← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1404/2024dismissed

Mahender Singh (Since Deceased) Through Lr And Others v. Rattan Singh

2024-07-03Mrs. Justice Ritu Tagore12 pages





 ! " #    " 

$%&'$%()* +

 

         +,

 

            &  -!. /+ /          ! " #     ! "  $%&'('%)()' " *& $%&('+%)()' ,,,,    * & -

.. 



 "#! !

% 

" ./  *0&")())        ) 1   !

%          &+(&)()' /%2

#    $ !

3  

!

 "

4

 3 5 # 

/% 6 "

 #  -

7     8-

7        )9 " -  "

 

"  &+0:  " " ; <"

#  !#

 "    %         #   " '&&9268%5 5. "/    " "/ "  : 1    !          #! !

%   ! !

= " 5 '  !" 

 "     

   #! !

%   "

$ !

  *)9 )+(&)(('     "

     

      -  "   5   !

  .    &2(:)(&(

/ %& -    $ 

     "

5 .

 /# 5% > 

  

    

              

         

        

   !                    "

                # 6 -     





      . "       

       . &2(:)(&( / %& ? &+(')(&&      %#7  " .

#   $5

  

 "   @ .

  A    5  

 !

  .):(')(&) /%)5    $ %

 

      

                & '       (

 '  

       # 0      * :(2)%)(&) " #    5 



)6(6)()) /%:- !"  .

# 

$  % $ 

  

        & ( )      '   

# 2 4     "    /  "   . 

  " "



 "   .    %  "

/  #" B/ $- "

 

 

!  #      %.  #

 " / %  

 

" 

"     )9 "   #       %         .5  . "." .

#   $  ! " "

 "  /         

. ."  "". !

5" !

"  )9"     -%   "

 

     

 ? 

B/ $

# 



   )9" !

 . &+(&)()' / %2 9    "      

     &+(&)()' /%2

 B/ $ "

     #  7 #        !  #.

 %  .

5       /%&   . ."  5 . "

"  ."/ " C

! " "

 "  /       %          .    A.   /         

   !.      .".   "

/ # 

 

 5



  .

 5      

  5



. 

"%  

/ "  -  #.

" "  . %  #5

 ". 

"    "  "

". 

"!.

=

!!

"  )9"    B/  $ "

     

 "  !

"  )9"  " 5



 

!      

      

  #   

"

#    )9"  + -7  " 

#.

      B/ $ 5#     .  %      .  . "    5 

 

..

#     " 5 C

#.

 

.  /%2

" #  5

#  #  C "

 .  " ."

$    " 01(20%1$3!

 "$+ 13 $))(): & $

$ !

020 ."D<#  .$  " + /2)1(4+%(%$ 2*)():

)$ $ !

&:6 &( $

   "    %  " 

  !

%   "  .%#  "

  /   

  "! "    .

5  

! 5  # 

D<#  .$-  ! "

    . 

       5  

    "           

/ %&   .%#   " * & #"  $5  /  "! "    %  5   .  "   "  8 .    ""#"  $ 5

!

7

"  "/ "   && C

#.

 #      "     

 

!  /%&#   $5 

#. "

#   

$ 5





"#  .%# -   %  .  5   "

 . ".E      .%#  /      ". - .%# .!  

/ # 

5



/    / %&   7  %      . . -         .

   .%## 



"

5 "

 #         /  "  

!   "  .%##.

 % 5  5

/E  5

# 5

/ .



 

"!"

  /    "  

 "      -

 #.

 

  .%# 5 5

.

5 !#"

" !  # 

8   )9"  

/ "    !

"  )9" 



#  

! "     B/  $   





# 

"

  )9" "   &)  " 5

  "

              .  . "    .

 5      "   B/

$ 

   / #    

  5



    "  %      /    #.

      !

 #

"    (2())():     #! .  " 5 "

  !

    &6())()'  ):())()'   !

 1    #! #.

   

 . " 

 " #!   !

%

# .

 &:    "    ! #   %#7 

.    

" . "    &'-"  



#! 

  ! 7 !

"  )9"  

 #    !

5   "

5  $ 

 

     

 

 

   



   

       * +,   

   

                                                                                 

    (     *-+,     * + .

*+            

                        * +        

                                            (        

            */+%                            * +                         0. *+            1 * +

        

        *2+                     *3+&            # &6 

!

"?)( &)% $$

=  #  5 /  $

 

  

  

 

 

     



 ,     

                                          # &0    #!   .     &2(:)(&(

/%& !

  ."  %   . $8 #      %  34     !  C    5

! %  34/

 "!" 5 . "." 

 "   . A.    %  5

!

7

"  "/ "

  F #       

 /

    #

 

.  %  34   / -"  5 .#    %

5 # 

 "



#"B/ $         .  #  . "     .



    " /  "   # #

 .".

".

5       /%&5 !#""

. #    

 $    "  !    5    .%#  5 #   

"

 5    

 #  

 $"

 /

 ". .     . "

 5  . #    

 $  5





 &2  "!

"  )9"   .  #

 %   # ."

 !

!

% 

  .5      

 # ".

"%

" . /%&  

5

!%   # ."   C     .%# 5  .      . #.   /5 . " 

"C  .

 !

"  )9"   ! !

"."  %#7 . 

#  ". /%&%2  /  "   5     =  "   %  .%#   C " "          7 "  / "C

""



"

"    )6(6)())   %%  " 5  " # . "  34.

5  

! .    .   / %& "

  /     ))(9)()) 

 " . .  "   - "  !    "

#   . . " 5

  

"# !7   )9" C

   5 5

/E 

 " &9-5  )9" 



    # /

 5 

 5

"  "     " %   .

5 .

"D5!$   

 

-$



    . =  

!   )9" !

 

" # .

" &+ C

!" . / .  !#  

B/ $  5 

#    "



#

 "   )9 "     

    #   .

  " 



   !

 "  )9"    

#     

 



 . #!  "



#  B/ $ ""

.*

  # 

 "      #    B/ $# # "  5 )( "?)( &)% $$ 5  ! "

 "

 ".  $

   "

    5  5    .

  # . C        

  "

 * # .  B/ $ #  / 1  .   "

 """"   . .          7   

  

. . -#  =  

   

!#  B/ $%  #  ."  5 .

!" # 

- .  #  " 5! "   

#    01(2 0%1$3 /%5$   5

    .%# !

#   5 5. 

/ C +/2)1( %5$   5   "%     # 

 

7   C!

5"#!" 

 

"

5  ".  %

5 A.  "

"

 

$ #

!

    #  /   "  .   " "



 "   (2())(): " #         ."

$  !

"

&6())()'):())()'   !

-

 ."" " 



  ! 

" )& D!

    " "

#! 

  B/ $ 



/

 

  5

 5 

  #" 5 

"# 

$ ))     #  #!%.  !

%

  

# .

 ):   .



  

"   

  " 

     

"

$%&'$%()*  F 7 8   G 8* F#  G 8*