8*(( ,"#!+#0)*$("())+-,(*-$,+() %&#!$(!//#$+!(4#"+*-!$3( ,+)'*0,$(#(!)$)/&)#$',-(#!$"!3$#(*-,")/

. ( ,+,/,$+#$(4,-,)8(#!$,+81( ,%&#!$(!//4 ,-,*%)$( !"/)-3,+#$+ /#8-!'#(,+#3-,,0,$(()",&& #"8,,$,A,'*(,+ !"#-3*0,$()/&,#-$,+')*$",&-*$"')$(-#-1() !",#-&!,- "*80!""!)$"$)(!',+#8)5,4 ,-,!$ ,%)!$(,+)*(+,/,'(!$( ,#3-,,0,$( ()",&&#$++!"'-,%#$'1!$( ,%#10,$()/,#-$,"(0)$,1 +0!((,+&1$) ,5!+,$',4#"#++*',+81( ,+,/,$+#$(()%-)5,( ,!$"(-*0,$(#"/)-3,+)- /#8-!'#(,+

,"*&(#$(&1 /!$+!$3 $) 0,-!( !$ ( !" #%%,#& 0*' &,"" !$5)&5,0,$()/#$1"*8"(#$(!#&B*,"(!)$)/&#4$)3-)*$+!"0#+,)*(/)- !$(,-/,-,$',81( !" )*-(

!"0!"",+

,%(,08,-

*&#(!

&' E ,( ,- ,%)-(#8&, ,"=) E ,( ,-%,#;!$3= ,#")$,+ ,"=)